[Ed.]What requires that I pay the income tax?

So does that leave you with an IQ of 0?

Show me the law genius, where is the law? It is easy to call people CT's and nuts without one shred of proof, it shows intelligence when you can actually back up your ad hominem retoric with facts. So where is it. Site the law. What chapter? What section? Are we not a nation of law or can the IRS do what they want without a law? Why wont the IRS debate this openly? Why are ex-IRS agents saying it is a fraud? Do you have any talking points to add to the debater or are you here just to give an opinion based on nothing but hot air?

When insulting another's IQ it's always a good idea not to show yourself to be uneducated.

rhetoric
site=location. I think you were looking for "cite".

I'm now certain you are the sock of the 19 year old OP'er.

Normally this kind of thing is overlooked, but not when you're calling out someone else as dumb.

Speaking of, what do you think of the information he provided you?
 
BWHAHAHAHAHA. I'm talking like a communist. I'm quite a libertarian (philosophically, not a member of the party), actually, and I not only symathize with tax reform groups, I occasionally volunteer for them.

Your CT stripes are showing.

Your communist comments are obvious. You want people who have problems with the government to leave, that's not very Libertarian. Where are my CT stripes, perhaps they're lost along with the law that requires tax on wages. If there is one I sure wish you would site it instead of just talking about philosophy and CT's
 
I wasn't telling you to leave if you don't like it. I should have been more clear by saying "commune" not kibbutz.

If your argument isn't based in fact or truth, then the most polite conclusion is that it's very much a philosophical argument.

If my argument isn't based on fact or truth then show the law. That is my whole argument, there is no law. If I am wrong then show me the law.

Here I say it again, show me the law.

Communes are European and I am American so either way commune or Kibbutz you are telling me to leave the country.
 
Your communist comments are obvious. You want people who have problems with the government to leave, that's not very Libertarian. Where are my CT stripes, perhaps they're lost along with the law that requires tax on wages. If there is one I sure wish you would site it instead of just talking about philosophy and CT's

Sticks and stones, kid. Sticks and stones. Calling me a commie only makes me laugh. Keep doing it, I'll keep laughing.

What makes you look like a CT'er is that you have been shown the law and all of the facts repeatedly, yet you ignore it and continue on with the same hair-splitting. The fact that you ask for the law to be "sited" shows me that you have zero legal knowledge.

Why not visit your local ACLU. If Americans are being taxed unconstitutionally, they'd be all over it, no?
 
When insulting another's IQ it's always a good idea not to show yourself to be uneducated.

rhetoric
site=location. I think you were looking for "cite".

I'm now certain you are the sock of the 19 year old OP'er.

Normally this kind of thing is overlooked, but not when you're calling out someone else as dumb.

Speaking of, what do you think of the information he provided you?

Simple mistakes when responding on the fly, and I was reponding to his insults on my intelligence. As far as what do I think of his information, maybe I missed that part. I see no information that is compelling.
 
So does that leave you with an IQ of 0?

Show me the law genius, where is the law? It is easy to call people CT's and nuts without one shred of proof, it shows intelligence when you can actually back up your ad hominem retoric with facts. So where is it. Site the law. What chapter? What section? Are we not a nation of law or can the IRS do what they want without a law? Why wont the IRS debate this openly? Why are ex-IRS agents saying it is a fraud? Do you have any talking points to add to the debater or are you here just to give an opinion based on nothing but hot air?

You put me in mind of a bloke who parked his mini-van @ 20th and M streets NW, Downtown Washington DC. He papered the outside of it with bogus "Certificate(s) of Occupancy" and for 24 hours dared the police (or anyone coming within earshot) to oust him. They did.

Simply put WOR, your type cannot be ad-hom'd in the traditional sense. This is simply because the rational level of your argument is below that of slightly retarded individuals. You guys (CT types) are so self-deluded that calling you an idiot and having that critique actually dent your misguided sense of purpose could only be construed by rational people as an uncommon kindness.

I however am not so kind. When I meet such insane people in person I am always ready to agree with them and make nice as the men with butterfly nets and white coats slyly approach from behind. Thus may I wish you luck and much happiness in your *ahem* eccentric pursuits??
[gives the signal]
Get 'im boys!

-z

PS: Not to worry...Federal prisons have many fine mental health professionals on staff.
 
If my argument isn't based on fact or truth then show the law. That is my whole argument, there is no law. If I am wrong then show me the law.

Here I say it again, show me the law.

Communes are European and I am American so either way commune or Kibbutz you are telling me to leave the country.

THE LAW HAS BEEN SHOWN TO YOU AGAIN AND AGAIN, and you dismiss it.

There are many, many communes in the United States. There are five that I know about simply by proximity in my own state. Obviously in my sarcasm I gave you far too much credit.
 
Last edited:
Sticks and stones, kid. Sticks and stones. Calling me a commie only makes me laugh. Keep doing it, I'll keep laughing.

What makes you look like a CT'er is that you have been shown the law and all of the facts repeatedly, yet you ignore it and continue on with the same hair-splitting. The fact that you ask for the law to be "sited" shows me that you have zero legal knowledge.

Why not visit your local ACLU. If Americans are being taxed unconstitutionally, they'd be all over it, no?

I have been shown the law repeatedly? maybe you would like to repost that because no one showed me a law.

I have enough legal knowledge to know that the Government has no authority unless a law gives them such authority. So where is the legal authority. You say it was posted, I don't see it. Post it again would you.

I offered no theories therefore I cannot be a conspiracy theorist. I said there is no law. Until someone shows it to me then I will continue to believe that the law doesn't exist. If someone shows me a law then that would be all the convincing I need.

The Tax Honesty Movement did contact the ACLU and the response was that they only deal in cases involving;
  • Your First Amendment rights
  • Your right to equal protection under the law - equal treatment regardless of race, sex, religion or national origin.
  • Your right to due process
  • Your right to privacy
And they suggested we take it up with the IRS. Since the IRS refuses to answer our questions... then what?

Oh and this time don't forget to post the law you said has been posted several times.
 
I have been shown the law repeatedly? maybe you would like to repost that because no one showed me a law.

I have enough legal knowledge to know that the Government has no authority unless a law gives them such authority. So where is the legal authority. You say it was posted, I don't see it. Post it again would you.

I offered no theories therefore I cannot be a conspiracy theorist. I said there is no law. Until someone shows it to me then I will continue to believe that the law doesn't exist. If someone shows me a law then that would be all the convincing I need.

The Tax Honesty Movement did contact the ACLU and the response was that they only deal in cases involving;
  • Your First Amendment rights
  • Your right to equal protection under the law - equal treatment regardless of race, sex, religion or national origin.
  • Your right to due process
  • Your right to privacy
And they suggested we take it up with the IRS. Since the IRS refuses to answer our questions... then what?

Oh and this time don't forget to post the law you said has been posted several times.

Hey, anybody got a cute cat picture?
 
Right, list the examples that are constitutional but leave out the ones that are not. Are you aware of the Constitution and how it states that taxes must be apportioned or indirect? Which is the income tax?

Doesn't matter. The 16th Amendment says that "The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among the several States, and without regard to any census or enumeration."

So the statement that taxes must be apportioned or indirect is no longer true, when we're speaking of the income tax.

Any, by definition, "taxes on incomes, from whatever source derived" are constitutional under the same amendment. So there are no examples of sources of income upon which a tax would be unconstitutional.



enlighten me, because I can get into the actual wording if you want.

Yeah, I can Google, too. But can you read the actual wording?

What do you think the 16th Amendment means?
 
So does that leave you with an IQ of 0?

Show me the law genius, where is the law? It is easy to call people CT's and nuts without one shred of proof, it shows intelligence when you can actually back up your ad hominem retoric with facts. So where is it. Site the law. What chapter? What section? Are we not a nation of law or can the IRS do what they want without a law? Why wont the IRS debate this openly? Why are ex-IRS agents saying it is a fraud? Do you have any talking points to add to the debater or are you here just to give an opinion based on nothing but hot air?

I'll take a wild guess and presume that you are not a CPA, tax lawyer, or tax court judge. I'll go further out on that limb, and also presume that you are not an IRS agent.

Which law? The statutes I was alluding to regarding fraudulent schemes to circumvent the legal obligation to pay federal income taxes? If that is your question, the answer is rather simple. It's in the United States Code, at 26 U.S.C. Section 7201 for attempts to evade or defeat income tax liability, and also at 26 U.S.C. Sections 7206(1) and (2) for willfully and knowingly making false or fraudulent statements on your tax returns or schedules.

For a layperson's primer on tax schemes I mentioned in my post above, see the IRS' website itself. They have a nice description of what these things look like, and they address some of the ridiculous (and tired) arguments tax protestors (that's what they informally call CTers regarding income taxes) typically raise regarding income:

http://www.irs.gov/businesses/small/article/0,,id=106498,00.html

AS
 
I have been shown the law repeatedly? maybe you would like to repost that because no one showed me a law.

I have enough legal knowledge to know that the Government has no authority unless a law gives them such authority. So where is the legal authority. You say it was posted, I don't see it. Post it again would you.

I offered no theories therefore I cannot be a conspiracy theorist. I said there is no law. Until someone shows it to me then I will continue to believe that the law doesn't exist. If someone shows me a law then that would be all the convincing I need.

The Tax Honesty Movement did contact the ACLU and the response was that they only deal in cases involving;
  • Your First Amendment rights
  • Your right to equal protection under the law - equal treatment regardless of race, sex, religion or national origin.
  • Your right to due process
  • Your right to privacy
And they suggested we take it up with the IRS. Since the IRS refuses to answer our questions... then what?

Oh and this time don't forget to post the law you said has been posted several times.

Here's a quick lesson in spotting a CTer:

Has Truth or Honesty been incorporated into the name of their anti-gub'mint cult...erm.... I mean "Movement"??

If so then there you are....

Good luck in jail
-z
 
How, exactly, are wages not "compensation for services"?
Compensation for services including fees, commissions, fringe benefits, and similar items. Not wages, they are referring to business activity. People don't charge there employer fees. A wage is not a commission or a benefit. Wages are not similar to those items either.
The Supreme Court ruled

[FONT=Verdana, Times New Roman, Times, serif]
[/FONT]
[FONT=Verdana, Times New Roman, Times, serif]b.. 1916: Brushaber vs. Union Pacific Railroad, 240 U.S. 1. Established that the 16th Amendment had no affect on the constitution, and that income taxes could only be sustained as excise taxes and not as direct taxes. [/FONT]
[FONT=Verdana, Times New Roman, Times, serif]"...the proposition and the contentions under [the 16th Amendment]...would cause one provision of the Constitution to destroy another; [/FONT]
[FONT=Verdana, Times New Roman, Times, serif]That is, they would result in bringing the provisions of the Amendment exempting a direct tax from apportionment into irreconcilable conflict with the general requirement that all direct taxes be apportioned; [/FONT]
[FONT=Verdana, Times New Roman, Times, serif]This result, instead of simplifying the situation and making clear the limitations of the taxing power, which obviously the Amendment must have intended to accomplish, would create radical and destructive changes in our constitutional system and multiply confusion. [/FONT]
[FONT=Verdana, Times New Roman, Times, serif]Moreover in addition the Conclusion reached in the Pollock Case did not in any degree involve holding that income taxes generically and necessarily came within the class of direct taxes on property, but on the contrary recognized the fact that taxation on income was in its nature an excise entitled to be enforced as such unless and until it was concluded that to enforce it would amount to accomplishing the result which the requirement as to apportionment of direct taxation was adopted to prevent, in which case the duty would arise to disregard form and consider substance alone and hence subject the tax to the regulation as to apportionment which otherwise as an excise would not apply to it.[/FONT]


[FONT=Verdana, Times New Roman, Times, serif]And once again[/FONT]


[FONT=Verdana, Times New Roman, Times, serif]1916: Stanton v. Baltic Mining, 240 U.S. 103. Declared that the 16th Amendment conferred no new powers of taxation to the U.S. government, but simply prevented income taxes from being taken out of the category of indirect (excise) taxes to which they inherently belonged.[/FONT]


[FONT=Verdana, Times New Roman, Times, serif]And again[/FONT]


[FONT=Verdana, Times New Roman, Times, serif]1918: Peck v. Lowe, 247 U.S. 165. Stated that the 16th Amendment does not extend the taxing power to new or excepted subjects, but removed the need to apportion direct taxes on income.[/FONT]


[FONT=Verdana, Times New Roman, Times, serif]Or this[/FONT]


[FONT=Verdana, Times New Roman, Times, serif]1920: Eisner v. Macomber, 252 U.S. 189. Defined income within the meaning of the 16th Amendment as "profit". Prohibited direct, unapportioned taxation of income of a stockholder. [/FONT]
[FONT=Verdana, Times New Roman, Times, serif]The Sixteenth Amendment must be construed in connection with the taxing clauses of the original Constitution and the effect attributed to them before the amendment was adopted. In Pollock v. Farmers' Loan & Trust Co., 158 U.S. 601 , 15 Sup. Ct. 912, under the Act of August 27, 1894 (28 Stat. 509, 553, c. 349, 27), it was held that taxes upon rents and profits of real estate and upon returns from investments of personal property were in effect direct taxes upon the property from which such income arose, imposed by reason of ownership; and that Congress could not impose such taxes without apportioning them among the states according to population, as required by article 1, 2, cl. 3, and section 9, cl. 4, of the original Constitution. [/FONT]
[FONT=Verdana, Times New Roman, Times, serif]Afterwards, and evidently in recognition of the limitation upon the taxing power of Congress thus determined, the Sixteenth Amendment was adopted, in words lucidly expressing the object to be accomplished: [/FONT]
[FONT=Verdana, Times New Roman, Times, serif]'The Congress shall have power to lay and collect taxes on incomes, from whatever source derived, without apportionment among [252 U.S. 189, 206] the several states, and without regard to any census or enumeration.'
[/FONT]


[FONT=Verdana, Times New Roman, Times, serif]1978: Central Illinois Public Service Co. v. United States, 435 U.S. 21. Established that wages and income are NOT equivalent as far as taxes on income are concerned.[/FONT]


[FONT=Verdana, Times New Roman, Times, serif]Is the Supreme Court irrelevant[/FONT]?
 
Oh sorry....moreover I meant to post:
 

Attachments

  • 2.jpg
    2.jpg
    58.3 KB · Views: 1
Here's a quick lesson in spotting a CTer:

Has Truth or Honesty been incorporated into the name of their anti-gub'mint cult...erm.... I mean "Movement"??

If so then there you are....

Good luck in jail
-z

That is a pretty simple minded statement. I guess Academic Honesty is a bunch of conspiracy theorists also. What about soldiers for the truth foundation? American Congress for truth? All conspiracy nuts. O.k. buddy, what ever you say.

Obviously you failed to read my arguments or you would know that I pay my taxes because the law is clearly written that business owners have to pay taxes, so I won't be going to jail. As far as my employees go, they are not reqired by law, don't write me back saying they are, just show me the law.
 
That is a pretty simple minded statement. I guess Academic Honesty is a bunch of conspiracy theorists also. What about soldiers for the truth foundation? American Congress for truth? All conspiracy nuts. O.k. buddy, what ever you say.

Yeah, tough ain't it? how the dishonest and purposeful misuse of a word twists its meaning 180 degrees. "It's true!" :)
Obviously you failed to read my arguments or you would know that I pay my taxes because the law is clearly written that business owners have to pay taxes, so I won't be going to jail. As far as my employees go, they are not reqired by law, don't write me back saying they are, just show me the law.

Sure, but the people you'd have believe your total lies...they'd go to the big house for taking your sage advice wouldn't they? You are a liar. You've had the case law shoved in your face numerous times but still say "Show me the law!" Your arguments are simply not worth my "sacred time" to read.

-z
 
I'll take a wild guess and presume that you are not a CPA, tax lawyer, or tax court judge. I'll go further out on that limb, and also presume that you are not an IRS agent.
You are correct, but my associates in the Tax Honesty Movement are CPA's, tax lawyers, and former IRS agents.

Which law? The statutes I was alluding to regarding fraudulent schemes to circumvent the legal obligation to pay federal income taxes? If that is your question, the answer is rather simple. It's in the United States Code, at 26 U.S.C. Section 7201 for attempts to evade or defeat income tax liability
That shows the penalties for evading taxes, it is not a law stating we have to pay tax on wages

, and also at 26 U.S.C. Sections 7206(1) and (2) for willfully and knowingly making false or fraudulent statements on your tax returns or schedules.

Ok, I can't make fraudulent statements on my return, still no law requiring taxable wages.

For a layperson's primer on tax schemes I mentioned in my post above, see the IRS' website itself. They have a nice description of what these things look like, and they address some of the ridiculous (and tired) arguments tax protestors (that's what they informally call CTers regarding income taxes) typically raise regarding income:

http://www.irs.gov/businesses/small/article/0,,id=106498,00.html
http://www.irs.gov/businesses/small/article/0,,id=106498,00.html

All rhetoric, no law cited.

Maybe you don't get it, if the IRS is right then there should be a law that says wages are taxable. How do you convict someone from breaking a non-law?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom