Drone strikes possible on American soil - Holder

I don't believe this is correct. The Constitution provides some protections to persons that wage war against the US, including American's within America. Indeed, the manner of charging such persons with treason is spelled out in the constitution.
That's not more protections, it's less. Not only are there no Constitutional issues with killing Americans who wage war agaionst the USA, but if captured they can be charged with treason rather than cooling their heels in a POW camp until the end of hostilities as non-American POWs can.
 
There is no difference between a terrorist getting shot dead by a cop, or shot dead by a drone.

Actually, there is.

Cops aren't allowed to simply shoot, they can only use deadly force in certain circumstances. So if a suspect (even a terrorist suspect) is just walking down the street, a cop can't just pull up and shoot them. They're supposed to just arrest the suspect if possible, and only use deadly force in response to direct threats.

But drones don't, and can't, work that way. The only recourse an armed drone has is shoot to kill. And that really does make it fundamentally different than police shootings, at least legally justified police shootings (although we've seen recently police don't always act that way).

MaGZ is generally just a hateful troll, and I despise taking what even looks like "his" side on an issue. But there really is a massive due process problem here. There is no formal check on the president's power to determine who is a terrorist, including US citizens, and if people so designated can be summarily killed on US soil, then the president really is claiming the power to kill whomever he wants. At the moment, I can't imagine that the president would do something like use this power to kill a political adversary (say, Rush Limbaugh), because the chain of command would probably rebel at such a blatant abuse of power. But the fact is that this check on his power isn't actually part of the formal system. And it needs to be. The defense of "they wouldn't do that" isn't good enough, the process must include mechanisms so that we can say with confidence, "they cannot do that."

Look, I don't want terrorists treated like common criminals. And if you decide to become a terrorist whose goal is the destruction of our country, you've got no claim to constitutional protections anymore, as far as I'm concerned. But the issue isn't just about what protection terrorists deserve. It's about what protection we all deserve. The process MUST have checks against abuse, or one of these days it will get abused.
 
MaGZ is generally just a hateful troll, and I despise taking what even looks like "his" side on an issue. But there really is a massive due process problem here. There is no formal check on the president's power to determine who is a terrorist, including US citizens, and if people so designated can be summarily killed on US soil, then the president really is claiming the power to kill whomever he wants.
The President has made no such claim. No one but MaGZ is suggesting this.
 
Wouldn't a US citizen waging war against the Government of the United States be committing treason under Article III - 3 of your Constitution?

Treason against the United States, shall consist only in levying War against them, or in adhering to their Enemies, giving them Aid and Comfort. No Person shall be convicted of Treason unless on the Testimony of two Witnesses to the same overt Act, or on Confession in open Court. The Congress shall have Power to declare the Punishment of Treason, but no Attainder of Treason shall work Corruption of Blood, or Forfeiture except during the Life of the Person attained.

Come to think of it, any US Citizen who assists Arab terrorists against America's "War on Terror" (e.g. Ahmad Abousamra) would also be committing treason wouldn't they?

You ask some good questions, therefore I will attempt an answer.

If a citizen of the USA allies himself with a country/organization which is making war against the USA,
And if the USA is in a state of war with that country/organization,

Then, that person would not automatically be considered to be engaged in treason.

For example, there were vast numbers of Confederate soldiers who were fighting the Union, but there were not vast numbers of these soldiers charged with treason. However, there were vast numbers of them who were captured and treated as prisioners of war.

Therefore, a US citizen can wage war on the USA without necessarily being a traitor, however that person is also in danger of becoming a prisioner of war or perhaps an enemy who is killed in the course of the war.

I hope this helps.
 
The President has made no such claim.

The President has been... less than transparent on the issue. If you think I'm wrong, do tell: what formal process in in place to check the president's power in this regard?
 
CTists: Bush said he planned the 9/11 attacks
Rational Person: The president has made no such claim
The President has been... less than transparent on the issue. If you think I'm wrong, do tell: what formal process in in place to check the president's power in this regard?
 
MaG threads bring out the best in all of us

As long as the AG is imagining things, I’ll imagine that the only Americans ever likely to need drone therapy are right-wing nazi-wannabes. To be sure, the great majority of these dime-store Himmlers don’t actually take any action; they stay up in their rooms, or out in the garage, or down in Mom’s basement, posting and pasting on internet forums while modeling their brown shirts and trying on Charlie Chaplin moustaches in front of the mirror.

But they’re certainly crazy enough, and evil-minded enough, to be led by a sufficiently charismatic arsch hohle to fashion bombs and try for some sort of fame by attacking, say, a day-care center or a veterans’ hospital. (Some of them have already canonized Little Tim McVeigh, so why not imitate him?) In cases like that, Old Dr. Hellfire’s Radical-Ridding Enema will be just the ticket.
 
I don't believe this is correct. The Constitution provides some protections to persons that wage war against the US, including American's within America. Indeed, the manner of charging such persons with treason is spelled out in the constitution.

Of course, if what you mean is that the Constitution does not guarantee that Americans waging war against America from within America will not have a missle land on them, I agree.

Fair enough. I accept your interpretation without reserve.
 
The President has been... less than transparent on the issue. If you think I'm wrong, do tell: what formal process in in place to check the president's power in this regard?
Seriously? That is what you're going with? "Prove that he can't"?

Should we just cut to the chase and send this to CT?


eta: perhaps I was premature. Not holding my breath, but waiting for confirmation.
 
Last edited:
Upchurch - we have a memo released lately that is apparently largely in-agreement with the real legal memo outlining the drone strike justification.

But so far it is still "secret law". We don't know what might be in the secret memo that didn't make it to the public in the publicized one. So far there is no indication another branch of government has any kind of meaningful input, though it looks like congress might have a bit more of a role here than the judiciary, which is entirely absent.
 
Last edited:
Upchurch - we have a memo released lately that is apparently largely in-agreement with the real legal memo outlining the drone strike justification.

But so far it is still "secret law". We don't know what might be in the secret memo that didn't make it to the public in the publicized one. So far there is no indication another branch of government has any kind of meaningful input, though it looks like congress might have a bit more of a role here than the judiciary, which is entirely absent.

The judiciary has no role unless a case is brought before it.

The legislature has a substantial oversight role, but that role is also discretionary.

There is no "secret law"; the AG's memos simply convey his interpretation of the current laws. If he writes a confidential memo to the president, saying the president can violate the constitution, that's not a secret law, that's just bad advice. If the president acts on that advice, he's not enacting a secret law, he's just following bad advice. And if the legislature catches him doing it, they can impeach him and remove him from office.

It would be extremely silly for the AG to tell congress he's giving the president good advice, while secretly giving the president bad advice.

But, okay, whatever. The point is, the legislature has plenty of oversight authority over the president at war. Currently, the legislature is satisfied that the president is acting within the boundaries of the war powers they authorized, and within the boundaries of the constitution. The legislature is fully empowered to increase their oversight activities, constrain the president's authority, or bring a case before the judiciary, at any time.

What, specifically, would you like the legislature to do, above and beyond what they are currently doing to oversee the president at war?
 
A month ago there were posters on this very forum that swore up and down that the memo in question would never apply to drones over US soil and that the idea was preposterous. When it was pointed out that the memo didn't exclude it they still said that it wouldn't apply and that the people who thought that it could were crazy.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=252711&page=4

Who's crazy now. Holder himself has now said that it could apply to American citizens on American soil. Now I don't really think that Obama is going to do this but it sets a precedent that the next president (or the one after that, repeat as needed) will end up using and cite this as precedent.
 
The judiciary has no role unless a case is brought before it.

Sure, so why not take the FISA model and bring it into the drone strike program and bring cases before it?

TThe legislature has a substantial oversight role, but that role is also discretionary....

They are brought in late, shown only documents the executive self-selects, and prevented from seeing documents the executive wants to keep secret. Even established committees that ostensibly are in-place to deal with secrecy are not trusted fully - otherwise we wouldn't have members of the legislature complaining that they don't have all the facts.

What I would prefer is that drone policy not be formulated and executed by the President but rather formulated by congress by the passage of a law that the President subsequently executes. Within this law would be a codification of when strikes are legal, congress would have full understanding of the legal rationale (the rationale would be a part of the legislation and thus open to everybody, including the public, to see). I would also like to see some form of review after the fact that enables accountability to be exercised over the executive by the legislature. Ideally each drone strike would be approved in a FISA-like court, with potentially some avenue for retroactive review from a FISA-like court in instances where it is determined speed-to-action is so critical a prior check isn't possible.

At least with the knowledge those strikes would be immediately reviewed by another branch of government, the executive would ensure that strikes which can't be approved in advance stand up to scrutiny after the fact.

This would make me much more comfortable.


There is no "secret law"; the AG's memos simply convey his interpretation of the current laws.

There is a secret memo, which no one outside the executive has seen, with the legal rationale enabling the president to kill foreigners and Americans with drones. Because the rationale is not known and is secret, the legal basis from which the President derives this power is secret and thusly "secret law".

Further reading on "secret law":
http://www.theatlantic.com/politics...ourts-from-enforcing-the-constitution/266779/
http://www.theatlantic.com/politics...nes-like-a-secret-is-inherently-crazy/273458/
 
Who's crazy now. Holder himself has now said that he supposes it is possible to imagine an extraordinary circumstance where it could apply to American citizens on American soil.

Fixed it for you. And those same people are still crazy.
 
Except that people were adamant in saying that there was no possible situation where the memo would apply to US Soil. Read the thread.

You read it. He didn't say it was actually possible or even remotely likely, only that he supposes it was possible to imagine an extraordinary circumstance. I could imagine something with space aliens or underground mole men.
 
Ya I think the concerns are a little more material than your scorn would indicate Upchurch... but hey, you're entitled to get your jollies from a little taunting... it CAN be fun I agree! ;)
 
Ya I think the concerns are a little more material than your scorn would indicate Upchurch... but hey, you're entitled to get your jollies from a little taunting... it CAN be fun I agree! ;)
:D

I'm not (intentionally) trolling. While the issue, itself, is a serious one, people are putting words in Holder's mouth by cherry-picking what he actually said. It's fine to be concerned about what the government thinks it can and cannot do, but we should still base it on evidence, rather than logical fallacies and the lack of evidence.
 
It is not often that I agree with theprestige here in Politics, but this is no-brainer.

Holder is saying that it is possible to come up with an imaginary scenario where you might Constitutionally use drone strikes against US citizens on US soil. Of course, it is. Here, I'll give you one right now:

There is an invading foreign army invading Oregon from the north, complete with tanks, mobile missile launchers, air support, the whole nine yards. Included in that army are, let's say, 1000 US citizens who have actively taken up arms against their country. They are driving equipment, firing guns, and wearing the uniforms of the foreign army. In such a situation, would it not be reasonable for the US to use drone strikes (and more) against those US citizens?​

There ya go. I have imagined a scenario where you might Constitutionally use drone strikes against US citizens.
Most of us are more worried about targeting single individuals.

I suspect you knew that when you decided to pull that scenario out of ...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom