Drone strikes possible on American soil - Holder

And that decision should be reviewed by judicial system afterwards.

Well, you may be correct about that.

However, the way that the law is currently written does not provide any sort of after-action judical reviews.

Therefore, if you really want some sort of judicial oversight, then the law will have to be changed.
 
John Walker Lindh was supposedly an enemy combattant, so much so they couldn't prove any charge against him and had to go for a plea bargain.
 
John Walker Lindh was supposedly an enemy combattant, so much so they couldn't prove any charge against him and had to go for a plea bargain.

I don't think that you understand how plea bargains work. You don't cop a plea if the case against you is so weak that they "Can't prove any charges". You take a plea bargain when you know that you're guilty of the charges and you think that the prosecution can prove it well enough to send you to prison. In return the prosecution offers to ask for leniency from the judge on your behalf or some other offer such as reduced charges.

Now then, there are a few people with bad lawyers who took a plea bargain when they shouldn't have because they didn't want to risk an even longer sentence in a tougher prison but Lindh didn't have bad lawyers representing him so that wasn't why he took the plea. There are also people who have refused a plea bargain even knowing that they are guilty and throw the dice as to whether or not a jury will convict. They basically hope for an OJ Simpson outcome, which is very rare as most people cannot afford the "Dream Team" that he could.
 
You couldn't see a political prisoner if he stood right in front of you and peed on your shoes.
 
John Walker Lindh was supposedly an enemy combattant, so much so they couldn't prove any charge against him and had to go for a plea bargain.

And the courts smacked bush down hard for that, almost as if the system of checks and balances works.
 
Well, you may be correct about that.

However, the way that the law is currently written does not provide any sort of after-action judical reviews.

Therefore, if you really want some sort of judicial oversight, then the law will have to be changed.

Wrongful death lawsuits would at least partially account for that.
 
John Brennan Sworn in as CIA Director Using Constitution Lacking Bill of Rights

Marcy Wheeler said:
According to the White House, John Brennan was sworn in as CIA Director on a “first draft” of the Constitution including notations from George Washington, dating to 1787.

That means, when Brennan vowed to protect and defend the Constitution, he was swearing on one that did not include the First, Fourth, Fifth, or Sixth Amendments — or any of the other Amendments now included in our Constitution. The Bill of Rights did not become part of our Constitution until 1791, 4 years after the Constitution that Brennan took his oath on. [...]


:rolleyes:
 
Really? Well, I can see how the sentence following my quote must be a quite alien concept to you.

Sorry, I was too busy laughing about the other article at that site where the blogger thinks that the government has started tracking her online viewing habits because she clicked on a particular YouTube video, and as evidence cites the fact that she discovered a new follower on her own YouTube channel after she watched that video.
 
Well its just a little silly CE - I mean, I am not sure that Brennan or any sitting staff of the president needs to pull a trick like that to get by the constutition. They have the weight of the presidency behind them. AS per Nixon, when the President does something, that means its legal!

Why the need to resort to tricks like a secret-swap of what he is actually swearing on?

I guess the idea is that if push comes to shove and there's a legal challenge, Brennan will say, "well I didn't actually swear on amendment _____ - so our administration is going with a version of the constitution that doesn't include that"...?

Its all unnecessary and a little silly!
 
I'm reminded of all the Truther idiots who were upset that Bush and Cheney didn't testify under oath to the 9-11 Commission. Apparently, they believe that the Prez & VP were willing to plot the terrorist attacks, thus becoming responsible for 3000 or so murders, but they balked at committing perjury to cover it up.

This does bother me for another reason:

“Director Brennan was sworn in with his hand on an original draft of the Constitution that had George Washington’s personal handwriting and annotations on it, dating from 1787.”

I hope some effort was made to protect that document from direct contact with his hand.
 
I hope some effort was made to protect that document from direct contact with his hand.

If not, and the oils in his skin cause that document to deteriorate and disintegrate, that website can start posting alarmist articles about how Brennan and Obama literally destroyed the Constitution.
 
How come all the Conservatives who didn't give a **** about American citizens being detained in the USA without charge/trial under Bush, are now suddenly lovers of the Constitution?
 
How come all the Conservatives who didn't give a **** about American citizens being detained in the USA without charge/trial under Bush, are now suddenly lovers of the Constitution?

Are you surprised? I'm not. It is, after all, about WE MUST BE IN CONTROL, and the actual policies and outcomes of those policies are utterly, absolutely irrelevant. The only "conservative" (yes, that is quotes of contempt, not scare quotes) policies now are "IT'S NOT OBAMA".

It's not very far from "HE'S BLACK" either in many places.
 
How come all the Conservatives who didn't give a **** about American citizens being detained in the USA without charge/trial under Bush, are now suddenly lovers of the Constitution?

The same reason they didn't care about deficits when Bush was POTUS.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom