Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

Geez I thought this little act of barbarism was outlawed long ago. Imagine my surprise when I caught this story on our national broadcaster;

Recent medical trials suggest that circumcision can reduce HIV transmission rates by about sixty per cent.

Full Story


and then a few nights later this story on Sixty Minutes;
Circumcision's been around for centuries, but here in Australia it's no longer fashionable. Stand by for a new and heated round of debate, to cut or not to cut.

Full story

Both stories were rather uncritical and relied more on opinion than evidence and appeared biased toward getting the chop quoting I assume this study and anecdotes about urinary tact infections etc.

The sixty minutes after-show discussion with Prof Brian Morris is truly blood boiling if you're looking for a balanced insight into the pro's and cons of circumcision;

Jayson asks: What are some reasons not to have my son circumcised?
Prof Brian Morris: I can't think of any.
.
.
golden asks: Professor, I know infections can happen, but why would boys get infections constantly?
Prof Brian Morris: Because the bacteria cannot be washed away. Uncircumcised boys have hygiene problems, after washing the bacteria return within hours. With age they get a malodorous film that is full of dead skill cells and bacteria, urine and dirt that is called smegma.
.
.
Full transcript

Arrggghhhh!!! Smegma!!!

-EHLO (intact, and still clean after 34 years)
 
There are anatomical and conventional details. If a parent wanted a hoodectomy for their infant daughter, I might think "okay... that's kinda weird... um... why... would you want that? are you sure that's a good idea?" But I wouldn't think "My god they butchered her genitals beyond all recognition and function! What a barbaric and savage act of bloodcurdling cruelty"

See, the difference between you and me is that I believe there should be significant physical advantages for a non-consenting individual to be put through a procedure that causes, both during and after, significant physical pain and alters the sensation and functionality of a body part.

You realize I went into the very extreme defining of mutilation, right? If your definition is so broad that it includes any body modification that is not directly and entirely medically therapeutic.

Yes, now you’re getting the idea. Unless a physical alteration is performed for therapeutic reasons or to correct a deformity, it is mutilation.

Let me give you an example: I had my wisdom teeth removed. I was only 16 years old. Occasionally kids get them early and they are even younger. I wasn't old enough to entirely make my own decisions.

Did it hurt? Yea. My mouth was swollen for a while after. Could it have had complications? Yeah. They gave me antibiotics to prevent infection, but of course that's not 100% effective... Now my wisdom teeth are gone and will never grow back. I have a patch of empty gum behind my molars.

So what was the problem they were causing? Nothing. Nothing at all.

My molars were in good alignment and the dental professionals warned that wisdom teeth, when they become impacted can push other teeth out of alignment. They could mess up my bite. Or even if they came in mostly well, as I grew, they could shift and there would not be enough room and thus impact into the molars.

Were they doing this? No. It was preventative. Would they cause problems? They might. Having really bad problems with wisdom teeth is not uncommon... it's not really likely but major problems happen on occasion. And minor problems, like missalignment are quite common. Not that they can't be delt with or you can't live with them. But they are common enough that it was thought warneted to yank them out just to assure that this would not be a concern.


Does this effect my body? Yes. Perminantly.

Does this effect how I eat/chew? Yeah, a bit. I have one less set of potential back teeth to grind with. Would I have used them much? Well.. probably not that much. But did it change the way I potentially chew? Yea.

Did it make me chew better? Did it make me chew worse? Dunno. Never will.


Explain how this is not mutilation.

I don’t know how competent your dentist is or was, but I’ve never known anybody in my lifetime that has had their wisdom teeth removed if they were not causing a problem, only if they were or were likely to cause a problem. Was your dentist fairly old?

Was it mutilation? If they were unlikely to cause a problem, then yes. However, I doubt having your wisdom teeth removed has negatively effected your enjoyment of chewing, how you chew, or another person’s pleasure when you are chewing.

I think you may have not come to realize that mutilation has an implicit magnitude aspect to it. It is obviously subjective to some end. But I would not call breaking the tip of my pencil a "catastrophe" even if it meets the definition as being something unplanned and negative and damaging, because "Catastrophe" carries an implicit convention of being extreme.

The word ‘mutilate’ and its definition that I gave describe non-therapeutic circumcision of either sex accurately.

How extreme does a circumcision have to be to pass your personal threshold of mutilation?

A typical male circumcision removes 50% or more of the skin of the penis and 20,000 highly sensitive nerve endings. A study done this year has demonstrated the foreskin is the most sensitive part of a man’s penis. Additionally, the foreskin has mechanical functions during intercourse and masturbation. Circumcised men have to adapt their technique to masturbate and most find it more difficult and less enjoyable than before they were circumcised.
 
I can't really figure out how you'd even do it, or what the possible point could be. Male infant circumcision at least provides things you can call benefits, and I'd assume that is another part of why the laws are different. For example, hunting around sex-ed sites for stats, I did run into a lot of Q&A boards with numerous guys who were running into phimosis problems. Of course these should be solved with information and treatment, not routine circumcision, but again you can see the issues bewteen genders are simply different.

About 0.6% of male boys need to be circumcised for therapeutic reasons. My cousin’s son is currently being assessed to see if he needs to be circumcised. The doctor has responsibly and professionally decided to treat his particular problem conservatively to start off with, only considering circumcision as a last resort.

The other legal reasoning probably is the one stated here before, that female circ is generally done specifically to reinforce the lower status of women, while male circ is generally done for a bunch of stupid reasons, and the only one that involves male repression is the idea that it makes it less fun to masturbate.

Many keep on saying this but I’ve yet to see any evidence that this is the case. In fact, many see it as a rite of passage; a girl becoming a woman, similar to the way male circumcision is seen to transform a boy into a man. It is often mothers who have the procedure performed on their daughters and it is the mother who holds them down while they are having it done.

And even if it is done to “reinforce the lower status of women”, who are you to say that is wrong in culture other than your own? Are any of the women complaining about their status? If they are, let them change it.

See, this is where the cultural relativist argument falls flat on its face – whatever a culture does is right for the people who belong to that culture, since a cultural relativist does not believe there is an external reference to judge one culture’s behaviour against another. It’s a very modern and trendy way to think about the world, but totally unrealistic for cultures that interact with one another on a regular basis.

I would have no problem with routine male circumcision becoming illegal in the US in the same way infant female circumcision is illegal in the US. Whatever US Muslims have to do to get their girls a hoodectomy for tradition, US Jews and other traditionally circ'd groups can do to get their boys circumcised for tradition. Or both can simply wait till they're old enough to get one legally.

But you would run into trouble deciding who to sue when there were diesgreements over what was medically necessary or not. In the short term it makes much more sense to simply campaign against it sensibly with education.

Which is why I keep on saying that physicians should be telling parents that infant circumcision is painful, cruel and a waste of time and money. It is hardly a monster that has gotten away from them; they perform the vast majority of the circumcisions in the US! But they don’t do that, because they can’t even admit it to themselves, hence all the nonsense about medical benefits that pretty much the whole of Europe manages to get by without.

I’m still waiting for someone to explain why, if removing the prepuce of an infant female is illegal in the US, doing the same to an infant male is not?
 
...
And even if it is done to “reinforce the lower status of women”, who are you to say that is wrong in culture other than your own? Are any of the women complaining about their status? If they are, let them change it.
...

The problem is that because of their lower status they can't change it.
 
Really? How did women change their status in our culture then?

Considering that women are still paid less than men for equal work in our cultures?

But striving for equality requires people on both sides to do the work. For instance the women's suffrage movement in the U.S. required women and men to give women the right to vote. Women were at the core of the movement but it's success required male state and federal congressmen who were sympathetic to their cause to put forth and vote for amendments that gave them the right to vote (and hold offices themselves).
 
Considering that women are still paid less than men for equal work in our cultures?

But striving for equality requires people on both sides to do the work. For instance the women's suffrage movement in the U.S. required women and men to give women the right to vote. Women were at the core of the movement but it's success required male state and federal congressmen who were sympathetic to their cause to put forth and vote for amendments that gave them the right to vote (and hold offices themselves).

So why could this not happen in cultures that practice FGM?

What right do you have to impose your morality on them, especially when you condone the abuse of infant males in a similar way to that which they do to girls?

You can't logically believe in universal human rights and cultural relativism.
 
So why could this not happen in cultures that practice FGM?

It does change sometimes. Which is why clitorectomies will not be performed by many hospitals, even in those countries where the practice remains prevalant.

What right do you have to impose your morality on them, especially when you condone the abuse of infant males in a similar way to that which they do to girls?

You can't logically believe in universal human rights and cultural relativism.

You can believe in universal human rights and cultural relativism if you place no real value on a foreskin beyond what that culture places on it.

Removing a foreskin is not abuse. Thus I am not condoning abuse of infant males. Removing the clitoral hood is not abuse. Cultures which do so are not abusing females.

Removing the glans or penis or testacles would be abuse. Just as removing the clitoris would be abuse. I condemn both these actions. Cultures which do either are abusing children.

What you're doing is saying an inch=mile. Relativism allows us to have multiple units of measurement.

Did you agree with France's poorly thought out law banning headscarves in school?
 
You can believe in universal human rights and cultural relativism if you place no real value on a foreskin beyond what that culture places on it.

Removing a foreskin is not abuse. Thus I am not condoning abuse of infant males. Removing the clitoral hood is not abuse. Cultures which do so are not abusing females.

So you're a cultural relativist...

Removing the glans or penis or testacles would be abuse. Just as removing the clitoris would be abuse. I condemn both these actions. Cultures which do either are abusing children.

...but now you're applying the standards of your culture to others. That is not logically consistent.

You are clearly very confused.

What you're doing is saying an inch=mile. Relativism allows us to have multiple units of measurement.

No, what I'm saying is that if you want to use cultural relativism as a defence then you cannot say any other cultures' practices are wrong.

Did you agree with France's poorly thought out law banning headscarves in school?

Adults should be free to wear (or not wear) whatever they want, unless an item of clothing (or lack thereof) is likely to put them or others at significant risk of harm. I.e. eye protection is required while arc-welding.

If a school has a uniform policy, then the children should be wearing it and the teachers enforcing it.
 
Thanks for missing the point.

Linda has to miss the point or she'll be in danger of having to agree with me because my position, or the opposite (which she has already said she does not agree with), are the only two logically consistent ones to take.

Either she thinks it is ok to mutilate an individual male's or female's genitals to a degree depending on the culture they belong to (cultural relativist), or it is not (universal human rights).

So, which is it Linda?
 
Last edited:
Linda has to miss the point or she'll be in danger of having to agree with me because my position, or the opposite (which she has already said she does not agree with), are the only two logically consistent ones to take.

Either she thinks it is ok to mutilate an individual male's or female's genitals to a degree depending on the culture they belong to (cultural relativist), or it is not (universal human rights).

So, which is it Linda?

I'm agreeing with Linda on this part. I don't think it's a position that's unreasonable to hold. Both the absolute and the relative can be taken into account in the overall opinion. And you're not letting her hold the actual position she has taken, either. It was very clear and I agree with it.

You are right that FGM is seen as a rite of passage, feminization the same way ritual circumcision is masculinization. The part you keep ignoring is that in those societies the men get all the power, and the women get all the chores. The ONLY reason women in the West have been able to get a fairer deal is because the men, because of their culture, have been more receptive to the idea of women wanting more freedoms, and the women, because of their culture, have been more willing to embrace those freedoms, and because the culture itself has been flexible enough to allow people with modern and traditional ideas about what's right to live side by side.

Thing weren't going so very differently in Iran before the religious extremists took over. Everyone with more liberal feelings got out, if they could. There's no fighting the sort of attitude they have there. In the US if a factory full of people burned to death because of chained up doors there'd be an unrestrained outcry. In Iran if students burned to death because the girls couldn't go outside without their burkas there'd be people arguing that that was totally the right thing to do.

Why do women support their own subjugation in these cultures? Same sort of reason fundamentalists support their own sexual repression. They need to believe it. Only these women have no choice, they can't get out. If they couldn't accept and feel they had a proper place in their cultural situation they'd go nuts. Only the people who have the resources to live without their society's approval can do anything about it at all.

The evidence and tesimony I have read and heard does not support the idea that happily circumcised men consider their johnsons to ba A-OK because they need to believe it.

I am much less interested in fighting FGM not because I consider it OK but because it is part of a culture that is NOT interested in change. I am much more interested in campaigning against routine male circumcision not because I consider it a hideous atrocity but because it's practically an afterthought, a candles-on-birthday-cake type tradition that could easily be changed with a little convincing.
 
Last edited:
I don't have the time to read this whole thread . I am a witness to about a hundred infant circumcisions. It was about 35 years ago when I was a corpsman in the army working in the hospital at Ft Stewart Georgia.
To prep the 2 day old infant I would strap him to the "circ" board. The circ board was a molded plastic cradle that had velcro straps to restrain the arms and legs of the infant. One size fits all. The doctor would probe under the foreskin with hemostats to loosen the skin and then clamp the forceps. There was always a scream from the infant from the pain after the clamp was applied. The doctor then applied a small bell shaped cap under the foreskin and tied a string around the bell in the provided groove. By now the baby is screaming bloody murder. No anesthesia was ever used. The doctor then cut with scissors around the bell just above the string and removed the foreskin. One of the nurses aids saved all the foreskins and claimed they made the best fish bait.
I miss my prepuce. I am so glad there is infantile amnesia because I would not want to remember my own circumcision. It must have hurt like hell. I know now that that ring around my penis is scar tissue.
I don't know what it would be like to have a prepuce. Most women I have talked to prefer a circumcised male. That fact may be a large part of the social pressure to be circumcised.
I can say that I don't care much for the taste and smell of smegma under labia. That might be a reason for the female objections of uncircumcised males.
A a curious aside, I always shared a bath with my younger brother when I was a boy. His penis was split from the urethra halfway through the glans. I now know how that happened. When the doctor applied the hemostats he accidentally inserted it into the urethra before he clamped down thus splitting the glans. Now that had to really hurt.
 
When the doctor applied the hemostats he accidentally inserted it into the urethra before he clamped down thus splitting the glans. Now that had to really hurt.

Thats the funny thing about being deformed from a procedure that never had a reason to have been done in the first place. Bet hes had a fun life.

Depressing story, not that I havnt seen things like this or worse.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom