Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

Clearly, we can add the anti-circumcision crowd to the list that includes creationists, 9-11 and JFK conspiracy theorists, anti-global warming kooks, the probed-by-E.T. folks, and all the other fringe believers in various and sundry nonsense. The illogic, dishonesty, resistance to evidence, additional dishonesty, and blatant obsession all point to the same "scratch" on their mental DVD.
Just because it's the sort of issue that inspires some of the people arguing about it to get emotional doesn't mean it's a nonissue if you're not plumb crazy.

I know it's just another anecdote, but as a small woman (5'2 and petite), I personally have trouble with painful intercourse and minor UTIs when I have sex with circumcized men, no matter how gentle they are or how much lubrication is used. I don't have any problems when I have sex with uncircumcized men, because there's much less friction against the areas that get irritated. I know I'm part of a small minority (heh) but weighed against the benefits of circumcision, this is a pretty huge negative mark. It's frustrating enough that I never want to have kids, because I don't want to pass down this stupid little pelvis, that makes it impossible to simply enjoy vanilla sex with my sweetheart. There's been entire years where we just did without because it wasn't worth it. Thank goodness I'm good with my mouth. :p
 
Last edited:
Just because it's the sort of issue that inspires some of the people arguing about it to get emotional doesn't mean it's a nonissue if you're not plumb crazy.

I know it's just another anecdote, but as a small woman (5'2 and petite), I personally have trouble with painful intercourse and minor UTIs when I have sex with circumcized men, no matter how gentle they are or how much lubrication is used. I don't have any problems when I have sex with uncircumcized men, because there's much less friction against the areas that get irritated. I know I'm part of a small minority (heh) but weighed against the benefits of circumcision, this is a pretty huge negative mark. It's frustrating enough that I never want to have kids, because I don't want to pass down this stupid little pelvis, that makes it impossible to simply enjoy vanilla sex with my sweetheart. There's been entire years where we just did without because it wasn't worth it. Thank goodness I'm good with my mouth. :p
WAY, WAY too much information!

ETA: That problem is with your anatomy, not the guy's anatomy. And, which one of you swings the flogger?
 
Let's take your post as an example, shall we? First off, the phrase "genital mutilation" eliminates any possibility of rational discussion with you. Once you've got your heart set on that, no evidence can sway you, no reasoning can temper your view. You have predetermined that anyone who disagrees with you is promoting child abuse. So, what else is there to discuss logically, when you've defined the debate in such a way that no one can disagree with you without you seeing them as a monster?

Secondly, equating circumcision, which is a generally accepted medical procedure, with "anything to your daughter", also seems rather illogical, and also designed to frame the debate in such a way that no argument will ever be acceptable to you. Also, comparing a medical procedure to someone cutting a girl's clitoris out with a piece of glass is 100%, blatantly, ruthlessly dishonest. I assume you don't mean "clitoral hood removal", which actually can IMPROVE sexual response in women?

Third, you assume a cultural bias in everyone, even if they have none. I, for instance, have nothing much that could be described as a specific "culture" that would give me a position for or against circumcision. I have no tradition to look to, in order to judge the situation.

Fourth, you seem willing to give lip service to the idea of "benefits and detriments", but it seems rather dishonest when, in the same sentence, you use the phrase "genital mutilation."

And, the phrase "right for the wrong reasons" means that the position is based on emotionalism and illogical processes, and is only correct accidentally. For instance, you could correctly "predict" the next presidential election based on astrology or numerology or a coin toss, and have the "why" of it completely wrong.

Substitute the word mutilation for genital cutting, so that were more politically correct.

There are benefits to genital cutting, both for males and females.

Also, for female genital cutting lets assume its done in a hospital with a trained and professional doctor, instead of your emotionally charged assumption of broken glass. Lets consider the male circumcisions conducted with a piece of broken glass too, working under your model.

Was there not a study describing the foreskin as the most sensitive portion of the penis? The vagina is still perfectly able to function missing a clitoris, labia, or number of other things. Function including orgasm.

And no, Ive not predetermined that anyone who disagrees is immediately wrong. I, along with pretty much everyone in the thread, has said that medically indicated circumcision is fine. So, provided that you gave a scenario involving the occurrence of something that would medically indicate circumcision I would most likely agree with you, save that the argument doesnt involve the medical necessity of fitting in in the locker room.

Clitoral hood removal, do you then consider it ethical because it improves sexual relations, working under the assumption that it does?

Ive not predetermined that anyone who disagrees with me is wrong, Im still waiting on an argument thats based on something meaningful, and no, I dont consider social conformity or the marginal benefits granted to be meaningful. Give me something outside of that that validates the practice, and Ill be nice and quiet, I do think youle have a hard time producing something decent however.

To cover the HIV issue before you say something about it, as has been said previously by others in this thread, it would be ethically irresponsible to consider genital cutting on females to reduce HIV. Also, my view on the matter, if you do something enough, regardless of risk, eventually youre going to encounter the statistically reduced element. Like increasing the number of barrels in a revolver from 6 to 12, still one bullet, but perhaps you have to try a few more times to find it.

Ill wait to see if the suggestion of circumcision in Africa is taken seriously/implemented and if it has the effect that its supposed to. Till then, I await, happily receptive of any argument based on reality, that justifies the practice of genital cutting on infants.
 
WAY, WAY too much information!

ETA: That problem is with your anatomy, not the guy's anatomy. And, which one of you swings the flogger?

God forbid someone disagree with you and presents a little anecdote just like you did.
 
*yawn*

More of the same rehash that you've been posting since the beginning. Heck, if these great minds can't sway you, I doubt I can. All I can do is note the phenomenon, and move on. Because, really, the ridiculousness of your posts points to an unflappable position.

Before I go, let's look at something fairly silly in that last post of yours:

Was there not a study describing the foreskin as the most sensitive portion of the penis? The vagina is still perfectly able to function missing a clitoris, labia, or number of other things. Function including orgasm.
Clearly, the implication you are making is that the penis is somehow not able to function perfectly without a foreskin, "function including orgasm". Several thousand years of Jewish men impregnating their wives pretty much negates that idea, as well as the idea that uncircumcised men are somehow automatically "mutilated".

Here's a crazy idea for you, just as a "what the hell". Check on adult circumcision, and see how many of those men feel "mutilated" afterwards, or have lost some pleasure or sensation. Really, it is the best way for you to prove your case.
 
Just because it's the sort of issue that inspires some of the people arguing about it to get emotional doesn't mean it's a nonissue if you're not plumb crazy.

I know it's just another anecdote, but as a small woman (5'2 and petite), I personally have trouble with painful intercourse and minor UTIs when I have sex with circumcized men, no matter how gentle they are or how much lubrication is used. I don't have any problems when I have sex with uncircumcized men, because there's much less friction against the areas that get irritated. I know I'm part of a small minority (heh) but weighed against the benefits of circumcision, this is a pretty huge negative mark. It's frustrating enough that I never want to have kids, because I don't want to pass down this stupid little pelvis, that makes it impossible to simply enjoy vanilla sex with my sweetheart. There's been entire years where we just did without because it wasn't worth it. Thank goodness I'm good with my mouth. :p

Based on my reading, as well as personal experience, via talking to women whove had both, Ive heard the same thing a number of times.

Dont mind the prudish attitude, your description was pretty clean in fact.
 
WAY, WAY too much information!

ETA: That problem is with your anatomy, not the guy's anatomy. And, which one of you swings the flogger?

Oh, I agree the problem is with my anatomy, but it would not be a problem if he was uncircumcised. That's the whole point. Thanks for your sympathy, by the way.
 
Oh, I agree the problem is with my anatomy, but it would not be a problem if he was uncircumcised. That's the whole point. Thanks for your sympathy, by the way.
Sorry, I don't do online sympathy very well. I do :grouphug5 and :cheerleader5 pretty well, though.

The point I was making is that your anatomy wouldn't make a penis enlargement into a form of "mutilation" either... cripes, I hate to discuss your genitals this way. I'm not your doctor! :p
 
*yawn*

More of the same rehash that you've been posting since the beginning. Heck, if these great minds can't sway you, I doubt I can. All I can do is note the phenomenon, and move on. Because, really, the ridiculousness of your posts points to an unflappable position.

Before I go, let's look at something fairly silly in that last post of yours:

Clearly, the implication you are making is that the penis is somehow not able to function perfectly without a foreskin, "function including orgasm". Several thousand years of Jewish men impregnating their wives pretty much negates that idea, as well as the idea that uncircumcised men are somehow automatically "mutilated".

Here's a crazy idea for you, just as a "what the hell". Check on adult circumcision, and see how many of those men feel "mutilated" afterwards, or have lost some pleasure or sensation. Really, it is the best way for you to prove your case.

Check out your idea and tell me why a man circumcised at birth cant comment on loss of sensation.

The penis can function, the penis can function with the glans cut off, the penis can function in all arrays of impaired state. Your comment is unconvincing. There have been several studies of men circumcised as adults, the majority report reduced pleasure but increased satisfaction as I understand it.

As for feeling mutilated, find me a study of the number of people who even know what circumcision actually is, cause Ive encountered a fair number that dont really have a clue. Never have I or anyone else said that circumcised penises couldnt impregnate someone. Thats not the argument though now is it. Function is reduced.

Tell me how my posts are ridiculous. Ive remained pretty cool in the majority of them, aside from having a tendency to use what is I guess colorful language, while you prefer more politically correct content.

Please dodge the female question some more. It makes you appear educated. Is it ethical to genitally cut females? Would hood removal be ethical because it supposedly increases pleasure?

Likewise, I can say youre unflappable and pointless to talk with as well, like I just did.

Eta: I dont expect a response.
 
Last edited:
The point I was making is that your anatomy wouldn't make a penis enlargement into a form of "mutilation" either... cripes, I hate to discuss your genitals this way. I'm not your doctor! :p

XD no problem...

I didn't call circumcision mutilation - my point was that it can create a serious problem in relationships with girls on the small end of the bell curve. So when I evaluate the issue for countries with good medical practices and modern living conditions:

Pro:
smaller risk of (easily treatable) infant UTIs
cleaner (only an issue for guys who don't want to bathe enough)
longer-lasting in bed (due to reduced sensitivity)
possible cultural benefits

Con:
slight risk of complications (some terrible)
loss of sensitivity (even if you don't miss it)
less things for your partner to play with
very slight risk of painful intercourse for your girl

I'm going to have to go in favor of keeping the foreskin, on this one.

BTW I'm pretty sure there's still not actually any such thing as a real penis enlargement. Best they can do is put some temporary collagen in it.. 'beesting penis?'
 
Last edited:
XD no problem...

I didn't call circumcision mutilation - my point was that it can create a serious problem in relationships with girls on the small end of the bell curve. So when I evaluate the issue for countries with good medical practices and modern living conditions:

Pro:
smaller risk of (easily treatable) infant UTIs
cleaner (only an issue for guys who don't want to bathe enough)
longer-lasting in bed (due to reduced senitivity)
possible cultural benefits

Con:
slight risk of complications (some terrible)
loss of sensitivity (even if you don't miss it)
less things for your partner to play with
very slight risk of painful intercourse for your girl

I'm going to have to go in favor of keeping the foreskin, on this one.
See, your position seems rather well-reasoned and not at all extremist. It stands in rather sharp contrast to the "you stole a vital part of my manhood!!!!!" position of many on the anti-circumcision side.
 
See, your position seems rather well-reasoned and not at all extremist. It stands in rather sharp contrast to the "you stole a vital part of my manhood!!!!!" position of many on the anti-circumcision side.

Note that shes a woman and doesnt have a "manhood."

You feel fine, so everyone should, your reasoning seems pretty clear.
 
See, your position seems rather well-reasoned and not at all extremist. It stands in rather sharp contrast to the "you stole a vital part of my manhood!!!!!" position of many on the anti-circumcision side.

Thanks. But really, in this culture, I don't know how on earth you're expecting the average man to keep it completely cool, calm and rational regarding injustices, real or perceived, against their penis. Or expecting them not to project that into arguments on behalf of the innocent penises of others.

Though some women do get awfully worked up about it, I suspect that stems from good old fashioned penis envy and the 'fun' of activism. It's certainly true that happily functional circumcised men on average don't give much of a crap. Maybe a twinge of curiosity. But as has been said earlier, satisfaction with a functional body is just part of being mentally healthy, so I don't take that as an argument for circumcision being okay.
 
Thanks. But really, in this culture, I don't know how on earth you're expecting the average man to keep it completely cool, calm and rational regarding injustices, real or perceived, against their penises. Or expecting them not to project that into arguments on behalf of the innocent penises of others.

Though some women do get awfully worked up about it, I suspect that stems from good old fashioned penis envy and the 'fun' of activism. It's certainly true that happily functional circumcised men on average don't give much of a crap. Maybe a twinge of curiosity. But as has been said earlier, satisfaction with a functional body is just part of being mentally healthy, so I don't take that as an argument for circumcision being okay.
I think there's something wrong with the guys when they are that obsessed with the penis. I often wonder if they are having unrelated issues, and are blaming a lack of foreskin for inadequacies in other areas. I notice that, as you said, mentally healthy men don't seem to have any problem with it.

What I'm saying is that it seems like a scapegoat for other issues.
 
I think there's something wrong with the guys when they are that obsessed with the penis. I often wonder if they are having unrelated issues, and are blaming a lack of foreskin for inadequacies in other areas. I notice that, as you said, mentally healthy men don't seem to have any problem with it.

What I'm saying is that it seems like a scapegoat for other issues.

A lot of guys don't think about it that often, but get sort of pissed off when they do.
I doubt my (circumcised) husband thinks about it more than maybe once a month? I don't really know for sure. But when the subject comes up, he's quite passionate about it.
 
A lot of guys don't think about it that often, but get sort of pissed off when they do.
I doubt my (circumcised) husband thinks about it more than maybe once a month? I don't really know for sure. But when the subject comes up, he's quite passionate about it.

Is it mostly when it isn't football season? I find that I rant about one insignificant thing when my main ranting target is otherwise inaccessible. :cool:
 
As I said above in degree it is different however it is still genital mutilation for no rational reason. Part of the reason I believe it is still carried out is because the mutilation part of it is hidden behind a socially acceptable word - circumcision.

If parents were asked "Do you want us to assault your baby and mutilate his genitals?" I am sure many who would answer yes to "Do you want you baby circumcised?" would answer no.

Mutilation is a very loaded and extreme word. Are you saying that FGM and circumcision of male infants are somehow equatable?

I'm sorry, but it's one thing to say both are bad and unwanted, but equating the two is just ridiculous or to use wording implying so.


I assume you think it's wrong to hurt people, correct? And that both organized genocide and physical violence to vent anger are both wrong?

In that case, would you say something like "That hockey player who threw the other against the wall has committed an egregious and intolerable crime against humanity and stained the history of his nation with an atrocity which cannot be ever forgotten."

I would think not.



And you might want to consider all the parents who pierce infants ears (apparently itallian families do it all the time) or for that matter... how many kids do you know... under the age of 18 and unable to make their own decisions alone who are subjected to having their wisdom teeth torn out?

Damn.. i was only 16 and I probably couldn't have prevented it if I wanted to. The dentist said I should see an oral surgeon because I was ready to have em pulled and so my parents sent me. It was preventative, to prevent possible impaction. As it was, they weren't causing any problems. 100% natural too.

Now I have no wisdom teeth because my gums were mutulated like that.


Not to mention all the braces and skin tag removals and other things which are done entirely because of astetics and such. Hell, it's prefectly natural to have crocked teeth. Most teeth don't come in straight on their own, and most of the time it's not serious enough to cause major health problems.And yet parents impose mutulating braces.
 
Mutilation is a very loaded and extreme word. Are you saying that FGM and circumcision of male infants are somehow equatable?

I'm sorry, but it's one thing to say both are bad and unwanted, but equating the two is just ridiculous or to use wording implying so.


I assume you think it's wrong to hurt people, correct? And that both organized genocide and physical violence to vent anger are both wrong?

In that case, would you say something like "That hockey player who threw the other against the wall has committed an egregious and intolerable crime against humanity and stained the history of his nation with an atrocity which cannot be ever forgotten."

I would think not.



And you might want to consider all the parents who pierce infants ears (apparently itallian families do it all the time) or for that matter... how many kids do you know... under the age of 18 and unable to make their own decisions alone who are subjected to having their wisdom teeth torn out?

Damn.. i was only 16 and I probably couldn't have prevented it if I wanted to. The dentist said I should see an oral surgeon because I was ready to have em pulled and so my parents sent me. It was preventative, to prevent possible impaction. As it was, they weren't causing any problems. 100% natural too.

Now I have no wisdom teeth because my gums were mutulated like that.


Not to mention all the braces and skin tag removals and other things which are done entirely because of astetics and such. Hell, it's prefectly natural to have crocked teeth. Most teeth don't come in straight on their own, and most of the time it's not serious enough to cause major health problems.And yet parents impose mutulating braces.

YEAH!!! HELL YEAH!!!

I want my wisdom teeth back, dammit! I was mutilamated!!
 
I think there's something wrong with the guys when they are that obsessed with the penis. I often wonder if they are having unrelated issues, and are blaming a lack of foreskin for inadequacies in other areas. I notice that, as you said, mentally healthy men don't seem to have any problem with it.

What I'm saying is that it seems like a scapegoat for other issues.


When you say "obsessed with the penis" do you mean with the member in and of itsself?

Or would that include being obsessed with the action it gets (or lack thereof) and also where they would want to put it?

Because if it's the later, then I guess that might.... well nevermind..
 
When you say "obsessed with the penis" do you mean with the member in and of itsself?

Or would that include being obsessed with the action it gets (or lack thereof) and also where they would want to put it?

Because if it's the later, then I guess that might.... well nevermind..
I don't know what you're going on about, but I think it is somehow worse than what I'm going on about. :eye-poppi
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom