Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

so, if the only piece of the body that should be removed at birth is the umbilical cord, and we eat that, and we also routinely lop off foreskins, should we eat them too? i mean, they have all that wonderful nerve tissue, right? gotta be good for something.
 
so, if the only piece of the body that should be removed at birth is the umbilical cord, and we eat that

Who in the name of a merciful God EATS the umbilical cord?! I've heard of people occasionally eating the placenta, and that's weird enough...
 
Most animals gnaw it off. Presumably humans would have done the same before developing edgy rocks to do it for them.
 
I was just about to explode in a rant requiring evidence, but I realize that you are talking about the umbilical cord, not foreskin - shoooo. ;)
 
Most animals gnaw it off. Presumably humans would have done the same before developing edgy rocks to do it for them.

Oh, well, that's something else again.

I was trying to figure out how people would prepare the umbilical cord, and all I could come up with was chopped into little rings and deep fried, and it was a disturbing image...

(Also, luchog, "Digger 2" is due out this summer some time...)
 
Oh, well, that's something else again.

I was trying to figure out how people would prepare the umbilical cord, and all I could come up with was chopped into little rings and deep fried, and it was a disturbing image...
I'm visualizing a sort of weird, calamari-looking thing. I think I'll just skip lunch today.

(Also, luchog, "Digger 2" is due out this summer some time...)
I don't want to wait that long. :(
 
I was circumsised as an adult, so I've had both. I suffered from phimosis, which meant that the foreskin did not stretch all it should, resulting in some pain when I had an erection.

There's been comment on lack of sensitivity... maybe true. The first days after the operation (not good days, you have stitches all around) showering, the contact with your underwear... are all quite painful but then you stop noticing it. I guess that means the glans is less sensitive. But that doesn't mean my sexual experience is worse now... not at all. First, there's the obvious issue of the discomfort I had before. The loss of sensitivity is not a problem. Some people pointed out that you lose the frenulum, but the bit that was just under it remains as sensitive (which is quite sensitive indeed) so it's not a big loss.

On the whole, I've noticed no negative side effects at all and it has clearly improved my life. I even think it would be more comfortable, even if I hadn't had phimosis. This doesn't mean it's worth it if you don't have that problem. The convalecence is quite nasty. I don't approve of circumsision in babies.
 
it has clearly improved my life.-Dr.Fendetestas

In what way? Just the tight foreskin problem? So you would only advise it as treatment for this , or similar , problems?
 
it has clearly improved my life.-Dr.Fendetestas

In what way? Just the tight foreskin problem? So you would only advise it as treatment for this , or similar , problems?

Yes, that's the only thing I meant.

I was answering to some people who have posted about 'loss of functionality', saying that I haven't experienced any. But of course the real debate is about circumsising people without these problems, in which case it shouldn't be done. My post was only to express my opinion that 'loss of functionality' was not the reason. You can find lots of better reasons: possible complications after the operation, a very painful couple of weeks... It's a surgical operation after all (although a very simple one, you are awake all the time and it doesn't last too long). And it's a part of the body, maybe it does something we don't know about.
 
Last edited:
Hmmm... "newborn male circumcision" and "female genital mutilation". In what way is the male circumcision not genital mutilation ?

Exactly. My genitals were mutilated soon after birth because of ancient, archaic, ritualistic religious reasons.

Given, evidently, these are also sensitive parts, this should be banned immediately. Just as your right to swing your arm ends where my nose begins, your religious rights end where my penis begins.

Perhaps a better way to attack this would be to sue doctors who perform it.
 
Circumcision of males is no big deal. On one hand, there are a few rare complications. On the other hand, circumcised males suffer less from urinary tract infections, the very rare penile cancer, and possibly HIV.


And women without breasts suffer less breast cancer. What's your point again? Should women have their breasts removed at birth?

And let's not lie to ourselves: This was, and is done for religious reasons, and it has nothing to do with health matters. Those are Monday morning quarterbacking, grasping at straws to justify ancient religious rituals where people, in their usual manner of making up gods and things that gods want, had enormous hangups on sex and penises and virginities.
 
Circumcision of males is no big deal. On one hand, there are a few rare complications. On the other hand, circumcised males suffer less from urinary tract infections, the very rare penile cancer, and possibly HIV.

As far as I'm aware, the only downside is the risk of complications, which are pretty rare and not usually serious. It is in no way comparable to female genital mutilation (which destroys a woman's capacity to ejoy sexual intercourse, or even endure it comfortably), nor to losing a limb.

Please cite your sources for your assertion that circumcision causes fewer UTIs, and other problems you said... I believe that assertion is mistaken, and is a common one among those who don't know any better.

My two sons are not circumcised. I consider it to be an unnecessary surgery, and a violation of the Hippocratic oath of the doctors who do it.

Check out http://www.nocirc.org/ ... I know they have an agenda, but I have verified much of their information through independant sources such as WebMD, etc...
 
As I said above in degree it is different however it is still genital mutilation for no rational reason. Part of the reason I believe it is still carried out is because the mutilation part of it is hidden behind a socially acceptable word - circumcision.

I was under the impression that circumcision reduced the risk of some forms of infection. That would explain why some early cultures practiced it. Of course, now it's a religious thing. Otherwise I don't have an opinion about it one way or another (except, of course, for medical reasons.) Obviously, as far as female "circumcision" goes, it's an entirely different discussion.

Blue Bubble said:
In any case, do you think that such an adult who requests that he be circumcised could be deemed a rational thinker ?

Are people who get piercing rational ? How does reason factor into all this ?

Melendwyr said:
And considering that you're removing essentially the entire mucuous membrane of the penis... it seems clear that this is considered minor only because it's traditionally accepted.

Well, I'd consider getting a nail removed "minor". Whether or not it's tradition.
 
I was under the impression that circumcision reduced the risk of some forms of infection. That would explain why some early cultures practiced it.

...snip...


I don't think it does provide the necessary evidence to suppose there was originally a "rational" reason for the practice. At best this difference in infection rates is minimal so given the rest of their environment I can't see how they could even have generated the evidence to be able to rationally assume a link between uncircumcised men and a very slightly lower infection rate among circumcised men.
 
I don't think it does provide the necessary evidence to suppose there was originally a "rational" reason for the practice. At best this difference in infection rates is minimal so given the rest of their environment I can't see how they could even have generated the evidence to be able to rationally assume a link between uncircumcised men and a very slightly lower infection rate among circumcised men.

Allright. Anyway, barring medical reasons, the "owner" of the foreskin should have final say. All I said was, maybe the belief that it reduced risks of infection was the original reason for that tradition. Then again, maybe not.
 
Allright. Anyway, barring medical reasons, the "owner" of the foreskin should have final say. All I said was, maybe the belief that it reduced risks of infection was the original reason for that tradition. Then again, maybe not.

How would a people who lived thousands of years before the germ theory of disease even make this intuative leap, assuming there was even any discernable evidence?
 
Well, I know when I was a child, it was a common belief (wherever it was that my parents had me... Arizona, I think) that foreskins were more prone to infections than those without. My parents had me circumcised using some heat method - apparently, a photo of my willy has appeared in a medical journal - and other than an unusual ring of darker skin (like a circumferential freckle), I have absolutely no complaints. My Mr. Happy is every bit as pleasurable as I could possibly want it - sometimes more so than I need - and every bit as sensitive as I'd like and then some. Plenty large - perhaps too large, actually - and has never, EVER given me a spot of problems. Plenty of lubrication involved as well. So I'm in no way upset over the loss of such an apparently unimportant and possibly bothersome bit of skin, just as I'm not at all upset over losing my wisdom teeth.

Those were removed by the military, who decided that wisdom teeth are too hard to clean and maintain, and are a bother; so they wanted them out. Mine were perfect - absolutely perfect - but they asked me to have them removed anyway, and I agreed. I don't miss them, either.

If I could get someone to remove my tonsils or my appendix or any other unnecessary bit before they become a problem, I wouldn't mind that at all, either.

Of our children, though, only part of them are circumcised. My wife and I both were under the same belief about cleanliness and infections, so we had our earlier children circumcised; our 3-year-old ended up getting a medical circumcision at age 1 1/2, due to his unusual skin problems; and my baby boy remains uncircumcised at the behest of his mother, who has personal/psychological reasons for not wanting the child cut.

Our experience with our circumcised boys is that they are generally happier and cleaner than our uncircumcised boys (which includes the two stepchildren) regarding their wriggle worms. The procedure was, apparently, not at all uncomfortable or painful, except for a brief period for our three-year-old right after it happened - but, he was already suffering from inflamed skin all around his genitals, so I can't rule that out as a cause of discomfort.

At this stage of my life, as I've learned to be more pro-active with what I believe and now, I'm not personally invested in the idea of circumcision. I haven't seen sufficient evidence for OR against the idea that an uncut penis is more prone to infection and disease, or harder to clean. I do, however, maintain a personal preference for the cut organ, and I admit it is for purely psychological and personal reasons - the uncut critter looks remarkably bestial in appearance, and the only people I knew (before my own kids) with uncut penises were NOT the cleanest people on earth anyway, and I can only imagine the funk that would arise from an exposed ripple of fore-flesh on those guys... ugh!

Female genital mutilation is a horrible practice, and there is absolutely no good reason to ruin a young girl's sex life. Circumcision doesn't ruin anyone's sex life, unless you're some kind of sick fore-phile... :D

As for childhood ear piercings, I'm all for it. Most piercings, after all, close up (in the lobe, anyway) if left alone, so they still can have that choice after they've matured anyway.

Childhood BODY piercings are a different matter, since a few of those locations don't quite heal normally if left alone.

Childhood tattoos I am against, at least until someone comes up with a foolproof, inexpensive, and safe way to remove tattoos. Can you imagine a future with people getting tattooed for a while? I might get one, then.

I remember reading, at some point in the past, an article attempting to relate the hymen of a girl to the foreskin of a boy... I wish I could remember where I read it, or how long ago, but I'd swear the article was either an attempt to make circumcision seem wrong, or an attempt to promote a standard procedure of early childhood deflowering, for some health-related reason. I also remember reading some reader reaction to the article, and was struck - even then! - by how much cultural fashion and taboo held sway. Of course, most everyone was against the idea, but not because it was 'an unnecessary practice' - rather, opinion swayed heavily into the camp of 'the hymen represents youth, chastity, and purity; its removal should be the gateway to womanhood'.... yada yada yada. (I largely agree, but it just struck me as odd).

*shrug* Eh... I'm not afor cutting pricks, nor agin it... but don't try to claim that 'cut men can't function right anymore'.
 
I haven't heard one circumcised man say he doesn't enjoy sex because he was circumcised. This whole argument is ridiculous. The only thing I can equate it with is little baby girls getting their ears pierced. No one has boards about that...

Could it be because circumcised men don't know any difference? After all, they never experienced anything MORE or different!

It's like saying a person blind since birth doesn't miss sight.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom