Easy solution to the pirate problem...

So you agree that it isn't actually normal for ships' crews to be taken hostage for weeks and months at a time? Certainly none of those links appear to dispute that.


If you're counting the total number of ships sailing through the area, then yes. It is unusual for crews to be held for any length of time.

If you're considering the plight of those actually captured, then no. The links I provided show it is not at all unusual for those seized to be held for weeks and months at a time. The articles also provide evidence to dispute the idea that the Somali pirates always treat their captives well.

Even more support for the idea that it's better not be captured.
 
Obviously you are not an officer. Those bad guys have got guns. They have no training. They might hurt you if you use your guns. You are merely in charge of a bunch of disciplined, well-armed-and-trained, fit soldiers who occupy the high ground.
Obviously, you must throw down the guns and give up [/french accent]

Generaly merchant seamen are not disciplined, trained and fit soldiers. The high ground in this case doesn't mean as much as you would expect since PRGs redress the balance somewhat. As for no trainin the the pirates side they aparently managed to survive in somalia.
 
Generaly merchant seamen are not disciplined, trained and fit soldiers. The high ground in this case doesn't mean as much as you would expect since PRGs redress the balance somewhat. As for no trainin the the pirates side they aparently managed to survive in somalia.
Reading comprehension is NOT your strong suite, is it?
Quad was talking about HIS GUYS. Not Merchant Marines.
Please try to keep up, m'kay?
 
What is your solution except roll over and play dead for the pirates?

Explain to the shipping companies that you do not view the fate of Liberian and Belize registered ships as your problem. Use any money raised from re-flagging to purchase anti-pirate patrol boats (should be posible to convert someone of the smaller and faster container ships).
 
I've known Quad4_72 from the SLC blog back in 2006 and seen enough of his back-and-forth with Unsecured Coins (himself an Army Sergeant) about the vagaries of life in the military to have no doubt whatsoever he is what he claims to be.
That does change my opinion slightly, and not necessary in a good way. I would be more forgiving of the act of stupidity if it was from a teen.
 
Reading comprehension is NOT your strong suite, is it?
Quad was talking about HIS GUYS. Not Merchant Marines.
Please try to keep up, m'kay?

Not really significant because the people on the ships are merchant seamen and will continue to be for the forseable future.

What well trained soldiers can do is really of no significance in such a senario.
 
That does change my opinion slightly, and not necessary in a good way. I would be more forgiving of the act of stupidity if it was from a teen.
I've seen no stupidity from him, only the courage of his convictions.

Maybe you should also go on a rant about the SEALs who took out the three pirates last week?
 
I've seen no stupidity from him, only the courage of his convictions.

The problem is his convictions are not supported by any standard theory of warfare or actual combat history involveing untrained fighters or small boats.


Maybe you should also go on a rant about the SEALs who took out the three pirates last week?

Not really relivant.
 
Not really significant because the people on the ships are merchant seamen and will continue to be for the forseable future.

What well trained soldiers can do is really of no significance in such a senario.
You don't have to be a world-class marksman to hit a boatload of pirates in an open boat from the stern of a ship.

I'd bet it's a hell of a lot easier than hitting them with the water cannons they are relegated to currently.
 
The problem is his convictions are not supported by any standard theory of warfare or actual combat history involveing untrained fighters or small boats.
And what is the "standard theory" of untrained fighters in small open boats attacking an 800 foot boat with armed men aboard?

Not really relivant.
Except for being a recent real-world example of exactly what we're talking about...
 
I've seen no stupidity from him, only the courage of his convictions.
There is no courage in convictions, only in actions. If he is to blindly follow his convictions no matter what the circumstances it will lead to senseless tragedy.

There is more courage in a leader who would offer himself as a hostage then a macho who would rather see everyone die in a blaze of glory. For the people who desire a blaze of glory don't have the courage to face their own ego after a defeat.


Maybe you should also go on a rant about the SEALs who took out the three pirates last week?
I don't actually think those SEALs had a choice, the shot had to be made.
 
Shooting pirates does not, in any way, address the cause of piracy. Until the socioeconomic problems in Somalia are addressed, there'll just be more pirates.

I see it as a bit of a medical analogy.

The socio-economic collapse of Somalia may be the cause of the disease, with rampant piracy being one of the symptoms.

Just because we don't currently have a cure for the cause, does that mean we should not try and alleviate the symptoms?

Blowing the pirates out of the water may not be the best way to deal with this, but sitting back and waiting for the root cause to be fixed seems to be a very naive approach.

V.
 
You don't have to be a world-class marksman to hit a boatload of pirates in an open boat from the stern of a ship.

I'd bet it's a hell of a lot easier than hitting them with the water cannons they are relegated to currently.

Now the interesting thing about that claim is we actualy know about a case where less than world class people have tried. Back in what was probably 72 the Egyptains who are aparently slighly more relaxed about safety standards than most of us put a guy in a sea truck (a boat designed by James Dyson of vacuum cleaner fame) and tried to shoot him. They failed.

In case you are woundering why Egypt tried this it was because it went on to use them during the first day of the Yom Kippur War.
 
Now the interesting thing about that claim is we actualy know about a case where less than world class people have tried. Back in what was probably 72 the Egyptains who are aparently slighly more relaxed about safety standards than most of us put a guy in a sea truck (a boat designed by James Dyson of vacuum cleaner fame) and tried to shoot him. They failed.

In case you are woundering why Egypt tried this it was because it went on to use them during the first day of the Yom Kippur War.
I think you'll find the time it takes to cross the Suez canal in a high-speed boat is considerably less than the amount of time it takes to chase down and board a ship in a similar boat. The banks are also much lower than the deck of a ship.

I highly doubt they were using them to attack Israeli ships, unless they were suicide missions.
 
Obviously you are not an officer. Those bad guys have got guns. They have no training. They might hurt you if you use your guns. You are merely in charge of a bunch of disciplined, well-armed-and-trained, fit soldiers who occupy the high ground.
Obviously, you must throw down the guns and give up [/french accent]

Lol of course. Why fight back when you can surrender and hope not to get harmed!
 
I see that you can't refute or answer my statements. What you propose would be a disaster. Convoys, pirate hunting and coastal port suppression is the way to handle pirates.

I find the way that you act is consistent with a young macho teenager role-playing an army character. Hopefully they will be able to give you some common sense if you ever get in a real boot camp. Or someone in serious need of an OTH.

Why talk about military tactics with someone who has absolutely no comprehension of them? As far as me being an officer, I could post my CAC card if you would like but I have no means of blocking out my pic/name etc. If I sent it to Wildcat and had him confirm it would you believe me then?
 
Why talk about military tactics with someone who has absolutely no comprehension of them?
Go look at yourself and be ashamed:
You take casualties in war, but you sure as HELL never surrender.



As far as me being an officer, I could post my CAC card if you would like but I have no means of blocking out my pic/name etc. If I sent it to Wildcat and had him confirm it would you believe me then?
Go read posts:
120, 125, 127, 131.
 
There is no courage in convictions, only in actions. If he is to blindly follow his convictions no matter what the circumstances it will lead to senseless tragedy.

There is more courage in a leader who would offer himself as a hostage then a macho who would rather see everyone die in a blaze of glory. For the people who desire a blaze of glory don't have the courage to face their own ego after a defeat.


I don't actually think those SEALs had a choice, the shot had to be made.

No where did I ever say that I would love for my men to go down in a blaze of glory. But you can bet your ass we would do everything in our power to defend the ship.
 
I think you'll find the time it takes to cross the Suez canal in a high-speed boat is considerably less than the amount of time it takes to chase down and board a ship in a similar boat. The banks are also much lower than the deck of a ship.

No evidence that hight helps you against small craft. And the example I was useing was the testing not the actual attack.

I highly doubt they were using them to attack Israeli ships, unless they were suicide missions.

I think the Egytians demonstraited that they didn't need suicide tactics in that area when they took out INS Eilat in 67. Fortunety I don't think the somalis are likely to get their hands on anti-ship missiles and time soon. If they do we have a serious problem.
 
Go look at yourself and be ashamed:




Go read posts:
120, 125, 127, 131.

Not following here. You take casualties in war and you don't surrender to the enemy if you have a means to fight. Whats so hard to understand?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom