bonzombiekitty
Graduate Poster
- Joined
- Jun 23, 2011
- Messages
- 1,848
There is no difference between a terrorist getting shot dead by a cop, or shot dead by a drone.
In theory, the terrorist getting shot by a cop is directly engaging the cop and the cop is protecting himself from an immediate threat to his life. There's an active attempt to detain the suspect that has gone violent. That's not really happening with a drone strike - we've decided ahead of time to kill him.
I do agree that talking about drones is kinda obscuring the issue. The question shouldn't be about whether or not we could use drones to kill US citizens on US soil, but rather, can the government make the advanced, deliberate decision to kill a US citizen on US soil? If so, whether that is done by drone, cruise missile, sniper rifle, artillery bombardment, etc is irrelevant.
An argument can be made either way. We control the land and therefore should be able to manage to detain the person in question. Then comes the issue of what happens if it turns into a standoff - the person has fortified themselves in such a position that we no longer control the land and attempts to remove the person is a direct danger to others. Is it OK in that situation? How long until we get to that point? What about if there is an immediate threat from the location, say a person can launch a rocket filled with nerve gas at a moment's notice?
I would assume that if you have a suspect on US soil, the gov't would be way more interested in capturing him/her. They'd be much more valuable alive than dead, and capture is infinitely more feasible on your own soil than foreign soil. So blowing them up would be only in an emergency sort of deal. Of course, that's assuming that the government only goes after people it truly thinks are terrorists and has good evidence that they are real threat rather than using "oh he/she was a terrorist, so we had to kill him/her" as an excuse to off whomever they wanted to.
I'd argue that in extreme situations, it would be OK, but there needs to be accountability when the decision is made. It would have to essentially be a warrant. If there's not enough time in advance to do that (e.g. "guy is going to set off a nuke in 5 minutes, we need to kill him NOW!" situation), then there needs to be review after the fact. Why was it done? Was it the only reasonable course of action? All of it would have to be made public eventually.
Last edited: