Drone strikes possible on American soil - Holder

The use of deadly force to stop a violent attacks in progress has long been recognized as acceptable, not only on the part of the military but on the part of police and even civilians. Your scenario is not the where the controversy lies. The controversy is about the use of deadly force on people who are not currently engaged in such an act.

In a conventional military conflict, the use of deadly force against enemy forces is acceptable even if those enemy forces are not currently engaged in hostile action. In conventional law enforcement, the use of deadly force against suspects who are not currently engaged in a crime and not posing immediate threat is not acceptable. The question before us is how to handle these new, non-conventional scenarios. And your hypothetical isn't an example, since it fits easily and unambiguously into existing frameworks.

For foreign terrorists on foreign soil, the overwhelming consensus of American opinion is that the use of deadly force is acceptable even in the absence of any immediate threat. I'm OK with that too. But when it comes to Americans on American soil, I think we need to tread a lot more carefully. At the moment, it appears that there is no legal impediment to the president ordering the killing of an American on American soil, if the president designates that person a terrorist, even if that person poses no immediate threat (and again, this distinguishes the controversy from your scenario, where the answer has always been obvious).

And in principle, I'm actually OK with a terrorist being killed even if they're American, on American soil, and not posing an immediate danger. But because of the potential for abuse or even simple error, I think that the decision to do so cannot rest in the hands of one man, as it currently appears to. There must be a process behind it which would make people feel comfortable no matter who the president was. And I simply don't find it credible that everyone defending Obama on this issue would actually feel comfortable if Bush was doing this instead. If you can't abide by a president you hate wielding a power, then it's too much power, even for a president you like.

Its not too hard to dream up a scenario (and one that it not at all unlikely) in which an air attack against US Citizens not actually engaged or in the process of an attack, could be authorised.

I can imagine one where a domestic terrorist such as Timothy McVeigh was planning an attack on a Federal Building, but this time, the Feds had intelligence that it was going to happen. Their sources also told them that he was holed up in the woods and that there was a large contingent of militia ready to defend his booby trapped compound. Best tactical assessments show that any Federal Task Force would suffer unacceptably high (30%?) losses trying to take him down.

In those circumstances, I don't think many ordinary US citizens would oppose the idea of the President simply ordering up a massive air-strike and turning the compound and its environs into a series of big craters. Do you?
 
Does this mean they might blow up Noam Chomsky?

Anything the CTs and other radicals can use to try and call the govt illegitimate and evil, they will use, no matter how logically asinine.
 
I can't wait to see the hysteria when the gov't starts killing people with tiny robots with face-recognition.
 
Its not too hard to dream up a scenario (and one that it not at all unlikely) in which an air attack against US Citizens not actually engaged or in the process of an attack, could be authorised.

I can imagine one where a domestic terrorist such as Timothy McVeigh was planning an attack on a Federal Building, but this time, the Feds had intelligence that it was going to happen. Their sources also told them that he was holed up in the woods and that there was a large contingent of militia ready to defend his booby trapped compound. Best tactical assessments show that any Federal Task Force would suffer unacceptably high (30%?) losses trying to take him down.

In those circumstances, I don't think many ordinary US citizens would oppose the idea of the President simply ordering up a massive air-strike and turning the compound and its environs into a series of big craters. Do you?

Really? You don't think that many Americans would care that the government bombed it's own citizens in a place where the situation can be contained and waited out? You must not remember Waco and the fallout and aftermath that that brought with it. And that was arguably either an accident or an arson started by the people inside depending upon who you ask.
 
Posse Comitatus is still the law of the land. Holder would be on stronger ground if he were talking about law enforcement using drones rather than the military. Some police forces already have robots that they use in dangerous situations.

That said, I'm still a results guy. If it succeeds in preventing an attack I'd be the first to say no harm, no foul.
 
Really? You don't think that many Americans would care that the government bombed it's own citizens in a place where the situation can be contained and waited out? You must not remember Waco and the fallout and aftermath that that brought with it. And that was arguably either an accident or an arson started by the people inside depending upon who you ask.

What if it can't be contained or waited out? What if they are bunkered in with enough supplies to last them 50 years? What if they have medium range rockets that they could fire at the nearest towns?

I know that is somewhat extreme, but I am arguing that there must be a point of escalation, before an actual attack is "in progress", at which the US Government will feel that the containment and waiting game is not an option.

I am feeling for what that point might be.

There may be questions asked afterwards, but if rockets start falling in town towns, there will be bigger, tougher questions like, why the hell didn't you take them out when you had the chance.
 
I have to wonder if Rand Paul would be acting the same if we had a GOP Administration and AG...........

My guess is yes, he would. Certainly his dad was never one to let loyalty to his political party override his libertarian principles. And I say this as someone who was never a Ron Paul fan.
 
Its not too hard to dream up a scenario (and one that it not at all unlikely) in which an air attack against US Citizens not actually engaged or in the process of an attack, could be authorised.

I can imagine one where a domestic terrorist such as Timothy McVeigh was planning an attack on a Federal Building, but this time, the Feds had intelligence that it was going to happen. Their sources also told them that he was holed up in the woods and that there was a large contingent of militia ready to defend his booby trapped compound. Best tactical assessments show that any Federal Task Force would suffer unacceptably high (30%?) losses trying to take him down.

In those circumstances, I don't think many ordinary US citizens would oppose the idea of the President simply ordering up a massive air-strike and turning the compound and its environs into a series of big craters. Do you?

Yes, I do think most people would oppose the idea. In your scenario, simply surrounding him would be possible, and most of the public would prefer it, as well they should. Casualties for law enforcement in defensive positions would be low (if any), and you could simply wait him out.

You're basically arguing that the president should be able to disregard due process, and I don't find that acceptable in the least. Regardless of the particular details of the case, who is making the decision to use lethal force here? It's one thing when there is no alternative (an imminent attack), but when there IS an alternative, it should take more than one man's will to choose to forgo that alternative. I'm not opposed to having such action possible, but I am against having a president with the power to make that call himself.

And that's what I don't get here: even if you think there are scenarios in which the use of lethal force against an American on American soil is justified even in the absence of an imminent threat, how can you not think that the power to make this decision should not have strict oversight and review by some other party besides the president? Judicial review on warrants doesn't prevent the police from searching suspects' houses, for example. What you ultimately want to happen can still happen, but it shouldn't happen on one man's say-so alone.
 
Last edited:
I have no problem using drones to kill terrorists carrying explosives or other weapons, on their way to commit a terrorist act.

Other than that, use humans to conduct arrests.

I agree. However, I think there should be due process after the fact to ensure that such an even was the case.
 
What if it can't be contained or waited out? What if they are bunkered in with enough supplies to last them 50 years? What if they have medium range rockets that they could fire at the nearest towns?

I know that is somewhat extreme, but I am arguing that there must be a point of escalation, before an actual attack is "in progress", at which the US Government will feel that the containment and waiting game is not an option.

I am feeling for what that point might be.

There may be questions asked afterwards, but if rockets start falling in town towns, there will be bigger, tougher questions like, why the hell didn't you take them out when you had the chance.

That is a lot of "What if's" with the inclusion of something that wasn't in your original premise. And that something is it is actually imminent and with the capability to act.

The question Rand Paul was asking was more in the vein of a non-combatant US citizen is sitting somewhere not being an imminent danger to anyone can the US government kill him using the current administrations drone policy. Holder did not say no which can be seen as saying yes. Holder tried to obfuscate the question by bringing up 9]11 - Pearl Harbor but that wasn't the question being asked of him.
 
A terrorist group (for argument's sake with American citizens on board as willing participants) is sailing a large cargo ship with a million pounds of high-explosives wired up as a massive bomb into New York Harbour at full speed ahead.

How are your police and courts going to stop them, with an arrest warrant or court order?
Your scenario is not what problematic drone attacks are being used for. In your senario, you can attack with anything you have available, the law says you can, imminent danger.

Drones are being used to assassinate 'enemies', however that's defined. This issue is not about using them on a battlefront.

This is not about police using drones, they use robots sometimes, who cares?

But taking out a terrorist you could just go arrest? That's what Holder ignorantly didn't just say, "we go arrest them when they are in the US".
 
Last edited:
... At the moment, it appears that there is no legal impediment to the president ordering the killing of an American on American soil, if the president designates that person a terrorist, even if that person poses no immediate threat (and again, this distinguishes the controversy from your scenario, where the answer has always been obvious).

And in principle, I'm actually OK with a terrorist being killed even if they're American, on American soil, and not posing an immediate danger. But because of the potential for abuse or even simple error, I think that the decision to do so cannot rest in the hands of one man, as it currently appears to. There must be a process behind it which would make people feel comfortable no matter who the president was. And I simply don't find it credible that everyone defending Obama on this issue would actually feel comfortable if Bush was doing this instead. If you can't abide by a president you hate wielding a power, then it's too much power, even for a president you like.
I agreed with you up to the point before what I've quoted.

No law against the government ordering an assassination of a US citizen on US soil? That's ludicrous, it's not only illegal and unconstitutional (it's called the right to due process), it's sad that anyone has come to believe the lie this kind of thing isn't prohibited. Maybe the Constitutionality hasn't been challenged, but that doesn't mean it's actually legal.

Why have you abandoned the principle you arrest such a person and they have a right to defend themselves against the charges? What is wrong with you?:eek:
 
Mostly.

Unless the Governor asks for help (e.g.; Blair Mtn., Warren Harding)

Or it's in DC, which is another of the exceptions to the Posse Comitatus Act. (e.g.; Bonus Army, Herbert Hoover)

Or to enforce certain Civil Rights (e.g; school desegregation, Eisenhower)

etc.
Well, we did have "Four dead in Ohio" and a few more in that other university no one remembers. But I believe some people distinguish between the national guard and the military.

It's called the Posse Comitatus Act.
 
Is there something about a drone that makes the decision or the application different than any piece of military hardware being used by law enforcement? If the cops are going to kill someone, I think they should use the most efficient means possible, even when it's only a single responsible party making a judgement call.

This sort of thing must happen all the time. The "process" is the authority having jurisdiction making a decision. That person then has to justify the decision and face the consequences of making a poor decision. Why does a particular piece of equipment change any of this or even need presidential involvement?

What about a tank? Or a cannon? If the police can find a use for it, then give them a few. Same thing with drones. They could have used one on the cop killer holed up in the cabin. They can use one for the next fleeing felon in the tank he stole. The people to ask don't work in Washington, the people to ask are the cops. "Do you want this capability? Do you think you'll have a use for it?" They probably don't and won't. At least not the version with the missile. The camera stuff is pretty cool though.
 
Is there something about a drone that makes the decision or the application different than any piece of military hardware being used by law enforcement? If the cops are going to kill someone, I think they should use the most efficient means possible, even when it's only a single responsible party making a judgement call.

This sort of thing must happen all the time. The "process" is the authority having jurisdiction making a decision. That person then has to justify the decision and face the consequences of making a poor decision. Why does a particular piece of equipment change any of this or even need presidential involvement?

What about a tank? Or a cannon? If the police can find a use for it, then give them a few. Same thing with drones. They could have used one on the cop killer holed up in the cabin. They can use one for the next fleeing felon in the tank he stole. The people to ask don't work in Washington, the people to ask are the cops. "Do you want this capability? Do you think you'll have a use for it?" They probably don't and won't. At least not the version with the missile. The camera stuff is pretty cool though.

No. The meat of the issue isn't the tool, it's the policy that authorizes using that tool in certain situations.
 
Well, we did have "Four dead in Ohio" and a few more in that other university no one remembers. But I believe some people distinguish between the national guard and the military.

It's called the Posse Comitatus Act.


You mean the Posse Comitatus Act I mentioned in the post you quoted?

... another of the exceptions to the Posse Comitatus Act.


That one ?

And yes, some (many, actually) people do distinguish between the NG and the U.S. military in certain circumstances, because that's what the Posse Comitatus Act was explicitly meant to do.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom