Easy solution to the pirate problem...

You are not at risk. The priates have been pretty good at treating the captive crews well.
They're also on record as saying they will kill any American or French nationals they capture.
 
They're also on record as saying they will kill any American or French nationals they capture.


Whoever "they" are. Somali pirates are disconnected small groups, so whoever made this claim about killing Americans and French can't make it happen. Live hostages bring ransom. Money is the point of the enterprise.
 
I think there's a much easier solution to this problem. That part of the ocean is already crawling with naval vessels filled with highly trained, skilled and well quipped men and women. Recently NATO forces liberated a ship only to disarm the pirates and let them go because they had no authority to detain them.

That can be solved with a simple piece of paper.

Give all UN-member naval forces open ROEs for dealing with pirates. Shoot them on sight. That would be bound to make piracy a less appealing prospect.
 
You won't stop the pirates just by shooting them.


You must be joking.

If not, what do you think the pirate in my example above who takes the 12-gauge shotgun round to the face is going to say?

"Arrgh ... you may have blown my face off, but I'll be back for more, matey ..." ?!?

You must mean "You won't stop all piracy by shooting some of them" because I can pretty well guarantee the one who gets his eyes blown out is done.

And even if you don't stop all piracy, the crew's goal is to convince those specific pirates that attacking their ship is a bad idea and that there are other easier targets out there. Shooting them is a very good way to emphasize this point.
 
Give all UN-member naval forces open ROEs for dealing with pirates. Shoot them on sight. That would be bound to make piracy a less appealing prospect.


Exactly. This and armed merchant crews would make a big difference.
 
Last edited:
Whoever "they" are. Somali pirates are disconnected small groups, so whoever made this claim about killing Americans and French can't make it happen. Live hostages bring ransom. Money is the point of the enterprise.
And the French and Americans have made it tougher to make money by killing pirates.

And in fact, they already tried to kill Americans:
The 64,000-tonne Liberty Sun was pounded with rocket propelled grenades and automatic weapons fire but eventually managed to escape.

"This attack was the first against our prime target," Abdi Garad, a pirate commander from central Somalia, said.

"We intended to destroy this American-flagged ship and the crew on board but unfortunately they narrowly escaped us.

"We assigned a team with special equipment to chase and destroy any ship flying the American flag in retaliation for the brutal killing of our friends."
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/wor...-cargo-ship-to-avenge-deaths-of-comrades.html
 
You must be joking.

If not, what do you think the pirate in my example above who takes the 12-gauge shotgun round to the face is going to say?

"Arrgh ... you may have blown my face off, but I'll be back for more, matey ..." ?!?

You must mean "You won't stop all piracy by shooting some of them" because I can pretty well guarantee the one who gets his eyes blown out is done.

And even if you don't stop all piracy, the crew's goal is to convince those specific pirates that attacking their ship is a bad idea and that there are other easier targets out there. Shooting them is a very good way to emphasize this point.
*sigh*. Way to miss the point.

Shooting pirates does not, in any way, address the cause of piracy. Until the socioeconomic problems in Somalia are addressed, there'll just be more pirates. And as a disincentive? Like I said - it worked SO well in Iraq, didn't it? You shoot a Somali, that Somali's brother or cousin or uncle or wife now has another reason to be angry. Who do you think they'll take that anger out on?
 
Perhaps because the solution to some problems is not simply to throw more guns at it? Somali piracy is a complex societal problem, not a problem about who has more firepower. You won't stop the pirates just by shooting them. I mean, look at how well that has worked in Iraq.
You may be right but the time scale to deal with the societal problems is measured in decades. By using armed resistance, you are dealing with the problem measured in, say, weeks, while the longer term solutions are sought. The two approaches are not mutually exclusive.
 
Just because a person is armed with a rifle, shotgun or machine gun does not mean they can put the bullets on target while shooting down from a moving ship. Add in the smaller faster moving speed boat, pirates possibly shooting at those defending the ship and the likely relative inexperience of the ship's crew in weapons use, it is not at all certain that the crew can successfully defend themselves. Things can get easier for the defenders if they shoot from concealment at any pirates who managed to board the ship.

I’m sure some people have heard stores like 7-11 that prohibit armed cashiers for insurance purposes. Some shipping companies take the same view. They do not trust their crew to defend themselves and not damage the cargo or ship in the process.

Ranb
 
Last edited:
I’m not sure if this has been discussed in other threads, but if pirates are such a big problem, why don't the crews of ships ARM THEMSELVES??? I really have trouble seeing why they don't do this. Even if you had just one AK47 on a ship and a person who was even remotely trained with it, they could defend an entire tanker. Its really easy to see if another little boat is approaching your ship. All you have to do is grab the AK, fire some warning shots at it. If they fail to stop, light them up. Its not like there is much cover that can be used on those crappy little boats those pirates ride. Then on top of that they would have to board the ship while being shot at. As for them firing back, well its pretty hard to lay down any accurate fire when riding those little rafts that get knocked around everywhere.

Is there a reason crews have not taken to arms to defend their ships?

Your macho antics are just going to get you and the rest of the crew killed.

AK47 effective range: 800m
RPG7 used as anti-personell weapon range at self detonation: 920m

Whereas, if you just surrender to the pirates and wait for the company to pay the ransom, you get treated well, get to relax as the pirates take over your shipboard duties and even earn an overtime bonus.

The time for armed assault against the pirates is when you have overwhelming firepower and trained troops. Not when it's a crew of 20 or less against at least that many pirates.
 
If crews were armed it never would have come to a shoot out. Simply look at the many examples of unarmed crews driving off pirates. The pirates are not hardened soldiers willing to go into battle. They're opportunists, using the posturing of their weapons and relying on the submission of their targets.

If their targets stop being submissive and start protecting themselves the pirates will rapidly decide to look elsewhere for their targets.
 
You may be right but the time scale to deal with the societal problems is measured in decades. By using armed resistance, you are dealing with the problem measured in, say, weeks, while the longer term solutions are sought. The two approaches are not mutually exclusive.
*double sigh*

I suppose.

I do have to say that I was impressed when those SEALs took out the three pirates last week.
 
Your macho antics are just going to get you and the rest of the crew killed.

AK47 effective range: 800m
RPG7 used as anti-personell weapon range at self detonation: 920m

Whereas, if you just surrender to the pirates and wait for the company to pay the ransom, you get treated well, get to relax as the pirates take over your shipboard duties and even earn an overtime bonus.

The time for armed assault against the pirates is when you have overwhelming firepower and trained troops. Not when it's a crew of 20 or less against at least that many pirates.

Incorrect. You apparently are a sheep. I am an officer in the United States Army. Trust me, if someone were to try and board a ship I was on and I had a rifle, every one of those pirates would get a controlled pair right in the chest. What is it with these people that think no harm will happen to them if they just comply with the bad guys? Such cowardice. This is just inviting pirates to hi jack any ship they want knowing that they will get whatever they want from the ransom.
 
Why don't they arm themselves and get into firefights with pirates? For the same reason most bankiers and cashiers don't arm themselves and get into firefights with robbers. Because their lives, not their material possessions, are paramount. Pirates manage to board, keep crew alive, get ransom, release crew members alive so they can go home to their families.

Just don't understand it.
Well, I don't understand, for the bare life of me, how "human lives over material goods" is so hard to understand for certain residents of a certain otherwise-very-civilized-and-mostly-great-to-live-in North American country. Everyone else seem to understand it so well:confused:.
 
Why don't they arm themselves and get into firefights with pirates? For the same reason most bankiers and cashiers don't arm themselves and get into firefights with robbers. Because their lives, not their material possessions, are paramount. Pirates manage to board, keep crew alive, get ransom, release crew members alive so they can go home to their families.

Well, I don't understand, for the bare life of me, how "human lives over material goods" is so hard to understand for certain residents of a certain otherwise-very-civilized-and-mostly-great-to-live-in North American country. Everyone else seem to understand it so well:confused:.

Its not about defending material goods. Its about defending yourself. If you really think that no harm would come to you if you just comply with pirates (remember these guys come from a society where killing is an everyday thing to them and means nothing) then you are gravely naive. What if the negotiations go bad and they don't get what they want and they start killing hostages? There goes your little philosophy right out the window.

If all ships were armed and pirates knew they would be getting into a firefight if they boarded ships, I can guarantee you piracy would go down substantially. The reason they board ships is to hope that there are passengers such as yourself. People who are too scared to defend themselves. That is the problem with much of society today and that is the only reason crime exists. There are always weak people to pray on.
 
*sigh*. Way to miss the point.

Shooting pirates does not, in any way, address the cause of piracy. Until the socioeconomic problems in Somalia are addressed, there'll just be more pirates. And as a disincentive? Like I said - it worked SO well in Iraq, didn't it? You shoot a Somali, that Somali's brother or cousin or uncle or wife now has another reason to be angry. Who do you think they'll take that anger out on?


My post was in response to your statement:

arthwollipot said:
You won't stop the pirates just by shooting them.


As noted above, shooting pirates will stop those particular individuals. In addition, it will provide a strong disincentive to target that particular ship.

If I were on the ship the armed pirate were attempting to capture, I'm very certain I wouldn't give a rat's ass what his brother or cousin or uncle thought about the fact that I just shot his gun-wielding relative in the course of defending myself from being kidnapped and held for ransom or worse.

This is so blindingly obvious to me, I can't help but wonder again if you're actually serious.
 
Last edited:
Why don't they arm themselves and get into firefights with pirates? For the same reason most bankiers and cashiers don't arm themselves and get into firefights with robbers. Because their lives, not their material possessions, are paramount. Pirates manage to board, keep crew alive, get ransom, release crew members alive so they can go home to their families.


Is it normal for bank tellers and cashiers to be taken hostage for weeks and months at a time?

How is armed kidnapping treated by the police in your country? No big deal? Are potential kidnap victims expected to roll over and not offer any resistance? Let me guess, that usually works out fine ... except for the times it doesn't, right?
 
Last edited:
I think there's a much easier solution to this problem. That part of the ocean is already crawling with naval vessels filled with highly trained, skilled and well quipped men and women. Recently NATO forces liberated a ship only to disarm the pirates and let them go because they had no authority to detain them.

...snip...

It's not so much the authority to detain them it's that most of the NATO countries' legal systems don't allow them to prosecute people who haven't attacked their nationals, or when the crimes have taken place in international waters and so on, so once you've caught them you haven't got any options.

I wouldn't be surprised if it wouldn't be the same with the idea of a "ROE" approach - certainly summary execution of suspected criminals is not allowed in any of the legal systems of the EU countries.
 
It's not so much the authority to detain them it's that most of the NATO countries' legal systems don't allow them to prosecute people who haven't attacked their nationals, or when the crimes have taken place in international waters and so on, so once you've caught them you haven't got any options.

I wouldn't be surprised if it wouldn't be the same with the idea of a "ROE" approach - certainly summary execution of suspected criminals is not allowed in any of the legal systems of the EU countries.
I don't understand why they can't be turned over to the countries whose nationals they did attack.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom