Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

An anecdote is inaccurate by its very nature Im afraid.
Sorry, it's accuracy is not in question. Its applicability to the general may be.

It has far more going for it than your rwords, in that is has something of substance: evidence. Granted, it is a single datum, but it is a datum, not a load of emotive bollocks, hot air, and assumption.
The elements of your post (the entire thing) will go right next to all the other nonsense produced I have to deal with.
You don't have to deal with it.
By the way, inability for you to form a rational argument in support of circumcision is no evidence of emotional involvement on my part. Every one of the pro camp cries emotional involvement in lieu of any really substantive argument.
I am not offering an argument, nor have I time to waste on one. Forty three pages of this thread suffice for that. :) I don't need your opinion to make a decision. My intent was to agree with LL about elective medical procedures, since he is correct on that, to poke you since you are being a prick, and to offer a datum, rather than what you offer, which is bile and hot air. If you have a son, and choose to leave him with a turtle neck, good on ya. It's your choice.

Cheers

DR
 
Sorry, it's accuracy is not inquestion. Its applicability to the general may be.

It has far more going for it than your rubbish. It has something good going for it: evidence. Granted, it is a single datum, but it is a datum, not a load of emotive bollocks, hot air, and assumption.

You don't have to deal with it.

I am not offering an argument, nor have I time to waste on one. I don't need your opinion to make a decision. My intent was to agree with LL about elective medical procedures, since he is correct on that, to poke you since you are being a prick, and to offer a datum, rather than what you offer, which is bile and hot air. If you have a son, and choose to leave him with a turtle neck, good on ya. It's your choice.

Cheers

DR

Yes, your story clearly wasnt meant to apply in blanket fashion to all circumcised men. You just came it to say that you were very happy with it, and heavily imply that everyone else is, via your sexcapade nonsense.

The point is that its not my choice. It is my choice to have him vaccinated, or to feed him bananas, not to cut off part of his penis to make it conform to my ideals of beauty, since the medical argument has been flattened.

You fly into the topic, dont really contribute anything other than your fun little anecdote, are clearly emotionally embroiled yourself, since youre lacking your "turtle neck" as you like to call it, and call all my reasonings emotive bollocks.

About me being a prick, Im not here to impress you Mr.Rotor. Find me offensive, find me wonderful, its no skin off my nose (other areas maybe), the issue still exists.

Youre not making an argument, youre just here to press buttons and be a nuisance, as you said yourself. And no, I dont have to deal with it, I can just go become uncircumcised anytime I want.... ohh wait. Good point, thanks.
 
You know Linda, I like you, but you never really seem to say much.

I find it difficult to translate the way that I think (spatial rather than verbal) into language. I continue to make the attempt, however. Believe me, it frustrates me more than you. ;)

The origins of our ideas.... Ok, lets discuss the origin of our ideas. Can I stab you? Yes no? Why not? Where did that idea come from?

It depends. You may stab me in preparation for the removal of my inflamed appendix, but not just to hurt me. You seem to be indicating it is up to me to decide? I think that idea originated most strongly with The Enlightenment (but I am by no means an expert).

How does cutting off part of a baby's genitals not violate their rights?

When it is done with their consent.

Does cutting off a finger? 2 fingers? 17 fingers? How much or what do you have to cut off for it to violate someones rights? And where does this idea originate?

Rather than a specific number, I think it depends upon the source of the decision. Again this seems to be part of the ideas promoted through liberalism during The Enlightenment and beyond.

I said, that if you believe that everything is subjective, then sure, youre right. However, that being said, if I say that you are wrong, I am right, because its all subjective. You have a self refuting argument, if everyone is right, noone is right.

Yes, it precludes the assumption of an absolute.

I consider other people's perspectives. And I honestly have no idea what youre talking about with your self determination line. Self determination to what end? Ive self determined that I have no idea what youre going on about.
It seems like you just said the exact same thing I said, but put me down for saying it.

Self-determination in the sense of "determination of one's own fate or course of action without compulsion".

I did say the same thing as you. I simply confined the application to myself.

Linda
 
What is the function of the penis? How is this function different in the circumcised man?

What is the function of the vagina? How is this function different in a circumcised woman?

Those examples are different from what I am talking about, though. The only thing (at present) I consider an absolute is symmetry, and they could all fail on that basis (examples - role reversal, the veil of ignorance).

Great minds must (sometimes) think alike then. That’s the conclusion I’ve come to, too. All you can achieve as far as ethics is concerned is to be consistent.

ETA: So instead of condemning FGM, you should be trying to promote safer and less invasive practice of it, otherwise you're just imposing your will on the cultures that think it's important.
 
Last edited:
It depends. You may stab me in preparation for the removal of my inflamed appendix, but not just to hurt me. You seem to be indicating it is up to me to decide? I think that idea originated most strongly with The Enlightenment (but I am by no means an expert).

When it is done with their consent.

Yes, it precludes the assumption of an absolute.

Self-determination in the sense of "determination of one's own fate or course of action without compulsion".

I did say the same thing as you. I simply confined the application to myself.

Linda

Lets say Im stabbing you because I think the scar will look cute.

I think people had feelings about being stabbed pre-enlightenment.

Babies cant consent.

Please explain, precludes the assumption of the absolute?

Self determination is violated in infant genital mutilation. I dont understand how you can confine it to yourself. Only you have the right to determine what happens to you? Again, this sounds like the "good so long as its not to me" ideology.

I apologize for my responses to you, Im not quite understanding what youre saying completely.
 
Would you also support adults being free to having limbs chopped off ? This situation (a man requesting that his arm be removed, even though there was nothing wrong with the arm) happened fairly recently in this country (UK), and, as far as I remember, the request was refused.

In any case, do you think that such an adult who requests that he be circumcised could be deemed a rational thinker ?

If someone wanted to cut off one of their limbs or even add one, it really has nothing to do with me, a very moot point IMO. As long as it doesn't effect others I think people should have the freedom to do whatever they want, and may I repeat *As long as it doesn't effect others*
 
I have a great idea! Why don't we just making a study of if this really is a useful procedure or not, also keeping in mind current standards of medical knowledge and sanitation. If it really is dangerous for us to keep our foreskin then fine, let's just get to the proof of or proof against. If it turns out to be a merely cosmetic thing and has no medical basis, then a child should not be subjected to it (it's almost equivalent to giving your baby a "Prince Charels")
 
Lets say Im stabbing you because I think the scar will look cute.

The example seems unchanged - it still doesn't depend upon what you think.

I think people had feelings about being stabbed pre-enlightenment.

I think so too, however that isn't what I said. I was referring to the idea of who has authority over decisions. And I did not mean to imply that no one had these ideas before.

Babies cant consent.

What is your solution?

Please explain, precludes the assumption of the absolute?

If you recognize the subjective nature of judgments, it means that there isn't an absolute standard against which right and wrong can be measured.

Self determination is violated in infant genital mutilation.

Who should have primary responsibility for an infant's interests?

I dont understand how you can confine it to yourself.

I don't want someone else to overrule what I think is best for me or my child without good reason*.

Only you have the right to determine what happens to you? Again, this sounds like the "good so long as its not to me" ideology.

I think that should apply to everyone and that you are not responsible for my son's interests.

Linda

*Can be re-iterated if necessary.
 
I have a great idea! Why don't we just making a study of if this really is a useful procedure or not, also keeping in mind current standards of medical knowledge and sanitation. If it really is dangerous for us to keep our foreskin then fine, let's just get to the proof of or proof against. If it turns out to be a merely cosmetic thing and has no medical basis, then a child should not be subjected to it (it's almost equivalent to giving your baby a "Prince Charels")

I don't think that there is much medical controversy over this, though. So I'm not sure a study of the necessary size and length would be useful.

What's a "Prince Charels (Charles?)"?

Linda
 
I have a great idea! Why don't we just making a study of if this really is a useful procedure or not, also keeping in mind current standards of medical knowledge and sanitation. If it really is dangerous for us to keep our foreskin then fine, let's just get to the proof of or proof against. If it turns out to be a merely cosmetic thing and has no medical basis, then a child should not be subjected to it (it's almost equivalent to giving your baby a "Prince Charels")

I believe you meant to say Prince Albert.

Such studies have been done. Read the whole thread.

Medical reasons are only a small part of the picture though. Culture is more of a factor. Again, read the whole thread. Try to keep the thread from just running in circles if you can.
 
1.The example seems unchanged - it still doesn't depend upon what you think.

2.I think so too, however that isn't what I said. I was referring to the idea of who has authority over decisions. And I did not mean to imply that no one had these ideas before.

3.What is your solution?

4.If you recognize the subjective nature of judgments, it means that there isn't an absolute standard against which right and wrong can be measured.

5.Who should have primary responsibility for an infant's interests?

6.I don't want someone else to overrule what I think is best for me or my child without good reason*.

7.I think that should apply to everyone and that you are not responsible for my son's interests.

Linda

*Can be re-iterated if necessary.

1. Ok, so I can stab you, and you wouldnt care. Good.

2. Authority over decisions = origin of ideals?

3. Not cutting parts off your baby's genitals? Edit: let me put this in here, because I know common sense has went out the window. WITHOUT MEDICAL INDICATION. Now noone can say "What about medical indication?"

4. No, but there is a set of rights, seeing as we live in a some sort of society which has a set of rules.

5. The parent should have primary interest over the child yes. Why do you want that to extend to permanent modifications to genitals for no benefit that cant be gained by doing the procedure later, other than the supposed UTI benefit. Should I, being the parent, be able to tattoo my baby? Or do some other branding action? Why is circumcision different? Why can I cut his penis, but not her clitoris?

6. Without good reason... Give me a good reason. Also, you sub divided this response for no discernible reason. Id say violating a baby's right to bodily integrity is a good reason, a baby IS a person. Let me branch for a moment, I disagree with docking dog's ears, but its a dog, it is effectively property, is a human property in the same way?

7. You think it should apply to everyone, with the exclusion of infants, gotcha. Infants not being a part of everyone.
 
Last edited:
Clearly, we can add the anti-circumcision crowd to the list that includes creationists, 9-11 and JFK conspiracy theorists, anti-global warming kooks, the probed-by-E.T. folks, and all the other fringe believers in various and sundry nonsense. The illogic, dishonesty, resistance to evidence, additional dishonesty, and blatant obsession all point to the same "scratch" on their mental DVD.
 
BTW, the correct answer to the earlier trivia question was "Not Without My Foreskin"...
 
Clearly, we can add the anti-circumcision crowd to the list that includes creationists, 9-11 and JFK conspiracy theorists, anti-global warming kooks, the probed-by-E.T. folks, and all the other fringe believers in various and sundry nonsense. The illogic, dishonesty, resistance to evidence, additional dishonesty, and blatant obsession all point to the same "scratch" on their mental DVD.

Edited by prewitt81: 
Incivility removed.


Illogical in the same sense that opposing female genital mutilation is illogical. Show how its illogical, show how its dishonest, show how it resists evidence, show how its "additionally" dishonest, and show how its obsessive(or at least more obsessive than demanding your son's penis be cut into based on your taste in penises), and explain what sort of defect is indicated by opposition.

Koshy, please familiarize yourself with the Membership Agreement. Be civil and polite.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: prewitt81


Apologies to the mods.
 
Last edited:
Clearly, we can add the anti-circumcision crowd to the list that includes creationists, 9-11 and JFK conspiracy theorists, anti-global warming kooks, the probed-by-E.T. folks, and all the other fringe believers in various and sundry nonsense. The illogic, dishonesty, resistance to evidence, additional dishonesty, and blatant obsession all point to the same "scratch" on their mental DVD.

Oh come on, Joe. You know Darat, the admin of this forum, is one of the "anti-circumcision" crowd, too.

It's a human rights issue to many people.

Just because you disagree doesn't make it woo.
 
Oh come on, Joe. You know Darat, the admin of this forum, is one of the "anti-circumcision" crowd, too.

It's a human rights issue to many people.

Just because you disagree doesn't make it woo.
It has very little to do with whether or not I disagree, and mostly to do with the way they frame the issue. Hell, they could even be right. But, from where I'm sitting, they would be "right for the wrong reasons", if you can dig it.
 
It has very little to do with whether or not I disagree, and mostly to do with the way they frame the issue. Hell, they could even be right. But, from where I'm sitting, they would be "right for the wrong reasons", if you can dig it.


Which of course you wont elaborate on.
 
Which part would you like me to elaborate on?

Well, how exactly is the argument against illogical, dishonest, etc?

Also explain what you mean by right for the wrong reasons.

I understand people's attitudes regarding traditional practices and the like, however I absolutely cannot see how its possible that the opinion exists that circumcision is ok, but doing anything to your daughter is bad.

Why is protection extended to females and not males, taking into consideration the benefits and detriments of both male and female genital mutilation.
 
Well, how exactly is the argument against illogical, dishonest, etc?

Also explain what you mean by right for the wrong reasons.

I understand people's attitudes regarding traditional practices and the like, however I absolutely cannot see how its possible that the opinion exists that circumcision is ok, but doing anything to your daughter is bad.

Why is protection extended to females and not males, taking into consideration the benefits and detriments of both male and female genital mutilation.
Let's take your post as an example, shall we? First off, the phrase "genital mutilation" eliminates any possibility of rational discussion with you. Once you've got your heart set on that, no evidence can sway you, no reasoning can temper your view. You have predetermined that anyone who disagrees with you is promoting child abuse. So, what else is there to discuss logically, when you've defined the debate in such a way that no one can disagree with you without you seeing them as a monster?

Secondly, equating circumcision, which is a generally accepted medical procedure, with "anything to your daughter", also seems rather illogical, and also designed to frame the debate in such a way that no argument will ever be acceptable to you. Also, comparing a medical procedure to someone cutting a girl's clitoris out with a piece of glass is 100%, blatantly, ruthlessly dishonest. I assume you don't mean "clitoral hood removal", which actually can IMPROVE sexual response in women?

Third, you assume a cultural bias in everyone, even if they have none. I, for instance, have nothing much that could be described as a specific "culture" that would give me a position for or against circumcision. I have no tradition to look to, in order to judge the situation.

Fourth, you seem willing to give lip service to the idea of "benefits and detriments", but it seems rather dishonest when, in the same sentence, you use the phrase "genital mutilation."

And, the phrase "right for the wrong reasons" means that the position is based on emotionalism and illogical processes, and is only correct accidentally. For instance, you could correctly "predict" the next presidential election based on astrology or numerology or a coin toss, and have the "why" of it completely wrong.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom