Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

Three rational reasons for Male circumcision

1. Personal Hygene (maybe English chicks like smegma, but round here they don’t)
2. Medical studies suggest that “the cut” helps prevent the spread of cervical cancer
3. A circumcised tool is less prone to premature ejaculation (again; medical studies)

Female genital mutilation has very little in common with male circumcision (except it involves the “pee pee” perhaps it’s your ignorance of female anatomy that makes you rant so), it is more a form of sexual imprisonment in that the clitoris is cut away and the intent is to make the sex act non pleasurable and often painful.
 
Might that be because these men have a way of comparing the difference?

And because, I'd think, because the differecne would be a lot bigger than with just a missing foreskin?

I have no doubt that it would be a lot less pleasurable - but do these men usually stop having sex alltogether? (On grounds that they don't enjoy the experiance anymore, as compared to being ashamed or maybe experiencing pain, of course.)

Rasmus.

I know a few guys who got circed as adults (one because of Jewish conversion--not required, but he wanted to--and another do to a medical condition) I asked them if there was any difference in sexual pleasure or performance, and they both said no. The one with the medical problem said it was better. I know, it's hardly scientific, but that's all I have to go on.

I KNOW that if I didn't have a clitoris, I would never get turned on or orgasm. Men who are circumcised do not have that problem...;)
 
Three rational reasons for Male circumcision
1. Personal Hygene (maybe English chicks like smegma, but round here they don’t)

Pssssssst......

we wash!

But don't let anyone know that I let that out to you, please.
 
Way back when I was in the army, (mid 60s) circumcision was one of the few "elective" surgies the army would do for you. I was a medic, and for some reason there was a surprising level of interest in having the procedure done. We referred several GIs who wanted to get "cut".

I did not have any opportunity to ask any of them "why?"
 
I KNOW that if I didn't have a clitoris, I would never get turned on or orgasm. Men who are circumcised do not have that problem...;)

I don't think it is anywhere near reasonale to compare the degree of cruelty behind the two procedures, and I doubt that the majority of men are met with severe difficultiues because of it.

I am somewhat suprised that one of your two examples didn't notice a difference. That a neccesary medical treatment would lead to betterement is less suprising, though.

Rasmus.
 
This is just my opinion, and I know this is anecdotal. But I am someone who has had both kinds attached to partners.

-- TMI Warning --

The texture in the head skin gets kind of leathery-feeling without the foreskin; with the foreskin, it's more like lips. The intact penis is bumpier in coitally-strategic places. It is more sensitive as well, more easily stimulated.
These are different partners, though, not one guy uncut and then later cut, so differences between individuals have to be considered.

----

In summary, I personally prefer the rollnecks.
 
As an artist, I gotta say, the circumcised ones are a heckuva lot easier to draw.

Since a lot of the arguments flying both for and against seem subjective as hell, I figure I might as well add that to the pile.

I suspect "Chop your wang for art!" probably will not be a good slogan for the pro-circumcision campaign, though.
 
I consider circumcision (both male and female) to be abhorrent and barbaric.

Can any rational thinker consider it otherwise ?

No, they can't. It's completely unnecessary mutilation of an unconsenting person (a baby). All such genital mutilation of children should be banned. Religious Jews and other nuts can like it or lump it.

For those of age, the question of "doing as they please" gets trickier since there's the danger of sufficient immigration importing horrific practices like the FGM. Once enough such people arrive and form a ghetto, peer and parental pressure will assure the practise continues underground.

Adult males lacking a medical excuse who get circumcised strike me as slightly mentally unbalanced. How hard is it to keep your cock clean? Worried about HIV? Stay out of that part of town, mayhap.
 
As an artist, I gotta say, the circumcised ones are a heckuva lot easier to draw.

Since a lot of the arguments flying both for and against seem subjective as hell, I figure I might as well add that to the pile.

I suspect "Chop your wang for art!" probably will not be a good slogan for the pro-circumcision campaign, though.
Apparently the photos of nude lady models for magazines such as playboy are retouched so as to remove 'unsightly' bits. Have we become so boring that everything we look at has to be aerodynamically sleek and teflon smooth?

At least in the playboy case the 'offending' bits are virtually, not surgically, removed.
 
Three rational reasons for Male circumcision

1. Personal Hygene (maybe English chicks like smegma, but round here they don’t)
An unwashed cut penis is every bit as nasty as an unwashed uncut penis. Sweaty crotches are sweaty crotches.
2. Medical studies suggest that “the cut” helps prevent the spread of cervical cancer
This implies sharing one cut unprotected penis among several women is better than sharing one uncut unprotected penis among several women. So perhaps a guy who just plain refuses to wear a condom, but can find lots of women dumb enough to have unprotected sex with him, might have himself cut as a courtesy? Also, you haven't provided any indication as to whether it was statistically significant - if it's 4%...who cares?
3. A circumcised tool is less prone to premature ejaculation (again; medical studies)
Can you provide some cites, please?

Female genital mutilation has very little in common with male circumcision (except it involves the “pee pee” perhaps it’s your ignorance of female anatomy that makes you rant so), it is more a form of sexual imprisonment in that the clitoris is cut away and the intent is to make the sex act non pleasurable and often painful.
Widespread infant circumcision in the United States may have started to try to prevent masturbation and curtail sexual pleasure.
 
Have we become so boring that everything we look at has to be aerodynamically sleek and teflon smooth?

At least in the playboy case the 'offending' bits are virtually, not surgically, removed.

Tcha! Now we're making assumptions about what constitutes "easier to draw."

Now, I happen to like lumpy and textural things in general, and I paint a fair number of chunky fat deposits and concrete walls. I'd be happy to link to my gallery if you need examples, but modesty forbids such shameless plugging cold. I can assure you however, I do not generally spend a lot of time goin' crazy with the airbrush to get that nice inhuman sheen.

But if anything, it's the definition and specific, not-vague shape of the cut wang that's helpful! It's the lump at the end that makes it! My attempts to draw an uncircumcised penis mostly made me feel like I was drawing a flesh tube sock. It's a long blob without clear waypoints. Like spelling "banana," it can be hard to know when to stop.

The circumcised penis, on t'other hand, has a definite end point. You get to the end, there's the nice little mushroom shape, full stop, the pencil rests. It's like a exclamation point. The bump and the ridges and the weird texture is what makes it work! If anything, I'd say it's less streamlined, and it's that weird ridge and whatnot that gives the artful penis character!

...and that is way more enthusiastic than I EVER expected to wax on this topic, thank ya verra much.

Edit: Also, if you draw a lot of phallic rock formations, as I do, possessing a very juvenile sense of humor, they really gotta be circumcised, or everybody wonders what's up with all the giant tube worms.
 
I KNOW that if I didn't have a clitoris, I would never get turned on or orgasm. Men who are circumcised do not have that problem...;)
I think I'd still get turned on if I didn't have a penis. If you didn't have a clitoral hood, what impact do you think that would have?
 
No, they can't. It's completely unnecessary mutilation of an unconsenting person (a baby). All such genital mutilation of children should be banned. Religious Jews and other nuts can like it or lump it.
Heh. Okay, now someone has suggested outlawing it.:D
 
Tcha! Now we're making assumptions about what constitutes "easier to draw."

Now, I happen to like lumpy and textural things in general, and I paint a fair number of chunky fat deposits and concrete walls. I'd be happy to link to my gallery if you need examples, but modesty forbids such shameless plugging cold. I can assure you however, I do not generally spend a lot of time goin' crazy with the airbrush to get that nice inhuman sheen.
Well, and airbrushed photos are too planar and two-dimensional. Trying to draw from a Playmate photo might be a pretty image, but it's not like trying to draw a naked human sitting in front of you.

...and that is way more enthusiastic than I EVER expected to wax on this topic, thank ya verra much.

Edit: Also, if you draw a lot of phallic rock formations, as I do, possessing a very juvenile sense of humor, they really gotta be circumcised, or everybody wonders what's up with all the giant tube worms.
Heh.
There was a guy in one of my life drawing classes who would ignore the model and just draw penises in a vase. I mean...what's the point of life drawing if you aren't going to take the opportunity to draw the model?! But he was one of those people who figures "Van Gogh was a jerk, so if I act like a jerk I'm more arty!"
Now I'm trying to remember his drawings...I think they were all circumcised. :p
 
My boys are different. The first got circ'd. I couldn't believe my eyes afterwards, and I had to take care of the wound with gauze and petroleum jelly. He cried when he peed until it healed over. Then there are the horror stories about the boys who were turned into girls accidently...why increase the risk of your newborn losing more than foreskin? My second is "intact". I couldn't do that to him.
 
Tcha! Now we're making assumptions about what constitutes "easier to draw."

Now, I happen to like lumpy and textural things in general, and I paint a fair number of chunky fat deposits and concrete walls. I'd be happy to link to my gallery if you need examples, but modesty forbids such shameless plugging cold. I can assure you however, I do not generally spend a lot of time goin' crazy with the airbrush to get that nice inhuman sheen.

But if anything, it's the definition and specific, not-vague shape of the cut wang that's helpful! It's the lump at the end that makes it! My attempts to draw an uncircumcised penis mostly made me feel like I was drawing a flesh tube sock. It's a long blob without clear waypoints. Like spelling "banana," it can be hard to know when to stop.

The circumcised penis, on t'other hand, has a definite end point. You get to the end, there's the nice little mushroom shape, full stop, the pencil rests. It's like a exclamation point. The bump and the ridges and the weird texture is what makes it work! If anything, I'd say it's less streamlined, and it's that weird ridge and whatnot that gives the artful penis character!

...and that is way more enthusiastic than I EVER expected to wax on this topic, thank ya verra much.

Edit: Also, if you draw a lot of phallic rock formations, as I do, possessing a very juvenile sense of humor, they really gotta be circumcised, or everybody wonders what's up with all the giant tube worms.
Thanks for the details! :p

I wasn't trying to have a go at at the 'easier to draw' statement. It was the "chop yer bits for art" that got me thinking about how we already do that, virtually, in Playboy and that type of mag.

I also do life drawing, in fact, I think I may have posted one or two in some other thread a while back. I'd probably have to agree with you that the exposed knob is easier to draw. Well, quicker, at least. I struggle so much with drawing that it's all difficult.
 
Why don't we ask the expert?
Ron%20Jeremy%20150.jpg
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom