Ivor the Engineer
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Feb 18, 2006
- Messages
- 11,103
I'm agreeing with Linda on this part. I don't think it's a position that's unreasonable to hold. Both the absolute and the relative can be taken into account in the overall opinion. And you're not letting her hold the actual position she has taken, either. It was very clear and I agree with it.
How can you hold both absolute and relative opinions at the same time?
How is Linda’s position, of believing non-therapeutic male child circumcision is wrong for her sons and boys in her care (good
What’s ironic is that she attempts to convince the likes of Rodney that his beliefs are irrational, who (to my knowledge) harms nobody, but then has a go at me for attempting to do the same to LossLeader, who in a few weeks will be having a large chunk of flesh cut off his newborn child’s penis because of his irrational beliefs!
You are right that FGM is seen as a rite of passage, feminization the same way ritual circumcision is masculinization. The part you keep ignoring is that in those societies the men get all the power, and the women get all the chores. The ONLY reason women in the West have been able to get a fairer deal is because the men, because of their culture, have been more receptive to the idea of women wanting more freedoms, and the women, because of their culture, have been more willing to embrace those freedoms, and because the culture itself has been flexible enough to allow people with modern and traditional ideas about what's right to live side by side.
Do the men get all the power? Are you sure about that? Even if they do, why is that not just different as opposed to wrong? What yardstick are you using to determine that a society organised that way is wrong? Are you saying they are inferior in some respect to your own culture?
If FGM was that harmful, wouldn’t cultures that practice it quickly die out?
Thing weren't going so very differently in Iran before the religious extremists took over. Everyone with more liberal feelings got out, if they could. There's no fighting the sort of attitude they have there. In the US if a factory full of people burned to death because of chained up doors there'd be an unrestrained outcry. In Iran if students burned to death because the girls couldn't go outside without their burkas there'd be people arguing that that was totally the right thing to do.
If you believe in cultural relativism then it is possible it would be the right thing to do. If you believe all humans should have fundamental rights, including the right to life, then no, it would not be the right thing to do.
Which are you? A cultural relativist or believer in fundamental human rights, including the right to bodily integrity?
There is no rational middle ground to take.
Why do women support their own subjugation in these cultures? Same sort of reason fundamentalists support their own sexual repression. They need to believe it. Only these women have no choice, they can't get out. If they couldn't accept and feel they had a proper place in their cultural situation they'd go nuts. Only the people who have the resources to live without their society's approval can do anything about it at all.
The evidence and tesimony I have read and heard does not support the idea that happily circumcised men consider their johnsons to ba A-OK because they need to believe it.
So you don’t think the resistance to stopping infant male circumcision displayed in this thread has anything to with American parents’ and circumcised men’s “need to believe” that what they have left down there is the same or better somehow?
The message: “I’ve lost a huge chunk of erogenous tissue from my primary sex organ and I don’t think my sexual pleasure has been negatively affected”, from most of the circumcised men posting in this thread sounds exactly like that of a deluded individual who “needs to believe” to me.
Look how long it took to convince American physicians that circumcisions on infants are extremely painful. They managed to ignore all the obvious signs that the child was in distress or shock, claiming that babies could not feel pain or the baby was sleeping!
I am much less interested in fighting FGM not because I consider it OK but because it is part of a culture that is NOT interested in change. I am much more interested in campaigning against routine male circumcision not because I consider it a hideous atrocity but because it's practically an afterthought, a candles-on-birthday-cake type tradition that could easily be changed with a little convincing.
After 46 pages of this thread and a total lack of will from the physicians posting in it to do anything to discourage parents, I think you’re fooling yourself.
