Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

1. Ok, so I can stab you, and you wouldnt care. Good.

Didn't I say that the first time you asked?

2. Authority over decisions = origin of ideals?

No. You seem to have misunderstood which idea I was talking about the origin of.

3. Not cutting parts off your baby's genitals?

The idea that we forego all substituted decisions until the baby is old enough to consent is extremely harmful and I cannot agree. I doubt any parent could stand by and do nothing to promote the health and life of their child simply because the child can't decide for himself.

If you are proposing that we forego some substituted decisions, what is your test to figure out which ones?

4. No, but there is a set of rights, seeing as we live in a some sort of society which has a set of rules.

Yes.

5. The parent should have primary interest over the child yes. Why do you want that to extend to permanent modifications to genitals for no benefit that cant be gained by doing the procedure later, other than the supposed UTI benefit.

That is the wrong question. The question is rather, what actions should be excluded?

Should I, being the parent, be able to tattoo my baby? Or do some other branding action? Why is circumcision different? Why can I cut his penis, but not her clitoris?

The test is what is considered acceptable by the society in which you live (and "society" is defined by the circumstances). In the US, you can dress your children in ugly clothes, pierce their ears, teach them to speak Mandarin, but cutting off the glans of the penis clearly is on the other side of the line (and, of course, the whole point of this discussion is where to draw this line). Realistically, the line is not influenced just by reason, but also by history/culture/habit.

6. Without good reason... Give me a good reason.

I previously specified this here.

Also, you sub divided this response for no discernible reason. Id say violating a baby's right to bodily integrity is a good reason, a baby IS a person.

I just wanted to be able to be specific that there are several steps to the process. Your responses would seem to indicate that you have yet to understand this.

Let me branch for a moment, I disagree with docking dog's ears, but its a dog, it is effectively property, is a human property in the same way?

Clearly the answer is no, which makes it a mystery as to why you introduced this straw man.

7. You think it should apply to everyone, with the exclusion of infants, gotcha. Infants not being a part of everyone.

This kind of response supports the assertion that your thinking is of the type exhibited by those on Joe's list.

Linda
 
Just because it's the sort of issue that inspires some of the people arguing about it to get emotional doesn't mean it's a nonissue if you're not plumb crazy.

That's not what Joe was saying, though.

I know it's just another anecdote...

I snipped the rest so as not to offend those who found it TMI (;)), but I think this example supports my idea.

I think the relatively high circumcision rates in the US are the result mostly of social conformity and parents not putting much thought into the decision. Right now, the anti-circumcision crowd has the appearance of a fringe group, and their words are easily dismissed by the average person. For example, the assertion that circumcision is detrimental to sexual function doesn't make sense to the average couple whose experience is otherwise. However, it does make sense to Lithrael because she is in the unusual position of her experience confirming the idea. I suspect that she wouldn't have put much thought into the issue if sex wasn't different between the two?

It looks like the opinions of those in this thread follow from my idea - that they are shaped by social conformity (those from outside the US where it is not the norm are not in favour) and the direction of their personal experience with regard to sexual function (or as a scapegoat for interpersonal interactions). There are exceptions - I think KellyB is one, although I'd have to refresh my memory on that.

I think that the rates are more likely to change if parents put more thought into it, and if the uncircumcised state is seen as conforming. I suspect that ranting and using extreme language has the opposite effect - that parents shut out what is being said and that the speakers are seen as radical. I am open to arguments on either side.

Linda
 
<snip>

I think that the rates are more likely to change if parents put more thought into it, and if the uncircumcised state is seen as conforming. I suspect that ranting and using extreme language has the opposite effect - that parents shut out what is being said and that the speakers are seen as radical. I am open to arguments on either side.

Linda

I think the reason that so many US parents still have their children circumcised is because physicians still give the procedure tacit approval. The medical profession introduced this bizarre idea to the US public and the medical profession should stop it.

What physicians should be saying to parents enquiring about non-therapeutic circumcision is that it is cruel, painful and waste of money and time, though they do turn a nice profit from doing them.

What does a physician think about when they are hurting a baby for no medical reason? The money?
 
There is one reason I know of that would "defend" circumcision. If the foreskin of the penis does not retract correctly (or at all) then circumcision is a way of fixing this.
 
Didn't I say that the first time you asked?

No. You seem to have misunderstood which idea I was talking about the origin of.

The idea that we forego all substituted decisions until the baby is old enough to consent is extremely harmful and I cannot agree. I doubt any parent could stand by and do nothing to promote the health and life of their child simply because the child can't decide for himself.

If you are proposing that we forego some substituted decisions, what is your test to figure out which ones?

That is the wrong question. The question is rather, what actions should be excluded?

The test is what is considered acceptable by the society in which you live (and "society" is defined by the circumstances). In the US, you can dress your children in ugly clothes, pierce their ears, teach them to speak Mandarin, but cutting off the glans of the penis clearly is on the other side of the line (and, of course, the whole point of this discussion is where to draw this line). Realistically, the line is not influenced just by reason, but also by history/culture/habit.

I previously specified this here.

I just wanted to be able to be specific that there are several steps to the process. Your responses would seem to indicate that you have yet to understand this.

Clearly the answer is no, which makes it a mystery as to why you introduced this straw man.

This kind of response supports the assertion that your thinking is of the type exhibited by those on Joe's list.

Linda

Honestly Linda, Im not trying to be offensive to you, Im having trouble understanding however how youre phrasing your responses.

For isntance, you say that self determination is something that everyone should have yes? You exclude male infant from that though. Such that, yes, they have self determination, but that the parent can override it for little to no reason.

And no no no no, that wasnt what I said. Not cutting off a part of your baby's genitals does not equate to throwing away all parental right to decide anything for them.

And alright then. Lets understand where the line is drawn. As I understand it the line is pretty arbitrary. Cutting off the glans is "over the line" as you say, but why is it? I assume if some religion came around saying that it was tradition that we would just flat out deny them the right to do it. Why though would we? Why is that appalling, but the other not? The same for other issues, dropping bombs on people, vs people exploding themselves as bombs, the effect is pretty much the same Id imagine, but one is far more appalling.

What sort of test would you propose for deciding what decisions are over the line? I would say that, to address the issue specifically, that the cutting of infant's genitals for non medically indicated reasons should be prohibited by law, of course you could take a much more broad approach to it, but its harder to write a proposed law system that applies to a large body of situations vs a small body.

The reason that used the dog example. I am asking whether children are property. Is a child owned in the same way that a dog is owned, and thus, you can do most anything you want to with it? I would argue that while the practice of docking dog's ears isnt something I support, its being conducted on an animal, which I would think most here agree with, is intrinsically of lower "value" than a human, so the process is being conducted on something that has no real ability to think of its own destiny at the time of the docking or later.

Lets transport the issue, as it pertains to drawing the line, and stick with the ear docking example. Would it be acceptable to dock the ears of an infant, who is incapable of consent or understanding of the procedure? Would it be acceptable to dock the ears of an adult who incapable of consent? What if, as is the typical argument, the adult felt neutrally about it, but still didnt decide it for himself, such that I could just walk up and snip his ear off and he doesnt really care.

(This doesnt directly pertain, however. I will admit that I have a bias for the protection of children. We are discussing now the ethics concerned in determining a line of acceptability vs the direct morality of it, so dont say that admittance of a bias is somehow crushing to my argument.
But yes. Nothing gets me more up in arms than hearing about child abuse, neglectful parents, false parents, any of the myriad of sexual cases that can be heard about on the news, etc. I feel that because children are incapable of "proper"(which is a discussion into itself) decisions they should be afforded MORE protection, not less. Ill end that for now.)
 
I think the reason that so many US parents still have their children circumcised is because physicians still give the procedure tacit approval. The medical profession introduced this bizarre idea to the US public and the medical profession should stop it.

What physicians should be saying to parents enquiring about non-therapeutic circumcision is that it is cruel, painful and waste of money and time, though they do turn a nice profit from doing them.

What does a physician think about when they are hurting a baby for no medical reason? The money?

Do you really think it's a money issue? I mean, seriously, in the context of giving birth and the care of the mother and infant afterwards, the vaccinations, checkups and so on does the circumcision really amount to any significant amount of additional money?

And does the doctor, in a hospital setting, really see that much return from the procedure? I suppose it would depend on the payment system at the hospital, but if the doctor who advises the parents is not the same one who actually carries out the circumcision (which it is likely it won't be) then they won't see any money.

I doubt many circumcisions are preformed in a private practice where the doctor would collect directly from the fee. One would expect them to be nearly universally private-practice if it were for the money.

And if they are paid on a per-procedure baisis, one would think that they could make a lot more money by devoting their time to something which would likely have a higher pay rate.

Unless of course, there is some giant conspiracy between the hospitals and all the doctors on the premisis to sell whatever procedures they can. I'm not aware of any doctors who work on a sales commission...
 
I snipped the rest so as not to offend those who found it TMI (;)), but I think this example supports my idea.

Perhaps "snipped" is not the best terminology in this situation... something like "removed some of the text in the quotation" would be better...
 
Honestly Linda, Im not trying to be offensive to you, Im having trouble understanding however how youre phrasing your responses.

For isntance, you say that self determination is something that everyone should have yes? You exclude male infant from that though. Such that, yes, they have self determination, but that the parent can override it for little to no reason.

I'm not excluding the male infant. I'm saying that in order for him to have the right of self-determination during a time when he is unable to exercise that right, his parents do it for him. What you see as acting against his interest they see as acting for his interest. The parents are not over-riding his interests (of what possible use is circumcision to them?), but rather ensuring his interests.

And no no no no, that wasnt what I said. Not cutting off a part of your baby's genitals does not equate to throwing away all parental right to decide anything for them.

And alright then. Lets understand where the line is drawn. As I understand it the line is pretty arbitrary. Cutting off the glans is "over the line" as you say, but why is it?

You don't think most people would consider it over the line?

I assume if some religion came around saying that it was tradition that we would just flat out deny them the right to do it. Why though would we? Why is that appalling, but the other not? The same for other issues, dropping bombs on people, vs people exploding themselves as bombs, the effect is pretty much the same Id imagine, but one is far more appalling.

What sort of test would you propose for deciding what decisions are over the line? I would say that, to address the issue specifically, that the cutting of infant's genitals for non medically indicated reasons should be prohibited by law, of course you could take a much more broad approach to it, but its harder to write a proposed law system that applies to a large body of situations vs a small body.

Okay. So your solution is to prohibit specific activities. So how do we decide which specific activities should be prohibited?

The reason that used the dog example. I am asking whether children are property. Is a child owned in the same way that a dog is owned, and thus, you can do most anything you want to with it? I would argue that while the practice of docking dog's ears isnt something I support, its being conducted on an animal, which I would think most here agree with, is intrinsically of lower "value" than a human, so the process is being conducted on something that has no real ability to think of its own destiny at the time of the docking or later.

Lets transport the issue, as it pertains to drawing the line, and stick with the ear docking example. Would it be acceptable to dock the ears of an infant, who is incapable of consent or understanding of the procedure? Would it be acceptable to dock the ears of an adult who incapable of consent? What if, as is the typical argument, the adult felt neutrally about it, but still didnt decide it for himself, such that I could just walk up and snip his ear off and he doesnt really care.

(This doesnt directly pertain, however. I will admit that I have a bias for the protection of children. We are discussing now the ethics concerned in determining a line of acceptability vs the direct morality of it, so dont say that admittance of a bias is somehow crushing to my argument.

My answer has always been that it is up to the individual to consent, and if they are unable to consent, the person(s) charged with promoting their interests.

But yes. Nothing gets me more up in arms than hearing about child abuse, neglectful parents, false parents, any of the myriad of sexual cases that can be heard about on the news, etc. I feel that because children are incapable of "proper"(which is a discussion into itself) decisions they should be afforded MORE protection, not less. Ill end that for now.)

I think everyone should be afforded the same protections. From a practical point of view, that means that children and other vulnerable people receive extra attention in order to achieve the same level of protection as non-vulnerable people. It seems to me that my viewpoint is consistent with this idea, and that it represents the current status of the law.

Linda
 
Perhaps "snipped" is not the best terminology in this situation... something like "removed some of the text in the quotation" would be better...

I will confess that my choice of words is not always accidental.

Linda
 
{snip} Unless of course, there is some giant conspiracy between the hospitals and all the doctors on the premisis to sell whatever procedures they can. I'm not aware of any doctors who work on a sales commission...
No, not on commission, they just get tips.
 
1. I'm not excluding the male infant. I'm saying that in order for him to have the right of self-determination during a time when he is unable to exercise that right, his parents do it for him. What you see as acting against his interest they see as acting for his interest. The parents are not over-riding his interests (of what possible use is circumcision to them?), but rather ensuring his interests.

2. You don't think most people would consider it over the line?

3. Okay. So your solution is to prohibit specific activities. So how do we decide which specific activities should be prohibited?

4. I think everyone should be afforded the same protections. From a practical point of view, that means that children and other vulnerable people receive extra attention in order to achieve the same level of protection as non-vulnerable people. It seems to me that my viewpoint is consistent with this idea, and that it represents the current status of the law.
Linda

Alright.

1. I understand that most parents arnt outwardly thinking "Im going to cut his penis he he he, what fun for me." However, you are excluding the big peer pressure issue. Not circumcising could result in alienation of the parents from others, temporarily or permanently. Most fathers want their son to "look like them." There is also pressure from the doctors, and additional pressure from the father thinking that, as was in my case, "If I didnt get it(the foreskin), he doesnt need it either." The list could go on forever.

2. I do think most people would consider it over the line, aside from the ones that do it to themselves, but what I was asking is why? Do you think that if it was practiced from the same period as circumcision and still an established procedure that the opposition would be met with the same "youre stupid" attitude? Im uncertain if the removal of the glans would reinforce the superiority over intact persons position or if it would just be seen as universally appalling, in either situation though why would you think that reaction is given?

My response would be that males are very much tied to their sexual identity through their genitals. So that if something is done that they had no consent to it would tend to be ignored or assumed to be positive. (Only applying to something like institutionalized circumcision, a natural detrimental occurrence I wouldnt expect someone to believe has made them better.)

3. My question yes, how do we decide? I say that the issue has already been addressed in the UN statement of rights, though ignored. The right to bodily integrity. How would you propose that we decide?

4. Yes, however, why are females more protected? Is unequal. Which involves the line drawing issue, ignoring that however, the protection given is just unequal.

"Nothing in this Declaration may be interpreted as implying for any State, group or person any right to engage in any activity or to perform any act aimed at the destruction of any of the rights and freedoms set forth herein." They dont address the overlaps though.
 
Last edited:
Alright.

1. I understand that most parents arnt outwardly thinking "Im going to cut his penis he he he, what fun for me." However, you are excluding the big peer pressure issue. Not circumcising could result in alienation of the parents from others, temporarily or permanently. Most fathers want their son to "look like them." There is also pressure from the doctors, and additional pressure from the father thinking that, as was in my case, "If I didnt get it(the foreskin), he doesnt need it either." The list could go on forever.

I've already said that I think that forms the bulk of the reason why parents, in the US, have their sons circumcised for non-religious reasons. I'm not excluding it, I'm saying that is where the perception that their son will be at a disadvantage otherwise comes from.

2. I do think most people would consider it over the line, aside from the ones that do it to themselves, but what I was asking is why? Do you think that if it was practiced from the same period as circumcision and still an established procedure that the opposition would be met with the same "youre stupid" attitude? Im uncertain if the removal of the glans would reinforce the superiority over intact persons position or if it would just be seen as universally appalling, in either situation though why would you think that reaction is given?

Do you honestly think it could become established as a practice?

My response would be that males are very much tied to their sexual identity through their genitals. So that if something is done that they had no consent to it would tend to be ignored or assumed to be positive.

Surely there are limits to this. It would take a fair bit of delusional thinking to persuade a man he's better off without half of his penis - especially when there are others around who would obviously be having a lot more fun than him. Plus, given that men have traditionally been in the position of power, your ability to coerce is significantly curtailed.

(Only applying to something like institutionalized circumcision, a natural detrimental occurrence I wouldnt expect someone to believe has made them better.)

I don't understand what you are trying to say here.

3. My question yes, how do we decide? I say that the issue has already been addressed in the UN statement of rights, though ignored. The right to bodily integrity. How would you propose that we decide?

I've explicitly stated how several times, including the post that you just responded to.

4. Yes, however, why are females more protected? Is unequal. Which involves the line drawing issue, ignoring that however, the protection given is just unequal.

How are females more protected?

Linda
 
Okay, lets get something straight here. If you want to compare females to males in terms of circumcision then the FGM stuff you think of in the middle east ain't exactly a fair comparison.

A rough equivalent to male circumcision for a female would be a partial hoodectomy, sometimes known as a hood reduction or labia minora reduction. It also is sometimes known as a "clitoral circumcision," but this is not to be confused with a "clitectomy." But basically it also removes some skin around the gland region.

That's probably the best analog. Chopping out all the bits they can is more equivalent to emasculation.

And yes, this procedure is preformed in the west. It's not all that uncommon, although I'm not sure it's something they tend to do in infants, in general or anything. But it's done to improve sexual response, for ascetics or for those who may be prone to complications, inflamation, infection and such...Usually it's elective and not really medically necessary, in the purest sense.
 
Do you really think it's a money issue? I mean, seriously, in the context of giving birth and the care of the mother and infant afterwards, the vaccinations, checkups and so on does the circumcision really amount to any significant amount of additional money?

And does the doctor, in a hospital setting, really see that much return from the procedure? I suppose it would depend on the payment system at the hospital, but if the doctor who advises the parents is not the same one who actually carries out the circumcision (which it is likely it won't be) then they won't see any money.

I doubt many circumcisions are preformed in a private practice where the doctor would collect directly from the fee. One would expect them to be nearly universally private-practice if it were for the money.

And if they are paid on a per-procedure baisis, one would think that they could make a lot more money by devoting their time to something which would likely have a higher pay rate.

Unless of course, there is some giant conspiracy between the hospitals and all the doctors on the premisis to sell whatever procedures they can. I'm not aware of any doctors who work on a sales commission...

1 million circumcisions in the US per year @ $125 each = $125million/year

A circumcision takes about 20 minutes to perform (even quicker and less expensive if proper pain relief is not used).

Some other questions are:

What happens to all those foreskins? Are most just thrown away or are they sold on? If so, how much for and does this extra income reduce the fee charged for the circumcision? Are the parents asked for their consent for the sale of their child's tissue?

It would be interesting to see how the money is made and divided up. Perhaps one of the US physicians on this forum knows or could find out and tell us?
 
<snip>

How are females more protected?

Linda

You've got to be kidding!

http://aappolicy.aappublications.org/cgi/content/full/pediatrics;102/1/153

AAP said:
The American Academy of Pediatrics:

Opposes all forms of female genital mutilation (FGM).
Recommends that its members actively seek to dissuade families from carrying out FGM.
Recommends that its members provide patients and their parents with compassionate education about the physical harms and psychological risks of FGM.
Recommends that its members decline to perform any medically unnecessary procedure that alters the genitalia of female infants, girls, and adolescents.

http://aappolicy.aappublications.org/cgi/content/full/pediatrics%3b103/3/686

AAP said:
Existing scientific evidence demonstrates potential medical benefits of newborn male circumcision; however, these data are not sufficient to recommend routine neonatal circumcision. In the case of circumcision, in which there are potential benefits and risks, yet the procedure is not essential to the child's current well-being, parents should determine what is in the best interest of the child. To make an informed choice, parents of all male infants should be given accurate and unbiased information and be provided the opportunity to discuss this decision. It is legitimate for parents to take into account cultural, religious, and ethnic traditions, in addition to the medical factors, when making this decision. Analgesia is safe and effective in reducing the procedural pain associated with circumcision; therefore, if a decision for circumcision is made, procedural analgesia should be provided. If circumcision is performed in the newborn period, it should only be done on infants who are stable and healthy.
 
1.Do you honestly think it could become established as a practice?

2. Surely there are limits to this. It would take a fair bit of delusional thinking to persuade a man he's better off without half of his penis - especially when there are others around who would obviously be having a lot more fun than him. Plus, given that men have traditionally been in the position of power, your ability to coerce is significantly curtailed.

3.I don't understand what you are trying to say here.

4. I've explicitly stated how several times, including the post that you just responded to.

5. How are females more protected?

Linda

1. Do you honestly think cutting off 50% of the penile skin of an infant could ever become a standard practice? Its a hypothetical example...

2. I dont think it would take that much delusional thinking. There are studies afterall that say that the glans is mostly receptive to pain yes? So, the justification that could be used is the same as with the foreskin, its just a redundant piece of flesh that doesnt really serve much of a purpose in our streamlined modern society. Again, the question was IF it already was established, not could it be now.

3. If someone does it to you and alot of other people the natural thought is going to be that it must be good right?

4. Jesus H. Artemis Gordon Christ. I said YOU, not society at large, can I please have some personal input from you, not every other person in the world that youre speaking for.

5. Females are more protected because all forms of non medically indicated female genital cutting is prohibited in the US, as I understand it. I can cut off my sons foreskin, but not my daughters labia. Both are pretty pointless from a functionality standpoint.
 
1 million circumcisions in the US per year @ $125 each = $125million/year

A circumcision takes about 20 minutes to perform (even quicker and less expensive if proper pain relief is not used).

Some other questions are:

What happens to all those foreskins? Are most just thrown away or are they sold on? If so, how much for and does this extra income reduce the fee charged for the circumcision? Are the parents asked for their consent for the sale of their child's tissue?

It would be interesting to see how the money is made and divided up. Perhaps one of the US physicians on this forum knows or could find out and tell us?


That's not a lot. $125 million in a country like the US?

There is 7 billion dollars spent on greeting cards annually. There are 33 million umbrellas sold each year.

According to the WHO there are one million Doctors/Nurse Practitioners or other licensed medical practitioners in the US. According to the department of labor there are 800,000 medically licensed doctors

Now lets consider the amount for the doctor minus malpractice, taxes, the cut the hospital or clinic gets.... Seems like nit would be not so much.

Consider that I went to the doctor recently because I take allergy medication that, very very rarely causes heart issues and thus I'm supposed to get checked a few times after starting. The nurse took my pulse, listened to my heart, took blood pressure. The doctor comes in, looks at the chart, then puts the stethoscope to my chest and says "Okay" then looks at the chart again and says "No shortness of breath or anything like that?" I say no and he says "Alright. Have a nice day"

Literally took 5 minutes and was 150 dollars without insurance. Granted, he personally won't get all that, but still... that's how it goes.


Sources:

http://www.greetingcard.org/thegreetingcard_facts.html
http://answers.cbfl.net/answers/threadview?id=592995
(the umbrella thing I red somewhere recently... will try to find out)
 
That's not a lot. $125 million in a country like the US?

There is 7 billion dollars spent on greeting cards annually. There are 33 million umbrellas sold each year.

According to the WHO there are one million Doctors/Nurse Practitioners or other licensed medical practitioners in the US. According to the department of labor there are 800,000 medically licensed doctors

Now lets consider the amount for the doctor minus malpractice, taxes, the cut the hospital or clinic gets.... Seems like nit would be not so much.

Consider that I went to the doctor recently because I take allergy medication that, very very rarely causes heart issues and thus I'm supposed to get checked a few times after starting. The nurse took my pulse, listened to my heart, took blood pressure. The doctor comes in, looks at the chart, then puts the stethoscope to my chest and says "Okay" then looks at the chart again and says "No shortness of breath or anything like that?" I say no and he says "Alright. Have a nice day"

Literally took 5 minutes and was 150 dollars without insurance. Granted, he personally won't get all that, but still... that's how it goes.


Sources:

http://www.greetingcard.org/thegreetingcard_facts.html
http://answers.cbfl.net/answers/threadview?id=592995
(the umbrella thing I red somewhere recently... will try to find out)

If youre at work and someone walks in and offers you an additional 20$, how much money do you have to be making to just outright refuse it? "No thanks, I dont want extra money."

Granted this is all conjecture from both sides without some sort of survey, which youre never going to get accurate results from. ("Yeah I totally cut baby penises for extra money.")

However, I have read testimonials from Docs including "I love it because its the only surgery I can conduct on a healthy child"(ETA3: No citation cause I dont want to look for it, take it however you like) and the like. Money is a very powerful motivator, if I make 200 thousand a year normally, why would I dispute making 205? Better yet why would I try not to?

ETA: Were also neglecting to mention the lucrative skin graft industry.
ETA2: 150$ is pretty good, my dermatologist charged 300 for the same amount of time....
 
Last edited:
Perhaps I am just being too trusting of the medical field, but I tend to think most doctors would not be up for doing something they felt was harmful and unnecessary for a few extra bucks. Especially considering it's likely that they could use the time for something else to make money.

I make a lot less than most doctors, I would tend to think. If someone offered me an extra few bucks I'd say sure. But not if it involved much. If somebody said "You want 20 bucks. All you have to do is listen to ten minutes of music you really hate" I think I'd likely turn that down.

If someone were making a lot of money and offered a bit more, sure they would probably take it. But try this: Offer a doctor fifty bucks if they'll spend 20 minutes listening to music they hate or eat some food that is way too spicey for their liking or spend a day with their office air conditioning off on a hot day. None of these are really that big a deal or all that painful or difficult, but I highly doubt you'd have many takers.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom