Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

I think the relatively high circumcision rates in the US are the result mostly of social conformity and parents not putting much thought into the decision. Right now, the anti-circumcision crowd has the appearance of a fringe group, and their words are easily dismissed by the average person. For example, the assertion that circumcision is detrimental to sexual function doesn't make sense to the average couple whose experience is otherwise. However, it does make sense to Lithrael because she is in the unusual position of her experience confirming the idea. I suspect that she wouldn't have put much thought into the issue if sex wasn't different between the two?
I would agree with this, which is why I've never tried to use the "less sensation" argument.

I understand the social conformity and parents not thinking argument. First, the parents not putting much thought into it. Why isn't their doctor trying to give them all the information? I know, Linda, you've said that you don't want to push your ideas on others, but don't doctors do that by default? Say you have a cyst (I know this is completely unrelated to circumcision), the doctor says, well, here's what we're going to do to treat it. You can listen to him/her or not, but the fact remains that he's/she's offered his/her opinion of treatment for you. If a patient brought in their infant daughter and asked for you to trim her labia, or cut off her labia minora, you would again offer your opinion, which would be to dissuade them from the procedure, and even inform them that it's illegal. Yet, if someone brought their son in, and asked for you to cut off his foreskin, you would not dissuade them? To me, it says "double standard."

Now to social conformity. Perhaps you would not dissuade parents of sons from circumcision because most men are circumcised, thus, the social conformity argument. Well, from one of the studies posted, that breaks down circumcisions by state, it's clear that rates in the west are much lower than 50%, thus making being intact the norm. What would you suggest to parents in that case?

It looks like the opinions of those in this thread follow from my idea - that they are shaped by social conformity (those from outside the US where it is not the norm are not in favour) and the direction of their personal experience with regard to sexual function (or as a scapegoat for interpersonal interactions). There are exceptions - I think KellyB is one, although I'd have to refresh my memory on that.
I would like to think that I'm not one of the rabid anti-circs being talked about here. I think I've tried to be understanding and use non-inflammatory language. I think I've truly tried to delve into this subject and really understand what's going on with the circumcision phenomenon. I don't think parents who circumcise their boys are bad people.

You keep bringing up "where do we draw the line?" questions with Koshy, and at the risk of answering for him, I do not draw the line at circumcision because of social conformity (in the US or outside the US). For me (we're welcome to talk about this more, if you want) it's an issue of consent. Everything is an issue of consent. Nobody should do anything to you without your consent, and if they do so, that is illegal. (I know, in an ideal world.) If you have sex with someone, it should be because you mutually consent to it. One party not consenting is rape. If a doctor recommends treatment, and if you follow it, it's because you have been informed about the treatment, both pros and cons, and consent to following it. I could go on, but it's getting long-winded.

So, there's still issues of children who cannot consent, and those adults who, for whatever reason, are incapable of consenting. The adults question is not relevant here, which leaves us with children. I believe that parents should be able to consent for medical procedures for their children, with some caveats. Children, to me, are special cases, different from incapacitated adults, because they will one day be able to consent for themselves.

Now, the caveats. I do not believe that parents should be able to consent for their children, any procedure which is not medically necessary, and is permanent. This is because if it not medically necessary, there is still time to decide, and since the child will be able to decide for himself someday, he should choose for himself. Note that this does not apply to say, vaccinations, because they are medically necessary to prevent life-threatening diseases. Circumcision is not a medically necessary procedure, because many groups of physicians have decided by consensus that it is not. (Of course, their recommendations may change, and in light of that change it may be possible that circumcision is medically necessary, at which point I would reassess my views.) Circumcision is also permanent, which means that there should be good evidence for performing a non-reversible medical procedure. In some cases there are, such as phimosis, although I think that other technologies are becoming available, such as stretching, that makes such a drastic solution unnecessary. In the case of non-therapeutic circumcision, its very name implies that it's being performed for no medical reason. I do not think that parents should be able to perform permanent, non-therapeutic procedures on their children without their consent because there is no indication for doing so. I suppose this would include procedures like ear-piercing and tattoos. I, personally, am glad that my parents did not pierce my ears or tattoo my body without my consent. I do not consider parents' responsibility over their children to extend to the ability to consent for permanent, unnecessary procedures.

It could be possible to bring up cultural/societal reasons for circumcision. Unfortunately, I find many of these arguments lacking, and having to do more with conforming to society's expectations, than focusing on the child's right to consent. Also, society can be capricious and whimsical, meaning that its expectations can change at any time, and to me, an illogical barometer to follow.

Some might bring up "what age can a child consent?" I fully admit that I don't know, but different ages can be debated. Certainly, he cannot consent before he can vocalize. I, personally, think an adult is more able to understand the full implications of circumcision, which is why I think it's most logical that we should wait until the child is an adult. This can, of course, be debated.

I think that the rates are more likely to change if parents put more thought into it, and if the uncircumcised state is seen as conforming.
How are parents going to learn, since many parents are very unknowledgeable, and this topic seems very uncomfortable and taboo to most people? I think through their physicians. Their physicians must be able to take a stand and tell their patients the truth about circumcision, both pros and cons.
 
1. Do you honestly think cutting off 50% of the penile skin of an infant could ever become a standard practice? Its a hypothetical example...

2. I dont think it would take that much delusional thinking. There are studies afterall that say that the glans is mostly receptive to pain yes? So, the justification that could be used is the same as with the foreskin, its just a redundant piece of flesh that doesnt really serve much of a purpose in our streamlined modern society. Again, the question was IF it already was established, not could it be now.

These things follow patterns. They may be dramatic or obvious, but they stop short of impairing important functions. More atrocious acts are saved for those who are vulnerable and without power - women, slaves, prisoners. Can you think of an exception? Have you played the taboo game on the National Geographic site? Is there anything there that wouldn't be chosen over chopping off half of your penis?

3. If someone does it to you and alot of other people the natural thought is going to be that it must be good right?

Uh...no.

4. Jesus H. Artemis Gordon Christ. I said YOU, not society at large, can I please have some personal input from you, not every other person in the world that youre speaking for.

This is what I have said in recent posts (i.e. within the last two pages).

"My answer has always been that it is up to the individual to consent, and if they are unable to consent, the person(s) charged with promoting their interests."

"I think everyone should be afforded the same protections."

"It really depends upon the nature of the harm. I use a hierarchy of death, disability, disease, discomfort, dissatisfaction. I think that in most cases, I would find the first three adequate reasons to interfere. The last two would depend upon the details."

"I don't want someone else to overrule what I think is best for me or my child without good reason*."

Please specify what aspect of the question I have not covered and I will attempt to rectify the situation.

5. Females are more protected because all forms of non medically indicated female genital cutting is prohibited in the US, as I understand it. I can cut off my sons foreskin, but not my daughters labia. Both are pretty pointless from a functionality standpoint.

Females are more vulnerable than males, even in the US (the laws prohibiting discrimination on the basis of sex didn't come about because men were being discriminated against). FGM reflects this vulnerability, so if there are laws prohibiting it, it is in recognition that extra attention needs to be paid to females in order for them to effectively have the same level of protection as males.

Linda
 
I would agree with this, which is why I've never tried to use the "less sensation" argument.

I understand the social conformity and parents not thinking argument. First, the parents not putting much thought into it. Why isn't their doctor trying to give them all the information?

Why do you think the doctor has any special information to impart when it comes to the issue of conformity?

I know, Linda, you've said that you don't want to push your ideas on others, but don't doctors do that by default? Say you have a cyst (I know this is completely unrelated to circumcision), the doctor says, well, here's what we're going to do to treat it. You can listen to him/her or not, but the fact remains that he's/she's offered his/her opinion of treatment for you.

The doctor has special knowledge to impart, in that situation.

If a patient brought in their infant daughter and asked for you to trim her labia, or cut off her labia minora, you would again offer your opinion, which would be to dissuade them from the procedure, and even inform them that it's illegal. Yet, if someone brought their son in, and asked for you to cut off his foreskin, you would not dissuade them?

I would dissuade both. I personally think the AAP recommendations are too hands-off. However, the situation is not analogous since the reason for labia trimming is different from the reason for circumcision. The reason for the latter is only marginally acceptable, whereas the reason for the former is over the line.

To me, it says "double standard."

I think the situations are different.

Now to social conformity. Perhaps you would not dissuade parents of sons from circumcision because most men are circumcised, thus, the social conformity argument. Well, from one of the studies posted, that breaks down circumcisions by state, it's clear that rates in the west are much lower than 50%, thus making being intact the norm. What would you suggest to parents in that case?

I cannot judge the value of conformity for someone else.

I would like to think that I'm not one of the rabid anti-circs being talked about here. I think I've tried to be understanding and use non-inflammatory language. I think I've truly tried to delve into this subject and really understand what's going on with the circumcision phenomenon. I don't think parents who circumcise their boys are bad people.

That's good to hear. And when I mentioned the anti-circumcision crowd, I was also thinking of what one encounters on anti-circumcision websites, or parenting sites.

You keep bringing up "where do we draw the line?" questions with Koshy, and at the risk of answering for him, I do not draw the line at circumcision because of social conformity (in the US or outside the US). For me (we're welcome to talk about this more, if you want) it's an issue of consent. Everything is an issue of consent. Nobody should do anything to you without your consent, and if they do so, that is illegal. (I know, in an ideal world.) If you have sex with someone, it should be because you mutually consent to it. One party not consenting is rape. If a doctor recommends treatment, and if you follow it, it's because you have been informed about the treatment, both pros and cons, and consent to following it. I could go on, but it's getting long-winded.

So, there's still issues of children who cannot consent, and those adults who, for whatever reason, are incapable of consenting. The adults question is not relevant here, which leaves us with children. I believe that parents should be able to consent for medical procedures for their children, with some caveats. Children, to me, are special cases, different from incapacitated adults, because they will one day be able to consent for themselves.

Now, the caveats. I do not believe that parents should be able to consent for their children, any procedure which is not medically necessary, and is permanent. This is because if it not medically necessary, there is still time to decide, and since the child will be able to decide for himself someday, he should choose for himself. Note that this does not apply to say, vaccinations, because they are medically necessary to prevent life-threatening diseases. Circumcision is not a medically necessary procedure, because many groups of physicians have decided by consensus that it is not. (Of course, their recommendations may change, and in light of that change it may be possible that circumcision is medically necessary, at which point I would reassess my views.) Circumcision is also permanent, which means that there should be good evidence for performing a non-reversible medical procedure. In some cases there are, such as phimosis, although I think that other technologies are becoming available, such as stretching, that makes such a drastic solution unnecessary. In the case of non-therapeutic circumcision, its very name implies that it's being performed for no medical reason. I do not think that parents should be able to perform permanent, non-therapeutic procedures on their children without their consent because there is no indication for doing so. I suppose this would include procedures like ear-piercing and tattoos. I, personally, am glad that my parents did not pierce my ears or tattoo my body without my consent. I do not consider parents' responsibility over their children to extend to the ability to consent for permanent, unnecessary procedures.

Sigh. I just went back to page 5 of this discussion to link to the first of the twenty times this issue has already been hashed over. I think it is probably time that I learned my lesson.

It could be possible to bring up cultural/societal reasons for circumcision. Unfortunately, I find many of these arguments lacking, and having to do more with conforming to society's expectations, than focusing on the child's right to consent. Also, society can be capricious and whimsical, meaning that its expectations can change at any time, and to me, an illogical barometer to follow.

Some might bring up "what age can a child consent?" I fully admit that I don't know, but different ages can be debated. Certainly, he cannot consent before he can vocalize. I, personally, think an adult is more able to understand the full implications of circumcision, which is why I think it's most logical that we should wait until the child is an adult. This can, of course, be debated.

How are parents going to learn, since many parents are very unknowledgeable, and this topic seems very uncomfortable and taboo to most people? I think through their physicians. Their physicians must be able to take a stand and tell their patients the truth about circumcision, both pros and cons.

Physicians are already supposed to present the pros and cons. I don't think parents are weighing this issue on a medical basis.

Linda
 
1.These things follow patterns. They may be dramatic or obvious, but they stop short of impairing important functions. More atrocious acts are saved for those who are vulnerable and without power - women, slaves, prisoners. Can you think of an exception? Have you played the taboo game on the National Geographic site? Is there anything there that wouldn't be chosen over chopping off half of your penis?

2.Uh...no.

3. This is what I have said in recent posts (i.e. within the last two pages).

"My answer has always been that it is up to the individual to consent, and if they are unable to consent, the person(s) charged with promoting their interests."

"I think everyone should be afforded the same protections."

"It really depends upon the nature of the harm. I use a hierarchy of death, disability, disease, discomfort, dissatisfaction. I think that in most cases, I would find the first three adequate reasons to interfere. The last two would depend upon the details."

"I don't want someone else to overrule what I think is best for me or my child without good reason*."

Please specify what aspect of the question I have not covered and I will attempt to rectify the situation.

4.Females are more vulnerable than males, even in the US (the laws prohibiting discrimination on the basis of sex didn't come about because men were being discriminated against). FGM reflects this vulnerability, so if there are laws prohibiting it, it is in recognition that extra attention needs to be paid to females in order for them to effectively have the same level of protection as males.

Linda

1. If youre trying to inform me of the myriad of bad things that go on in the world, youre a little late.
Cutting off a female's labia doesnt interfere with baby making, which it seems everyone thinks is the only function of the genitals.

2. Um yes. Im sure youve never heard the expression "if theyre all doing it it must be good."

3. Again, you think everyone should be afforded the same protection, except infant males. You drop alot of abstract terms without really defining your stance on the same terms you just dropped. Im not the only person have trouble with it.

4. Thats great, however they dont have the same level of protection, they have a superior level of protection. As Ive said, why can I cut my son but not my daughter. Not that Im arguing against female protection, but your statements about protection and equality are pretty squarely off. I detect some feminist sentiment in your position.
 
4. Thats great, however they dont have the same level of protection, they have a superior level of protection. As Ive said, why can I cut my son but not my daughter. Not that Im arguing against female protection, but your statements about protection and equality are pretty squarely off. I detect some feminist sentiment in your position.

You can cut your son but not your daughter? Again, do you have the slightest idea what the difference between FGM and male circumcision are, in terms of magnitude?

Now let me ask you this: If you "cut" your daughter in the sense of a reduction of the clitoral hood, you would consider that the same sort of mutilation, or even in the same league as what goes on in North Africa?

Granted, I think if you posed the request to a doctor "Excuse me, I was thinking you could possibly reduce the skin around my daughters upper labia" they would look at you a bit strange, because it's not exactly something which is done in general in infancy.


Seriously there is something puzzling to me about using male circumcision and female genital mutilation in the statement. Try reading my post above or go get an anatomy text book.

If you want to say "Male circumcision is something that should not happen to a males genitals, just like FGM is something that is wrong and shouldn't happen to a female..."

Well then you may as well say "That guy who spraypainted swasticas on the Jewish community center is just like HITLER"

or

"Some guy bumped me and left a big gash in my rear bumper, it was an accident, just like the Titanic"

or

"Someone spilled their drink on my carpet. It was a tragic and unexpected event that damaged property, just like Hurricane Katrina and the Asian Tsunami combined did"

or

"The decision of the mayor to not continue the pothole repair program lead to a damaged city, in much the same way as the atomic bombing of Hiroshima lead to a damaged city"

or

"I disagree with that guy's idea of what makes for a good meal, in much the same way I do with Jeffery Dahlmer"

or

"Putting a whoopie cushion on his chair before the meeting was cruel and uncalled for, in the same way the Spanish Inquisition was"

or

"Loosing my car keys would be bad, just like having a large meteor destroy the human race would be"
 
You can cut your son but not your daughter? Again, do you have the slightest idea what the difference between FGM and male circumcision are, in terms of magnitude?

Now let me ask you this: If you "cut" your daughter in the sense of a reduction of the clitoral hood, you would consider that the same sort of mutilation, or even in the same league as what goes on in North Africa?

Granted, I think if you posed the request to a doctor "Excuse me, I was thinking you could possibly reduce the skin around my daughters upper labia" they would look at you a bit strange, because it's not exactly something which is done in general in infancy.


Seriously there is something puzzling to me about using male circumcision and female genital mutilation in the statement. Try reading my post above or go get an anatomy text book.

If you want to say "Male circumcision is something that should not happen to a males genitals, just like FGM is something that is wrong and shouldn't happen to a female..."

Well then you may as well say "That guy who spraypainted swasticas on the Jewish community center is just like HITLER"

or

"Some guy bumped me and left a big gash in my rear bumper, it was an accident, just like the Titanic"

or

"Someone spilled their drink on my carpet. It was a tragic and unexpected event that damaged property, just like Hurricane Katrina and the Asian Tsunami combined did"

or

"The decision of the mayor to not continue the pothole repair program lead to a damaged city, in much the same way as the atomic bombing of Hiroshima lead to a damaged city"

or

"I disagree with that guy's idea of what makes for a good meal, in much the same way I do with Jeffery Dahlmer"

or

"Putting a whoopie cushion on his chair before the meeting was cruel and uncalled for, in the same way the Spanish Inquisition was"

or

"Loosing my car keys would be bad, just like having a large meteor destroy the human race would be"

Please post some links about the various types of FGM and male circumcision so that we can all see how different the two practices are. The reason I'm asking you to do this is because I think you have done zero research on this subject and think that you know that all types of FGM are worse than male circumcision.

Note that we should only be comparing the two practices as they are performed in the same region, not, for example, US infant circumcision vs. African FGM, because if FGM was practiced in the US it would have probably become similar in magnitude to infant circumcision.
 
<snip>

Females are more vulnerable than males, even in the US (the laws prohibiting discrimination on the basis of sex didn't come about because men were being discriminated against). FGM reflects this vulnerability, so if there are laws prohibiting it, it is in recognition that extra attention needs to be paid to females in order for them to effectively have the same level of protection as males.

Linda

Nice display of mental gymnastics.

How did the laws prohibiting discrimination based on sex come about? Do you think men were using the same type of arguments that pro-circumcision people are now and women were occasionally calling them names?

How, exactly, is a female child under the age of 10 "more vulnerable" than a male child under the age of 10?

And just how many females were circumcised in the US before the law banning it came into force, compared to males? I don't know, but I bet it was a tiny, tiny fraction. So, if this was the case, then boys were (and are) being discriminated against more than girls, thus by your logic it was males that needed the "extra attention", not females.

Sorry Linda, laws against sexism are always worded to say an individual will not be discriminated against based on their sex. It does not matter which sex they were brought into protect, they apply to both equally.
 
1. If youre trying to inform me of the myriad of bad things that go on in the world, youre a little late.

That wasn't my point at all. My point was that various cultures do various things with their bodies in order to mark themselves as members of a group. And while the choice of activity may be variable, they follow a similar pattern. They do not significantly interfere with important functions. So you may see cultures pierce and make other sorts of holes in their lips, you don't see one that sews the lips shut, as that would seriously impair their ability to eat.

So that you don't see any cultures chopping off half of their son's penis isn't just a matter of happenstance and cultural relativism, it's because half a penis significantly impairs or eliminates the enjoyment of sex and the ability to make new sons. And it is important, biologically, for men to enjoy sex, as ejaculation is necessary for continuation of the species.

Cutting off a female's labia doesnt interfere with baby making, which it seems everyone thinks is the only function of the genitals.

Exactly. Which is why it can be successfully used on your own women and children without interfering with the biological continuation of your family.

2. Um yes. Im sure youve never heard the expression "if theyre all doing it it must be good."

I don't think repeating an aphorism serves as proof that members of a culture are completely unable to evaluate the harm in a procedure just because it is frequently performed.

3. Again, you think everyone should be afforded the same protection, except infant males.

No. I have stated that their protection should be based on the judgment of those with their best interests in mind (i.e. their parents/guardians) and on the protection afforded by society equally to all its individual members. You seem to think that their protection should be based on over-ruling those protections and prohibiting specific activities. I asked you to explain how you would go about that - how you would choose which activities to prohibit.

You drop alot of abstract terms without really defining your stance on the same terms you just dropped. Im not the only person have trouble with it.

I have repeatedly (including within the post that you quoted) stated that if you need me to specify a definition, I would do so. I have also stated that I will elaborate on any point that isn't clear. I have also done that very thing multiple times in my posts to you. The post of mine that you quoted includes an example of that - a statement plus a specific definition of one of the abstract terms used in the statement. Your complaint is particularly specious given that you have neglected to bother answering many of my very specific questions to you. I will be generous and consider that, though you seem to ignore those questions where the answer would show your argument is fallacious, this is merely coincidence.

4. Thats great, however they dont have the same level of protection, they have a superior level of protection. As Ive said, why can I cut my son but not my daughter. Not that Im arguing against female protection, but your statements about protection and equality are pretty squarely off.

You are equating two things that are not the same - laws and protection. That there are laws prohibiting discrimination against someone because they are black, does not mean that black people have more protection than white people. Black people require extra legal attention in order for their protection to be equal to that of white people within the setting of US history.

The problem, as I have mentioned several times, is that males are cut for a completely different reason than females are cut. You are pretending that they are somehow the same because the area in which they are cut is vaguely similar. That's like saying that allowing the wearing of the Sikh kirpan sewn into a sheath, but not allowing the carrying of a loaded gun in school is unfair.

Let's see how clever you are. Let's see if you can guess why the law is unequal. Let's see if you can guess why there aren't laws prohibiting specific activities performed for the purpose of subjugating white males in the US.

I detect some feminist sentiment in your position.

I presume that is meant to be pejorative. Nice.

What is the name of the movement initiated for the express purpose of ensuring equal treatment of white males in the US?

Linda
 
<snip>
You are equating two things that are not the same - laws and protection. That there are laws prohibiting discrimination against someone because they are black, does not mean that black people have more protection than white people. Black people require extra legal attention in order for their protection to be equal to that of white people within the setting of US history.

There are no laws that prohibit discrimination against someone because they are black.

The law will state that discrimination based on ethnicity or skin colour is illegal.

The problem, as I have mentioned several times, is that males are cut for a completely different reason than females are cut. You are pretending that they are somehow the same because the area in which they are cut is vaguely similar. That's like saying that allowing the wearing of the Sikh kirpan sewn into a sheath, but not allowing the carrying of a loaded gun in school is unfair.

Really? Got any evidence to back that up? Are you saying all male circumcisions are performed for benevolent reasons and female circumcisions are done out of malice? Even if they are, so what? How do the reasons for the act change the physical abuse to the child?

Let's see how clever you are. Let's see if you can guess why the law is unequal.

The law is unequal because it was worded specifically so male infant circumcision could continue to be practiced in the US.

Let's see if you can guess why there aren't laws prohibiting specific activities performed for the purpose of subjugating white males in the US.

Linda

Cute. The “white males” came up with a law that did not affect what they think of as acceptable behaviour.
 
Yes, your story clearly wasnt meant to apply in blanket fashion to all circumcised men. You just came it to say that you were very happy with it.
Happy enough with the functions of my manhood, but as to the sensation question, I can't compare it to otherwise. (As you and Ivor and a few others have noted.)
and heavily imply that everyone else is,
Nope. You read that into the post, I didn't write that, nor did I mean that. You projecting, not me writing. I was/am a single datum.
The point is that its not my choice. It is my choice to have him vaccinated, or to feed him bananas, not to cut off part of his penis to make it conform to my ideals of beauty, since the medical argument has been flattened.
That is your opinion, based your self centered morality, and LL (or anyone's) is not required to so base decisions on your closely held, personal tentes. He did cite the law, correctly, which you then reacted to as an invalid position. That too I felt needed mention.
are clearly emotionally embroiled yourself,
No, that's you projecting again, and reading into what was written. My only emotion, as it were, was empathy for LL, as a father, and seeing some mean spirited internet post wishing harm on his son.
since youre lacking your "turtle neck" as you like to call it, and call all my reasonings emotive bollocks.
Note my "good on ya, your choice" remark, which contradicts what you just stated. If the turtle neck is your thing, good for you, or for anyone.
About me being a prick, Im not here to impress you Mr.Rotor. Find me offensive, find me wonderful, its no skin off my nose (other areas maybe), the issue still exists.
Indeed, I am able to undertake the arrogant prick role myself. The issue is in your mind, and based on how you posted, in your emotions. Absent your wish for harm to LL's kid, no post from me. This thread has been very informative without my participation to date. The thread, suitably filtered for emotionally charged points, puts the E into JREF rather nicely.
Youre not making an argument, youre just here to press buttons and be a nuisance, as you said yourself.
You state I wanted to be a nuisance, I did not, and yes, I was interested in tweaking your nose based on your intentions/wishes for mishap to LL, or rather to his son. I like LL. He's been a warrior in the war against stupid for some years.
And no, I dont have to deal with it, I can just go become uncircumcised anytime I want.... ohh wait. Good point, thanks.
Exactly. Your choice. No one else ought to meddle in your business.

We have an accord.

I read a little snippet in Atlantic Monthly this weekend, which coincidentally enough briefly summarized a small study about the sensitivity nodes on uncircumsiced penises (five, IIRC). The summary seems to parallel nicely some of the comments in this thread.

This got me thinking.

If the sensitivity bonus of being uncircumcised is an order of magnitude greater, then one outcome of that lucky condition might be a higher incidence of premature (or at least difficult to control) ejaculation. One sincerely hopes that your nickname wouldn't be Quick Koshy for any reason other than your intellect, if that were the case. Practice does allow for mitigation of that risk. FWIW, if you have not had kids yet, the Kegel exercises taught in Lamaze class to women for pre pregnancy muscle toning can be helpful for men in that arena.

Putting the E into JREF, and at last something new and useful from me, to you, on this topic, sorta.

DR
 
Last edited:
Please post some links about the various types of FGM and male circumcision so that we can all see how different the two practices are. The reason I'm asking you to do this is because I think you have done zero research on this subject and think that you know that all types of FGM are worse than male circumcision.

Note that we should only be comparing the two practices as they are performed in the same region, not, for example, US infant circumcision vs. African FGM, because if FGM was practiced in the US it would have probably become similar in magnitude to infant circumcision.


Alright:

Male -

Partial Circumcision - Basically a circumcision which leaves a significant This is commonly done for a foreskin that cannot be retracted or is irritated because it is too large for cleaning or movement.

Standard Circumcision (Preputioplasty) - Removal of the majority of the foreskin, but done loosely with the remaining tied. The frenulum generally remains and the "Lower foreskin" is usually mostly left. (this is the type which is preformed on infants and such)

Re-Circumcision - An adult procedure for those who are circumcised but want more of the foreskin removed or who have a partial attachment issue or scar.

Complete Circumcision - A rather general term meaning circumcision which favors removal of as much foreskin tissue as possible, even earing on the side of removing additional tissue. It commonly results in very tight skin pulling to cover the area, and this can cause issues. It also can sometimes include attachment of the gland to the skin of the shaft, without an obvious transition - This is not generally a western medical procedure, but is popular in Islam.

Partial Penectomy - Ask John Wane Bobbet

Complete Penectomy (Emascultion) - Removal of the complete penis, usually including the root structure.

Castration - Removal of the testies

Complete Emasculation - Removal of all the goods.



Female:

Type I: (this is the only type at all common in modern western medicine)

Partial Hoodectomy/hood slitting - Removal of part of the clitoral hood or cutting of it. This is actually somewhat common in Western Medicine for hood structures which are too tight, cause irritation or cannot be retracted to clean and therefore are prone to inflammation or infection. Also for sexual reasons.

Hoodectomy/Clitoridectomy - Removal of most of the hood or dramatic reduction such that the clitoral gland is exposed except for the labia. Usually, as with medical male circumcision it is done conservatively with some skin left behind. This is most common in adult women and is generally elective. In some cases, it may improve sexual stimulation, depending on the anatomy of the individual. However it can also lead to oversensitivity. It is relatively rare in infants.

Labiaplasty - Refers to any medical procedure which involves reshaping of the labia (usually primarily labia minora) Usually this is a reduction, but it can also be reshaping or extension. It is usually elective surgury


Type II: (common in Islam. Also in Africa and parts of South Asia. Some more progressive muslims contend it is not an islamic practice, but a cultural one that is not required. However, it is mentioned in the Koran and the more conservative islamic sects generally consider it a religious necessity)

Excision or clitoridectomy - Removal of the clitoral gland, clitoral hood and some or all of the labia minora. This is not generally done in modern western medicine, except as an extreme measure for cancer or a severe defect. This is very rare.

It is one of the most common forms of female genital cutting in the middleeast and other parts of the world. It is sometimes done in a medical setting but may also be done by religious figures or family memebers, often in non-sterile, uncontrolled conditions without any pain control.

It is preformed in the non-islamic world electively by islamic converts. However, in many European countries, it has been deemed illegal for parents to to this to minors or have a doctor do it. Of course, this does not stop it, and some may go to hospitals in the middleeast to have it done to their child, or have a local shake or Islamic midwife do it.

Usually the woman is left incapable of orgasm or normal sexual function, although it can sometimes be achieved by the remaining clitoral stem.

Complete or internal clitoridectomy: Like above, but also rips out any roots of the clitoris and sometimes digs the tissue around it to ensure nothing may be left behind. Also common in Islam

Type III:

Infibulation - This is NEVER done in western medicine, but a similar procedure may, in extreme examples, be done if there is very rampant cancer or for extreme cases.

Although sometimes done in Islam, most developed Islamic countries consider this to be just too extreme for most cases. However, it's still popular in parts of Africa and other less developed regions. But it is used in many mainstream islamic countries for women who are deemed to be immoral or suspected of adultry. It is seen as a mild punishment, compared to death by torture.

It takes type II to the next level. It removes all the external structures and tissues and scrapes the vaginal and cervical walls. The only remaining tissue is parts of the anal region and urethra.

Even the "monds pubis" is dug out, in most cases.

The large raw open wound is bandaged or partially stitched up with a scared hole left behind for menstruation and urination and sexual intercourse. However, how it heals (assuming death does not occure first) is not really controlled. It may become a mound of scar tissue or a gaping void or something in between.



Infabulation with sewing - same as above, but the wound is allowed to partially heal then opened up and sewn so as to leave a small pencil-sized hole for menstruation and urination.


This procedure removes even the most remote possibility of female sexual physical pleasure. It also commonly causes major complication and may require additional cutting to re-open the urethra or remove scar tissue.


This is most common in Africa and preformed by village elders on those 2-9 years old. In areas where it is not the general practice it may also be done to women as punishment or if they are thought to be too "loose" or "rebellious" or are a risk of adultery.


Upon marriage the area is generally cut or ripped open for sexual intercourse. Of course, the scaring and lack of the normal structures impedes child birth, and this is usually remedied with more cutting/digging. Or simply pushing really hard. Which will result in birth... not a very pretty birth, but if it's pushed hard enough, something has to give.


Sources:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Female_genital_cutting
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Episiotomy
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Circumcision
http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs241/en/

http://www.circlist.com/

http://www.religioustolerance.org/fem_cirm.htm
http://www.who.int/mediacentre/factsheets/fs241/en/
http://www.circinfo.net/
http://www.cirp.org/
http://www.doctorsopposingcircumcision.org/


Note: I'm not going to footnote and number each and everything. I ain't writing a thesis and this was unpleasant enough to check out.
 
1. You state I wanted to be a nuisance, I did not, and yes, I was interested in tweaking your nose based on your intentions/wishes for mishap to LL, or rather to his son. I like LL. He's been a warrior in the war against stupid for some years.

2. Exactly. Your choice. No one else ought to meddle in your business.

We have an accord.

DR

1. No worse than what happened to me.

2. You did read that yes?
 
I completely agree that using inflammatory language does NOT help solve the problem. It doesn't even matter how true it can potentially be, the moment you come up to a parent and use 'mutilate' and 'your son' in the same sentence, they are not listening to you anymore.

I think there's something wrong with the guys when they are that obsessed with the penis. I often wonder if they are having unrelated issues, and are blaming a lack of foreskin for inadequacies in other areas. I notice that, as you said, mentally healthy men don't seem to have any problem with it.

Hrmm. On the one hand I'm sure this is sometimes true, on the other the way you say it seems pretty harsh to me. It's not at all unheard of that there are unpleasant results or outright mishaps. The few who are stuck living with the results are naturally going to tend to be pretty pissed off. And those with a lot of empathy are going to be pissed off that anyone is forcing such an unnecessary risk on their kids, no matter how small the risk is.

But I also completely agree that FGM and the vast majority of male circumcisions are simply a world apart. There is a risk of things going wrong in male circs and that's part of why I'm against it. When it's done right it takes away a little potential fun for a typical guy trying to enjoy himself. It's sad, but it won't ruin him in the slightest. When FGM is done right... o.O

In response to those saying that anticirc videos are propaganda, though, I'd love to see a pro-circ video showing the kind of calm experience with an alert, reasonably distress-free baby that some of the posters here have described.
 
I completely agree that using inflammatory language does NOT help solve the problem. It doesn't even matter how true it can potentially be, the moment you come up to a parent and use 'mutilate' and 'your son' in the same sentence, they are not listening to you anymore.

Hrmm. On the one hand I'm sure this is sometimes true, on the other the way you say it seems pretty harsh to me. It's not at all unheard of that there are unpleasant results or outright mishaps. The few who are stuck living with the results are naturally going to tend to be pretty pissed off. And those with a lot of empathy are going to be pissed off that anyone is forcing such an unnecessary risk on their kids, no matter how small the risk is.

But I also completely agree that FGM and the vast majority of male circumcisions are simply a world apart. There is a risk of things going wrong in male circs and that's part of why I'm against it. When it's done right it takes away a little potential fun for a typical guy trying to enjoy himself. It's sad, but it won't ruin him in the slightest. When FGM is done right... o.O

In response to those saying that anticirc videos are propaganda, though, I'd love to see a pro-circ video showing the kind of calm experience with an alert, reasonably distress-free baby that some of the posters here have described.

If I had been born female and subsequently mutilated, would you expect me to lack empathy for males?

Regardless of everyone's desire for PC language the word mutilate is quite accurate for both male and female.

I hate that it happens to females, I hate that it happens to males. Ive been careful to balance my views pertaining to male and female. I think drawing a line of badness between the two is counterproductive, if that makes sense.
They are both reprehensible, they are both terrible, they should both be completely banned, outside of medical indication.

Sorry I havnt responded to any of the larger posts today, Ive been rather busy.
 
If I had been born female and subsequently mutilated, would you expect me to lack empathy for males?

Regardless of everyone's desire for PC language the word mutilate is quite accurate for both male and female.

I hate that it happens to females, I hate that it happens to males. Ive been careful to balance my views pertaining to male and female. I think drawing a line of badness between the two is counterproductive, if that makes sense.
They are both reprehensible, they are both terrible, they should both be completely banned, outside of medical indication.

Sorry I havnt responded to any of the larger posts today, Ive been rather busy.


That is... beyond ridiculous. Seriously... it's... absolutely ridiculous.... It's... well... idiotic and insulting really.

I honestly cannot see how a human behind who is clear minded and of slightly bellow average intelligence or better could come to that conclusion. To compare the two is so beyond the realm of what I could fathom one logically thinking, I can only come to the conclusion that either A) this is rhetorical or designed to make a point B) This is just trolling C) I am not infact seeing this and I am either in some sort of drug induced coma or have been slipped LSD or something equally powerful D) You have been subject to some very severe exposure to material designed to cause psycological effects which would go against basic logic E) You are insane or on some very powerful drugs F) You're a complete and utter idiot G) You are evil.


Now, I do not know where to draw the line for "mutulation" and I will not get into the stupid "The world is not black and white" argument or be told that I somehow am making myself the standard bearer.


Okay... lets use this analogy. Lets say the "grey spectrum" of what is mutilation is a map of the world... you follow?

Ok good. The middle ground of the grey area is somewhere in the atlantic. It's subjective and people can disagree. It's impossible to be sure. Maybe it's going through greenland... some might even say it is as far as the canaries islands. A few might even come to the conclusion that it's off the coast of Florida.

Ok? Grey area. So stuff that falls in that area... there's conjecture.

But Male circumcision... that's in eastern Europe. It's not in the area of reasonable conjecture. It's not even that close. Some might say it's close, but... it's far enough away that it's pretty apparent which end it is on.

Okay, you follow so far?

Female genital mutilation is in Japan. It's so far to the east, that there's absolutely no way a reasonable person could say it's on the side that is not mutilation.


Okay... lets try to make another analogy, because of all the damn relativists here. (and I have a feeling athon or nails is going to consider this bait to say something).

Can we all agree on what constitutes an "Old person"? No. Some might say 75. Others 65. Some might say you only have to be beyond adulthood.

So we cannot draw the line, can we?


But... can we universally agree, or at least, nearly universally agree that a 108 year old is an "old person." And can we pretty much say the same about a 96 year old? and can the vast majority of us say the same about a 89 year old?


And can we equally agree that a seven year old is not an old person?





Lets look at the definition of mutilation:

To Mutilate. The act of mutuliting.

Mutilate:
(via Oxford Dictionary)

1. To injure, disfigure, or make imperfect by removing or irreparably damaging necessary parts. Implies severe. To make unrecognizable.

2. To destroy or severely disfigure, such as change appearance beyond reconstruction or remedy. To reduct to usability.

3. To cause severe and intentional injury; implies torture; implies dishonor.

(oxford expanded)

By convention implies severe and intentional injury, with the intention of irreversible and dramatic change in appearance, such as to make unrecognizable or entirely non-functional. Includes amputations of limbs or other disfigurement. Often used in the context of disbarment, as with a dead body or for the purpose of torture or punishment.

Forms of mutilation would include branding, gouging of eyes, traumatic amputations, emasculation, burning of flesh, branding.

Mutilation may be an aspect of torture, but torture resulting in disfigurement, but without the direct intent thereof, is not necessarily mutilation. Often mutilation of a person would be done such as to render them incapable (blind, deaf, unable to reproduce, handicapped) or to make them disfigure, undesirable or ashamed. Sometimes considered a "lifelong punishment" see: branding, marking (criminal), humiliation (punishment).







(via American Heritage)

1. To cause disfigurement to or to make severely disfigured. To decompose the appearance of.
2. To destroy the function and shape of. (Us: Human animal or remains)
3. To completely and severely misshape.
4. To destroy beyond repair.


(via Randomhouse Websters Complete)

1. The absolute destruction, disfigurement or reduction of. [Person or animal by convention]
2. Torture to the degree of complete disfigurement. To cause great pain to and damage to. To make unable through torture.
3. To injure in a manner which implies severity.
4. To make entirely incapable of performing a function or being recognized.
5. To remove all beauty or to render ugly.

(Britannica Dictionary of the American Language)

To cause the destruction of/to totally destroy/to torture and disfigure/to harm beyond recovery/to make incapable (imp: In anger, to cause pain, to make suffer)


Also as: Vandalize, Disfigure, Injure, dishonor, completely destroy, mangle, rip, shred
 
Ok. I just realized I left something open for Nails/Athon/Pisc to get me on.

By old person: I mean within human age constrains and not applying to the whole of human history including those who are dead.

and I mean in a time scale which is not based on the age of the universe or the halflife of positronium. But in general human time, in common usage.

(please don't ask me to define common usage or general)

It means... in most contextual idioms in current societies.

Okay... define most... lets say "the vast majority of"... okay.. we'll call it 75%



And nobody in this analogy is traveling at a velocity which is great enough to result in appreciable time distortion.

And by appreciable, I mean large enough to be detected by some means which is less precise than a rubidium atomic clock. And I know those will be different.

So lets say the design specs for a mass-produced frequency standard operating properly and within good repair.

Okay.. define what is good enough to be considered "good repair"

um...

Seriously... none of the persons in the above example are even near enough to make a difference...

Okay... now you want to know what constitutes "enough" and "difference"


um


nevermind. Seriously. Nevermind.
 
Ok. I just realized I left something open for Nails/Athon/Pisc to get me on.

By old person: I mean within human age constrains and not applying to the whole of human history including those who are dead.

and I mean in a time scale which is not based on the age of the universe or the halflife of positronium. But in general human time, in common usage.

(please don't ask me to define common usage or general)

It means... in most contextual idioms in current societies.

Okay... define most... lets say "the vast majority of"... okay.. we'll call it 75%



And nobody in this analogy is traveling at a velocity which is great enough to result in appreciable time distortion.

And by appreciable, I mean large enough to be detected by some means which is less precise than a rubidium atomic clock. And I know those will be different.

So lets say the design specs for a mass-produced frequency standard operating properly and within good repair.

Okay.. define what is good enough to be considered "good repair"

um...

Seriously... none of the persons in the above example are even near enough to make a difference...

Okay... now you want to know what constitutes "enough" and "difference"


um


nevermind. Seriously. Nevermind.

So, in the spectrum of analysis that youve so clearly outlined. Lets just say that something is acceptable because its not "as bad" as something else.

I suppose rape at knife point would be made illegal, but plain rape with no weapon would be just fine.

They are both human rights violations, they are both horrible, they both should end, for the second time, I dont feel a need to elaborate, and I WILL draw the comparison between the two, because they are easily comparable.

I argue that both are bad and need to end, meanwhile you say no no female genital mutilation is worse, and so males deserve to endure circumcision because the female version is worse, right. Both are bad, both should end.

Youre also failing to think of the various other forms of male infant genital mutilation, practiced in various tribes around the world. Look it up on google.

Drawing a line of whats bad and worse in two things that are all together deplorable is pointless. If I could end male circumcision at the expense of continuing female circumcision for another 200 years would I? No. If I could do the inverse, would I? No. They both should end. There are quite a few other things that should end as well, but yes, you understand.

Iunno if I quoted the right part, have quite a headache at current.
 
So, in the spectrum of analysis that youve so clearly outlined. Lets just say that something is acceptable because its not "as bad" as something else.

I suppose rape at knife point would be made illegal, but plain rape with no weapon would be just fine.

They are both human rights violations, they are both horrible, they both should end, for the second time, I dont feel a need to elaborate, and I WILL draw the comparison between the two, because they are easily comparable.

I argue that both are bad and need to end, meanwhile you say no no female genital mutilation is worse, and so males deserve to endure circumcision because the female version is worse, right. Both are bad, both should end.

Youre also failing to think of the various other forms of male infant genital mutilation, practiced in various tribes around the world. Look it up on google.

Drawing a line of whats bad and worse in two things that are all together deplorable is pointless. If I could end male circumcision at the expense of continuing female circumcision for another 200 years would I? No. If I could do the inverse, would I? No. They both should end. There are quite a few other things that should end as well, but yes, you understand.

Iunno if I quoted the right part, have quite a headache at current.




Christ. No.

Both rape and rape at knife point would be illegal.

Slashing of tires would also be illegal, but not nearly as bad, or even close.

Yelling obscenities at someone... well... that's into the gray area. Perhaps if it was a threat or disturbed the peace or was an attempt to incite violence.

Sticking your tongue out at someone... not illegal... but possibly not a nice thing to do...

Picking flowers... even further into the "undoubtedly legal" area....


Wow... do you honestly do this for fun or what? Seriously, there's some sort of epidemic of this idea that if you can't quantify something universally, you can't tell where the hell it falls.

(I don't know exactly how much my car weighs, btw. I don't have a scale that big and I didn't look it up in the manual. But it weighs more than a loaf of bread. I'm damn sure of that. How much more? I don't know, but a lot. A real lot. Enough that I can tell it ain't even close. Oh, and I think it weighs less than my brothers car. But you might look at them and say "No I think your brothers car looks like it weighs more." And that's not unreasonable. But if you honestly think that it looks like it weighs more than a 747... well.. sorry, I have trouble believing that you would actually come to that conclusion)


Note to persons mentioned above and others. This is not an invitation to debate the weight of cars. Yes, it is different than the mass. And... relative boyant weight in the atmosphere as well... and I know... evaluating the weight of objects is an imperfect analogy, because you could quantify them, if you had a scale. Analogies are often imperfect. This should not be news to you. To say X is like Y does not mean X is identical to Y. They may simply have a similarity which is useful for illustrating a point... such as evaluating things which are clearly many degrees of mantidue in difference vrs those which are clearly close, such as rape and rape with a kife, which, some people don't seem to understand the difference between.
 
Your conclusion on the universal ethics of genital mutilation based on your perceived notion of rates of damage is wonderful, however not agreeable to.

I dont want females cut, I dont want males cut. Whats not agreeable about this? Why do you feel the need to draw some arbitrary line.

So rape is unacceptable no matter what. Genital cutting is more or less acceptable depending on how much whoevers doing it decides to cut off. There are much more radical forms of male genital cutting as well.

Most of your differences arise from the fact that males have a penis and females have a vagina. Listing the way that a vagina is cut vs a penis doesnt make sense, theyre quite different organs, despite their shared developmental courses. I fail to see why opposing female circumcision for the same reason as male is somehow insane or stupid.

I regret that females have their genitals forcibly cut for no real reason. I regret that males have their genitals forcibly cut for no real reason. I oppose both.

Why do you think male circumcision is more acceptable than female?

ETA: Id be curious to hear the viewpoint about why female circumcision is more acceptable than male from areas that only cut females. Assuming that would be the answer. Just a side note of curiosity.
 
Last edited:
I dont want females cut, I dont want males cut. Whats not agreeable about this? Why do you feel the need to draw some arbitrary line.

Nobody's arguing that that's not a perfectly good position to take. The problem is talking about the two issues as if they were practically the same.

So rape is unacceptable no matter what. Genital cutting is more or less acceptable depending on how much whoevers doing it decides to cut off. There are much more radical forms of male genital cutting as well.

That's pretty much it, yeah. FGM and extreme male genital cutting are both out. If 'hoodectomy' was the norm I'd feel it was bad but not an outright atrocity. Male circumcision is bad but not an outright atrocity. The culture we're in simply doesn't think of male circumcision as mutilation. It's your right to call it that and I don't think it's outside the realm of reason or anything, but the fact remains you can't get a dialog going like that. You can't change any part of society from the outside.

Most of your differences arise from the fact that males have a penis and females have a vagina. Listing the way that a vagina is cut vs a penis doesnt make sense, theyre quite different organs, despite their shared developmental courses. I fail to see why opposing female circumcision for the same reason as male is somehow insane or stupid.

There are analogs to what the bits are for. If you've had your whole genital region turned to hamburger, you've lost all capacity for sexual pleasure. If you've lost a clitoris, you've often lost capacity for orgasm. If you've lost a clitoral hood, you've just lost some sensitive tissue. If you've lost most of a penis, you've often lost capacity for orgasm. If you've lost a foreskin you've just lost a lot of sensitive tissue. The spectrum runs from "loss of some sensation" to "hamburger." That's the difference. There you go.

Why do you think male circumcision is more acceptable than female?

ETA: Id be curious to hear the viewpoint about why female circumcision is more acceptable than male from areas that only cut females. Assuming that would be the answer. Just a side note of curiosity.

Why do I think it's more acceptable in western society? Because traditionally guys love sex either way, and cut girls basically can't. Because guys are in a position of power, and girls aren't. Guys feel protective towards girls, and they don't feel protective towards themselves or other guys. Because it's established tradition. All of those are reasons.

Why is FGM acceptable where it's practiced? Well, shock surprise, because it's part of a culture of expressing explicit male dominance over women. I would imagine traditionalists who think of themselves as more level-headed simply consider it an important part of ensuring a woman will be clean, respectable and marriageable.

If you're trying to point up that male circ is all about making men feel subjugated or bad about sex, I wouldn't say there was never or that there can't now be an element of that involved. I have heard religious people say it's important to help prevent masturbation, which is a hideously backward attitude but there you go. However, most of the time, in the modern setting, it's simply an unfortunate blind adherence to tradition.

I can understand not wanting to dilute one's culture in LL's situation, though I can't say I agree with him. But then I don't really understand the attraction of belonging to a culture. Nobody raised me to value it for my own good, heh. In the end, I don't consider the practice bad enough to do more than try hard to change his mind about it, which has already happened here anyway.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom