Drone strikes possible on American soil - Holder

No. The meat of the issue isn't the tool, it's the policy that authorizes using that tool in certain situations.

But isn't this done all the time with whatever lethal tools we allow law enforcement to have? Wouldn't it be something like, "use the fully automatic setting on your weapons if you think it's necessary" or something akin to that? In other words, "here is what this thing does" is then balanced against whatever problem arises.

For any lethal tool, wouldn't the justification be exactly the same? So, in any situation where I am allowed to kill someone, I get to use my best judgement on how to go about it. I have to face the review board later, but the decision is left up to the man on the ground -- as it should be. The only policy needed is, "don't kill people you aren't supposed to."

I hope the part about who I am supposed to kill is already in the training somewhere. If it isn't, they need to fix that.
 
Last edited:
All ok then as long as POTUS only kills people you dislike? For some President's I suggest Dr.King would have been a good target.

Had Bush-Cheney's AG tried this crap, the folderal would still be on-going.

So we can agree that Clinton's attacks on bin Laden by cruise missile were unconstitutional? I want some consistency here.
 
I have no problem using drones to kill terrorists carrying explosives or other weapons, on their way to commit a terrorist act.

Other than that, use humans to conduct arrests.

So air strikes on terrorist camps are wrong?
 
Posse Comitatus is still the law of the land. Holder would be on stronger ground if he were talking about law enforcement using drones rather than the military. Some police forces already have robots that they use in dangerous situations.

That said, I'm still a results guy. If it succeeds in preventing an attack I'd be the first to say no harm, no foul.

So was the scambling of air assets durring 9/11 wrong if they had actually done anything? An illegal and unconstitutional act?
 
That is a lot of "What if's" with the inclusion of something that wasn't in your original premise. And that something is it is actually imminent and with the capability to act.

That's right. As I said, I am amending/ramping up the scenario, trying to feel for what the limits are; at what point does due process go out the window, and definitive action become called for.

So, instead of imminent danger, what about this?

In 1919, the U.S. Supreme Court said that “The most stringent protection of free speech would not protect a man falsely shouting fire in a theatre and causing a panic” . This case was about the first amendment right to free speech, and effectively has set a precedent which limits that right.

The USSC thereby made it clear that the right to free speech is not absolute, in that freedom to speak you mind is not freedom to endanger the lives of others. It had to pass a test called “Clear and Present Danger.”

Some years ago I read a Tom Clancy fiction novel of the same name, in which the President authorised his Chief of Staff to order up an air-strike on a Drug Lord's mansion in Columbia because he considered that Cartel to be a clear and present danger to the United States.

1st Question: Can the Clear and Present Danger test be applied to anything other than the First Amendment right to free speech? In other words, can it be used to assess someone's actions rather than speech?

2nd Question: If so, could the President use this as a constitutional justification to order an air-strike against the target I mentioned earlier?
 
.. snipped for relevance ...

Hang on though. Wasn't the fact that the President at the time ((Johnson) granted them an amnesty (by a proclamation) the only reason they weren't charged with treason?

Without that amnesty, they could still have been charged.

Well, that is partially right.

While it is true that President Johnson did provide a blanket amnesty to all Confederate soldiers, however that amnesty did not extend to other officials; and yet, there was not a single treason trial.

For example, even Jefferson Davis (the President of the CSA) was not charged with treason and was released after being held for two years.
 
Well, that is partially right.

While it is true that President Johnson did provide a blanket amnesty to all Confederate soldiers, however that amnesty did not extend to other officials; and yet, there was not a single treason trial.

For example, even Jefferson Davis (the President of the CSA) was not charged with treason and was released after being held for two years.

Just because they were not charged doesn't mean they could not have been. It was a political decision to try to get past the war to not prosecute them.
 
What I would prefer is that drone policy not be formulated and executed by the President but rather formulated by congress by the passage of a law that the President subsequently executes. Within this law would be a codification of when strikes are legal, congress would have full understanding of the legal rationale (the rationale would be a part of the legislation and thus open to everybody, including the public, to see). I would also like to see some form of review after the fact that enables accountability to be exercised over the executive by the legislature. Ideally each drone strike would be approved in a FISA-like court, with potentially some avenue for retroactive review from a FISA-like court in instances where it is determined speed-to-action is so critical a prior check isn't possible.

Except I think those are strategic and tactical decisions. That is 100% in the president's commander-in-chief power and anything congress passed would be void.
 
Just to reiterate, here is what Holder said:

In the letter, Holder said “It is possible I suppose to imagine an extraordinary circumstance in which it would be necessary and appropriate under the Constitution and applicable laws of the United States for the President to authorize the military to use lethal force within the territory of the United States.“

Now, who here, besides the OP, doesn't understand what the highlighted words mean?

This is another case of a mountain being made out of a molehill. I am not a fan of Holder, I am generally against the drone strikes outside of the US, but of course it is possible to imagine the extraordinary circumstance where it would be necessary in the US against a US Citizen.

In no way does this indicate that Attorney General Holder or President Obama thinks non emergency drone strikes in the US are allowed under the constitution.
 
Just because they were not charged doesn't mean they could not have been. It was a political decision to try to get past the war to not prosecute them.

That is an excellent point!

It also supports the point that I made which was that if a citizen of the USA were to wage war on the USA, then that person is not automatically considered to be a traitor to the USA.
 
1st Question: Can the Clear and Present Danger test be applied to anything other than the First Amendment right to free speech? In other words, can it be used to assess someone's actions rather than speech?

Police are authorized to use lethal force when it's appropriate (when they or another party is in imminent threat of someone using lethal force against them). For example, in Scott v. Harris (2007), a police officer's bumping a fleeing, speeding car (lethal force, even though the guy survived the ensuing crash) in order to end a high speed chase that put other people in danger.
 
I like how Lindsey Graham pointed out the hypocrisy of those who are criticizing Obama on the drone strikes by asking where they were when Bush was doing so.

Although, I still don't agree with the drone strike policy.
 
Police are authorized to use lethal force when it's appropriate (when they or another party is in imminent threat of someone using lethal force against them). For example, in Scott v. Harris (2007), a police officer's bumping a fleeing, speeding car (lethal force, even though the guy survived the ensuing crash) in order to end a high speed chase that put other people in danger.

The Police don't have the tools to do what I suggest, the military does. Can the President authorise the military to use lethal; force carry out these air strikes?

What about using the Air National Guard? Apparently, the President can "federalise" the ANG in times of crisis. Some states ANG's are equipped with suitable aircraft such as A-10 Warthogs, e.g. Massachusetts - 104th Tactical Fighter Wing (TFW), Idaho - 124th FW, Indiana - 122nd FW, and some are equipped with the drones were are discussing, e.g. New York - 174th Attack Wing is equipped with MQ-9 Reaper attack drones.
 
The Police don't have the tools to do what I suggest, the military does. Can the President authorise the military to use lethal; force carry out these air strikes?

What about using the Air National Guard? Apparently, the President can "federalise" the ANG in times of crisis. Some states ANG's are equipped with suitable aircraft such as A-10 Warthogs, e.g. Massachusetts - 104th Tactical Fighter Wing (TFW), Idaho - 124th FW, Indiana - 122nd FW, and some are equipped with the drones were are discussing, e.g. New York - 174th Attack Wing is equipped with MQ-9 Reaper attack drones.

If I may interject ...

In general, the US military is not supposed to get involved with law enforcement; but there are some exceptions to this rule provided that one can show that the military tools are being used to support lawful actions by the civilian authorities (such as drug interdiction).
 
If I may interject ...

In general, the US military is not supposed to get involved with law enforcement; but there are some exceptions to this rule provided that one can show that the military tools are being used to support lawful actions by the civilian authorities (such as drug interdiction).

The Posse Commitiatus act does NOT absoloutely forbid the Regular Military being used in the United States proper;it puts the conditions under which it can be used.

Lindsay Graham was right about this filibuster;it is Rand Paul playing on the paranoia of the left and right fringes. In other words, trying to fill the throne vacated by his Daddy.

If it ever reached the point where drones would be used in the US it would be a situation where things have gotten so bad that the military has been given control because normal law enforcement cannot handle it;and if that is the case I don' see much difference between a sending in a Seal or Army Ranger team or using a drone.
 
My guess is yes, he would. Certainly his dad was never one to let loyalty to his political party override his libertarian principles. And I say this as someone who was never a Ron Paul fan.

I suspect you are right. But some of the GOP senators who supported Paul....I think it's a different story.
 
The Posse Commitiatus act does NOT absoloutely forbid the Regular Military being used in the United States proper;it puts the conditions under which it can be used.

... snipped for relevance ...

And that is just about what I said about the issue.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom