1.Nobody's arguing that that's not a perfectly good position to take. The problem is talking about the two issues as if they were practically the same.
2.That's pretty much it, yeah. FGM and extreme male genital cutting are both out. If 'hoodectomy' was the norm I'd feel it was bad but not an outright atrocity. Male circumcision is bad but not an outright atrocity. The culture we're in simply doesn't think of male circumcision as mutilation. It's your right to call it that and I don't think it's outside the realm of reason or anything, but the fact remains you can't get a dialog going like that. You can't change any part of society from the outside.
3.There are analogs to what the bits are for. If you've had your whole genital region turned to hamburger, you've lost all capacity for sexual pleasure. If you've lost a clitoris, you've often lost capacity for orgasm. If you've lost a clitoral hood, you've just lost some sensitive tissue. If you've lost most of a penis, you've often lost capacity for orgasm. If you've lost a foreskin you've just lost a lot of sensitive tissue. The spectrum runs from "loss of some sensation" to "hamburger." That's the difference. There you go.
4.Why do I think it's more acceptable in western society? Because traditionally guys love sex either way, and cut girls basically can't. Because guys are in a position of power, and girls aren't. Guys feel protective towards girls, and they don't feel protective towards themselves or other guys. Because it's established tradition. All of those are reasons.
5.Why is FGM acceptable where it's practiced? Well, shock surprise, because it's part of a culture of expressing explicit male dominance over women. I would imagine traditionalists who think of themselves as more level-headed simply consider it an important part of ensuring a woman will be clean, respectable and marriageable.
6.If you're trying to point up that male circ is all about making men feel subjugated or bad about sex, I wouldn't say there was never or that there can't now be an element of that involved. I have heard religious people say it's important to help prevent masturbation, which is a hideously backward attitude but there you go. However, most of the time, in the modern setting, it's simply an unfortunate blind adherence to tradition.
Firstly thankyou for giving a reasonable response.
1. They are essentially the same. As a male I cant speak about pleasure loss for a female with any degree of accuracy, suffice it to say I would feel horribly violated and betrayed were it to happen to me. The dimorphism in the argument occurs in the popular functionality issue, which tries to ignore the aspect of pleasure. Women are still capable of functioning(in the most crass and common in these discussions use of the word) with bits removed, as are men.
I dont understand the divide between male and female genital cutting. Both have unknown psychological effects, both are damaging the reproductive organs, both are generally always uncalled for. I wouldnt say that female is worse because it is absolutely deplorable. I wouldnt say male is worse, it is absolutely deplorable. On my scale there is no lower. I dont rank horrible things that way, as I said I think its counter productive. Ranking horrible practices or occurrences seems to have a minimizing effect on them.
("Ohh this isnt as bad, we dont need to worry about it.")
2. The cutting of infants genitals, no matter how minimal, without medical indication and in a way that will permanently alter their bodies is always a violation of human rights.
Im well aware of rhetorical method, and hence when introducing someone new I start off slowly. The purpose of this dialog however isnt to masquerade around using more gentle terms, its to discuss the issues. It is mutilation against both male and female, changing the terminology doest effect the reality.
3. Yes, the structures are similar, however not completely parallel. There are many degrees of cut for both male and female, disregarding the more popular methods. Females are structured differently, I am aware yes. Not all female cuttings involve turning the vagina into a hamburger, some do, some male practices are also quite radical. Regardless of the level of cut they are all equally horrible.
4-5. Remembering that cut women are often times supportive of cutting future generations, the same as cut men. Both seem to be perpetuated by this supposed good will interest on the parent's part. The fact that a majority of adults may feel fantastic about their sex lives and being circumcised still doesnt affect the issue of another person's rights(the infant) being violated, in male or female. If a majority of cut women enjoyed sex would that become another justification for continuing the practice? Likewise in a sexually inverted society, if women took the traditional male role as we define it, would that also invert the current situation regarding genital cutting?(making male less acceptable and female more.)
6. Traditions need reevaluated from time to time. Something I consider most insulting about my particular case is the lack of will on my parent's part to even research on the topic. Tradition is important in a culture, and I support a number of traditions, none that violate the rights of another person though. Circumcision is a very complicated issue with many many facets. There is an objective reality involved however.
And on that Im going to bed. Thankyou again for your reasonable response. Im sorry if this is worded odd at all, Im very tired at present.