Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

1.Nobody's arguing that that's not a perfectly good position to take. The problem is talking about the two issues as if they were practically the same.

2.That's pretty much it, yeah. FGM and extreme male genital cutting are both out. If 'hoodectomy' was the norm I'd feel it was bad but not an outright atrocity. Male circumcision is bad but not an outright atrocity. The culture we're in simply doesn't think of male circumcision as mutilation. It's your right to call it that and I don't think it's outside the realm of reason or anything, but the fact remains you can't get a dialog going like that. You can't change any part of society from the outside.

3.There are analogs to what the bits are for. If you've had your whole genital region turned to hamburger, you've lost all capacity for sexual pleasure. If you've lost a clitoris, you've often lost capacity for orgasm. If you've lost a clitoral hood, you've just lost some sensitive tissue. If you've lost most of a penis, you've often lost capacity for orgasm. If you've lost a foreskin you've just lost a lot of sensitive tissue. The spectrum runs from "loss of some sensation" to "hamburger." That's the difference. There you go.

4.Why do I think it's more acceptable in western society? Because traditionally guys love sex either way, and cut girls basically can't. Because guys are in a position of power, and girls aren't. Guys feel protective towards girls, and they don't feel protective towards themselves or other guys. Because it's established tradition. All of those are reasons.

5.Why is FGM acceptable where it's practiced? Well, shock surprise, because it's part of a culture of expressing explicit male dominance over women. I would imagine traditionalists who think of themselves as more level-headed simply consider it an important part of ensuring a woman will be clean, respectable and marriageable.

6.If you're trying to point up that male circ is all about making men feel subjugated or bad about sex, I wouldn't say there was never or that there can't now be an element of that involved. I have heard religious people say it's important to help prevent masturbation, which is a hideously backward attitude but there you go. However, most of the time, in the modern setting, it's simply an unfortunate blind adherence to tradition.

Firstly thankyou for giving a reasonable response.

1. They are essentially the same. As a male I cant speak about pleasure loss for a female with any degree of accuracy, suffice it to say I would feel horribly violated and betrayed were it to happen to me. The dimorphism in the argument occurs in the popular functionality issue, which tries to ignore the aspect of pleasure. Women are still capable of functioning(in the most crass and common in these discussions use of the word) with bits removed, as are men.

I dont understand the divide between male and female genital cutting. Both have unknown psychological effects, both are damaging the reproductive organs, both are generally always uncalled for. I wouldnt say that female is worse because it is absolutely deplorable. I wouldnt say male is worse, it is absolutely deplorable. On my scale there is no lower. I dont rank horrible things that way, as I said I think its counter productive. Ranking horrible practices or occurrences seems to have a minimizing effect on them.
("Ohh this isnt as bad, we dont need to worry about it.")

2. The cutting of infants genitals, no matter how minimal, without medical indication and in a way that will permanently alter their bodies is always a violation of human rights.

Im well aware of rhetorical method, and hence when introducing someone new I start off slowly. The purpose of this dialog however isnt to masquerade around using more gentle terms, its to discuss the issues. It is mutilation against both male and female, changing the terminology doest effect the reality.

3. Yes, the structures are similar, however not completely parallel. There are many degrees of cut for both male and female, disregarding the more popular methods. Females are structured differently, I am aware yes. Not all female cuttings involve turning the vagina into a hamburger, some do, some male practices are also quite radical. Regardless of the level of cut they are all equally horrible.

4-5. Remembering that cut women are often times supportive of cutting future generations, the same as cut men. Both seem to be perpetuated by this supposed good will interest on the parent's part. The fact that a majority of adults may feel fantastic about their sex lives and being circumcised still doesnt affect the issue of another person's rights(the infant) being violated, in male or female. If a majority of cut women enjoyed sex would that become another justification for continuing the practice? Likewise in a sexually inverted society, if women took the traditional male role as we define it, would that also invert the current situation regarding genital cutting?(making male less acceptable and female more.)

6. Traditions need reevaluated from time to time. Something I consider most insulting about my particular case is the lack of will on my parent's part to even research on the topic. Tradition is important in a culture, and I support a number of traditions, none that violate the rights of another person though. Circumcision is a very complicated issue with many many facets. There is an objective reality involved however.

And on that Im going to bed. Thankyou again for your reasonable response. Im sorry if this is worded odd at all, Im very tired at present.
 
For all those who think FGM stops a woman enjoying sex or achieving orgasm, please read this post.

And again, it is not valid to compare the practices of male circumcision in the US to those used for female circumcision in Africa, since FGM would have evolved into something similar to male circumcision in the US, if it had not died out there in the 1950's (yeah, that's right - 1950's).

Turkey has a male circumcision ritual for young boys, usually performed about 8 years old.

This makes it sound so nice.

This is a picture of a boy after (don't worry, it's safe for work!)

And this one during (again, it's safe for work).

For all of you claiming that the amount of physical damage is an important difference between the two practices, do you feel the same about sexual abuse of children, or is that all bad (except circumcision, of course)?
 
Last edited:
(I don't know exactly how much my car weighs, btw. I don't have a scale that big and I didn't look it up in the manual. But it weighs more than a loaf of bread. I'm damn sure of that. How much more? I don't know, but a lot. A real lot. Enough that I can tell it ain't even close. Oh, and I think it weighs less than my brothers car. But you might look at them and say "No I think your brothers car looks like it weighs more." And that's not unreasonable. But if you honestly think that it looks like it weighs more than a 747... well.. sorry, I have trouble believing that you would actually come to that conclusion)

I think that the analogy you are looking for is whether or not both a loaf of bread and your car are heavy. And whether regulations governing work-place safety, that restrict the lifting of heavy objects, are unfair.

Linda
 
Aigh, Ivor. No, yeah, I'm all with you on that one. My argument's all about the whole infant-circumcision-in-hospitals-in-the-USA thing. The summary hacking off of anything in a ceremony is pretty damn horrible.

I also will not disagree with the potential for mental anguish from male circs, another reason I am against them.

But as for the quoted study I never said a type I or II female circumcision made it impossible to enjoy sex. A type I (partial hoodectomy) is what I'd call comparable to a male circ. A type II wouldn't preclude vaginal orgasms. And, for crying out loud, read what it says. "No significant differences between cut and uncut women were observed in ... the proportions reporting experience of orgasm during intercourse." DURING INTERCOURSE. You don't HAVE clitoral orgasms during intercourse. Clitoral orgasms are the kind a woman can have on her own. Hence the need to stop them. Certainly I've seen surveys of western women that reported a significant proportion, up around 30%, could only reach orgasm with the help of direct clitoral stimulation. And both surveys and 'girl talk' agree that easily one in four girls have serious trouble reaching orgasm in the first place. You guys have no idea how easy you have it! Heheh, penis envy much? Yeah, no kidding.

Men have it tough with performance issues. Endurance. Size. Real tough. I won't mince words. But at least you guys can get there. The few of you who have trouble getting it up are the ONLY ones who know what it's like for a hell of a lot of women.

It's not just an issue of sympathy for the poor clitorises and a big rule8-you to those worthless foreskins. I would be shocked and happily reverse my opinion if anyone could show me a study that shows that the foreskin is anything like as important to orgasm as the clitoris.

And I can't get behind anyone that's trying to say FGM, that type III, hamburger-meat version of 'female circumcision' is comparable in any way to a routine western male circumcision.

*cough*

I'm a nice girl, really.
 
Last edited:
A type I is what I'd call comparable to a male circ.

Just because this has caused some confusion in the past....

A Type I FGM may include removal of part of the clitoris, so it may help to specify that a hoodectomy or partial hoodectomy is the procedure that is comparable (if that is what you were thinking).

ETA: I suspect that if the only procedure in traditional use on females was a partial hoodectomy, that it would not be condemned as FGM.

Linda
 
Last edited:
And again, it is not valid to compare the practices of male circumcision in the US to those used for female circumcision in Africa, since FGM would have evolved into something similar to male circumcision in the US, if it had not died out there in the 1950's (yeah, that's right - 1950's).

Please clarify. I am under the impression that worldwide, FGM is fairly rare but practiced and that type I and II female circs are common. But it's a whole culture I disagree with, and though awful, female circs are probably not the worst of their problems. The fight against female circumcision is a whole different ballgame to the campaign against routine male circumcision in the US. That's kind of the whole point of this part of the argument.

For all of you claiming that the amount of physical damage is an important difference between the two practices, do you feel the same about sexual abuse of children, or is that all bad (except circumcision, of course)?

Actually yes, because what consitutes abuse also has a cultural element. I would have to say that the degree of harm and the cultural context would have to be an important difference in how I'd react to it. It would all still be bad, though, of course - just as all circumcision is bad. But that doesn't mean there's no scale. Unless you're going to put the sexualizing of kids in fashion and children's beauty pagaents, creepy uncle's bad touch after Thanksgiving dinner, and the ritual marriage of men to little girls in the same basket.
 
Last edited:
Please clarify. I am under the impression that worldwide, FGM is fairly rare but practiced and that type I and II female circs are common. But it's a whole culture I disagree with, and though awful, female circs are probably not the worst of their problems. The fight against female circumcision is a whole different ballgame to the campaign against routine male circumcision in the US. That's kind of the whole point of this part of the argument.

How do you think people who circumcise their females for cultural reasons will reply when Westerners tell them that it is “wrong” to mutilate (or cut if we’re being PC) girls’ genitals for non-medical reasons? My guess is they’ll tell them to “[rule 8] off, you do it to boys for non-medical reasons!”

Actually yes, because what consitutes abuse also has a cultural element. I would have to say that the degree of harm and the cultural context would have to be an important difference in how I'd react to it. It would all still be bad, though, of course - just as all circumcision is bad. But that doesn't mean there's no scale. Unless you're going to put the sexualizing of kids in fashion and children's beauty pagaents, creepy uncle's bad touch after Thanksgiving dinner, and the ritual marriage of men to little girls in the same basket.

The way I see it they are in the same basket, just at different levels of depravity within it.
 
Aigh, Ivor. No, yeah, I'm all with you on that one. My argument's all about the whole infant-circumcision-in-hospitals-in-the-USA thing. The summary hacking off of anything in a ceremony is pretty damn horrible.

I also will not disagree with the potential for mental anguish from male circs, another reason I am against them.

But as for the quoted study I never said a type I or II female circumcision made it impossible to enjoy sex. A type I (partial hoodectomy) is what I'd call comparable to a male circ. A type II wouldn't preclude vaginal orgasms. And, for crying out loud, read what it says. "No significant differences between cut and uncut women were observed in ... the proportions reporting experience of orgasm during intercourse." DURING INTERCOURSE. You don't HAVE clitoral orgasms during intercourse. Clitoral orgasms are the kind a woman can have on her own. Hence the need to stop them. Certainly I've seen surveys of western women that reported a significant proportion, up around 30%, could only reach orgasm with the help of direct clitoral stimulation. And both surveys and 'girl talk' agree that easily one in four girls have serious trouble reaching orgasm in the first place. You guys have no idea how easy you have it! Heheh, penis envy much? Yeah, no kidding.

Men have it tough with performance issues. Endurance. Size. Real tough. I won't mince words. But at least you guys can get there. The few of you who have trouble getting it up are the ONLY ones who know what it's like for a hell of a lot of women.

It's not just an issue of sympathy for the poor clitorises and a big rule8-you to those worthless foreskins. I would be shocked and happily reverse my opinion if anyone could show me a study that shows that the foreskin is anything like as important to orgasm as the clitoris.

And I can't get behind anyone that's trying to say FGM, that type III, hamburger-meat version of 'female circumcision' is comparable in any way to a routine western male circumcision.

*cough*

I'm a nice girl, really.

The point is that any type of genital cutting of girls for non-medical reasons have been deemed illegal in the US, no matter how minor. Therefore, the law discriminates against males. If the US wanted to be consistent it should allow similar cutting of girls that it does in boys.

Then the medical profession could promote it and produce a list of ailments it cures or substantially reduces the risk of contracting;)
 
Just because this has caused some confusion in the past....

A Type I FGM may include removal of part of the clitoris, so it may help to specify that a hoodectomy or partial hoodectomy is the procedure that is comparable (if that is what you were thinking).

ETA: I suspect that if the only procedure in traditional use on females was a partial hoodectomy, that it would not be condemned as FGM.

Linda

I suspect if US physicians had been more successful in promoting the removal of the clitoris in girls then you would be apologizing for that too;)
 
I can defend circumcision. Not the practice, especially when performed on newborns or children, but the state.

Its not so bad as to make out circumcised people as victims of mutilation. It is mutilation, it is a mutilating procedure and should be stopped. But telling men that they're worthless now to a woman is certainly not the sensible way to achieve that.
 
I can defend circumcision. Not the practice, especially when performed on newborns or children, but the state.

Its not so bad as to make out circumcised people as victims of mutilation. It is mutilation, it is a mutilating procedure and should be stopped. But telling men that they're worthless now to a woman is certainly not the sensible way to achieve that.
This thread continues to serve up some nice tidbits of info (Dr Buzzo's summary of the degrees of "genitalia meets knife" being one of them) but it doesn't answer a core question for me.

Presume for this musing that God didn't tell the Chosen, or much of anyone else, that he needed a foreskin here and there to cement the covenant, or for whatever reason. Leave religion at the door for the nonce.

In some place, in some time, there was a first trimming. Some guy, or guys, or woman for all I know, sat down and pondered a penis. After manipulating the foreskin back and forth a bit and considering the aesthetics hatted and bald, the trend setter(s) decided "this permanent attachment will not do." (We have the archetype Hollywood surgeon in the making, but this is no nose job.) Mind you, every guy wandering about has a foreskin, just as we each have a nose, a rectum, two hands, etc.

This guy, or these guys, arrive at the conclusion that "it's gonna be different in the dick department from here on out: bald is beautiful."

Why cut your dick with a sharp object? What series of ideas and linked decisions, or events, led these pud pondering pioneers to the conclusion that the next step in life ought to be to get that sharp piece of obsidian, or flint, or bronze, or whatever, and start slicing away at the manhood?

I will bet the over on this decision not being made alone, but on a dare. A bunch of guys sitting around (perhaps in some primal circle jerk in the Rift Valley), engaged in the usual shooting of the breeze, and one dares another. A pause. Do what? Eyes wide, laughs, and then you get the whole group daring and taunting each other in rapid succession. (Was this historic first undertaken after the invention of beer, somewhere in Egypt, or after the discovery of the first exotic mushrooms?) There is always one bull goose loony in a crowd, so one steps forward to demonstrate his status as "first to do this mad thing."

The trend setter sets to it with a will, wincing through the pain, and presto, he removes his bone's balaclava.

Here is the part I can't fathom.

He's bleeding. It hurts. The sausage is sensitive, and unlike its normal condition, not good or fun to touch. No fundamental change in function occurs, other than to increase the daily ration of pain and discomfort. This brilliant idea has, in the short run, some unpleasant consequences. Whatever he expects the positive outcomes to be are deferred, and to be discovered.

Here's the cream of the joke.

Another guy considers all of the above, and concludes that this was a great idea, he's going to do it too. Slice and dice, part two. Lemmings with lancets, heading over the cliff of circumcision. With reasoning power like that, it's a wonder that all of humanity didn't rush over a cliff one day, because it seemed like a good idea at the time.

It doesn't stop there, as I recently found out from a friend. He linked me to a site that advocates the joys and wonders of genital bifurcation. No, I shall not link it, I suspected it would be gross and it is. Not sure if it is for real or not, but it's all about mutilated manhood.

With the above considered, I'll postulate that "The Age of Reason" is a myth, a pocket of space time restricted to a few narrow clusters of humanity. Considered in the larger sense, and desire of the Foundation to extend reasoning to a broader spectrum of the population, methinks the JREF is tilting at windmills.

Why not? It seems like a good idea at the time. :)

Sancho, my lance!

DR
 
Last edited:
This thread continues to serve up some nice tidbits of info (Dr Buzzo's summary of the degrees of "genitalia meets knife" being one of them) but it doesn't answer a core question for me...DR

<trimmed for the sake of neatness>

I have pondered this as well, and while your suggestion is more amusing (and quite frankly, more consistent with the frat boy mindset it seems to require ;)), it seems more likely that it started as a surgical procedure in order to relieve phimosis which is likely to have been a more common problem than it is now.

Linda
 
And again, it is not valid to compare the practices of male circumcision in the US to those used for female circumcision in Africa, since FGM would have evolved into something similar to male circumcision in the US, if it had not died out there in the 1950's (yeah, that's right - 1950's).

For all of you claiming that the amount of physical damage is an important difference between the two practices, do you feel the same about sexual abuse of children, or is that all bad (except circumcision, of course)?

Thats pretty much my thoughts on the matter. We dont start ranking other things like this, why is circumcision different. The only reason I suspect is the normalization of it over the years, ala the tradition reasoning.

Like I said as well itd be curious in a male female inverted society what their position would be on the matter. Or the areas that practice female but not male, on why female is ok but the male is sacred or some nonsense(assuming thats how it would turn out, Ive not seen anything like that as of yet).

Good morning to the rest of the forum.
 
Thats pretty much my thoughts on the matter. We dont start ranking other things like this, why is circumcision different. The only reason I suspect is the normalization of it over the years, ala the tradition reasoning.

Like I said as well itd be curious in a male female inverted society what their position would be on the matter. Or the areas that practice female but not male, on why female is ok but the male is sacred or some nonsense(assuming thats how it would turn out, Ive not seen anything like that as of yet).

Good morning to the rest of the forum.

I'm not sure there is any society that only mutilates its females' genitals.
 
Thats pretty much my thoughts on the matter. We dont start ranking other things like this, why is circumcision different. The only reason I suspect is the normalization of it over the years, ala the tradition reasoning.

I think the reason that you are having trouble understanding is because your comparisons are inappropriate, for example, comparing rape to rape at knife-point is not analogous to the difference that is being drawn between male circumcision and FGM. We are not talking about ranking two acts that are seen as egregious by most involved, we are pointing out that one act is seen as egregious by most and one act is not seen as egregious by most. You may understand this if you ponder the difference between forced sexual intercourse at knife-point and grabbing a woman's butt as you walk by her on the street. Some people can (and do) claim that both are a sexual assault, but would you find it surprising if most people scoff at the idea that the latter should be a capital offense punishable by death?*

Most everything we do is ranked like this.

Like I said as well itd be curious in a male female inverted society what their position would be on the matter. Or the areas that practice female but not male, on why female is ok but the male is sacred or some nonsense(assuming thats how it would turn out, Ive not seen anything like that as of yet).

I suspect it would end up much the same way - that whatever procedures were performed on females would not make a difference in function from their perspective and whatever procedures were performed on males may be more extensive, but would not interfere with whatever function the females considered necessary (if you are comparing cultures with female dominance similar to cultures with explicit male dominance).

Linda

*Please note that the examples chosen for comparison were not chosen to represent the relative level of FGM vs. male circumcision, but to emphasize the difference in an attempt to make it obvious.
 
I think the reason that you are having trouble understanding is because your comparisons are inappropriate, for example, comparing rape to rape at knife-point is not analogous to the difference that is being drawn between male circumcision and FGM. We are not talking about ranking two acts that are seen as egregious by most involved, we are pointing out that one act is seen as egregious by most and one act is not seen as egregious by most. You may understand this if you ponder the difference between forced sexual intercourse at knife-point and grabbing a woman's butt as you walk by her on the street. Some people can (and do) claim that both are a sexual assault, but would you find it surprising if most people scoff at the idea that the latter should be a capital offense punishable by death?*

Most everything we do is ranked like this.

<snip>

Linda

*Please note that the examples chosen for comparison were not chosen to represent the relative level of FGM vs. male circumcision, but to emphasize the difference in an attempt to make it obvious.

Society decides if an act is legal or not. The "ranking" is only important when deciding on appropriate punishment for the offense. E.g., fines, community service, a prison sentence or (in some supposedly civilized parts of the world) the death sentence.

If all forms of female genital cutting of girls are illegal then, by symmetry, male circumcision of boys has to be too.

Or are you arguing for a change to US law to allow some forms of female genital cutting of young girls at the wish of parents?
 
Society decides if an act is legal or not. The "ranking" is only important when deciding on appropriate punishment for the offense. E.g., fines, community service, a prison sentence or (in some supposedly civilized parts of the world) the death sentence.

If all forms of female genital cutting of girls are illegal then, by symmetry, male circumcision of boys has to be too.

Or are you arguing for a change to US law to allow some forms of female genital cutting of young girls at the wish of parents?
Hoodectomy, the equivalent of circumcision, IS legal... and beneficial to some women.

Circumcision isn't genital mutilation. At most, it is like getting your tonsils removed or wisdom teeth pulled preemptively. You might have a better case if you came at it from that angle. You overheated and inaccurate rhetoric only hurts your position.
 
Hoodectomy, the equivalent of circumcision, IS legal... and beneficial to some women.

Labia trimming is legal too. But only for adults who can give informed consent.

Hoodectomy is illegal to perform on an infant at the request of a parent.

Circumcision isn't genital mutilation. At most, it is like getting your tonsils removed or wisdom teeth pulled preemptively. You might have a better case if you came at it from that angle. You overheated and inaccurate rhetoric only hurts your position.

How is my rhetoric inaccurate?

from: http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/mutilate

mutilate:

1. to injure, disfigure, or make imperfect by removing or irreparably damaging parts.

How is some or all of that definition not applicable to non-therapeutic circumcision (of either sex)?

ETA: And it looks like I've fallen into the "bad cop" role in this debate. But don't I make Linda look fabulous?:D
 
Last edited:
Hoodectomy is illegal to perform on an infant at the request of a parent.

I can't really figure out how you'd even do it, or what the possible point could be. Male infant circumcision at least provides things you can call benefits, and I'd assume that is another part of why the laws are different. For example, hunting around sex-ed sites for stats, I did run into a lot of Q&A boards with numerous guys who were running into phimosis problems. Of course these should be solved with information and treatment, not routine circumcision, but again you can see the issues bewteen genders are simply different.

The other legal reasoning probably is the one stated here before, that female circ is generally done specifically to reinforce the lower status of women, while male circ is generally done for a bunch of stupid reasons, and the only one that involves male repression is the idea that it makes it less fun to masturbate.

I would have no problem with routine male circumcision becoming illegal in the US in the same way infant female circumcision is illegal in the US. Whatever US Muslims have to do to get their girls a hoodectomy for tradition, US Jews and other traditionally circ'd groups can do to get their boys circumcised for tradition. Or both can simply wait till they're old enough to get one legally.

But you would run into trouble deciding who to sue when there were diesgreements over what was medically necessary or not. In the short term it makes much more sense to simply campaign against it sensibly with education.
 
Labia trimming is legal too. But only for adults who can give informed consent.

Hoodectomy is illegal to perform on an infant at the request of a parent.

There are anatomical and conventional details. If a parent wanted a hoodectomy for their infant daughter, I might think "okay... that's kinda weird... um... why... would you want that? are you sure that's a good idea?" But I wouldn't think "My god they butchered her genitals beyond all recognition and function! What a barbaric and savage act of bloodcurdling cruelty"


How is my rhetoric inaccurate?

from: http://dictionary.reference.com/browse/mutilate

mutilate:

1. to injure, disfigure, or make imperfect by removing or irreparably damaging parts.

How is some or all of that definition not applicable to non-therapeutic circumcision (of either sex)?

ETA: And it looks like I've fallen into the "bad cop" role in this debate. But don't I make Linda look fabulous?:D[/QUOTE]


You realize I went into the very extreme defining of mutilation, right? If your definition is so broad that it includes any body modification that is not directly and entirely medically therapeutic.

Let me give you an example: I had my wisdom teeth removed. I was only 16 years old. Occasionally kids get them early and they are even younger. I wasn't old enough to entirely make my own decisions.

Did it hurt? Yea. My mouth was swollen for a while after. Could it have had complications? Yeah. They gave me antibiotics to prevent infection, but of course that's not 100% effective... Now my wisdom teeth are gone and will never grow back. I have a patch of empty gum behind my molars.

So what was the problem they were causing? Nothing. Nothing at all.

My molars were in good alignment and the dental professionals warned that wisdom teeth, when they become impacted can push other teeth out of alignment. They could mess up my bite. Or even if they came in mostly well, as I grew, they could shift and there would not be enough room and thus impact into the molars.

Were they doing this? No. It was preventative. Would they cause problems? They might. Having really bad problems with wisdom teeth is not uncommon... it's not really likely but major problems happen on occasion. And minor problems, like missalignment are quite common. Not that they can't be delt with or you can't live with them. But they are common enough that it was thought warneted to yank them out just to assure that this would not be a concern.


Does this effect my body? Yes. Perminantly.

Does this effect how I eat/chew? Yeah, a bit. I have one less set of potential back teeth to grind with. Would I have used them much? Well.. probably not that much. But did it change the way I potentially chew? Yea.

Did it make me chew better? Did it make me chew worse? Dunno. Never will.


Explain how this is not mutilation.

I think you may have not come to realize that mutilation has an implicit magnitude aspect to it. It is obviously subjective to some end. But I would not call breaking the tip of my pencil a "catastrophe" even if it meets the definition as being something unplanned and negative and damaging, because "Catastrophe" carries an implicit convention of being extreme.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom