Easy solution to the pirate problem...

Almost the exact same actually. Its about defending yourself as I have said this entire time.

The pirate problem is not at this time the risk they pose to the crews.
 
The pirate problem is not at this time the risk they pose to the crews.
Did you miss the attack on the Liberty Sun last week? The goal was to destroy it and the crew. The pirates went in with guns blazing and launching RPGs at the ship, certainly not the MO they use when just looking to capture it and hold the crew ransom.
 
The pirate problem is not at this time the risk they pose to the crews.

Any time someone boards your ship with AK47s and holds you for ransom at gunpoint I am pretty sure that puts you at a pretty high risk. Since when is being held at ransom low risk?
 
Did you miss the attack on the Liberty Sun last week? The goal was to destroy it and the crew. The pirates went in with guns blazing and launching RPGs at the ship, certainly not the MO they use when just looking to capture it and hold the crew ransom.

Questionable they've hit cruise liners with RPG rounds before. I think the idea is to make them stop.
 
Any time someone boards your ship with AK47s and holds you for ransom at gunpoint I am pretty sure that puts you at a pretty high risk. Since when is being held at ransom low risk?

Since the Somalis started doing it. So far only reported deaths are the Faina's captian who aparently died of a hypertension-related stroke and the crew of that fishing boat the indian navy shot apart.

Compared to getting into a gun battle that counts as extreamly low risk.
 
Yes. I just have my branch insignia in my avatar because I think it looks cool. Lol. I am indeed an officer.
Sorry but I don't believe you, how can you ever be an officer without good perspective between gain and casualties? You also show complete lack of knowledge in other essential matters.

And looking at defending a ship from a tactical standpoint, pirates don't have a chance if they go up against a small group of individuals who have basic knowledge of firearms and BRM. This is especially true if you catch the boat approaching. The pirates on the small dinghys have very little hope of laying down accurate fire because of the platform they are shooting from. The people on the ship have a much more stable platform and have the advantage of height and cover. Not to mention the pirates still have to actually board the thing by throwing up hooks and ladders. This leaves them completely vulnerable. It would actually be relatively easy to defend a ship from pirates tactically.
Sure:
1. If you see them ahead of time.
2. If they go in a nice straight line for you to fire on them.
3. If they don't upgrade their weaponry.
4. If your cargo isn't explosive/combustive
5. If the pirates aren't already there as infiltrators and now you gave them the needed weapons.
6. If etc....

You also seem completely unable to understand that a cargo ship is slow and maneuvers poorly making it an easy target, unlike those small pirate boots.

As far as gun accidents go, I don't see them as accidents, I see them as negligence. With proper training you can completely avoid negligent discharges. And I actually have leaps and bound above police officers in forms of training as far as short rifle marksmanship, room clearing, battle drills, squad tactics, and basic rifle marksmanship go (Actually most police get NONE of this training).
Minor training with a rifle doesn't prevent accidents, except in imagination land.

And I actually do agree with you on the military convoy part. I don't believe the Navy has the resources to do this though (I may be wrong on that though).
It might just be cheaper and surely a lot saver then your idea.
 
Sorry but I don't believe you, how can you ever be an officer without good perspective between gain and casualties? You also show complete lack of knowledge in other essential matters.

Sure:
1. If you see them ahead of time.
2. If they go in a nice straight line for you to fire on them.
3. If they don't upgrade their weaponry.
4. If your cargo isn't explosive/combustive
5. If the pirates aren't already there as infiltrators and now you gave them the needed weapons.
6. If etc....

You also seem completely unable to understand that a cargo ship is slow and maneuvers poorly making it an easy target, unlike those small pirate boots.

Minor training with a rifle doesn't prevent accidents, except in imagination land.

It might just be cheaper and surely a lot saver then your idea.

Seems you aren't going to grasp simple military concepts. Noted.
 
Seems you aren't going to grasp simple military concepts. Noted.
Obviously you are not an officer. Those bad guys have got guns. They have no training. They might hurt you if you use your guns. You are merely in charge of a bunch of disciplined, well-armed-and-trained, fit soldiers who occupy the high ground.
Obviously, you must throw down the guns and give up [/french accent]
 
So what if you stop one pirate? So what if you stop one ship? There'll be another, and another, and another, who are all angry at you for shooting their folks.

And it doesn't matter that we're angry with them for kidnapping people who are trying to deliver aid to Africans?

Exactly what are we doing to politically stabilize Somalia? Nothing? Ok then, arms are the only choice.

How about some non-lethal force, then. Besides fire hoses, sonic weapons, optical weapons, etc could work.
 
Indeed they are. And if they realize that they are going to try and board a ship full of armed people willing to defend themselves against pirates, they will make the logical decision to look elsewhere for a submissive target. Thank you for illustrating that point.

Silly person. Don't you know it's much better to be taken hostage so your country can refuse payment? Or better to support the piracy by paying any and all ransoms? /sarcasm
 
Did you miss the attack on the Liberty Sun last week? The goal was to destroy it and the crew. The pirates went in with guns blazing and launching RPGs at the ship, certainly not the MO they use when just looking to capture it and hold the crew ransom.

This was a response to the SEALs shooting the pirate though. So it shows that shooting the pirates will escalate the violence.
 
I think merchant ships should arm themselves. They should provide weapons and training to every Sailor who can demonstrate the ability to safely handle a firearm.

From what I have read, some of the ships taken by the pirates did not have someone on security watch and were totally surprised. Increasing ship’s manning to include security watches, training and small arms can be expensive, but maybe less so than ransoms or replacing a cargo ship.

My experience in the Navy has taught me that a day or two of training does not make someone competent to protect a ship. This is why when the Navy really wants to protect something important, they use Marines. As far as I know, the only USN Sailors that get quality firearms training are the SEAL’s and CB’s. When I was stationed in Hawaii in the 90‘s, the typical submarine Sailor qualified to be on the armed security force shot 30 rounds through a pistol and rifle, and several rounds using a 12 gauge each year. The rest of the crew (most of the Nukes) were only allowed to use "weapons of opportunity" to defend themselves. The standard to pass was not very high. The only occasions I heard about a security watch discharging their firearms on the job were negligent discharges and two suicides.

Ranb
 
Last edited:
Obviously you are not an officer. Those bad guys have got guns. They have no training. They might hurt you if you use your guns. You are merely in charge of a bunch of disciplined, well-armed-and-trained, fit soldiers who occupy the high ground.
Obviously, you must throw down the guns and give up [/french accent]

Yep this is why we kicked ass and took names and won the Battle of Mogadishu.
 
Looking back first post was not actualy disagreeing with you, but an attempt to refine your point. My second responce was taken from what un misremembered your point to being as you took disagreement with what I was saying, when I was not indending to disagree with your point in my innitial responce to you.

So we're agreeing to... agree? Yes? :boggled:
 
Seems you aren't going to grasp simple military concepts. Noted.
I see that you can't refute or answer my statements. What you propose would be a disaster. Convoys, pirate hunting and coastal port suppression is the way to handle pirates.

I find the way that you act is consistent with a young macho teenager role-playing an army character. Hopefully they will be able to give you some common sense if you ever get in a real boot camp. Or someone in serious need of an OTH.
 
Last edited:
I see that you can't refute or answer my statements. What you propose would be a disaster. Convoys, pirate hunting and coastal port suppression is the way to handle pirates.

I find the way that you act is consistent with a young macho teenager role-playing an army character. Hopefully they will be able to give you some common sense if you ever get in a real boot camp. Or someone in serious need of an OTH.

Careful on the personal attacks (though I agree with you).

I agree that convoys, at least those with the intention to suppress or capture the pirates, is the way to go toward stopping the majority of these guys. For the ones a bit less risk-averse-- well, they're in for an unpleasant surprise (followed by a loud noise, followed quickly by the blankness of oblivion) if they try to take on military ships in a convoy. The only part I doubt is that these convoys are going to consist of many ships at a time. A few ships at once, maybe more if they're on the same schedule, is probably about all these ships are going to be able to manage with their 24/7 schedules.
 
Questionable they've hit cruise liners with RPG rounds before. I think the idea is to make them stop.
It's not questionable once you read what the pirates themselves have said about it.

And no other attacks have involved the firepower they attacked the Liberty Sun with.

And I fail to see how things could be worse if they had guns to shoot back with, instead of the water cannon they were limited to.
 
I find the way that you act is consistent with a young macho teenager role-playing an army character. Hopefully they will be able to give you some common sense if you ever get in a real boot camp. Or someone in serious need of an OTH.
I've known Quad4_72 from the SLC blog back in 2006 and seen enough of his back-and-forth with Unsecured Coins (himself an Army Sergeant) about the vagaries of life in the military to have no doubt whatsoever he is what he claims to be.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom