smartcooky
Penultimate Amazing
The use of deadly force to stop a violent attacks in progress has long been recognized as acceptable, not only on the part of the military but on the part of police and even civilians. Your scenario is not the where the controversy lies. The controversy is about the use of deadly force on people who are not currently engaged in such an act.
In a conventional military conflict, the use of deadly force against enemy forces is acceptable even if those enemy forces are not currently engaged in hostile action. In conventional law enforcement, the use of deadly force against suspects who are not currently engaged in a crime and not posing immediate threat is not acceptable. The question before us is how to handle these new, non-conventional scenarios. And your hypothetical isn't an example, since it fits easily and unambiguously into existing frameworks.
For foreign terrorists on foreign soil, the overwhelming consensus of American opinion is that the use of deadly force is acceptable even in the absence of any immediate threat. I'm OK with that too. But when it comes to Americans on American soil, I think we need to tread a lot more carefully. At the moment, it appears that there is no legal impediment to the president ordering the killing of an American on American soil, if the president designates that person a terrorist, even if that person poses no immediate threat (and again, this distinguishes the controversy from your scenario, where the answer has always been obvious).
And in principle, I'm actually OK with a terrorist being killed even if they're American, on American soil, and not posing an immediate danger. But because of the potential for abuse or even simple error, I think that the decision to do so cannot rest in the hands of one man, as it currently appears to. There must be a process behind it which would make people feel comfortable no matter who the president was. And I simply don't find it credible that everyone defending Obama on this issue would actually feel comfortable if Bush was doing this instead. If you can't abide by a president you hate wielding a power, then it's too much power, even for a president you like.
Its not too hard to dream up a scenario (and one that it not at all unlikely) in which an air attack against US Citizens not actually engaged or in the process of an attack, could be authorised.
I can imagine one where a domestic terrorist such as Timothy McVeigh was planning an attack on a Federal Building, but this time, the Feds had intelligence that it was going to happen. Their sources also told them that he was holed up in the woods and that there was a large contingent of militia ready to defend his booby trapped compound. Best tactical assessments show that any Federal Task Force would suffer unacceptably high (30%?) losses trying to take him down.
In those circumstances, I don't think many ordinary US citizens would oppose the idea of the President simply ordering up a massive air-strike and turning the compound and its environs into a series of big craters. Do you?