Drone strikes possible on American soil - Holder

That's right. As I said, I am amending/ramping up the scenario, trying to feel for what the limits are; at what point does due process go out the window, and definitive action become called for.

So, instead of imminent danger, what about this?

In 1919, the U.S. Supreme Court said that “The most stringent protection of free speech would not protect a man falsely shouting fire in a theatre and causing a panic” . This case was about the first amendment right to free speech, and effectively has set a precedent which limits that right.

The USSC thereby made it clear that the right to free speech is not absolute, in that freedom to speak you mind is not freedom to endanger the lives of others. It had to pass a test called “Clear and Present Danger.”

Some years ago I read a Tom Clancy fiction novel of the same name, in which the President authorised his Chief of Staff to order up an air-strike on a Drug Lord's mansion in Columbia because he considered that Cartel to be a clear and present danger to the United States.

I read that book and there are no actual comparisons as the intended targets were neither US Citizens or were they on US soil. All of that aside the ending was not favorable for the president and his advisers (the president didn't seek re-election and the architects of the plan either ended up out of a job or committed suicide) so you might not want to use that anyway.

1st Question: Can the Clear and Present Danger test be applied to anything other than the First Amendment right to free speech? In other words, can it be used to assess someone's actions rather than speech?

2nd Question: If so, could the President use this as a constitutional justification to order an air-strike against the target I mentioned earlier?

See Eric Holders letter in response to Rand Pauls question for the answer. His response was what I've been saying all along. People seem to be keep adding to the basic question to make the answer anything other than no.

Of course there will be conditions where deadly force is a valid action, to say otherwise is just plain stupid. However the general rule is that for the application of it has to be when the intended target is a direct threat at the time that deadly force is used. This is not a trick question or a gotcha question. It's a very straightforward question that needed a straightforward answer after the first answer was ambiguous by any reasonable measure considering the leaked memos regarding drone strikes on US Citizens abroad was intentionally written to get around the legalities involved.
 
That is an excellent point!

It also supports the point that I made which was that if a citizen of the USA were to wage war on the USA, then that person is not automatically considered to be a traitor to the USA.

Seems to be that US Government killed an awful lot of Confederate Soldiers without legal proceedings.
 
President Obama brings an Al-Qaeda terrorist to NYC to face a civilian trial in civilian court, with a tax-payer funded lawyer for his involvement in 9-11, and folks are actually afraid that Obama will use drones to kill American citizens in the USA?

Guys & girls, please get a grip.
 
See Eric Holders letter in response to Rand Pauls question for the answer. His response was what I've been saying all along. People seem to be keep adding to the basic question to make the answer anything other than no.

Of course there will be conditions where deadly force is a valid action, to say otherwise is just plain stupid. However the general rule is that for the application of it has to be when the intended target is a direct threat at the time that deadly force is used. This is not a trick question or a gotcha question. It's a very straightforward question that needed a straightforward answer after the first answer was ambiguous by any reasonable measure considering the leaked memos regarding drone strikes on US Citizens abroad was intentionally written to get around the legalities involved.

A satisfactory answer.

Thank you.
 
Because that is Al Qaeda's victory condition?

Fairly common sense logic actually - the most extreme moments shouldn't be a guide to how to act in far less extreme moments.

Click through, not a long piece by any means and Conor puts it pretty well!
 
So we can agree that Clinton's attacks on bin Laden by cruise missile were unconstitutional? I want some consistency here.
Wow. Nice strawman. The topic is US citizens in the US.

So no, we can't agree. Clinton's only fault imo was not taking bin Laden when the offer from Sudan (or was it some other country?) was made. We have him; do you want him?
 
If you are an American citizen who joins Al Qaeda, Hezbollah, Hamas, the IRA, Neo-Nazis, KKK, or some other terrorist group and strap bombs to you chest to blow up a mall or school, I don't care how you are killed....but you are gonna get snuffed.
 
You mean the Posse Comitatus Act I mentioned in the post you quoted?


That one ?

And yes, some (many, actually) people do distinguish between the NG and the U.S. military in certain circumstances, because that's what the Posse Comitatus Act was explicitly meant to do.
Sorry, my bad. :o I don't know what I was posting there. I think I got distracted when my son called on the phone and I was trying to finish the post up.

I didn't even finish my post. I meant to quote the exceptions paragraph in the Wiki link and point out I don't see the Nat'l Guard as the same thing as the military the Act refers to because they aren't under Federal control at that point:
Exclusions and limitations

There are a number of situations in which the Act does not apply. These include:

National Guard units and state defense forces while under the authority of the governor of a state;
Troops used under the order of the President of the United States pursuant to the Insurrection Act, as was the case during the 1992 Los Angeles Riots.
Under 18 U.S.C. § 831, the Attorney General may request that the Secretary of Defense provide emergency assistance if civilian law enforcement is inadequate to address certain types of threats involving the release of nuclear materials, such as potential use of a nuclear or radiological weapon. Such assistance may be by any personnel under the authority of the Department of Defense, provided such assistance does not adversely affect U.S. military preparedness. The only exemption is nuclear materials.
Support roles under the Joint Special Operations Command
 
....
See Eric Holders letter in response to Rand Pauls question for the answer. His response was what I've been saying all along. People seem to be keep adding to the basic question to make the answer anything other than no.....
Paul is bragging today that it took his 13 hr filibuster to get the answer and he's claiming US citizens in the US are now safe because he got his written answer. :rolleyes:


[sidenote] Rachel Maddow showed a clip tonight of young Ron Paul arguing with Morton Downey Jr (Paul's pro-drug and he points out Downey's cigarettes are much more deadly and legal). Young Ron really looks a lot like Rand. [/sidenote]
 
Paul is bragging today that it took his 13 hr filibuster to get the answer and he's claiming US citizens in the US are now safe because he got his written answer. :rolleyes:

I heard his comments and while I thought that that was a pretty dumb thing to say he did get what he asked for. I think that the question that he asked was an inevitable one though, how could it not be considering the language in the leaked memo? Of course the answer Holder gave was also obvious but there's nothing inherently wrong with dotting your i's and crossing your t's.
 
So was the scambling of air assets durring 9/11 wrong if they had actually done anything? An illegal and unconstitutional act?

Define "done anything". If you mean if they had shot down one of the hijacked aircraft, it's a tough question legally. You could certainly argue that Flight 93 or Flight 77 would have been intercepted in the course of attacking military targets (Flight 77 certainly did) and therefore were fair game for the military just as US fighters intercepting Russian fighters during the Cold War would have been. Flight 11 and 175? Tougher cases.

Of course this is in a strictly legalistic sense (and no, any shoot-downs that day would not have been unconstitutional; in fact violations of Posse Comitatus would not be unconstitutional per se, just illegal). But I don't know; it may be that Posse Comitatus does not apply in the sky for obvious reasons. Pragmatically of course, nobody would have had a serious problem with shooting down any of the four planes, if at least one had hit its target, because it would be accepted that it was the only rational solution to a very difficult problem. I don't think it would have been a problem even if (say) Cheney had authorized the shooting down of Flight 93 and it had happened, even though many legal scholars have stated he did not have that authority under the chain of command.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom