Drone strikes possible on American soil - Holder

There is no difference between a terrorist getting shot dead by a cop, or shot dead by a drone.

In theory, the terrorist getting shot by a cop is directly engaging the cop and the cop is protecting himself from an immediate threat to his life. There's an active attempt to detain the suspect that has gone violent. That's not really happening with a drone strike - we've decided ahead of time to kill him.

I do agree that talking about drones is kinda obscuring the issue. The question shouldn't be about whether or not we could use drones to kill US citizens on US soil, but rather, can the government make the advanced, deliberate decision to kill a US citizen on US soil? If so, whether that is done by drone, cruise missile, sniper rifle, artillery bombardment, etc is irrelevant.

An argument can be made either way. We control the land and therefore should be able to manage to detain the person in question. Then comes the issue of what happens if it turns into a standoff - the person has fortified themselves in such a position that we no longer control the land and attempts to remove the person is a direct danger to others. Is it OK in that situation? How long until we get to that point? What about if there is an immediate threat from the location, say a person can launch a rocket filled with nerve gas at a moment's notice?

I would assume that if you have a suspect on US soil, the gov't would be way more interested in capturing him/her. They'd be much more valuable alive than dead, and capture is infinitely more feasible on your own soil than foreign soil. So blowing them up would be only in an emergency sort of deal. Of course, that's assuming that the government only goes after people it truly thinks are terrorists and has good evidence that they are real threat rather than using "oh he/she was a terrorist, so we had to kill him/her" as an excuse to off whomever they wanted to.

I'd argue that in extreme situations, it would be OK, but there needs to be accountability when the decision is made. It would have to essentially be a warrant. If there's not enough time in advance to do that (e.g. "guy is going to set off a nuke in 5 minutes, we need to kill him NOW!" situation), then there needs to be review after the fact. Why was it done? Was it the only reasonable course of action? All of it would have to be made public eventually.
 
Last edited:
From the quote given, it does not appear that Holder is talking about "targeted assassination" specifically. "Extraordinary circumstances" could include tactical circumstances.
Lets say, a heavily-armed terrorist group holed up in a fortified area. An assault might be quite costly in terms of casualties... Whereas a Hellfire could take care of the situation rather neatly.
That's pretty much what the lads in combat do these days... Getting fire from building X? Blow up buiding X.
 
The Constitution doesn't actually protect American citizens who choose to wage war against America from within America's borders. Never has. Never will. Never should.

Seconded!

The way that the law is currently written, it is quite lawful for the President to kill anyone that the USA is at war with.

Therefore, as long as the President can show that he is properly acting within the war powers that have been provided, then drones, planes, guns, tanks, sticks, or barehands, or any other sort of weapon can be used to kill the individuals in question.

Accordingly, if someone has a problem with the way that the law is being executed, then the law needs to be changed.
 
So why does the President need to claim this power? Holder asserts that in the aftermath of a new attack, they would prefer "as a policy matter" (not legal, apparently) to rely on extant law enforcement forces to capture terrorists involved in a new attack.

But why would the President need to claim the power ahead of time - as if congress would not immediately grant any request to enable him to kill or capture terrorists involved?

We don't need to grant the executive a new power here, the existing constitutional and procedural processes for granting the executive power to do something should be sufficient. In the aftermath of an attack, why shouldn't we ask the President to get congressional authorization? Emergency sessions could be convened and I'm sure if something immediate needs to be done the congress could add some element of retroactivity for an action if it needed it...
 
So why does the President need to claim this power? Holder asserts that in the aftermath of a new attack, they would prefer "as a policy matter" (not legal, apparently) to rely on extant law enforcement forces to capture terrorists involved in a new attack.

But why would the President need to claim the power ahead of time - as if congress would not immediately grant any request to enable him to kill or capture terrorists involved?

We don't need to grant the executive a new power here, the existing constitutional and procedural processes for granting the executive power to do something should be sufficient. In the aftermath of an attack, why shouldn't we ask the President to get congressional authorization? Emergency sessions could be convened and I'm sure if something immediate needs to be done the congress could add some element of retroactivity for an action if it needed it...
Perhaps before our current president held office but now.....

I would expect if Russia and China troops landed on the east and west coasts, Republicans in Congress would demand any increase in spending to thwart the invasion would need to be offset by budget cuts to address the real problems facing this country, entitlements.
 
Yea that is why we need to disarm SWAT teams and never have police snipers. The executive assassinating americans that is.

Terminating a person who is actively engaged in a criminal activity is quite different from drone striking someone who is just suspect of criminal activity.
 
Well in a country ostensibly founded to oppose the writ of the deified King - whose gift to the world was a vision of democracy predicated on the prevention of authoritarian rule by the presence of a series of checks and balances embedded throughout the structure of government - it's a bit sad to see the erosion of these checks advance to such a place nowadays.

If Obama is claiming the Imperial Presidency requires the capacity to kill american citizens without oversight from another branch of government and no opportunity for accountability for these actions - and that an attack on American soil or other such emergency pre-justifies it - then isn't the American political system gone some way from it's founding principles?

The ability of kings to issue "bills of attainder", determining guilt by royal decree alone, was a galvanizing point driving America to revolution (in fact the constitution specifically forbids it). Not only is Obama claiming the right to issue a modern form of a "bill of attainder", but Holder is claiming that the grounds to support this rest in what would happen after an emergency. But aren't emergency and war situations the exact periods when tyrants are likely to show their colours and seek to leverage the emergency to consolidate their power? Wouldn't emergency and war situations - rather than being grounds to justify increasing executive power - be the moments when some form of control over the executive is actually most required?

There may be a latent trust in American political leadership that let's these erosions proceed unchecked - but the founders didn't rest their Republic on the bet that future leaders would be benign and wise and just. In fact they designed their whole system on the idea that maybe one day the leadership would require systemic checks against their power to prevent abuse and the potential death of republican democracy in America.
 
Drone strikes possible on American soil - Holder
http://security.blogs.cnn.com/2013/03/05/holder-drone-strike-against-americans-in-the-u-s-possible/
So much for constitutional protection.

Just to reiterate, here is what Holder said:
In the letter, Holder said “It is possible I suppose to imagine an extraordinary circumstance in which it would be necessary and appropriate under the Constitution and applicable laws of the United States for the President to authorize the military to use lethal force within the territory of the United States.“
Now, who here, besides the OP, doesn't understand what the highlighted words mean?
 
Wouldn't a US citizen waging war against the Government of the United States be committing treason under Article III - 3 of your Constitution?

Treason against the United States, shall consist only in levying War against them, or in adhering to their Enemies, giving them Aid and Comfort. No Person shall be convicted of Treason unless on the Testimony of two Witnesses to the same overt Act, or on Confession in open Court. The Congress shall have Power to declare the Punishment of Treason, but no Attainder of Treason shall work Corruption of Blood, or Forfeiture except during the Life of the Person attained.

Come to think of it, any US Citizen who assists Arab terrorists against America's "War on Terror" (e.g. Ahmad Abousamra) would also be committing treason wouldn't they?
Pretty much, yeah.

Are you offering this as an argument against using military force against Americans on American soil (in extraordinary circumstances)? Or as an argument for it?

Or are you just pointing it out as an interesting(?) bit of constitutional trivia?
 
Just to reiterate, here is what Holder said:

Now, who here, besides the OP, doesn't understand what the highlighted words mean?

Yep.

And even if it were to happen in these extraordinary circumstances, I see nothing that says there couldn't be oversight after the fact to make sure it was proper.
 
It is not often that I agree with theprestige here in Politics, but this is no-brainer.

Holder is saying that it is possible to come up with an imaginary scenario where you might Constitutionally use drone strikes against US citizens on US soil. Of course, it is. Here, I'll give you one right now:

There is an invading foreign army invading Oregon from the north, complete with tanks, mobile missile launchers, air support, the whole nine yards. Included in that army are, let's say, 1000 US citizens who have actively taken up arms against their country. They are driving equipment, firing guns, and wearing the uniforms of the foreign army. In such a situation, would it not be reasonable for the US to use drone strikes (and more) against those US citizens?​

There ya go. I have imagined a scenario where you might Constitutionally use drone strikes against US citizens.
 
It's funny when neo-nazis act like they're suddenly concerned about human rights.

I guess it's like Goering at Nuremburg.
 
Reasonable with room for due process as well.

What due process do people who have swat going after them get? It is all about what situation he was thinking of. It is hypothetically possible for air strikes in the us to be justifiable. I don't really care if a drone or a manned aircraft does it.
 
The Constitution doesn't actually protect American citizens who choose to wage war against America from within America's borders. Never has. Never will. Never should.

I don't believe this is correct. The Constitution provides some protections to persons that wage war against the US, including American's within America. Indeed, the manner of charging such persons with treason is spelled out in the constitution.

Of course, if what you mean is that the Constitution does not guarantee that Americans waging war against America from within America will not have a missle land on them, I agree.
 
It's funny when neo-nazis act like they're suddenly concerned about human rights.

I guess it's like Goering at Nuremburg.

Or Americans worrying about the plight of Afghan women in the 00's - but not so much in the 80s

;)
 
Last edited:
What due process do people who have swat going after them get? It is all about what situation he was thinking of. It is hypothetically possible for air strikes in the us to be justifiable. I don't really care if a drone or a manned aircraft does it.

It is situational, yes. In dire circumstance, the due process can be carried out afterwards.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom