smartcooky
Penultimate Amazing
Pretty much, yeah.
Are you offering this as an argument against using military force against Americans on American soil (in extraordinary circumstances)? Or as an argument for it?
Neither. I was just wondering whether it was relevant to the discussion. Would treason be a reason/excuse/just cause for the US Govt. to strike against US citizens?
You ask some good questions, therefore I will attempt an answer.
If a citizen of the USA allies himself with a country/organization which is making war against the USA,
And if the USA is in a state of war with that country/organization,
Then, that person would not automatically be considered to be engaged in treason.
For example, there were vast numbers of Confederate soldiers who were fighting the Union, but there were not vast numbers of these soldiers charged with treason. However, there were vast numbers of them who were captured and treated as prisioners of war.
Therefore, a US citizen can wage war on the USA without necessarily being a traitor, however that person is also in danger of becoming a prisioner of war or perhaps an enemy who is killed in the course of the war.
I hope this helps.
Hang on though. Wasn't the fact that the President at the time ((Johnson) granted them an amnesty (by a proclamation) the only reason they weren't charged with treason?
Without that amnesty, they could still have been charged.
Last edited: