I would agree with this, which is why I've never tried to use the "less sensation" argument.I think the relatively high circumcision rates in the US are the result mostly of social conformity and parents not putting much thought into the decision. Right now, the anti-circumcision crowd has the appearance of a fringe group, and their words are easily dismissed by the average person. For example, the assertion that circumcision is detrimental to sexual function doesn't make sense to the average couple whose experience is otherwise. However, it does make sense to Lithrael because she is in the unusual position of her experience confirming the idea. I suspect that she wouldn't have put much thought into the issue if sex wasn't different between the two?
I understand the social conformity and parents not thinking argument. First, the parents not putting much thought into it. Why isn't their doctor trying to give them all the information? I know, Linda, you've said that you don't want to push your ideas on others, but don't doctors do that by default? Say you have a cyst (I know this is completely unrelated to circumcision), the doctor says, well, here's what we're going to do to treat it. You can listen to him/her or not, but the fact remains that he's/she's offered his/her opinion of treatment for you. If a patient brought in their infant daughter and asked for you to trim her labia, or cut off her labia minora, you would again offer your opinion, which would be to dissuade them from the procedure, and even inform them that it's illegal. Yet, if someone brought their son in, and asked for you to cut off his foreskin, you would not dissuade them? To me, it says "double standard."
Now to social conformity. Perhaps you would not dissuade parents of sons from circumcision because most men are circumcised, thus, the social conformity argument. Well, from one of the studies posted, that breaks down circumcisions by state, it's clear that rates in the west are much lower than 50%, thus making being intact the norm. What would you suggest to parents in that case?
I would like to think that I'm not one of the rabid anti-circs being talked about here. I think I've tried to be understanding and use non-inflammatory language. I think I've truly tried to delve into this subject and really understand what's going on with the circumcision phenomenon. I don't think parents who circumcise their boys are bad people.It looks like the opinions of those in this thread follow from my idea - that they are shaped by social conformity (those from outside the US where it is not the norm are not in favour) and the direction of their personal experience with regard to sexual function (or as a scapegoat for interpersonal interactions). There are exceptions - I think KellyB is one, although I'd have to refresh my memory on that.
You keep bringing up "where do we draw the line?" questions with Koshy, and at the risk of answering for him, I do not draw the line at circumcision because of social conformity (in the US or outside the US). For me (we're welcome to talk about this more, if you want) it's an issue of consent. Everything is an issue of consent. Nobody should do anything to you without your consent, and if they do so, that is illegal. (I know, in an ideal world.) If you have sex with someone, it should be because you mutually consent to it. One party not consenting is rape. If a doctor recommends treatment, and if you follow it, it's because you have been informed about the treatment, both pros and cons, and consent to following it. I could go on, but it's getting long-winded.
So, there's still issues of children who cannot consent, and those adults who, for whatever reason, are incapable of consenting. The adults question is not relevant here, which leaves us with children. I believe that parents should be able to consent for medical procedures for their children, with some caveats. Children, to me, are special cases, different from incapacitated adults, because they will one day be able to consent for themselves.
Now, the caveats. I do not believe that parents should be able to consent for their children, any procedure which is not medically necessary, and is permanent. This is because if it not medically necessary, there is still time to decide, and since the child will be able to decide for himself someday, he should choose for himself. Note that this does not apply to say, vaccinations, because they are medically necessary to prevent life-threatening diseases. Circumcision is not a medically necessary procedure, because many groups of physicians have decided by consensus that it is not. (Of course, their recommendations may change, and in light of that change it may be possible that circumcision is medically necessary, at which point I would reassess my views.) Circumcision is also permanent, which means that there should be good evidence for performing a non-reversible medical procedure. In some cases there are, such as phimosis, although I think that other technologies are becoming available, such as stretching, that makes such a drastic solution unnecessary. In the case of non-therapeutic circumcision, its very name implies that it's being performed for no medical reason. I do not think that parents should be able to perform permanent, non-therapeutic procedures on their children without their consent because there is no indication for doing so. I suppose this would include procedures like ear-piercing and tattoos. I, personally, am glad that my parents did not pierce my ears or tattoo my body without my consent. I do not consider parents' responsibility over their children to extend to the ability to consent for permanent, unnecessary procedures.
It could be possible to bring up cultural/societal reasons for circumcision. Unfortunately, I find many of these arguments lacking, and having to do more with conforming to society's expectations, than focusing on the child's right to consent. Also, society can be capricious and whimsical, meaning that its expectations can change at any time, and to me, an illogical barometer to follow.
Some might bring up "what age can a child consent?" I fully admit that I don't know, but different ages can be debated. Certainly, he cannot consent before he can vocalize. I, personally, think an adult is more able to understand the full implications of circumcision, which is why I think it's most logical that we should wait until the child is an adult. This can, of course, be debated.
How are parents going to learn, since many parents are very unknowledgeable, and this topic seems very uncomfortable and taboo to most people? I think through their physicians. Their physicians must be able to take a stand and tell their patients the truth about circumcision, both pros and cons.I think that the rates are more likely to change if parents put more thought into it, and if the uncircumcised state is seen as conforming.