Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

One has to remember that Ron Jeremy is WIDEly known, has a LONG career, and is a BIG star in the porno industry (don't ask me how I could possibly know that!)... ;)
 
All of this back and forth, but noone has really answered the question: What is so pressing that requires the foreskin to be removed at birth, without the individual's consent - well, ability to consent at all?

We've heard the arguments about possibly reduced infection and so on, but these arguments fail since the rates are so low (probably lower than in other organs and definitely lower than in cases where genetic propensities exist).

I'm sorry, the overriding reasons are tradition, religion, cultural norms. Unless you can provide a clinical medical document that states that foreskin removal reduces risk of A by 50%, that excuse is Penn&Teller!

Unlike several thousand years ago, hygiene in non-third-world countries is far beyond any hygienic reasons for this barbarity. And with that recent innovation - technology - we have things like condoms. Keep on justifying this practice.
 
All of this back and forth, but noone has really answered the question: What is so pressing that requires the foreskin to be removed at birth, without the individual's consent - well, ability to consent at all?
There really is no good reason for the mass cutting off of foreskins of babies. None whatsoever.
 
So, did you hear the moyel retired?
Why?
He couldn't cut it anymore.
Why?
Because the tips were not so good..
 
I'd like to know how often infibulation is done on girls.

I saw a documentary on clitoridectomy in Arabic countries on teevee, and while it was certainly barbaric and horrible, there wasn't any infibulation and certainly no removal of the labia majora (which would make infibulation rather difficult anyway).

But if we're going to bring that up for shock effect, perhaps we should talk also about the places in Africa where they traditionally split the penis open along the urethra resulting in something that looks a bit like the fillet of a flat fish, or where they sew the foreskin closed.
 
Edit: Also, if you draw a lot of phallic rock formations, as I do, possessing a very juvenile sense of humor, they really gotta be circumcised, or everybody wonders what's up with all the giant tube worms.-UrsulaV
Phallic rock formations?
I guess I haven't been paying attention the last thirty years.
Examples?
 
I haven't heard one circumcised man say he doesn't enjoy sex because he was circumcised. This whole argument is ridiculous. The only thing I can equate it with is little baby girls getting their ears pierced. No one has boards about that...

Oh, I hate to bring up the anti-Semitism thing, but if you made it illegal, that would be...ummm....

I can't see how pointing out that one of the practices carried out under a "religious law" is in fact barbaric and irrational because it is genital mutilation can be in anyway described as anti-Semitic. (Especially given that the criticism is about a practice that other religions also have similar laws/customs about.)

Personally I think it should be illegal; it's rather irrational that it isn't actually illegal in countries like the UK or the USA where it is already illegal for parents to cause their child to be mutilated.
 
I can't see how pointing out that one of the practices carried out under a "religious law" is in fact barbaric and irrational because it is genital mutilation can be in anyway described as anti-Semitic. (Especially given that the criticism is about a practice that other religions also have similar laws/customs about.)

Personally I think it should be illegal; it's rather irrational that it isn't actually illegal in countries like the UK or the USA where it is already illegal for parents to cause their child to be mutilated.

I share Darat's view that it should be illegal.

It would be interesting to see what would actually happen if someone (A) were to take someone (B) to court for having B's infant circumcised. I suspect that here in the UK, B would have a good chance of being convicted.
 
Edit: Also, if you draw a lot of phallic rock formations, as I do, possessing a very juvenile sense of humor, they really gotta be circumcised, or everybody wonders what's up with all the giant tube worms.-UrsulaV
Phallic rock formations?
I guess I haven't been paying attention the last thirty years.
Examples?

Well, if you twist my arm...

WARNING: Links goes to paintings featuring giant stone wang, horrified lizards, and at least one naked mole rat in a beret! Not Safe For Work, Minors, Delicate Sensitivities, or anyone who believes we need more modest rock formations! No guarantees of quality expressed or implied!

http://snipurl.com/lb5m
http://snipurl.com/lb5o

If you want photos of genuine rock formations of a suggestive nature, I know there are websites dedicated to them, but I'm gonna let somebody ELSE trip merrily down that google path...
 
People have been ignorant due to there own beliefs for thousands of years. Look at the tribe of american indians that flattened the head of there infants for cosmetic purposes, or the tribes of people who stretch their necks with brass rings, actually the necks dont stretch, but rather their scapulas and clavicles are displaced inferiorly. Some polynesians tatoo or scar up their bodies for beauty or manhood. Its like religion, how many people do something because that how its always been done, or thats how my family or community does it. The only responsible way now, knowing what we all know, is to weigh the pros and cons and decide from there what would be best for our children. It shouldnt be up to the dr. or society to judge. Situations call for different decisions as they arise, not really privy to the judgement of outsiders. The children, however, have to live with the decisions we make, and other children can be mean and rude.
 
3. A circumcised tool is less prone to premature ejaculation (again; medical studies)

I'd be interested in cites on this one. When I was pregnant, my husband and I did some fairly half-assed research on circumcision, and I remember reading the exact opposite of this. Then we found out we were having a girl and didn't bother to pursue the issue further.
 
The most obvious way circumcision could reduce the chance of premature ejaculation is to deaden the sensation of sex, rather like the effect of wearing multiple condoms to accomplish that purpose (warning: increases risk of breakage and STD transmission. Do not attempt at home if such issues are worrisome.).

It shouldnt be up to the dr. or society to judge. Situations call for different decisions as they arise, not really privy to the judgement of outsiders.
So, DrRyanScarsella, do you think society should withhold judgement on the issue of female circumcision?
 
The only actual reasoning that made any sense to me was that parents don't want to clean the boy's part properly. I guess they think hygiene can be considered kinky? But I think that's probably the root reason, others are just cover stories.
 
Well, if you twist my arm...

WARNING: Links goes to paintings featuring giant stone wang, horrified lizards, and at least one naked mole rat in a beret! Not Safe For Work, Minors, Delicate Sensitivities, or anyone who believes we need more modest rock formations! No guarantees of quality expressed or implied!

http://snipurl.com/lb5m
http://snipurl.com/lb5o

If you want photos of genuine rock formations of a suggestive nature, I know there are websites dedicated to them, but I'm gonna let somebody ELSE trip merrily down that google path...
Damn.. Smart and talented! Nice knobs, btw.
 
My first post after lurking for a while - I couldn't resist clarifying the historical context of the origin of the term 'female circumcision'.

I read an article about this in a history journal a couple of years ago, so the details may be a bit off, but the term 'female circumcision' arose in the late 19th century. Female genital mutilation (not just the removal of the clitoris, but a rather more elaborate and traumatic procedure) was the norm in one of Britain's African colonies (Nigeria?). The local Presbyterian missionaries were not pleased, and they lobbied the colonial administration to try and ban the practise. Word about this procedure also made it back to the home country, where feminist and religious groups also lobbied the foreign office to create a ban.

The colonial administration did not want to compel the locals to stop the much beloved tradition (among the men at least - it was thought that the process enhanced male sexual pleasure etc. etc.) because their hold on power was tenuous. In the end, the (male) administrators and foreign office officials came up with a compromise. They banned (on paper) the traumatic form of mutilation that was traditional, while saying that a less groutesque (to them at least) form of 'circumcision' was acceptable. Essentially, they said it was okay to remove the clitoris, as long as the local tribespeople didn't do anything else.

And they invented the term 'female circumcision' to describe this process of cliterodectomy. This was more acceptable to the male missionaries and to the politicians back in Britain because the clitoris was seen as being largely non-functional (therefore equivalent to the foreskin) by some anatomists at the time (I think). Feminists were not happy, but because female sexual pleasure was a taboo subject there was no real way for them to object.

The problem was that a simple cliterodectomy (aka 'female circumcision') was never a traditional process for the locals themselves. They ignored the new law, and continued with the mutilation as they had done before and as many still do it.

Therefore, the term 'female circumcision' is inappropriate, because it was an invented term for a process that was seldom performed. It was created for political reasons, and had little meaning beyond its being a token way of appeasing Calvinists and feminists, and it had little success with the latter.

It is more correct to refer to the ongoing process that happens in many countries as 'female genital mutilation', because it is a procedure that goes beyond cliterodectomy, and it avoids the ridiculous doublespeak behind the use of 'circumcision'.

Whether male circumcision should also be classed as mutilation is another question (I certainly wouldn't want it done to me!) Just don't use the term female circumcision, as it is in many ways without meaning.
 
Well, if you twist my arm...

WARNING: Links goes to paintings featuring giant stone wang, horrified lizards, and at least one naked mole rat in a beret! Not Safe For Work, Minors, Delicate Sensitivities, or anyone who believes we need more modest rock formations! No guarantees of quality expressed or implied!

http://snipurl.com/lb5m
http://snipurl.com/lb5o

If you want photos of genuine rock formations of a suggestive nature, I know there are websites dedicated to them, but I'm gonna let somebody ELSE trip merrily down that google path...

I just spent an hour brousing. I love the sabre toothed mouse - and I think I saw a Skelt once. Wonderful work.
 
Just put me down as another 'it should be banned' voter - more specifically, mutilation of ANY kind, done to minors, of either sex, should be made illegal, except in cases of clear medical necessity. And no, a slightly decreased risk of HIV infection does obviously NOT constitute such a case. I can see how phimosis WOULD be a deserving case if severe enough.

Don't cut up or stab kids! Just what part of this simple premise do defenders of mutilation not understand? The only reason I can think of, that this procedure is not viewed as barbaric, is tradition. Our modern Western civilization has not yet shed all of its primitive superstitious baggage. Otherwise rational people continue to imagine that it's ok to mutilate their kids, because it's in their religion. And religious beliefs, as we all know, are off limits to critical discussion. :mad:
 
Oh heck I knew I'd forgotten a couple of bits to my rant. Firstly, in view of the way this thread developed at least on its first page, I should point out that what a consenting ADULT wishes to do to their body is their own business, mutilation is barbaric only when carried out forcibly (and as with other aspects of human life, I consider that minors are not legally capable of informed consent). If a sane adult wants to chop their own arm off, more power to 'em. Of course if they want someone else to do it for them (like a surgeon), that other person has to consent too!

Secondly I wanted to bring in a half-remembered thought from Arthur C Clarke on the matter. Since the cultural background of genital mutilation is religious, we ought to remind its defenders that "God created the human form. Circumcision is blasphemy!"
 
Why don't we ask the expert?
Ron%20Jeremy%20150.jpg

Ron Jeremy is circumcised.
(Well, he's Jewish, so I am assuming....never seen him in the movies)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom