Why don't they arm themselves and get into firefights with pirates? For the same reason most bankiers and cashiers don't arm themselves and get into firefights with robbers. Because their lives, not their material possessions, are paramount. Pirates manage to board, keep crew alive, get ransom, release crew members alive so they can go home to their families.
Well,
I don't understand, for the bare life of
me, how "human lives over material goods" is so hard to understand for certain residents of a certain otherwise-very-civilized-and-mostly-great-to-live-in North American country. Everyone else seem to understand it so well

.