Easy solution to the pirate problem...

Why don't they arm themselves and get into firefights with pirates? For the same reason most bankiers and cashiers don't arm themselves and get into firefights with robbers. Because their lives, not their material possessions, are paramount. Pirates manage to board, keep crew alive, get ransom, release crew members alive so they can go home to their families.
See post 26, where the Liberty Sun was attacked with the goal of destroying the ship and crew, not to collect ransom.
 
As noted above, shooting pirates will stop those particular individuals. In addition, it will provide a strong disincentive to target that particular ship.

If I were on the ship the armed pirate were attempting to capture, I'm very certain I wouldn't give a rat's ass what his brother or cousin or uncle thought about the fact that I just shot his gun-wielding relative in the course of defending myself from being kidnapped and held for ransom or worse.

This is so blindingly obvious to me, I can't help but wonder again if you're actually serious.
I'm totally serious. But I can see that I'm arguing against a brick wall here.

So what if you stop one pirate? So what if you stop one ship? There'll be another, and another, and another, who are all angry at you for shooting their folks.

Violence begets violence. This is so completely obvious that I'm surprised that you're actually serious. Shoot one guy in the face and you've just shot one guy in the face. That's all!

Ngahh! I can't stand "gun culture". The idea that you can solve a problem by shooting it is just plain ****ing stupid. That's all I have to say.
 
OK, let's say we arm and train the skeleton crews of civilian cargo ships. Let's even say it lowers the number of pirate attacks.

Let's think of the problem in entirely economic terms.

Some number of crew members are going to get killed in firefights. Ignoring the tragedy of that, violent deaths on the job will drive the insurance companies nuts.

Some amount of damage will be done to the ships (read, "capital investment") and cargo. Again, the insurance companies will panic.

Will the costs of the gung ho solution outweigh the benefits?

Will the pirate instead turn to killing the crew, running the tankers aground, and chopping the ship up for salvage when hostage taking is no longer a money making scheme?

I'm with arthwollipot in that Somali piracy is a symptom of the madness in Somalia. Piracy's a huge problem and isn't confined to the waters around Somalia anyway. Not all pirates have the same motivation - anymore than all hijackers are interested in ransom or transport, as 9/11 taught us. Will arming the crews stop pirates who want to blow up your ship in order to say, block a canal or harbor? Will it stop pirates who want to steal the cargo? Will it stop pirates who want to stop shipping in their region by making it too dangerous? There's any number of reasons for people to attack a ship and giving the crews guns to fend off attackers won't solve them all.
 
Last edited:
I'm totally serious. But I can see that I'm arguing against a brick wall here.

So what if you stop one pirate? So what if you stop one ship? There'll be another, and another, and another, who are all angry at you for shooting their folks.

Violence begets violence. This is so completely obvious that I'm surprised that you're actually serious. Shoot one guy in the face and you've just shot one guy in the face. That's all!

Ngahh! I can't stand "gun culture". The idea that you can solve a problem by shooting it is just plain ****ing stupid. That's all I have to say.

And I can't stand the coward culture who refuses to defend themselves and let the criminals win.
 
Incorrect. You apparently are a sheep. I am an officer in the United States Army. Trust me, if someone were to try and board a ship I was on and I had a rifle, every one of those pirates would get a controlled pair right in the chest. What is it with these people that think no harm will happen to them if they just comply with the bad guys? Such cowardice. This is just inviting pirates to hi jack any ship they want knowing that they will get whatever they want from the ransom.

If you are an officer, you need to be culled. You will jeopardize the lives of every one of your shipmates because you think you are Rambo.

You obviously haven't done any research. How many pirates are involved in a typical hijacking? How many boats do they use? Where are you going to be that you can intercept every one of them before they reach the rest of the crew?

Also, look up the statistics for complying with the pirates. How many hostages have been killed by the Somali pirates that didn't involve a military raid to try and free them?
 
If you are an officer, you need to be culled. You will jeopardize the lives of every one of your shipmates because you think you are Rambo.

You obviously haven't done any research. How many pirates are involved in a typical hijacking? How many boats do they use? Where are you going to be that you can intercept every one of them before they reach the rest of the crew?

Also, look up the statistics for complying with the pirates. How many hostages have been killed by the Somali pirates that didn't involve a military raid to try and free them?

I figured you would say something about me putting people at risk as a leader. Lucky for me, if it were me and my men on that ship, every one of us would be armed and the pirates would be swiss cheese by the time they reached the ship. What good would I be in the Army if I decided to give into the demands of my enemy and be a complete coward as you suggest I do? Its not about being rambo, its about defending yourself. Glad the military does not consist of people with your mindset. If that were the case, we would surrender every time a bullet was fired.
 
I'm totally serious. But I can see that I'm arguing against a brick wall here.

So what if you stop one pirate? So what if you stop one ship? There'll be another, and another, and another, who are all angry at you for shooting their folks.

Violence begets violence. This is so completely obvious that I'm surprised that you're actually serious. Shoot one guy in the face and you've just shot one guy in the face. That's all!

Ngahh! I can't stand "gun culture". The idea that you can solve a problem by shooting it is just plain ****ing stupid. That's all I have to say.


So what if I stop an armed pirate who, in the very best case scenario, is coming aboard *just* to kidnap me for ransom?

I'm alive and free, that's what.

It's not completely obvious to me that defending myself against one group of pirates will automatically result in being attacked by another group of pirates. It is very likely that killing one group of pirates will deter other individuals from coming after my ship.

But even if it does not deter others from taking up the profession, if shooting one guy in the face is what it takes me to stay alive and free, then I've still done more than just shoot one guy in the face.
 
I think it would be fairly easy to electrify the perimeter of the ships. Put about 440 volts @ 10 amps (deadly!) through a chain link fence mounted right where they throw their grappling hooks and they'd get a big surprise when they tried to board. An AK-47 or an RPG wouldn't effect an electric fence much. It wouldn't take any more crew and it would be "on guard" 24/7. Clean up would be easier too. No blood. Just shut the electricity off so the pirates that are stuck to the fence drop off into the ocean.
 
Is it normal for bank tellers and cashiers to be taken hostage for weeks and months at a time?

Is it normal for ship crews to be taken hostage for weeks and months at a time?

In 2008, there were 115 reported pirate attacks in the Gulf of Aden. 46 were actually successful. Source.
Around 20,000 ships pass through the Gulf each year. Source.

That gives a bit less than a 0.6% chance of being attacked, and just over 0.2% chance of actually being captured, assuming all sucessful attacks actually resulted in crew being taken hostage. Not exactly "normal".

For comparison - I couldn't find any figures for the number of bank robberies, but given the number of bank branches in the UK (around 10,000) you'd need 20 robberies to have the same chance of being a victim. I wouldn't be at all surprised if there were a lot more than that. Of course, if you're going by actual harm inflicted, I'm only aware of a single hostage who has been hurt by pirates, and that was the result of a firefight between the pirates and rescuers. I don't know of any hostages being harmed where no armed people tried to get involved. Given that more than zero people have been harmed in bank robberies, your logic would mean bank staff have far more reason to arm themselves than ship crews.

Are potential kidnap victims expected to roll over and not offer any resistance?

Of course they are. Going all John Mclane may work in Hollywood, but it's a really stupid idea in real life.
 
Is it normal for ship crews to be taken hostage for weeks and months at a time?

In 2008, there were 115 reported pirate attacks in the Gulf of Aden. 46 were actually successful. Source.
Around 20,000 ships pass through the Gulf each year. Source.

That gives a bit less than a 0.6% chance of being attacked, and just over 0.2% chance of actually being captured, assuming all sucessful attacks actually resulted in crew being taken hostage. Not exactly "normal".

For comparison - I couldn't find any figures for the number of bank robberies, but given the number of bank branches in the UK (around 10,000) you'd need 20 robberies to have the same chance of being a victim. I wouldn't be at all surprised if there were a lot more than that. Of course, if you're going by actual harm inflicted, I'm only aware of a single hostage who has been hurt by pirates, and that was the result of a firefight between the pirates and rescuers. I don't know of any hostages being harmed where no armed people tried to get involved. Given that more than zero people have been harmed in bank robberies, your logic would mean bank staff have far more reason to arm themselves than ship crews.



Of course they are. Going all John Mclane may work in Hollywood, but it's a really stupid idea in real life.

So would a complete massacre of all hostages by pirates who did not get there way be enough to convince you that people need to defend themselves? Why even let it get to that point? I can guarantee you that if pirates new that ships were arming themselves and fighting back, piracy attempts would go down drastically. Plus the people who are defending the ship tactically have a HUGE advantage over the pirates attempting to board.
 
Lucky for me, if it were me and my men on that ship, every one of us would be armed

Oh, good. Now you've just put weapons into the hands of untrained sailors.

What are you going to do when they start panicking and shooting themselves by mistake.


What good would I be in the Army if I decided to give into the demands of my enemy and be a complete coward as you suggest I do?

Quite possibly more good than you would be in your current state. You'll cause a lot less unnecessary casualties -- and are much less likely to end up facing a court-martial as a result.

Glad the military does not consist of people with your mindset.

Actually, for the most part, it is. That's why I feel confident writing you off as an incompetent Rambo-wannabe. Fortunately, I'm also fairly confident you'll wash out soon.
 
Oh, good. Now you've just put weapons into the hands of untrained sailors.

What are you going to do when they start panicking and shooting themselves by mistake.




Quite possibly more good than you would be in your current state. You'll cause a lot less unnecessary casualties -- and are much less likely to end up facing a court-martial as a result.



Actually, for the most part, it is. That's why I feel confident writing you off as an incompetent Rambo-wannabe. Fortunately, I'm also fairly confident you'll wash out soon.
Wow.
This has to be a joke. An Officer in the armed forces and his men who are not trained in small arms?
Get real. I know you're not that stupid.
 
Is it normal for ship crews to be taken hostage for weeks and months at a time?
..

MANILA, Philippines -- The U.S. Navy may have rescued an American cargo ship captain, but a dramatic military intervention is unlikely for most of the the 300 or so merchant seamen held by Somali pirates because their ships now lie at anchor in pirate strongholds.

Life for them -- and their families at home -- is a grueling stretch of weeks, even months in cramped, fearful conditions, wondering about the future....

Some hostages have told of mock executions in which pirates, angered that ransom negotiations weren't going well, lined up their captives and fired weapons close to their heads...


http://www.commercialappeal.com/news/2009/apr/20/rescue-off-radar-for-pirate-captives/

MANILA, Philippines (AP) — Some hostages are little more than skin and bones, their food running out and illnesses setting in as negotiations for their release drag on, angering their volatile captors.


http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/nationworld/sns-ap-as-piracy-hostages-plight,0,4315572.story

While sailors from richer countries get freed relatively quickly in exchange for multimillion-dollar ransoms, those from poorer countries like the Philippines, Bangladesh and Indonesia often wait for months, stuck in the middle because the companies they work for can't afford to make a big payoff.


http://www.heraldextra.com/content/view/306240/36/

Five Indian sailors who were among the crew of a Japanese-owned cargo ship hijacked by pirates and held for two months before a ransom was paid said Monday their captivity was "total desperation." ...

The sailors were generally in good health when they were released, but according to the five who spoke publicly Monday conditions aboard the Stolt Valor were severe and they lived for two months in continual fear of being killed by the pirates. "We were always ... all 24 hours we were on gunpoint," said Fernandes.


http://edition.cnn.com/2008/WORLD/asiapcf/11/24/india.pirates/index.html

Yeah. No thanks.
 
Part of the problem is that most ports do not permit entry to ships that are armed. Shipping lines would have to hire third-party security services who would have to disembark prior to the ship entering port. The general consensus is probably that by arming merchant ships, you would be trading the vulnerability of individual ships for the vulnerability of entire ports.
 
Oh, good. Now you've just put weapons into the hands of untrained sailors.

It's actually worse than that. He wants to put 300+ ton ships in the hands of untrained army grunts. What's he going to do when the pirates turn into terrorists out for revenge instead of money? If one small speedboat can blow a big hole in an armored military vessel, what do you think it could do to a cargo ship?
 
So would a complete massacre of all hostages by pirates who did not get there way be enough to convince you that people need to defend themselves? Why even let it get to that point?

Why let it get to what point? As I just noted, not a single hostage has actually been physically harmed by pirates. The only casualty I'm aware of was the result of exactly the situation you advocate - armed men fighting the pirates. Why even let it get to the point of a complete massacre of all the crew because they were in a fight with pirates before you realise that maybe just handing out weapons to everyone may not be the best solution?

I can guarantee you that if pirates new that ships were arming themselves and fighting back, piracy attempts would go down drastically.

No you can't. You can certainly claim it, but that won't make it true. Unless of course you have some evidence to back that claim up. Judging from the threads I've seen on this subject so far, I'm not expecting to see any of that any time soon.


So you agree that it isn't actually normal for ships' crews to be taken hostage for weeks and months at a time? Certainly none of those links appear to dispute that.
 
Oh, good. Now you've just put weapons into the hands of untrained sailors.

I was referring to men in my command in the Army. Trust me they are plenty trained.
What are you going to do when they start panicking and shooting themselves by mistake.

Like i said, they are trained. You obviously have no idea what we do in the Army do you?

Quite possibly more good than you would be in your current state. You'll cause a lot less unnecessary casualties -- and are much less likely to end up facing a court-martial as a result.

Definitely would not face a court martial for defending me and my men from pirates who want to kidnap us and hold us for ransom. You must be completely out of your mind.


Actually, for the most part, it is. That's why I feel confident writing you off as an incompetent Rambo-wannabe. Fortunately, I'm also fairly confident you'll wash out soon.

Again, you know nothing of the Army. Wanting to defend myself and my men against pirates is like Rambo? Actually its called executing my duties and carrying out the soldiers creed.
 
It's actually worse than that. He wants to put 300+ ton ships in the hands of untrained army grunts. What's he going to do when the pirates turn into terrorists out for revenge instead of money? If one small speedboat can blow a big hole in an armored military vessel, what do you think it could do to a cargo ship?

Untrained Army grunts? Far from it. You know NOTHING about the Army. And if they want to go suicidal so be it. You take casualties in war, but you sure as HELL never surrender.
 
Its not about defending material goods. Its about defending yourself.
No. From your posts I have more than gathered that this isn't about defending yourself at all. It's about macho bravado, a principle that if you don't choose violence as your first option you're a coward and "let the bad guys win". Hence - all about principles and material possessions. Personal safety isn't your objective, it's retaining your honour. It's this kind of thinking that made hordes of Japanese troops leap off of cliffs on Iwo Jimo.

You sound like a Viking afraid of not making the valkyrie ride to Valhalla, and I'm very, very glad, for the sake of the freight crews and the overall situation in the area, that the people in charge of the freight businesses don't think the way you do.

We have warships in the area for a reason. No one is talking about "letting the pirates go". What we're saying is that we currently have a situation in which freighter crews don't get hurt in the process, and neither we, nor the freighter crewmen, nor their loved ones, want a situation in which pirates capture ships by killing everyone on board with RPG-7 and AK-47 fire.

All of which is wasted on people like you, who are never happy with a conflict resolution that doesn't involve something getting blown up at the first opportunity.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom