Climate change scepticism - its sources and origins

Status
Not open for further replies.
You claimed that current scientific knowledge does not justify doing more to curb emissions. Do you think it justifies what we do now? Why or why not?

Hmmm...

I'm not sure how to answer this really. Beyond what we are already doing, what more can be done? At some point this voluntary effort will have to become policed or mandated right? I mean it's fine and dandy for us in the Western world to pay more for gas, and put high efficiency windows in our homes, but how do we mandate this to the up and coming societies of the world, who have only begun to consume energy at a similar rate? How much money can we throw at this problem while another hole forms in the dike? Can the US economy afford to build 150 nuclear power plants, while 300 coal plants get built overseas?

It seems like token efforts until we fully understand what we can do and how it will affect the climate. Then we can sit down and say you need to do this, you need to do that, we'll do this, he'll do that, in 15 years the level will be back to X ppm and the temperature will stabilize at y degrees.

That's neglecting my personal opinion that there are far better ways at mitigating CO2 effects than simply shifting money around western society.

"Justifies" is probably the wrong word, because an immediate ban on CO2 emissions would be justified. I mean a zero tolerance policy could be justified at this point. It would mean a heck of a change in civilization. Maybe the word I'm looking for is warranted?
 
Look, I've given up on convincing you of anything to do with the science of AGW, but please, if you take anything away from these multiple threads, let it be the notion of supporting your claims withe evidence.

Who are you talking about? Over the course of the last 30 years we have literally multiplied our understanding of climate dynamics by a large factor. Maybe we thought CO2 should have done more in 1990, but then scientists discovered more information about sinks and other related factors.

You're making a blanket statement based on something that no one here but you has any notion of. If you just give us a reference, we can have a discussion, but what exactly do you want me to say about that claim you just made? I have no idea what you're talking about.


This isn't a hard concept really. Just bring up "Since the 1800's the concentration of CO2 has risen 35% from 285 ppm to 385 ppm and the temperature has risen about 1 degree" with a few random people and see what kind of reaction you get. Explain to them how many tons this actually is. If they go running away screaming then it was surprisingly high, if they shrug on go "oh really" it was surprisingly low.

Or try saying "last year the concentration of CO2 rose 2 ppm last year, that's almost like 0.02 grams per cubic foot!" and see how they react.

It's merely a reflection of what we are measuring. A 35% increase in CO2 seems high, and it is, but 1 degree seems kinda low but isn't.
 
This isn't a hard concept really. Just bring up "Since the 1800's the concentration of CO2 has risen 35% from 285 ppm to 385 ppm and the temperature has risen about 1 degree" with a few random people and see what kind of reaction you get. Explain to them how many tons this actually is. If they go running away screaming then it was surprisingly high, if they shrug on go "oh really" it was surprisingly low.

Or try saying "last year the concentration of CO2 rose 2 ppm last year, that's almost like 0.02 grams per cubic foot!" and see how they react.

It's merely a reflection of what we are measuring. A 35% increase in CO2 seems high, and it is, but 1 degree seems kinda low but isn't.

So your "evidence" supporting this claim of yours, "The increase in CO2 concentration has had a surprisingly small effect to date," is that random people might agree with that statement if asked in a certain way?

I don't even know what to say at this point.

Walk around the streets of the United States and ask people to point out Iraq on a map. Chances are 2/3rds of them will be way off. Does that mean Iraq is in Australia?

Are you abandoning your claim about the limited impact of CO2 then? This is just baffling. You initially asserted the CO2 claim as though it was fact, and now you say it isn't fact, just misguided perception. What is your point with all of this?
 
I do however represent a portion of the population trained in the fundamentals of climate science and heavily invested my time and energy in the pursuit of producing power for human use. I'd say there are possibly 5% of the population in a better position than myself to lead the way. I've positioned myself to be in the business of running, buying and selling power plants within the next 10 years. With an MBA I could probably achieve this sooner, but that would take another 2 years of University.

Dude. Let me get this straight. You have a vested interest in *power plants*. You know, those things dotted around the planet that are one of the primary causes of all the man-made CO2 in the atmosphere... and you expect us to take anything you say about climate change seriously? Am I on freakin' Candid Camera? Did anyone else pick up on this?

OK, humour us. What *kind* of power plants are you planning on buying, running, and selling? :popcorn1
 
Dude. Let me get this straight. You have a vested interest in *power plants*. You know, those things dotted around the planet that are one of the primary causes of all the man-made CO2 in the atmosphere... and you expect us to take anything you say about climate change seriously? Am I on freakin' Candid Camera? Did anyone else pick up on this?

OK, humour us. What *kind* of power plants are you planning on buying, running, and selling? :popcorn1

PM me.
 
I knew it! I *am* on Candid Camera. No, I think the rest of the readers here would like to hear your explanation too.

And while we're at it, there's been a lot of wailing and gnashing of teeth here concerning the supposed uncertainty of climate models. Go here for a fantastic explanation of the greenhouse gas forcing *done without models*, just good ol' statistics:

http://tamino.wordpress.com/2009/08/17/not-computer-models/

But the deniers won't read that, of course.

I like what Steve Schneider said in the OP

In fact it always makes me laugh to hear circumspect scientists, especially physicists who know nothing about climate, coming in and telling us, 'I don't believe in models.' Oh sure, so what do you believe in? 'Well, I look at the data.' Well, as soon as you've associated two pieces of data you're a modeller, you're just a lousy modeller because it's so much better to be explicit in varied parameters you're unsure about than to sit there and assume that you can just extrapolate that kind of stuff. Or the alternative, say nothing and let the society fall into traps. Most of us would rather not do that.
 
I knew it! I *am* on Candid Camera. No, I think the rest of the readers here would like to hear your explanation too.

And while we're at it, there's been a lot of wailing and gnashing of teeth here concerning the supposed uncertainty of climate models. Go here for a fantastic explanation of the greenhouse gas forcing *done without models*, just good ol' statistics:

http://tamino.wordpress.com/2009/08/17/not-computer-models/

But the deniers won't read that, of course.

Sure, just post your phone number here and I'll call you and tell you all about it. :D

You're not new, you know better than ask for personal information to be posted. And I doubt if I can answer this satisfactorily without doing so but whatever. I work for a large company that has many plants, from wind turbine farms to nuclear all over the world. I'm barely involved with running one, and certainly not running one myself just yet. Heck I won't even work there in another week or so. I've been invited to work at other plants and there's certainly nothing from stopping me from working my way into a plant manager position within a few short years. I lack experience but have more than enough education right now. Being of the Common Wealth makes it that much easier for me to travel around the world, potentially buying and selling plants for the company in the process. It's not exactly a bad time to be a Power Engineer with a BSc. and no kids (that I know of at least). It's all a matter of what you want and going out and getting it. Even in this slow economy and despite global warming, the world needs electricity.

So what do you do?
 
Haha, weird stuff, really weird.

If you don't know how much you ate nor are you able to express the quantity, why should I believe you even on a matter this trivial?

Again, here was your statement:



That wasn't qualified with, "It surprises me that as much CO2 as we release, it isn't getting even hotter." Or even, "I've met some people who think..."

You expressed that as a factual claim and when pressed, resorted to a scattered reliance on the emotional response of random people to poorly explained numbers.

Are you saying that your statement about the effects of CO2 is not true? You said it but now you're reatracting it?

But the larger issue is this constant habit you have of making assertions and then pretending like you didn't make them and we're all crazy for challenging you.

You did the same thing with uke2se. You made a claim about eliminating CO2 because we put it there. He challenged your view, and you acted like he made it up.

Either three people who never talk to each other are posting from your account or you're making these arguments on the spur of the moment with such little thought that you have no memory of advancing them.

Yep, that horse ain't getting up again is it.

Is this your final answer? I hope so, because this is mine. The "large" increase in CO2 concentration, so large as to be 35%, has resulted in a surprisingly small increase in temperature, in the order of a single degree. One might be inclined to think such a large increase in concentration would result in a large increase in temperature. They would of course be wrong, as 1 degree IS a large number when we are talking about the climate.

As for uk, yes I am dumbfounded by his analogy with regards to CO2 and Chicago. AFAIK it is a simple matter or "pack in pack out" "take only pictures, leave only footsteps" etc. etc. CO2 we know is bad and should "go" bye bye. Chicago, and especially the Black Hawks (go Hawks!) should remain there as they are not pollution and forcing, but cities and people and other "good" things.

(the fact that you are apparently from Chicago has lead me to believe you two are manufacturing this nonsense. I've got my eye on you two)
 
I knew it! I *am* on Candid Camera. No, I think the rest of the readers here would like to hear your explanation too.

And while we're at it, there's been a lot of wailing and gnashing of teeth here concerning the supposed uncertainty of climate models. Go here for a fantastic explanation of the greenhouse gas forcing *done without models*, just good ol' statistics:

http://tamino.wordpress.com/2009/08/17/not-computer-models/....
The problem with a "two box model" like this is that you can just take those good old unwanted errors, and shove them into the second box. Now you've got a nice fit. Well, that just doesn't work in the real world.

Second, Tamino has ignored any semblance of natural longer term cycles, and this makes the trend fitting he did false - (and likely caused him to need to slug numbers into that "second box).

Consider for example what Tsonis found, that after subtracting a background secular trend, four major ocean cycles do well explain 20th century temperature trends.

This isn't congruent with Tamino's method, and this is a reason to reject Tamino's method. Neither would Tamino acquiesce to run the same analysis on Tsonis's "secular background trend" and attribute the results to greenhouse gas forcing. The results would be rather uninteresting...

From your link, Tamino preaching to the AGW Choir:

Without human causation, there’s no explanation for the global warming we’ve already observed. With human causation, there’s no explanation for a lack of global warming.

EG, the opposite conclusion of Tsonis. To put it another way, Tamino has in my opinion engaged here in self reinforcing circular logic, where his premises contain assumptions that in turn are "proven" by his statistical results. I've seen some pretty good work from him, but would not include this in that group.
 
Last edited:
Sure, just post your phone number here and I'll call you and tell you all about it. :D

You're not new, you know better than ask for personal information to be posted. And I doubt if I can answer this satisfactorily without doing so but whatever. I work for a large company that has many plants, from wind turbine farms to nuclear all over the world. I'm barely involved with running one, and certainly not running one myself just yet. Heck I won't even work there in another week or so. I've been invited to work at other plants and there's certainly nothing from stopping me from working my way into a plant manager position within a few short years. I lack experience but have more than enough education right now. Being of the Common Wealth makes it that much easier for me to travel around the world, potentially buying and selling plants for the company in the process. It's not exactly a bad time to be a Power Engineer with a BSc. and no kids (that I know of at least). It's all a matter of what you want and going out and getting it. Even in this slow economy and despite global warming, the world needs electricity.

So what do you do?

You're taking this the wrong way. I didn't ask for personal information. I only asked what *kind* of power plants you were planning to be involved with, because you were vague. Deliberately vague, I thought. Because a *lot* of power plants burn coal. Do you see where this is going? Even now, you didn't really answer my question. Instead you effectively dodge it with this statement:

I work for a large company that has many plants, from wind turbine farms to nuclear all over the world.

And it would indeed be a great thing if you were into renewables. But you *still* haven't told us what kind of power plants YOU are interested in buying, running, or selling! And you mentioned nothing about renewables at all in the original post with which I took issue.

For the record, I have a BSc. in electrical engineering. I used to design computers (mostly embedded systems) in the 80's, now I just programme them.
 
You're taking this the wrong way. I didn't ask for personal information. I only asked what *kind* of power plants you were planning to be involved with, because you were vague. Deliberately vague, I thought. Because a *lot* of power plants burn coal. Do you see where this is going? Even now, you didn't really answer my question. Instead you effectively dodge it with this statement:



And it would indeed be a great thing if you were into renewables. But you *still* haven't told us what kind of power plants YOU are interested in buying, running, or selling! And you mentioned nothing about renewables at all in the original post with which I took issue.

For the record, I have a BSc. in electrical engineering. I used to design computers (mostly embedded systems) in the 80's, now I just programme them.

Well the dodge was for obvious reasons. Maybe only to me at the moment.

I really can't say. What I'd like is to be involved in would be a combined cycle cogen with full carbon sequestering. A baseloader, peaking is a little too boring at times and not exactly the most efficient.
 
That's an impressive straw man you just erected there. I'm not moralising. I'm pointing out an obvious bit of cognitive dissonance on 3bodyproblems' part, something along these lines:

"I'm a power engineer who wants to work on power plants. Most 'power plants' produce a lot of CO2 (remember, he said *nothing* about renewables in the post I took exception to). Of course I wouldn't want to work on something that harms the environment, therefore I rationalise (to myself) that CO2 doesn't contribute to climate change."

As far as renewables not being very efficient yet, I realise that. But they're not going to get more efficient if there's no incentive to make them more efficient, i.e. continuing to throw billions and billions at the 'cheaper' fossil fuel solution and pretending that nothing's wrong.

ETA: I'll get back to you on the Tamino/Tsonis thing after I've read up on it. You conveniently didn't link to your source so now I have to chase it. It's getting late here, so probably have to wait till lunchtime tomorrow...

Touche. But I'm not scared of clean coal either. Cleans clean.
 
Tell us just what the models have to to do with THIS reality?

· The combined April global land and ocean average surface temperature was the warmest on record at 58.1 F (14.5 C), which is 1.37 F (0.76 C) above the 20th century average of 56.7 F (13.7 C). · The combined global land and ocean average surface temperature was the warmest on record for January to April at 56.0 F (13.3 C), which is 1.24 F (0.69 C) above the 20th century average.
· Separately, the global ocean surface temperature was 1.03 F (0.57 C) above the 20th century average of 60.9 F (16.0 C) and the warmest on record for April.

http://www.livescience.com/environm...ncecom+(LiveScience.com+Science+Headline+Feed)

Models AND measurements/observations - one reason I prefer analogue signals - the critters don't give a rats ass what ill informed h sapiens think. The get on with dealing with it.....as does the climate science community and most rational people...

•••••

Did you answer the sun question yet?:garfield:
 
If the derails, personal attacks and bickering continue, there are likely to be numerous suspensions and every thread on global warming will end up being moderated. Stop it. Now.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Cuddles
 
You're taking this the wrong way. I didn't ask for personal information. I only asked what *kind* of power plants you were planning to be involved with, because you were vague. Deliberately vague, I thought. Because a *lot* of power plants burn coal. Do you see where this is going? Even now, you didn't really answer my question. Instead you effectively dodge it with this statement:



And it would indeed be a great thing if you were into renewables. But you *still* haven't told us what kind of power plants YOU are interested in buying, running, or selling! And you mentioned nothing about renewables at all in the original post with which I took issue.

For the record, I have a BSc. in electrical engineering. I used to design computers (mostly embedded systems) in the 80's, now I just programme them.

Dont you feel like a bit like :bwall

Which confusers did you work on in the 80's?
 
Well the dodge was for obvious reasons. Maybe only to me at the moment.

I really can't say. What I'd like is to be involved in would be a combined cycle cogen with full carbon sequestering. A baseloader, peaking is a little too boring at times and not exactly the most efficient.
So, you an AGW opponent and you work for an Energy company. No bias there then.

I worked with a guy who was a denier (he would call himself a skeptic), and I was a bit stunned at first to meet someone with these views. He preached he knew alot about the science as he had researched it and understood it and that there were serious flaws with the IPCC etc.

So I spent a few weeks researching his claims (which was when I found JRef). And of course I found them all to have been popular amoungst the denier population. Infact his arguments were to pretty much exactly the same as you find on any denier blogk. Funny that hu.

Now its a few years later and I've followede threads like this, found that AGW wasnt the only denier fix (911 truthers was fun) and I see the guy in a completely new light. He fitsthe profile completely and far from researching and coming to a conclusions based facts, I find he was just repeating the mantra.

I mean for example, I've followed and investigated the assertion that the models cannot be trusted, and have found it to be completely debunked. Yet, this guy would sit in the tea room - with a captured audience, and spunk this stuff off as if he discovered/uncovered the truth just last week and that we are all being lied to.

3bodyproblem - i've heard it all before, you're living in denial or on the moon, or someplace where physical reality changes every few minutes.
 
On the topic of the OP, there's one huge underlying factor of climate denialism (one we haven't discussed mostly because the deniers around here don't seem to be in this camp), but especially in the United States, religiosity is a massive source of denial.

To their credit, lately some evangelical leaders have tried to focus on the importance of climate change, but it hasn't stuck:

http://www.nytimes.com/2007/03/03/us/03evangelical.html

Growing up in Kansas, I found that religious opposition to AGW took 2 forms:

1) The Bible says be fruitful and multiply, and humans have dominion over nature, therefore anything we do is justified. They literally do not think it's possible for humans to destroy the environment because God made it for us like a parent builds their kids a sandbox.

2) Who cares? The end times are nearing. In fact, chaos from environmental degradation might be a necessary precondition for Jesus' return--drill baby, drill!!

And a third, indirect reason is just the general hatred of science in which a great many religious folks indulge.

So in the US, between 30-40% of the population is hostile to AGW before anything resembling scientific investigation is ever mentioned. As a practical matter, it doesn't seem possible to sway this huge chunk of society. They're still arguing about 19th century issues.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom