Easy solution to the pirate problem...

Quad4_72

AI-EE-YAH!
Joined
Nov 7, 2006
Messages
6,354
I’m not sure if this has been discussed in other threads, but if pirates are such a big problem, why don't the crews of ships ARM THEMSELVES??? I really have trouble seeing why they don't do this. Even if you had just one AK47 on a ship and a person who was even remotely trained with it, they could defend an entire tanker. Its really easy to see if another little boat is approaching your ship. All you have to do is grab the AK, fire some warning shots at it. If they fail to stop, light them up. Its not like there is much cover that can be used on those crappy little boats those pirates ride. Then on top of that they would have to board the ship while being shot at. As for them firing back, well its pretty hard to lay down any accurate fire when riding those little rafts that get knocked around everywhere.

Is there a reason crews have not taken to arms to defend their ships?
 
I saw a news story that showed a crew that every crew member carried a pistol, and they also had M4 rifles in storage on the boat. They showed them on the range, and I don't think the pirates would have won the firefight. But my research shows that this is not at all common. Most boats rely on fire hoses to repel boarding parties. My guess is that pistols, at least, will become more common.
 
Why not just sail, oh, say, 100 miles further off the coast?

Like Qaddafi's fighter pilots who wouldn't fly in the dark, I'll bet the Somali pirates don't like to sail that far over the horizon. An extras 100 miles would make a lot of other targets seem easier to find.
 
Why not just sail, oh, say, 100 miles further off the coast?

Like Qaddafi's fighter pilots who wouldn't fly in the dark, I'll bet the Somali pirates don't like to sail that far over the horizon. An extras 100 miles would make a lot of other targets seem easier to find.

They took a tanker from 900 miles away, didn't they? Desperation knows no geography.
 
I saw a news story that showed a crew that every crew member carried a pistol, and they also had M4 rifles in storage on the boat. They showed them on the range, and I don't think the pirates would have won the firefight. But my research shows that this is not at all common. Most boats rely on fire hoses to repel boarding parties. My guess is that pistols, at least, will become more common.

See that makes sense. It blows my mind that there are all of these stories about pirates capturing ships and no one had armed themselves. Just don't understand it.
 
I’m not sure if this has been discussed in other threads, but if pirates are such a big problem, why don't the crews of ships ARM THEMSELVES??? I really have trouble seeing why they don't do this. Even if you had just one AK47 on a ship and a person who was even remotely trained with it, they could defend an entire tanker. Its really easy to see if another little boat is approaching your ship. All you have to do is grab the AK, fire some warning shots at it.

RPG-7 comeing the other way say hi Mr crewman about to ruin your whole day.

If they fail to stop, light them up. Its not like there is much cover that can be used on those crappy little boats those pirates ride. Then on top of that they would have to board the ship while being shot at. As for them firing back, well its pretty hard to lay down any accurate fire when riding those little rafts that get knocked around everywhere.

Which also makes them pretty much imposible to hit unless you are trained to western militry standards. Egypt was playing around with the idea of small boats back in the 70s? Found the things nearly impossible to hit.

Is there a reason crews have not taken to arms to defend their ships?

Not their ships. They don't own them or the cargo. They are not paid to get into firefights with Somalis. Somali pirates on there other hand by defintion live in somali where haveing someone spray AK fire at you is pretty much a daily hazard.
 
I’m not sure if this has been discussed in other threads, but if pirates are such a big problem, why don't the crews of ships ARM THEMSELVES??? I really have trouble seeing why they don't do this. Even if you had just one AK47 on a ship and a person who was even remotely trained with it, they could defend an entire tanker. Its really easy to see if another little boat is approaching your ship. All you have to do is grab the AK, fire some warning shots at it. If they fail to stop, light them up. Its not like there is much cover that can be used on those crappy little boats those pirates ride. Then on top of that they would have to board the ship while being shot at. As for them firing back, well its pretty hard to lay down any accurate fire when riding those little rafts that get knocked around everywhere.

Is there a reason crews have not taken to arms to defend their ships?

Whenever the question "but why don't thy..." is asked, 99% of the time the answer is the same. "money".

To do what you describe shipping companies would need to :

Buy in weapons. Buy in ammunition. This could range from a few grand per ship to a few million per ship, depending on what you buy.

Hire personnel to man the weapons. Here's your big worry. Most cargo ships have tiny crews; mounting even a single 24/7 guard means putting 2 or 3 extra crew on each ship. For a decent all around watch you can multiply that by 3 or 4, and you probably just doubled your personnel costs per trip at least.

Not to mention all that is harder and more expensive still if you want to operate in the dark.

Then there's the training for all these armed guards.

Then there are the insurance issues. How much is an insurance company going to charge you, per armed guard, to protect against some guy unloading at a passing fishing boat because he got spooked? I don't know, but I imagine it would be a lot.

And bear in mind that 99% of the time, these precautions accomplish precisely nothing because most shipping isn't attacked.

Somewhere along the way a bean counter has worked out the total cost of protecting all these ships, and then looked at the total cost of just paying off the pirates, and decided that X > Y.

Course the trouble with that calculation is that as the pirates realise how easy it is, they too will grow in numbers and audacity. This will happen until we reach a tipping point where Y becomes less than X, and that is the point at which armed guards will magically appear all over these ships.
 
RPG-7 comeing the other way say hi Mr crewman about to ruin your whole day.



Which also makes them pretty much imposible to hit unless you are trained to western militry standards. Egypt was playing around with the idea of small boats back in the 70s? Found the things nearly impossible to hit.



Not their ships. They don't own them or the cargo. They are not paid to get into firefights with Somalis. Somali pirates on there other hand by defintion live in somali where haveing someone spray AK fire at you is pretty much a daily hazard.

Most of what you said doesn't make sense and I am not sure what you are talking about. This is mainly due to poor grammar. But from what I can decipher, you are saying that the crew doesn't want to defend the ship because it isn't their cargo and they aren't paid to. This is true, but really is quite irrelevant. I don't know about you, but if pirates were approaching my ship I would be defending MYSELF, not the cargo.
 
Whenever the question "but why don't thy..." is asked, 99% of the time the answer is the same. "money".

To do what you describe shipping companies would need to :

Buy in weapons. Buy in ammunition. This could range from a few grand per ship to a few million per ship, depending on what you buy.

Hire personnel to man the weapons. Here's your big worry. Most cargo ships have tiny crews; mounting even a single 24/7 guard means putting 2 or 3 extra crew on each ship. For a decent all around watch you can multiply that by 3 or 4, and you probably just doubled your personnel costs per trip at least.

Not to mention all that is harder and more expensive still if you want to operate in the dark.

Then there's the training for all these armed guards.

Then there are the insurance issues. How much is an insurance company going to charge you, per armed guard, to protect against some guy unloading at a passing fishing boat because he got spooked? I don't know, but I imagine it would be a lot.

And bear in mind that 99% of the time, these precautions accomplish precisely nothing because most shipping isn't attacked.

Somewhere along the way a bean counter has worked out the total cost of protecting all these ships, and then looked at the total cost of just paying off the pirates, and decided that X > Y.

Course the trouble with that calculation is that as the pirates realise how easy it is, they too will grow in numbers and audacity. This will happen until we reach a tipping point where Y becomes less than X, and that is the point at which armed guards will magically appear all over these ships.

Very good point. Money is a huge factor. What would fix the money problem is allowing the crew to bring personal weapons aboard. Then there comes the insurance thing into it. Its quite sad that the shipping companies would be more worried about insurance issues with having weapons aboard rather then the crew having a means to defend themselves.
 
Most of what you said doesn't make sense and I am not sure what you are talking about. This is mainly due to poor grammar. But from what I can decipher, you are saying that the crew doesn't want to defend the ship because it isn't their cargo and they aren't paid to. This is true, but really is quite irrelevant. I don't know about you, but if pirates were approaching my ship I would be defending MYSELF, not the cargo.

You are not at risk. The priates have been pretty good at treating the captive crews well. But start a firefight with them and they will fight back. Remeber they are likely far more risk tolerant than you are.
 
Course the trouble with that calculation is that as the pirates realise how easy it is, they too will grow in numbers and audacity. This will happen until we reach a tipping point where Y becomes less than X, and that is the point at which armed guards will magically appear all over these ships.

That assumes that the cost is less than going via the horn of africa.
 
You are not at risk. The priates have been pretty good at treating the captive crews well. But start a firefight with them and they will fight back. Remeber they are likely far more risk tolerant than you are.


I'm not super brave. But if armed pirates were trying to kidnap me, I'd fight back. Regardless of how well other pirates have treated captives in the past.

I'm also not so sure about the risk tolerance thing. If I saw a grappling hook on the side of the ship, I'm pretty sure I could muster the courage to stick a 12-gauge shotgun over the side and pump a few rounds down the rope. Do you think your average pirate would be risk tolerant enough to climb up into that?
 
You are not at risk. The priates have been pretty good at treating the captive crews well. But start a firefight with them and they will fight back. Remeber they are likely far more risk tolerant than you are.

Uh yes, you are at risk if armed pirates come aboard your ship and hold you hostage. I think that is pretty much the definition of being at risk. And I can promise you this, if I caught some pirates trying to board my ship and I had a rifle, everyone of them would be dead and rotting at the bottom of the ocean. There are wolves, sheep, and sheep dogs in this world, and I will be DAMNED if I am ever a sheep.
 
The pirates are after easy money. Sure, if you shoot at them, most of them will shoot back, but if they realise that attacking ships flying American flags means that they will have to have a firefight, and a few of their pirate buddies don't come back from these "missions", they'll look for easier targets.


I sure wouldn't trust the mercy of dangerous criminals. If I was armed, I'd do my best to protect myself and my crew mates. As has been mentioned before in other threads, if you have a firearm, you have a chance, unarmed, you're helpless.
 
I saw an interesting suggestion somewhere to pay Somali locals, individuals and small groups -- like the pirates, to fight the pirates. Sort of funding a Somali coast guard for the benefit of external shipping. Of course many of these coast guard would be pirates or former pirates. Kind of like paying a protection racket, but it could work.
 
I saw an interesting suggestion somewhere to pay Somali locals, individuals and small groups -- like the pirates, to fight the pirates. Sort of funding a Somali coast guard for the benefit of external shipping. Of course many of these coast guard would be pirates or former pirates. Kind of like paying a protection racket, but it could work.


How is that any different from what's happening now?

"Pay us 'protection' and we'll let your ship and crew go."

What do we do when the "protection" pirates start colluding with the "pirate" pirates to drive up their "fee" by seizing more ships?

ETA: I'm normally not a big Ron Paul fan, but if we're going with the "fight fire with fire" route, I sort of liked the idea reviving letters of marque. Of course, one problem with that is privateers usually made their money from the sale of the captured ships. Most of the Somali pirate "ships" are tiny skiffs or other assorted pieces of crap.
 
Last edited:
How is that any different from what's happening now?

"Pay us 'protection' and we'll let your ship and crew go."

What do we do when the "protection" pirates start colluding with the "pirate" pirates to drive up their "fee" by seizing more ships?

ETA: I'm normally not a big Ron Paul fan, but if we're going with the "fight fire with fire" route, I sort of liked the idea reviving letter of marque. Of course, one problem with that is privateers usually made their money from the sale of the captured ships. Most of the Somali pirate "ships" are tiny skiffs or other assorted pieces of crap.



It's different in that it would entail ships not being hijacked (hypothetically, if it works) in the first place. Your question about the collusion between protector and pirate is a good one. It's a question of balance of the cost of ransom vs the cost of convoying vs the cost upfront protection payments, etc.

As for letters of marque, your point about the way money is made tells it all. There is no incentive for private interests to take this on for prize money -- there is none.
 
Perhaps because the solution to some problems is not simply to throw more guns at it? Somali piracy is a complex societal problem, not a problem about who has more firepower. You won't stop the pirates just by shooting them. I mean, look at how well that has worked in Iraq.

Anyway, with all these pirates about, we don't have to worry so much about global warming. :rolleyes:
 
Not their ships. They don't own them or the cargo. They are not paid to get into firefights with Somalis. Somali pirates on there other hand by defintion live in somali where haveing someone spray AK fire at you is pretty much a daily hazard.
People seldom need to get paid in order to defend themselves....
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom