1. Ok, so I can stab you, and you wouldnt care. Good.
Didn't I say that the first time you asked?
2. Authority over decisions = origin of ideals?
No. You seem to have misunderstood which idea I was talking about the origin of.
3. Not cutting parts off your baby's genitals?
The idea that we forego all substituted decisions until the baby is old enough to consent is extremely harmful and I cannot agree. I doubt any parent could stand by and do nothing to promote the health and life of their child simply because the child can't decide for himself.
If you are proposing that we forego some substituted decisions, what is your test to figure out which ones?
4. No, but there is a set of rights, seeing as we live in a some sort of society which has a set of rules.
Yes.
5. The parent should have primary interest over the child yes. Why do you want that to extend to permanent modifications to genitals for no benefit that cant be gained by doing the procedure later, other than the supposed UTI benefit.
That is the wrong question. The question is rather, what actions should be excluded?
Should I, being the parent, be able to tattoo my baby? Or do some other branding action? Why is circumcision different? Why can I cut his penis, but not her clitoris?
The test is what is considered acceptable by the society in which you live (and "society" is defined by the circumstances). In the US, you can dress your children in ugly clothes, pierce their ears, teach them to speak Mandarin, but cutting off the glans of the penis clearly is on the other side of the line (and, of course, the whole point of this discussion is where to draw this line). Realistically, the line is not influenced just by reason, but also by history/culture/habit.
6. Without good reason... Give me a good reason.
I previously specified this here.
Also, you sub divided this response for no discernible reason. Id say violating a baby's right to bodily integrity is a good reason, a baby IS a person.
I just wanted to be able to be specific that there are several steps to the process. Your responses would seem to indicate that you have yet to understand this.
Let me branch for a moment, I disagree with docking dog's ears, but its a dog, it is effectively property, is a human property in the same way?
Clearly the answer is no, which makes it a mystery as to why you introduced this straw man.
7. You think it should apply to everyone, with the exclusion of infants, gotcha. Infants not being a part of everyone.
This kind of response supports the assertion that your thinking is of the type exhibited by those on Joe's list.
Linda