Drone strikes possible on American soil - Holder

As long as the AG is imagining things, I’ll imagine that the only Americans ever likely to need drone therapy are right-wing nazi-wannabes. To be sure, the great majority of these dime-store Himmlers don’t actually take any action; they stay up in their rooms, or out in the garage, or down in Mom’s basement, posting and pasting on internet forums while modeling their brown shirts and trying on Charlie Chaplin moustaches in front of the mirror.

But they’re certainly crazy enough, and evil-minded enough, to be led by a sufficiently charismatic arsch hohle to fashion bombs and try for some sort of fame by attacking, say, a day-care center or a veterans’ hospital. (Some of them have already canonized Little Tim McVeigh, so why not imitate him?) In cases like that, Old Dr. Hellfire’s Radical-Ridding Enema will be just the ticket.
All ok then as long as POTUS only kills people you dislike? For some President's I suggest Dr.King would have been a good target.

Had Bush-Cheney's AG tried this crap, the folderal would still be on-going.
 
There is an invading foreign army invading Oregon from the north, complete with tanks, mobile missile launchers, air support, the whole nine yards. Included in that army are, let's say, 1000 US citizens who have actively taken up arms against their country. They are driving equipment, firing guns, and wearing the uniforms of the foreign army. In such a situation, would it not be reasonable for the US to use drone strikes (and more) against those US citizens?​

Oi, they'd have to go through us first.We'd just let them try to drive their tanks over the cascades, and it would all be over!
 
Remember when people thought Bush would be able to imprison Americans in Guantanamo Bay by declaring them terrorists? And how he could just have his enemies and critics sent there because there was nothing stopping him?

I don't know which is sillier: the paranoid expectation that a president is just waiting an opportunity to go all Palpatine, or that if he did he'd be easily stopped because someone wrote a memo more carefully.
 
Most of us are more worried about targeting single individuals.

Don't join al-Qaeda.

There, problem solved.

Had Bush-Cheney's AG tried this crap, the folderal would still be on-going.

Considering that this whole situation was basically made possible by Bush and Cheney doing things like this to American citizens in the name of the "War on Terror", maybe the members of the right should have thought their cunning plan through and heeded the warnings being sounded at the time by the terrorist-hugging Commie traitor libs who suggested that setting such a precedent might not bode well for the future (and who, you'll note, aren't exactly happy about Obama doing this, either).
 
A month ago there were posters on this very forum that swore up and down that the memo in question would never apply to drones over US soil and that the idea was preposterous. When it was pointed out that the memo didn't exclude it they still said that it wouldn't apply and that the people who thought that it could were crazy.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=252711&page=4

Who's crazy now. Holder himself has now said that it could apply to American citizens on American soil. Now I don't really think that Obama is going to do this but it sets a precedent that the next president (or the one after that, repeat as needed) will end up using and cite this as precedent.
Extraordinary circumstances.

Think of a US branch of al Qaeda that captures Key West or something.

Not "oh, there's a terrorist, let's smoke him".
 
The memo attempts to justify using drones against individuals (specifically targeted killing of US citizens abroad).
...killing a very specific kind of US citizen on foreign soil, and I don't see Holder's name on that memo.

The OP article is referring to what Holder said about drone attacks on US soil. Neither, the article nor Holder referred to that memo.

His full letter, however, does talk about targeting a single individual and he outright rejects the possibility. He only entertains the question as a hypothetical.
 
Sure, so why not take the FISA model and bring it into the drone strike program and bring cases before it?
Because the Executive branch has the Constitutional authority to prosecute a war, not the Judicial branch. This isn't a wiretap we're discussing.
 
Don't join al-Qaeda.

There, problem solved.
In my case should I become a target it won't be because I joined al-Qaeda.

Considering that this whole situation was basically made possible by Bush and Cheney doing things like this to American citizens in the name of the "War on Terror", maybe the members of the right should have thought their cunning plan through and heeded the warnings being sounded at the time by the terrorist-hugging Commie traitor libs who suggested that setting such a precedent might not bode well for the future (and who, you'll note, aren't exactly happy about Obama doing this, either).
I do? Nope, I don't see posts that imply that to me; it appears to me more "Go Obama".
 
In the filibuster thread I pointed out that Holder, when asked directly and repeatedly during a committee hearing today, did not absolutely rule out killing an individual "Sitting in a cafe'" with a drone as something that couldn't be done constitutionally speaking. That's a pretty simple yes or no question that he didn't give a definitive answer to.
 
In the filibuster thread I pointed out that Holder, when asked directly and repeatedly during a committee hearing today, did not absolutely rule out killing an individual "Sitting in a cafe'" with a drone as something that couldn't be done constitutionally speaking. That's a pretty simple yes or no question that he didn't give a definitive answer to.
What matters is whether or not said terrorist is in territory controlled by said terrorist group we are at war with. If that territory has a cafe and he's sitting in it of course we could smoke him there.
 
What matters is whether or not said terrorist is in territory controlled by said terrorist group we are at war with. If that territory has a cafe and he's sitting in it of course we could smoke him there.

It was a cafe' in Seattle (at least that's what was said in the filibuster). The person in question was not involved in combat or other hostile actions at the time. There was no mention of it being a place being held by a terrorist group.
 
It was a cafe' in Seattle (at least that's what was said in the filibuster). The person in question was not involved in combat or other hostile actions at the time. There was no mention of it being a place being held by a terrorist group.

So, Paul is filibustering a straw man, then?
 
So, Paul is filibustering a straw man, then?

Sort of. He's clarified that the filibuster is more about getting a clarification from Holder or the President on the question of using drones on US citizens not actively engaged in hostilities. He's even said that in extraordinary situation (9/11 - Pearl Harbor) that drone strikes of course might be justified. What he's seeking is clarification on the process of the decision to use drones because the current information is not clear on that at all, and he's right, it isn't.
 
What he's seeking is clarification on the process of the decision to use drones because the current information is not clear on that at all, and he's right, it isn't.
Seems pretty clear to me. Paul should checkout his own website where Holder says it is against policy to use military force on US soil.

It's hard to do a plain text flow chart, but the decision making process would look something like this:

Use drones on US soil? ---> No.
 
You would think so however they haven't explicitly said that in relation to the memo, even when asked the direct question under oath (I presume that it was under oath seeing as it was asked at a senate committee hearing), hence the filibuster. Rand Paul has said that a simple phone call from the President or a letter from Holder giving a straight answer to the question would end the filibuster immediately.
 
That's not more protections, it's less.

I didn't say there were more protections. The post I responded to said there were no protections. I said there are some protections.

Not only are there no Constitutional issues with killing Americans who wage war agaionst the USA, but if captured they can be charged with treason rather than cooling their heels in a POW camp until the end of hostilities as non-American POWs can.

No correct, exactly. If Americans acting against America from within America are comitting a crime rather than waging a war (it is not a semantic distinction),then they enjoy the full range of constitutional protections that any other accused would enjoy. If they are actually waging war,then they enjoy the protections that any other person acting similarly would,except that they may be charged with treason while a foreign agressor could not. Each could be charged with any crime they commit, and each could be punished according to US law - and in accordance with the Constitution.
 
I didn't say there were more protections. The post I responded to said there were no protections. I said there are some protections.
How is being charged with treason "protection"?

No correct, exactly. If Americans acting against America from within America are comitting a crime rather than waging a war (it is not a semantic distinction),
We're talking about combatants in a war here, not common criminals.
 
CTists: Bush said he planned the 9/11 attacks
Rational Person: The president has made no such claim

First off, I never made any claims about what the president said to the public, invalidating your comparison in the very first sentence. Second, you're offering up a red herring. Actual nutcase conspiracy theories can be dismissed by actually examining the facts. What have you offered? Not facts, but merely an ad hominem implication that I'm a nutjob.

So... can you actually offer up any evidence that there are procedures in place which would properly vet the use of drones against American citizens on American soil, to prevent the possibility of abuse? Because I see no evidence of anything of the sort, and nobody seems to be offering any. I don't think the administration has abused that power, and I don't think they want to abuse that power, and it's likely that this president never will abuse that power. But that's simply not good enough. It's about more than just what happens within the next four years.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom