Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

I consider circumcision (both male and female) to be abhorrent and barbaric.

Can any rational thinker consider it otherwise ?
Maybe it has something to do with the snake in the Garden of Eden? You know, how serpents shed their skin? Isn't that kind of what the darn thing looks like anyway, the head of a snake? I also understand that in some cultures the serpent is revered, and considered a sign of immortality. Sound similar to the covenant God made with the children of Israel perhaps? Maybe the whole thing is there to serve as a reminder of the fall?
 
Last edited:
I'm with Darat et al. This is purely a fashionable custom, child mutilation considered socially acceptable in some societies including the USA-largely because it's practised on infants who cannot protest.
Leave it on. If they want to cut it off when they are adults, that's their business.
The HIV argument IS interesting, but came long after the fashion.
As for the hygiene argument, that's rank puritan hogwash. We don't cut a kid's ears off because he might not wash behind them.
 
Last edited:
Seems it can still be said that the penis remains fully functional after circumcision. Certainly not for the squeamish, but the comparison with FGM, or assertion that harm is done is over the top.

I don't really buy the notion that the foreskin is very useful as a protective sheath. I suspect as adolescence hits, any protection is nullified by frequent self stimulation. You'd think all that rubbing would destroy such a sensitive gland.
 
If it wasn't for my foreskin I'd have nothing to trip over on my way to the bathroom in the morning.

ETA: btw, I say let them do it as adults if they want, but not to poor babies and kids.
 
Last edited:
What exactly would make it non-functional in your eyes?

Well, if males had done to them what females who experiance genital mutilation usually have done to them, then it would be non-functional in that most of it would be missing. Especially the tip ie anywhere that gives sexual pleasure.
 
I haven't heard one circumcised man say he doesn't enjoy sex because he was circumcised. This whole argument is ridiculous. The only thing I can equate it with is little baby girls getting their ears pierced. No one has boards about that...

Oh, I hate to bring up the anti-Semitism thing, but if you made it illegal, that would be...ummm....
 
Well, if males had done to them what females who experiance genital mutilation usually have done to them, then it would be non-functional in that most of it would be missing. Especially the tip ie anywhere that gives sexual pleasure.
I hate to break it to you, but studies have confirmed that men are perfectly capable of sexual functioning without any genital stimulation or response whatsoever. Technically, amputation wouldn't make men "non-functional".

Yet somehow I don't think you'd accept that as a fully functional system. Am I wrong?
 
I haven't heard one circumcised man say he doesn't enjoy sex because he was circumcised. This whole argument is ridiculous. The only thing I can equate it with is little baby girls getting their ears pierced. No one has boards about that...

Oh, I hate to bring up the anti-Semitism thing, but if you made it illegal, that would be...ummm....

I know several men who say that they wish they hadn't have been circumcised as infants, and now think their penises are numb to some degree as a result.
 
Actually, I think they are validly comparable.
I detest seeing little girls (do they do it to little boys too these days?) with pierced ears. Little kids aren't mini adults and shouldn't be required to look like them.
Making holes in people, or cutting bits off them, is not nice. Making holes in people who can't say no is bullying.

If adults want to make holes in themselves, that's up to them.
 
I hate to break it to you, but studies have confirmed that men are perfectly capable of sexual functioning without any genital stimulation or response whatsoever. Technically, amputation wouldn't make men "non-functional".

Yet somehow I don't think you'd accept that as a fully functional system. Am I wrong?

I hate to break it to you, but just about any man who lost the most important part of Mr. Happy ie the part that gives SEXUAL PLEASURE, would consider it very non-functional, or at best, un-functional.

Unless the only function that you consider is involved in the production of babies, Melendwyr?
 
They're not comparable, because small holes in ears grow closed if they're not kept open. Foreskins (and the associated nerves and membranes) do not regrow.
 
I hate to break it to you, but just about any man who lost the most important part of Mr. Happy ie the part that gives SEXUAL PLEASURE, would consider it very non-functional, or at best, un-functional.

Unless the only function that you consider is involved in the production of babies, Melendwyr?
Nope. I'm talking physical pleasure and orgasm. None of it actually requires a penis.
 
I hate to break it to you, but just about any man who lost the most important part of Mr. Happy ie the part that gives SEXUAL PLEASURE, would consider it very non-functional, or at best, un-functional.
I just realized something.

Are you circumcized, bignickel? Because men who aren't generally don't think the glans is the only part of the penis that gives pleasure. The most sensitive part of the penis, the frenulum, is removed in circumcision.
 
They're not comparable, because small holes in ears grow closed if they're not kept open. Foreskins (and the associated nerves and membranes) do not regrow.

Actually, there are ways for men to stretch out their foreskin so it is uncircumcised again. I saw it on Penn & Teller.

I am not defending either, but I think the whole debate is ridiculous, and comparing taking a tiny piece of skin from an infant to taking the entire genitalia and pleasure sensors off of a young girl is beyond ignorant.

As I said earlier, if I weren't Jewish, I wouldn't have gotten my son circumcised. I didn't want to do it...my non-Jewish husband was the one who wouldn't shut up about getting it done.
 
I hate to break it to you, but just about any man who lost the most important part of Mr. Happy ie the part that gives SEXUAL PLEASURE, would consider it very non-functional, or at best, un-functional.

Might that be because these men have a way of comparing the difference?

And because, I'd think, because the differecne would be a lot bigger than with just a missing foreskin?

I have no doubt that it would be a lot less pleasurable - but do these men usually stop having sex alltogether? (On grounds that they don't enjoy the experiance anymore, as compared to being ashamed or maybe experiencing pain, of course.)

Rasmus.
 
Actually, there are ways for men to stretch out their foreskin so it is uncircumcised again.
No. I've heard of methods that stretch the remaining shaft skin, but that no more reverses circumcision than getting a glass eye cures blindness - it's strictly cosmetic.

I am not defending either, but I think the whole debate is ridiculous, and comparing taking a tiny piece of skin from an infant to taking the entire genitalia and pleasure sensors off of a young girl is beyond ignorant.
It's a quarter of the total penile skin, shalomsteph. How does that constitute "tiny"?

As I said earlier, if I weren't Jewish, I wouldn't have gotten my son circumcised. I didn't want to do it...my non-Jewish husband was the one who wouldn't shut up about getting it done.
In regions where female genital mutilation is common, it's often the girls' mothers who arrange for it to be done.
 
I don't think anybody here has suggested making it illegal. The OP was wondering about rational reasons to circumcise.

So far, we have a few reasons for it: possible slightly reduced susceptibility to HIV transmission according to some studies (and that implies unprotected sex anyway? I think?), potential avoidance of extremely rare cancer, and of course sometimes it's medically necessary.
I can think of a couple more: someone may think it looks nicer cut, or think that other people will find it more attractive that way. Also, some studies indicate that uncircumsized boys have slightly less UTIs (urinary tract infections).

I honestly think that neither the HIV nor cancer issues are statistically significant, when you stack them up against cutting off skin, with nerves in it, especially from a sensitive sexual organ. I could understand someone with an intense family history of that particular cancer choosing to circumcize at a certain age, though, the way some women have had prophylactic mastectomies.

Aestheticswise, I guess that's personal, or you might argue it's cultural. But if someone met enough females who seemed to dislike his rollneck penis, he might have it cut on that rational basis. It would surprise me that any guy (at least in my own culture) would choose something that makes his penis the slightest bit smaller, though.

The UTI thing isn't clearly proven, and in any case, males just don't get UTIs much. So it's not a very important point. Incidentally, when young boys do have a problem, sometimes that's due to forcible retraction - some parents think they have to clean under the foreskin when it's not retracted yet, but it's better to leave it alone. Unrinsed soap or dirty bathwater can cause irritation and problems. It's not exactly bad hygiene, it's overzealous hygiene.

I do think foreskin removal may be analagous to the removal of the hood of the clitoris, as somebody said - consulting my New Well Pregnancy Book diagrams on fetal genital development. There are some adult women who choose to modify their genitals for better direct stimulation, for aesthetics, or to accomodate piercings, though, so maybe it works as a comparison. So the level of FGM we would have to use as a parallel would be removing the hood of the clitoris - not full-on labiectomy and infibulation.

I find this discussion interesting, by the way, since I'm having a son in a few more months. I plan to leave him intact.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom