Easy solution to the pirate problem...

Uh yes, you are at risk if armed pirates come aboard your ship and hold you hostage. I think that is pretty much the definition of being at risk. And I can promise you this, if I caught some pirates trying to board my ship and I had a rifle, everyone of them would be dead and rotting at the bottom of the ocean.

Doubtful. Winning a firefight against multiple opponets is never a safe bet.

There are wolves, sheep, and sheep dogs in this world, and I will be DAMNED if I am ever a sheep.

Oversimplifcations are unhelpful.
 
You must be joking.

If not, what do you think the pirate in my example above who takes the 12-gauge shotgun round to the face is going to say?

Not much. His mates in the boat on the other hand will be seeing how you react to an RPG-7 hit.
 
So you cooperate when you know ahead of time that that will be the best outcome, and kill all the pirates when you know ahead of time that will be the best outcome? Where are you getting this foresight?

Look at Quad4, he is advocating a strategy that is rather opposite the one that is working in Iraq. He is advocating force, when bribary is what is reducing violence in Iraq.

I think we might be talking past each other here. What is it you think I was saying initially?

What I was actually saying is that Dan O.'s statement applies more than once in this thread, particularly in reference to several statements by Quad4_72. If you thought I was saying something else, I hope that clarifies any misunderstanding.
 
I think we might be talking past each other here. What is it you think I was saying initially?

What I was actually saying is that Dan O.'s statement applies more than once in this thread, particularly in reference to several statements by Quad4_72. If you thought I was saying something else, I hope that clarifies any misunderstanding.

Looking back first post was not actualy disagreeing with you, but an attempt to refine your point. My second responce was taken from what un misremembered your point to being as you took disagreement with what I was saying, when I was not indending to disagree with your point in my innitial responce to you.
 
This is the same kind of warped logic I hear from people who want all robbers shot because "how do you know he won't shoot you once he has the money?". Short-sighted, non-thinking rubbish. A robber has a situation in which he can take the money at gunpoint, run, and evade an investigation for robbery. Or he can shoot the clerk, gain absolutely nothing in doing so, and get hunted for robbery and cold-blooded, homicide, plus an increased risk that store clerks will shoot on sight.

Robbers and pirates aren't blood-thirsty animals who kill, rape and take the lord's name in vain the first opportunity they get. They're human beings who are capable of making risk judgements.

Oh, wait, it's not about safety, it's about scoring Honour Points with Odin and great Patton in the sky so they won't think you're a bleeding-heart chicken. My bad.

I don't believe you. Not after we have pointed out, in just about every single one of our posts, that self-defence isn't necessary as the pirates have no reason to kill you.

Sorry, but I just don't believe you.

Indeed they are. And if they realize that they are going to try and board a ship full of armed people willing to defend themselves against pirates, they will make the logical decision to look elsewhere for a submissive target. Thank you for illustrating that point.
 
To be honest I would be very surprised if you are an officer. Forget about that, there is no way that you're an officer in any competent military. For every officer must be able to make a 'casualties vs gain' assessment and if the gain doesn't warrant the casualties and there is no way to retreat, then surrender must be considered. And you seem simply incapable of that.

You're likely to get some of the crew killed for no to little gain (in a good case scenario). The amount of gun accidents deaths is likely to be larger then that of hostage deaths. My advice to you is really stick with your specific army job as you don't even qualify to do police work.

If we really want to stop pirates then were more likely see a return of the convoy system with one or more military ships per convoy.

Yes. I just have my branch insignia in my avatar because I think it looks cool. Lol. I am indeed an officer. And looking at defending a ship from a tactical standpoint, pirates don't have a chance if they go up against a small group of individuals who have basic knowledge of firearms and BRM. This is especially true if you catch the boat approaching. The pirates on the small dinghys have very little hope of laying down accurate fire because of the platform they are shooting from. The people on the ship have a much more stable platform and have the advantage of height and cover. Not to mention the pirates still have to actually board the thing by throwing up hooks and ladders. This leaves them completely vulnerable. It would actually be relatively easy to defend a ship from pirates tactically.

As far as gun accidents go, I don't see them as accidents, I see them as negligence. With proper training you can completely avoid negligent discharges. And I actually have leaps and bound above police officers in forms of training as far as short rifle marksmanship, room clearing, battle drills, squad tactics, and basic rifle marksmanship go (Actually most police get NONE of this training).

And I actually do agree with you on the military convoy part. I don't believe the Navy has the resources to do this though (I may be wrong on that though).
 
Yes. I just have my branch insignia in my avatar because I think it looks cool. Lol. I am indeed an officer. And looking at defending a ship from a tactical standpoint, pirates don't have a chance if they go up against a small group of individuals who have basic knowledge of firearms and BRM. This is especially true if you catch the boat approaching. The pirates on the small dinghys have very little hope of laying down accurate fire because of the platform they are shooting from. The people on the ship have a much more stable platform and have the advantage of height and cover. Not to mention the pirates still have to actually board the thing by throwing up hooks and ladders. This leaves them completely vulnerable. It would actually be relatively easy to defend a ship from pirates tactically.

As far as gun accidents go, I don't see them as accidents, I see them as negligence. With proper training you can completely avoid negligent discharges. And I actually have leaps and bound above police officers in forms of training as far as short rifle marksmanship, room clearing, battle drills, squad tactics, and basic rifle marksmanship go (Actually most police get NONE of this training).

And I actually do agree with you on the military convoy part. I don't believe the Navy has the resources to do this though (I may be wrong on that though).


So all we have to do here is have the merchants only employ sailors with special forces training and we can win every pirate engagement like we won the battle of mogadishu.
 
So all we have to do here is have the merchants only employ sailors with special forces training and we can win every pirate engagement like we won the battle of mogadishu.

Lol. Not at all. Just MINOR training with a rifle (This can be done in a day or so) and if you see pirates defend yourself just as you would defend your home and family if it was invaded by robbers (from the looks of it though most people would not do even that).
 
Yes. I just have my branch insignia in my avatar because I think it looks cool.

Sounds more and more like it at every post.

There's a military surplus store down the road aways that does brisk business in army insignia. Rank insignia, too. They sell something like fifty general's stars a month.

As far as gun accidents go, I don't see them as accidents, I see them as negligence.

Oh, well, that clears things up nicely. Now that you've changed the word, your Merchant Marines will never again have a problem with them.

And I actually have leaps and bound above police officers in forms of training as far as short rifle marksmanship, room clearing, battle drills, squad tactics, and basic rifle marksmanship go

Right. I assume you got this training at the same surplus store where you bought your branch insignia and your captain's bars?
 
Sounds more and more like it at every post.

There's a military surplus store down the road aways that does brisk business in army insignia. Rank insignia, too. They sell something like fifty general's stars a month.



Oh, well, that clears things up nicely. Now that you've changed the word, your Merchant Marines will never again have a problem with them.



Right. I assume you got this training at the same surplus store where you bought your branch insignia and your captain's bars?

Lol. I really could care less if you believe I am an officer, but you can't seem to dispute my points.
 
Lol. I really could care less if you believe I am an officer, but you can't seem to dispute my points.

That's because there's nothing there to dispute. I don't need to dispute your points, because you're doing such a great job of it for me.

I pointed out that Merchant Marines aren't qualified to handle weapons, and you said that you'd replace all the merchant marines with your army buddies. It was pointed out that your army buddies aren't qualified to drive a container ship, and you decided instead that you'd train merchant marines to handle weapons. When it was pointed out that the amount of training needed would be cost-prohibitive, you decided that you were going to be able to give "a day or so" of training with a rifle and magically obtain a lower level of weapons accidents than the US Army has been able to achieve with a multi-week basic training program.

.... which you obtain by renaming "accidents" to "negligence," which apparently keeps sailors from shooting themselves.

Not to put too fine a point on it, you're claiming that YOU PERSONALLY have a system of weapons instruction that is substantially better than that used by any professional army anywhere in the world.

None of which really addresses the fact that this is cost-prohibitive due to the low number of pirate attacks in the first place (less than 1%), which means you'd have more than 100 times more ships armed with weapons they don't know how to use than you have actual incidents.

Simple reality -- something you are unfamiliar with -- states that a weapon hundreds of miles away is safer than a weapon right here no matter what your level of training is. Simple reality also says that until someone other than the pirates (like a stupid Rambo-wannabe) starts shooting, the ships crews are in essentially no danger whatsoever.

So your proposal would subject the crewmen of the ships -- both the ones attacked and the ones not attacked -- to substantially more danger. And your shifting about the actual skills and training of the badass Rambo wannabes you would put on the ship makes it clear that it wouldn't actually add any danger or deterrence for the pirates.

So basically, it's a lose-lose proposition for all involved except your machismo.

There's nothing left. Go back to your Halo game and fantasize about what a killing machine your thumb is.
 
That's because there's nothing there to dispute. I don't need to dispute your points, because you're doing such a great job of it for me.

I pointed out that Merchant Marines aren't qualified to handle weapons, and you said that you'd replace all the merchant marines with your army buddies. It was pointed out that your army buddies aren't qualified to drive a container ship, and you decided instead that you'd train merchant marines to handle weapons. When it was pointed out that the amount of training needed would be cost-prohibitive, you decided that you were going to be able to give "a day or so" of training with a rifle and magically obtain a lower level of weapons accidents than the US Army has been able to achieve with a multi-week basic training program.

.... which you obtain by renaming "accidents" to "negligence," which apparently keeps sailors from shooting themselves.

Not to put too fine a point on it, you're claiming that YOU PERSONALLY have a system of weapons instruction that is substantially better than that used by any professional army anywhere in the world.

None of which really addresses the fact that this is cost-prohibitive due to the low number of pirate attacks in the first place (less than 1%), which means you'd have more than 100 times more ships armed with weapons they don't know how to use than you have actual incidents.

Simple reality -- something you are unfamiliar with -- states that a weapon hundreds of miles away is safer than a weapon right here no matter what your level of training is. Simple reality also says that until someone other than the pirates (like a stupid Rambo-wannabe) starts shooting, the ships crews are in essentially no danger whatsoever.

So your proposal would subject the crewmen of the ships -- both the ones attacked and the ones not attacked -- to substantially more danger. And your shifting about the actual skills and training of the badass Rambo wannabes you would put on the ship makes it clear that it wouldn't actually add any danger or deterrence for the pirates.

So basically, it's a lose-lose proposition for all involved except your machismo.

There's nothing left. Go back to your Halo game and fantasize about what a killing machine your thumb is.
That is the 18th stupidest set of statements I have heard...
Displays a tremendous lack of reading comprehension, and extreme bias against anything except cowardice.
 
Lol. Not at all. Just MINOR training with a rifle (This can be done in a day or so) and if you see pirates defend yourself

Egyptian armies in the 1970s might have been nothing special but they had more than minor training. Still couldn't hit one of Dyson's Sea Trucks.

just as you would defend your home and family if it was invaded by robbers (from the looks of it though most people would not do even that).

Not comparible senarios.
 
That's because there's nothing there to dispute. I don't need to dispute your points, because you're doing such a great job of it for me.

I pointed out that Merchant Marines aren't qualified to handle weapons, and you said that you'd replace all the merchant marines with your army buddies. It was pointed out that your army buddies aren't qualified to drive a container ship, and you decided instead that you'd train merchant marines to handle weapons. When it was pointed out that the amount of training needed would be cost-prohibitive, you decided that you were going to be able to give "a day or so" of training with a rifle and magically obtain a lower level of weapons accidents than the US Army has been able to achieve with a multi-week basic training program.

.... which you obtain by renaming "accidents" to "negligence," which apparently keeps sailors from shooting themselves.

Not to put too fine a point on it, you're claiming that YOU PERSONALLY have a system of weapons instruction that is substantially better than that used by any professional army anywhere in the world.

None of which really addresses the fact that this is cost-prohibitive due to the low number of pirate attacks in the first place (less than 1%), which means you'd have more than 100 times more ships armed with weapons they don't know how to use than you have actual incidents.

Simple reality -- something you are unfamiliar with -- states that a weapon hundreds of miles away is safer than a weapon right here no matter what your level of training is. Simple reality also says that until someone other than the pirates (like a stupid Rambo-wannabe) starts shooting, the ships crews are in essentially no danger whatsoever.

So your proposal would subject the crewmen of the ships -- both the ones attacked and the ones not attacked -- to substantially more danger. And your shifting about the actual skills and training of the badass Rambo wannabes you would put on the ship makes it clear that it wouldn't actually add any danger or deterrence for the pirates.

So basically, it's a lose-lose proposition for all involved except your machismo.

There's nothing left. Go back to your Halo game and fantasize about what a killing machine your thumb is.

Yes. I will go back to defending people like you who are incapable (or unwilling) to defend themselves.
 
Egyptian armies in the 1970s might have been nothing special but they had more than minor training. Still couldn't hit one of Dyson's Sea Trucks.



Not comparible senarios.

Almost the exact same actually. Its about defending yourself as I have said this entire time.
 
and extreme bias against anything except cowardice.

In the situation we are in any course of action that significantly increases the currently very low risk to the crews (I think the leading cause of death is being shot by the indian navy) can be considered a failure.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom