Easy solution to the pirate problem...

Why let it get to what point? As I just noted, not a single hostage has actually been physically harmed by pirates. The only casualty I'm aware of was the result of exactly the situation you advocate - armed men fighting the pirates. Why even let it get to the point of a complete massacre of all the crew because they were in a fight with pirates before you realise that maybe just handing out weapons to everyone may not be the best solution?

Yes as of right now there have not been very many civilian casualties. But does that mean we should just let pirates keep hijacking vessels and give into their demands every time so nobody gets hurt? Great, the pirates win. Grow some damn spines people.

No you can't. You can certainly claim it, but that won't make it true. Unless of course you have some evidence to back that claim up. Judging from the threads I've seen on this subject so far, I'm not expecting to see any of that any time soon.


So you agree that it isn't actually normal for ships' crews to be taken hostage for weeks and months at a time? Certainly none of those links appear to dispute that.

No its not normal for crews to be taken hostage. Just like its not normal for fires to start in a building. But do you still have sprinkler systems and fire extinguishers?
 
No. From your posts I have more than gathered that this isn't about defending yourself at all. It's about macho bravado, a principle that if you don't choose violence as your first option you're a coward and "let the bad guys win". Hence - all about principles and material possessions. Personal safety isn't your objective, it's retaining your honour. It's this kind of thinking that made hordes of Japanese troops leap off of cliffs on Iwo Jimo.

You sound like a Viking afraid of not getting into Valhalla, and I'm very, very glad, for the sake of the freight crews and the overall situation in the area, that the people in charge of the freight businesses don't think the way you do.

I think I have stated in almost every post I made it's about defending yourself. If someone wants to do me harm or hold me hostage you bet your ass I am going to take some action and defend myself. Its sad that you would not do the same for yourself. That's your decision.
 
If crews were armed it never would have come to a shoot out. Simply look at the many examples of unarmed crews driving off pirates. The pirates are not hardened soldiers willing to go into battle. They're opportunists, using the posturing of their weapons and relying on the submission of their targets.

If their targets stop being submissive and start protecting themselves the pirates will rapidly decide to look elsewhere for their targets.

I find that questionable, somalia has not seemed to have problems finding people to fight for various warlords. Why would fighting for a pirate leader instead of a warlord change what risk people are willing to accept?
 
So would a complete massacre of all hostages by pirates who did not get there way be enough to convince you that people need to defend themselves? Why even let it get to that point?
This is the same kind of warped logic I hear from people who want all robbers shot because "how do you know he won't shoot you once he has the money?". Short-sighted, non-thinking rubbish. A robber has a situation in which he can take the money at gunpoint, run, and evade an investigation for robbery. Or he can shoot the clerk, gain absolutely nothing in doing so, and get hunted for robbery and cold-blooded, homicide, plus an increased risk that store clerks will shoot on sight.

Robbers and pirates aren't blood-thirsty animals who kill, rape and take the lord's name in vain the first opportunity they get. They're human beings who are capable of making risk judgements.

Oh, wait, it's not about safety, it's about scoring Honour Points with Odin and great Patton in the sky so they won't think you're a bleeding-heart chicken. My bad.

I think I have stated in almost every post I made it's about defending yourself.
I don't believe you. Not after we have pointed out, in just about every single one of our posts, that self-defence isn't necessary as the pirates have no reason to kill you.

Sorry, but I just don't believe you.
 
Last edited:
It's actually worse than that. He wants to put 300+ ton ships in the hands of untrained army grunts. What's he going to do when the pirates turn into terrorists out for revenge instead of money? If one small speedboat can blow a big hole in an armored military vessel, what do you think it could do to a cargo ship?

This bears repeating. More than once in this thread.
 
This is the same kind of warped logic I hear from people who want all robbers shot because "how do you know he won't shoot you once he has the money?". Short-sighted, non-thinking rubbish. A robber has a situation in which he can take the money at gunpoint, run, and evade an investigation for robbery. Or he can shoot the clerk, gain absolutely nothing in doing so, and get hunted for robbery and cold-blooded, homicide, plus an increased risk that store clerks will shoot on sight.

Robbers and pirates aren't blood-thirsty animals who kill, rape and take the lord's name in vain the first opportunity they get. They're human beings who are capable of making risk judgements.

Oh, wait, it's not about safety, it's about scoring Honour Points with Odin and great Patton in the sky so they won't think you're a bleeding-heart chicken. My bad.

I don't believe you. Not after we have pointed out, in just about every single one of our posts, that self-defence isn't necessary as the pirates have no reason to kill you.

Sorry, but I just don't believe you.
And I don't believe anyone is as idiotic as that attitude suggests.
I'll bet you're really sorry that your countrymen didn't feel that way back in the 1941-45 timeframe.
I, for one, am grateful that people like Quad4-72 exist, and are willing to go to the front, putting themselves between people like yourself and harm.
Pirates enter the field because it is lucrative. The price they pay (getting caught and released because most countries cannot prosecute-see links above) is well wothh the reward--$10-20 million ransom.
Make it worth their lives, and they start re-thinking.
Make apologies for them, feel sorry for them, and they keep doing it.
The idiotic notion that they'll leave us alone if we pay them off has NEVER worked.
 
And I don't believe anyone is as idiotic as that attitude suggests.
I'll bet you're really sorry that your countrymen didn't feel that way back in the 1941-45 timeframe.
I, for one, am grateful that people like Quad4-72 exist, and are willing to go to the front, putting themselves between people like yourself and harm.
Pirates enter the field because it is lucrative. The price they pay (getting caught and released because most countries cannot prosecute-see links above) is well wothh the reward--$10-20 million ransom.
Make it worth their lives, and they start re-thinking.
Make apologies for them, feel sorry for them, and they keep doing it.
The idiotic notion that they'll leave us alone if we pay them off has NEVER worked.

How many crews being killed does it make this a bad idea? This would mean that they don't try to take the crew alive for one. I am not sure that I would bet that you can't find enough men in the somalia to make this worth while even if they do get shot at. Child armies and the like don't break when ever someone shoots a few bullets at them.
 
This bears repeating. More than once in this thread.

So what, the people advocating force the most are not concerned with loss of life of the sailors, or loss of ships. It is about making the ethicaly correct choice not the most practical choice.
 
I don't understand why they can't be turned over to the countries whose nationals they did attack.

Ships are for the most part flagged in the likes of liberia. I'm not sure that trying to ship pirates there would work too well.
 
Not to seem like I'm choosing a side in this argument, because I really have no authority or knowledge when it comes to this topic, but many of the posters advocating the carrying of arms remind me of myself when I'm envisioning my "what-I'd-do-if-a-robber-came-in-the-middle-of-the-night" scenarios.

It always works out so perfectly. Despite the fact that have no martial arts experience and am half the size of most grown men, I imagine myself grabbing a lamp or nearby object and turning in to Jackie Chan on speed.

Now, I can see the other side's point of view. I'm certainly not going to lay there and give up when the robber shows up at my door. And having training in self-defense would certainly enhance my likelihood of being able to protect myself. But then again, it's not typical of house robbers to only want to hold the occupants for ransom.
 
I was referring to men in my command in the Army.

Like i said, they are trained. You obviously have no idea what we do in the Army do you?

No, you obviously don't know what they in the Merchant Marine do.

Definitely would not face a court martial for defending me and my men from pirates who want to kidnap us and hold us for ransom. You must be completely out of your mind.

No, it would be for willfully and unreasonably damaging non-military property. UCMJ, Article 109. And since the ship you just damaged is worth substantially more than $500, you're looking at 5 years and a DD.

Although I would hold onto that "completely out of your mind" line, because your only chance at court-martial would be an insanity defense.
 
You take casualties in war, but you sure as HELL never surrender.
To be honest I would be very surprised if you are an officer. Forget about that, there is no way that you're an officer in any competent military. For every officer must be able to make a 'casualties vs gain' assessment and if the gain doesn't warrant the casualties and there is no way to retreat, then surrender must be considered. And you seem simply incapable of that.

You're likely to get some of the crew killed for no to little gain (in a good case scenario). The amount of gun accidents deaths is likely to be larger then that of hostage deaths. My advice to you is really stick with your specific army job as you don't even qualify to do police work.

If we really want to stop pirates then were more likely see a return of the convoy system with one or more military ships per convoy.
 
So what, the people advocating force the most are not concerned with loss of life of the sailors, or loss of ships. It is about making the ethicaly correct choice not the most practical choice.

That's not what I'm saying, and it's not a mutually exclusive one-or-the-other choice.
 
I was referring to men in my command in the Army. Trust me they are plenty trained.

We are talking about merchant ship here, no? I'm no longer entirely sure if you are also talking about that branch, but I assume you are, because you claim to have an easy solution to the pirate problem, and surely most of the victims of piracy are commercial vessels.

You say that we should arm the crews. But not only that: it seems you also want to train them to be well-disciplined army sailors. That makes some sense, because putting weapons in the hands of the untrained is quite stupid. However, I think doing that is a bit steep if not silly. I don't think you can expect these crewmembers to get military training to before they can become commercial sailors. But hey, perhaps they have time for training when they are on long voyages, so we can get around that argument. Ofcourse the main objection, as has been brought up: it is just very very costly.

Now let's just throw those practicalities overboard and say that the harbors can be secured and there is enough money to arm the thousands of commercial ships and train their crews. It'll take a money forrest, but let's say it is deemed worth the investment.

There are a couple of foreseeable results. First, the pirates will just get vicious. Many ships will sink when the pirates are faced with a counterfire. Second, they will attack more oil tankers and carriers of other flamable stuff. (Oh, but we're in imagination land, so let's put plates of armor on those!) Third, weapons are explosive devices, in the figurative sense as well as literally. More weapons equals more bullets being fired by or against you. It makes the entire naval scape more volatile. And weapons are items which can be lost or stolen by crew. Or by infiltrating pirates. We're dealing with commercial ships and enterprises here. Crews get on and off boats, the boats are leased to different companies, it's far more chaotically organized than a single body such as the army (which might be pretty well organized and still not entirely unchaotic, you must know).

Reality forces me back to the practicalities, which I tried to throw overboard earlier in this reply. It is just inevitable. There's problems everywhere. You need to have a really good reason for me to discard those. You haven't. Nor is your solution ethically sound.

There are 2 big problems with your way of thinking.

One: You seem to envision that honour and cowardice are players of some significance in the real world. They have no commercial value and they are not going to repel or (resp.) attract pirate renegades by themselves. Money and poverty are big players for the pirates, and has everything to do with their survival and desperation.

Two: We're not in the army! Sailors are not armed personnel. They do not like to shoot people and can't be expected to do that as part of their job description. So guns do not belong in their equipment, either. Because guns are for killing. If you insist on putting arms on board, you need to put them in the hands of army squads, with a very high chance that they will be paid and unavailable for weeks, without contributing anything. The fact that it seems an easy solution to you to just distribute guns and training, to turn normal people into killing machines such as yourself is thoughtprovoking, or so it should be. Army boy.
 
Last edited:
That's not what I'm saying, and it's not a mutually exclusive one-or-the-other choice.

So you cooperate when you know ahead of time that that will be the best outcome, and kill all the pirates when you know ahead of time that will be the best outcome? Where are you getting this foresight?

Look at Quad4, he is advocating a strategy that is rather opposite the one that is working in Iraq. He is advocating force, when bribary is what is reducing violence in Iraq.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom