Drone strikes possible on American soil - Holder

Pretty much, yeah.

Are you offering this as an argument against using military force against Americans on American soil (in extraordinary circumstances)? Or as an argument for it?

Neither. I was just wondering whether it was relevant to the discussion. Would treason be a reason/excuse/just cause for the US Govt. to strike against US citizens?

You ask some good questions, therefore I will attempt an answer.

If a citizen of the USA allies himself with a country/organization which is making war against the USA,
And if the USA is in a state of war with that country/organization,

Then, that person would not automatically be considered to be engaged in treason.

For example, there were vast numbers of Confederate soldiers who were fighting the Union, but there were not vast numbers of these soldiers charged with treason. However, there were vast numbers of them who were captured and treated as prisioners of war.

Therefore, a US citizen can wage war on the USA without necessarily being a traitor, however that person is also in danger of becoming a prisioner of war or perhaps an enemy who is killed in the course of the war.

I hope this helps.

Hang on though. Wasn't the fact that the President at the time ((Johnson) granted them an amnesty (by a proclamation) the only reason they weren't charged with treason?

Without that amnesty, they could still have been charged.
 
Last edited:
We're talking about combatants in a war here, not common criminals.

Actually, from what Rand Paul is saying in the Senate right now the question asked in the Senate hearing today was concerning non-combatants on US soil. Holder danced around the answer.
 
I trust Obama to do whatever he feels right. After all, he won the Nobel Peace Prize and he's not George W. Bush.
 
I have no problem using drones to kill terrorists carrying explosives or other weapons, on their way to commit a terrorist act.

Other than that, use humans to conduct arrests.
 
You ask some good questions, therefore I will attempt an answer.

If a citizen of the USA allies himself with a country/organization which is making war against the USA,
And if the USA is in a state of war with that country/organization,

Then, that person would not automatically be considered to be engaged in treason.

For example, there were vast numbers of Confederate soldiers who were fighting the Union, but there were not vast numbers of these soldiers charged with treason. However, there were vast numbers of them who were captured and treated as prisioners of war.

Therefore, a US citizen can wage war on the USA without necessarily being a traitor, however that person is also in danger of becoming a prisioner of war or perhaps an enemy who is killed in the course of the war.

I hope this helps.

So treason's not the reason to make Americans in season?
 
Last edited:
Remember when people thought Bush would be able to imprison Americans in Guantanamo Bay by declaring them terrorists? And how he could just have his enemies and critics sent there because there was nothing stopping him?

I don't know which is sillier: the paranoid expectation that a president is just waiting an opportunity to go all Palpatine, or that if he did he'd be easily stopped because someone wrote a memo more carefully.

Except the American system of government is predicated on that "palpatinization" of America being prevented by a series of checks and balances which are absent with respect to this particular policy.

I agree it is unlikely, but I think the founders were wise to plan for that and try to create a system of government that would reliably prevent a return to Kingly rule by a usurper exploiting wars and emergencies to erode constitutional protections.

<insert easily google-able quote from random father here, may I suggest Madison and no country being able to protect its freedom in a state of perpetual war for starters?>
 
I have to wonder if Rand Paul would be acting the same if we had a GOP Administration and AG...........
 
Because the Executive branch has the Constitutional authority to prosecute a war, not the Judicial branch. This isn't a wiretap we're discussing.

We are getting into issues of current controversy here on unsettled policy. If you are suggesting that the war powers grant the President the authority to prosecute a war, and that in so doing his authority includes the power to waive basic constitutional rights to due process without a check from one or both other branches of government, then I think there is plenty of room for disagreement on this point.

What I am arguing here is not that the President can't prosecute a war - clearly he has war powers (though one might wonder what happened to the Congressional power to declare war, which seems to have been overlooked increasingly in the last century - another discussion). I am arguing instead that in the prosecution of this war, basic constitutional rights cannot be waived by unilateral decree subject only to the internal controls of the executive's own staff. Serious moves like this should require some balancing amongst all branches in some ratio.

More philosophically though and apart from the constitutional questions - don't we get better policy when it is shaped by competing forces whose bases of support may each bring perspective that results in better outcomes?

A "drone policy on a leash" for instance, might be more limited and see a better ratio of high-value kills to misfires than we are seeing today - retaining most of the benefit of being able to hit important targets while reducing the propagandizing effect, now spread amongst multiple countries and a huge swath of the ME and Africa, of the many misfires that happen when people are enabled to hit that button without having to worry about oversight.

It could very well be that an unrestrained drone program becomes an overal loser - when it comes to protecting America's vital interests.

Its tough for me to see the argument for keeping this the exclusive - and unchecked - province of the executive. I wonder if the bully pulpit and the center of gravity of the presidency - with its many advocates out there trying, as they always do, to preserve and enhance every aspect of presidential power isn't pulling the wool over your eyes. I think you're being snookered into supporting a bad structure that's gonna result in bad policy and bad outcomes.
 
Last edited:
Neither. I was just wondering whether it was relevant to the discussion. Would treason be a reason/excuse/just cause for the US Govt. to strike against US citizens?

My naive opinion would be "very yes."

But, were I the Commander In Chief, I'd certainly consult with my Attorney General regarding the exact legal basis, before ordering such a strike.
 
For the life of me, the answer was so easy, and Holder missed it, totally.

First, I'm not for this crap anyway. Don't know if we're making more terrorists than we're killing, I hope not. And I thought we already tried this assassination on foreign soil thing, it was a fail.

But I couldn't believe Holder missed the most obvious answer. In the US, you don't need a drone or an assassination, we have police, and courts. We're using drone murders where we have no such tools at our service.

Such a no brainer, and he missed it with all this, "we aren't planning that" reply, as if that was meaningful.
 
In the US, you don't need a drone or an assassination, we have police, and courts. We're using drone murders where we have no such tools at our service.

A terrorist group (for argument's sake with American citizens on board as willing participants) is sailing a large cargo ship with a million pounds of high-explosives wired up as a massive bomb into New York Harbour at full speed ahead.

How are your police and courts going to stop them, with an arrest warrant or court order?
 
A terrorist group (for argument's sake with American citizens on board as willing participants) is sailing a large cargo ship with a million pounds of high-explosives wired up as a massive bomb into New York Harbour at full speed ahead.

How are your police and courts going to stop them, with an arrest warrant or court order?

Do we really have armed drones that can engage such a target in the US?
 
A terrorist group (for argument's sake with American citizens on board as willing participants) is sailing a large cargo ship with a million pounds of high-explosives wired up as a massive bomb into New York Harbour at full speed ahead.

How are your police and courts going to stop them, with an arrest warrant or court order?

The use of deadly force to stop a violent attacks in progress has long been recognized as acceptable, not only on the part of the military but on the part of police and even civilians. Your scenario is not the where the controversy lies. The controversy is about the use of deadly force on people who are not currently engaged in such an act.

In a conventional military conflict, the use of deadly force against enemy forces is acceptable even if those enemy forces are not currently engaged in hostile action. In conventional law enforcement, the use of deadly force against suspects who are not currently engaged in a crime and not posing immediate threat is not acceptable. The question before us is how to handle these new, non-conventional scenarios. And your hypothetical isn't an example, since it fits easily and unambiguously into existing frameworks.

For foreign terrorists on foreign soil, the overwhelming consensus of American opinion is that the use of deadly force is acceptable even in the absence of any immediate threat. I'm OK with that too. But when it comes to Americans on American soil, I think we need to tread a lot more carefully. At the moment, it appears that there is no legal impediment to the president ordering the killing of an American on American soil, if the president designates that person a terrorist, even if that person poses no immediate threat (and again, this distinguishes the controversy from your scenario, where the answer has always been obvious).

And in principle, I'm actually OK with a terrorist being killed even if they're American, on American soil, and not posing an immediate danger. But because of the potential for abuse or even simple error, I think that the decision to do so cannot rest in the hands of one man, as it currently appears to. There must be a process behind it which would make people feel comfortable no matter who the president was. And I simply don't find it credible that everyone defending Obama on this issue would actually feel comfortable if Bush was doing this instead. If you can't abide by a president you hate wielding a power, then it's too much power, even for a president you like.
 
There is no difference between a terrorist getting shot dead by a cop, or shot dead by a drone.


Did you think Christopher Dorner should have been killed by drone? Apparently you wouldn’t have a problem with it. What would be the national reaction to see this man killed live on television by drone? I say Blacks would riot in every city like they did when King was assassinated.

BTW Dorner was a domestic terrorist.
http://en.metapedia.org/wiki/Christopher_Dorner
 
I admit that the whole Stasi-like setup created by 'W' really does give me the creeps, and I think there needs to be some kind of proceedings before killing someone on american soil EXCEPT IN COMMISSION OF A CRIME. If a cop would be justified in shooting, I have no problem with a drone.

I don’t know why you want to bring Bush into this. It is Obama and his Attorney General who wants the authority to kill US citizens who have been labeled as terrorists on American soil.
 
I agree completely.

I also agree with the Attorney General, that there may be extreme cases where the use of military force within the borders of the US is the most appropriate lawful route to take.

ETA: In fact, after reading over the last few posts in this thread, I think we're all pretty much in agreement*.












*With one obvious exception.

You can’t use the military to enforce civilian laws.
 
Remember the collateral damage made by drones.

A drone armed with a high-powered rifle would likely leave little to no collateral damage, when taking out a terrorist, Neo-Nazi, Klansman, "Patriot", or other enemy of the state.
 
I don’t know why you want to bring Bush into this. It is Obama and his Attorney General who wants the authority to kill US citizens who have been labeled as terrorists on American soil.

The Department of Justice is already authorized to kill any terrorist in the USA who is about to carry out a terror attack.

If someone is walking down the street wrapped in explosives, heading towards his target, the DOJ doesn't need permission to take him out, by any means available.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom