Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

Three rational reasons for Male circumcision

1. Personal Hygene (maybe English chicks like smegma, but round here they don’t)

As people have said already... it's a big secret that us men just don't want you to know about, but we DO wash our genitals every so often!

2. Medical studies suggest that “the cut” helps prevent the spread of cervical cancer

Okay, they SUGGEST... I've heard a lot of commercials for new medications where they say weasely things like "Clinical Studies SUGGEST"... that's not proof, that's a hypothesis.

3. A circumcised tool is less prone to premature ejaculation (again; medical studies)

Okay, that's interesting... people are saying there's no significant loss of stimulation or pleasure... But it helps prevent premature ejaculation? Isn't premature ejaculation prevented by LESSENING the stimulus, and thus the pleasure?

Female genital mutilation has very little in common with male circumcision (except it involves the “pee pee” perhaps it’s your ignorance of female anatomy that makes you rant so), it is more a form of sexual imprisonment in that the clitoris is cut away and the intent is to make the sex act non pleasurable and often painful.

Okay, so removing the clitoral hood, thus exposing the clit more is similar? I think not!

The labia minor and labia major both cover the clit when not in coitus. The clit is tripple protected... removing the inner-most protection doesn't really cause it to be overstimulated by things like clothing and such.

Now the penis on the other hand... Removing the ONLY protective covering from the most sensitive part, and exposing it to being stimulated at all times... and removing the skin that is also highly sensitive (as opposed to the hood of the clit, which isn't very sensitive... at least, not comparable to the male foreskin). The two procedures are not at all alike! As far as I can tell, the woman losing the clitoral hood would allow for MORE sexual stimulation during sex, while the opposte is true for the man who loses his foreskin.

Now, completely CUTTING OUT the clitorus is beyond barbaric. It's horrible child abuse. It's analagous to cutting off the entire penis. Might as well just fit a guy with a catheter and give him electric anal shocks to force ejaculation. While we're at it, let's just harvest sperm and keep it in sperm banks so sex isn't even necessary.

Let's face it, the whole circumcision thing is a relgious fundamentalist thing SPECIFICALLY DESIGNED to make sex less enjoyable, and less of a temptation. It's a method used to CONTROL the huddled masses, and to keep them from "SINNING".

Mr. Kellogg of breakfast cereal fame was a major anti-masturbation mover and shaker (pun intended)... I heard that he actually sold Corn Flakes as a food to help "reduce the desire to masturbate"... He was a huge supporter of male circumcision, because he felt it would lead to reduced sensitivity, and thus prevent the desire to masturbate.

It's all a bunch of crap, and I'm shocked the good people on this site are even debating the merits of it. To me, it's akin to arguing whether Jon of God is performing valid surgery!
 
He was a huge supporter of male circumcision, because he felt it would lead to reduced sensitivity, and thus prevent the desire to masturbate.

*scratch head* Look, there are perfectly good arguments against circumcision, but is the erroneous belief of a corn-flake fancier really one of them?

I mean, people used to use leeches to expel the evil humors, but the fact that they were completely wrong about how things worked and did a lot more harm than good, does not constitute a valid rational argument against the use of medical leeches today.

A number of good concerns about the effects of the tradition of circumcision have been brought up, but the generalized leap to "Circumcision is a tool of the religious/fundie/cornflake magnates to control the masses!" strikes me as bein' just a taaaaad over the top. Can you prove that this is some kind of conscious conspiracy to control the masses, as opposed to a vague traditional observance we've just inherited? Otherwise...I dunno.

'Course, I'm left with the mental image of Mr. Kellog cackling maniacally and screaming "I will show you fear in a handful of cornflakes!" and that's almost worth it right there.
 
They need to connect dirty conditions to infection.

And a lot more then that especially given that the rate of infections after the mutilation must have been much higher then todays given that hygiene* was not a prime concern.

So for it to be a rationally arrived at decision they must have known disease rates during later life, severity of those infections compared to increase infections at a younger age from the mutilation itself (even today there are serious complications and infections after the surgery).

I wonder if its origins were more about testing who was fit to live (which is a source for many initiation rights)? After all if your son died soon afterwards then it was a sign from God. Indeed that reason even seems consistent with the given biblical explanation for the reason circumcision should be carried out.


(* Hygiene as we now understand it thanks to germ theory of disease.)
 
I wonder if its origins were more about testing who was fit to live (which is a source for many initiation rights)?

One possible explanation for origins of circumcision notes that all societies where it arose lived in or near deserts and didn't have underwear in the sense that we have. It is then claimed that the combination of loose sand, foreskin, and lack of running water for washing is rather uncomfortable. I haven't tested the veracity of this claim and I don't intend to.
 
Hadn't thought about that one. Barbarians it is.

But to be fair they must have got quite good at doing the mutilation in a way that didn't kill off too many sons or cause too much harm else it wouldn't have been continued for so long. Mind you I do wonder if there is any correlation (which could indicate a link) between the rate of growth and/or success of the cultures that undertook the practice and those that didn't?
 
This from a history of circumcision:

"The third stage of ritual circumcision, the Messisa or Metzitzah, was not introduced until the Talmudic period (500-625 C.E). In Metzitzah, the mohel (ritual circumciser) sucks blood from the penis of the circumcised infant with his mouth. This procedure has been responsible for the death of many Jewish babies due to infection. In modern times, a glass tube is sometimes used instead."

Now that is gross - sucking the blood from babies' penises. That clearly has nothing to do with reducing infection.
 
It also provided a clear distinction between people "of the faith" and those not, because no one in the region practiced it.
 
Please cite your sources for your assertion that circumcision causes fewer UTIs, and other problems you said... I believe that assertion is mistaken, and is a common one among those who don't know any better.

Besides, even if it reduced the risk by 50%, that means that one in 750 men will have a UTI in their lives as opposed to 1 in 1000. Is that really worth it?

It would be one thing if it reduced the UTI rate in women, where it is actually a real problem for many if not most. But men?
 
At least more visible... like the subdermal beads or other VISIBLE bodily decorations on various African tribesmen. I mean, who wants to pull down their pants to prove they're Jewish??
 
Though they should have thought about a more visible, less permanent sign... say tattoo, body paint or holy amulet or something.
Easier to fake, less likely to put off people who aren't of the tribe. Remember, the ideal tribal mark should not only be umambiguous, but should irrevocably distinguish and separate in-tribe from out-tribe. Same deal with the prohibitions on food preparation.
 
This from a history of circumcision:

"The third stage of ritual circumcision, the Messisa or Metzitzah, was not introduced until the Talmudic period (500-625 C.E). In Metzitzah, the mohel (ritual circumciser) sucks blood from the penis of the circumcised infant with his mouth. This procedure has been responsible for the death of many Jewish babies due to infection. In modern times, a glass tube is sometimes used instead."

Now that is gross - sucking the blood from babies' penises. That clearly has nothing to do with reducing infection.

Ewwww.
Rare Circumcision Ritual Carries Herpes Risk
Rabbi probed for circumcised infants' herpes
 
I don't think the "clear distinction" applies here, unless it's specifically for the individual to come to that realization about himself; as Belz points out, it's not readily visible to the next guy.
 
Easier to fake, less likely to put off people who aren't of the tribe. Remember, the ideal tribal mark should not only be umambiguous, but should irrevocably distinguish and separate in-tribe from out-tribe. Same deal with the prohibitions on food preparation.

Maybe. But wouldn't something that didn't require them to get naked in front of other people be more appropriate ?
 
I hope people take the time to read everything. Repeting the same arguments will be quite ridiculous.

The way I see it, we have the following situation:

The practice has POSSiBLE, YET TO BE PROVEN advantages. It seems people are just looking for evidence to support their traditional practices instead of basing the practices on evidence. Sounds familiar?

The practice has possible, and some very likely, chance to go amiss, and it cannot be reverted. If the person decides against it in later life, his loss (literally).

So, in any OTHER situation, a possible disadvantage would prevent us from doing something with possible advantage. Why doesn´t this apply in this case?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom