Circumcision: can any rational thinker defend it ?

The penis remains completely functional after the procedure. That would not make it mutilation in my book. No more than, say, a appendectomy is mutilation of the body.

Equating the practice of female and male circumcision doesn't seem completely rational to me.


An appendectomy is carried out for medical reasons. There is no* medical reason for removing the foreskin in the vast majority of cases (although of course some circumcisions are carried out for medical reasons). To support circumcision for religious or societal reasons is to support the physical mutilation of a non-consenting person. Would you accept that say removing the ear lobes of a baby would be OK if some parents believed in doing so for religious reasons? Or other non-harmful physical mutilations?


*Albeit some initial research has demonstrated that it may reduce infection rates of HIV in some parts of Africa.
 
The penis remains completely functional after the procedure. That would not make it mutilation in my book. No more than, say, a appendectomy is mutilation of the body.

Equating the practice of female and male circumcision doesn't seem completely rational to me.

but of course the penis does not remain fully functional, the foreskin provides a protective sheath for the glans, as well as having plenty of nerve endings itself. Circumcision can seriously reduce the sensation in the penis. Admit idly many forms of FGM are far far more serious than circumcision, but there aer other forms which are more similar.

However I cannot see any justification for permanently removing a fully functional part of an infant, for cultural or cosmetic reasons.

An appendectomy is not a mutilation, as the appendix has no remaining function, and can pose a life threatening risk to a person. The foreskin has a function, and I dont think you could point to any one who ever died from having a foreskin.
Also, I'm not aware of any society which rottenly removes the appendix from a child as a preventive measure.

Routine infant circumcision is unnecessary surgery, would you any other support irreversible "cosmetic" or "cultural" surgery performed on infants who cannot give consent?


And in the end it has to come down to "if it ain't broke, don't fix it".
 
I'd like to poin out that most of the complications risks of male circumcsision arrise because it's done at infancy, when the foreskin is adhered to the glads, and circumcsision is much more difficult than it would be on an adult penis.
 
I don't want to sound like I'm adampantly pro-circumcision or anything, but I feel like there is not a lot of balance in this discussion. Circumcision is much less traumatic and much easier when performed on an infant than with an adult. The link I posted earlier (Straight Dope) says "Circumcision after infancy is far more traumatic and expensive and has a much higher rate of complications than infant circumcision."

And geni, I'm not aware of anything indicating that a circumcised penis is less than completely functional. Uruk (see post #4) might argue the other way.
 
Never in a Woman seldom in a Man.
Countries that perform this 'operation ' on young girls should be thrown out of the UN and all trade , contact etc banned until they stop this dreadful practice . Time to get tough with these morons .
 
Yeah, I think it's no big deal. It's quicker, simpler, and easier than having a mole or wart removed.
In adults? Certainly not. The only reason it's considered easier with infants is that they heal so much faster (and they can't complain of pain).

And considering that you're removing essentially the entire mucuous membrane of the penis... it seems clear that this is considered minor only because it's traditionally accepted.
 
I don't want to sound like I'm adampantly pro-circumcision or anything, but I feel like there is not a lot of balance in this discussion.
You mean you don't think there's adequate representation of the perspective you favor. "Balance" is meaningless, otherwise.

Circumcision is much less traumatic and much easier when performed on an infant than with an adult.
But why should it be performed at all?

And geni, I'm not aware of anything indicating that a circumcised penis is less than completely functional. Uruk (see post #4) might argue the other way.
Really? How much lubrication does a circumcised penis produce?
 
In any case, do you think that such an adult who requests that he be circumcised could be deemed a rational thinker ?

Oh, say, melanoma of the foreskin? Phimosis (as mentioned above)? Infection? ...
 
You must distinguish between newborn male circumcision and female genital mutilation. You can't even call the latter "circumcision" because there is no "foreskin" to remove. The former is a controversial medical procedure. The latter isn't.
It seems to me that the clitoral hood is somewhat analogous to the foreskin.
 
Oh, say, melanoma of the foreskin? Phimosis (as mentioned above)? Infection? ...
no one here is arguing against medically necessary circumcision, its routine and especially infant circumcision which I see as pretty much indefensible. there is an argument that a desire for unnecessary cosmetic surgery may be "irrational", but that is a different debate entirely.
 
Circumcision of males is no big deal. On one hand, there are a few rare complications. On the other hand, circumcised males suffer less from urinary tract infections, the very rare penile cancer, and possibly HIV.

As far as I'm aware, the only downside is the risk of complications, which are pretty rare and not usually serious. It is in no way comparable to female genital mutilation (which destroys a woman's capacity to ejoy sexual intercourse, or even endure it comfortably), nor to losing a limb.
According the American Cancer Society, you're wrong, and there's no statistically significant difference between circumcised and uncircumcised population. The biggest significant risk is unprotected sexual activity (exposure to HPV).

Women are roughly 10 times more likely to get labial cancer than men are to get penile cancer. The risk of male breast cancer is significantly higher than penile cancer.
 
There is a fairly common birth defect (hypospadous) in which the foreskin is normally used as a tissue supply for reconstructing the urethra. I had this done back in the 50s, required a series of operations at the time. (They are probably more efficient now) Mine seems to work OK...

I suppose you could consider it to be a form of "body modification", akin to piercings or tatooing in the case of males. The religious component is irrational, of course, but it's fairly widespread even amongst primitive peoples.

The female version is more aptly referred to as "genital mutilation", and normally involvs removal of the entire clitoris, as well as in some cases essentially sewing the labia closed. A reprehensible practice amongst peoples who still see women as property.
 
I am not a huge advocate of circumcision, HOWEVER, comparing it to female genital mutiliation is ridiculous, and shows how ignorant people are about the practice of FGM. It is usually performed on young girls to preteen age, without anesthesia, and involves removing the clitoris and the labia major, then sewing it shut. (Leaving a small hole for urination and mensturation) Women who undergo this RARELY experience pleasure from sex. I have never met a circumcised man (or had sex with one) who did not experience pleasure from sex.
If you want to debate whether or not circumcision should be performed, fine. But don't get ridiculous about it.
 
...snip...

The female version is more aptly referred to as "genital mutilation", and normally involvs removal of the entire clitoris, as well as in some cases essentially sewing the labia closed. A reprehensible practice amongst peoples who still see women as property.

Circumcision is genital mutilation, the fact it has it's own "acceptable" word just shows how embodied this assault is in many of our societies and cultures. Obviously and thankfully it is not mutilation to the same horrendous degree as what is inflicted on many women in other cultures that also allow physical mutilation to be carried out on non-consenting babies.
 
I am not a huge advocate of circumcision, HOWEVER, comparing it to female genital mutiliation is ridiculous, and shows how ignorant people are about the practice of FGM. It is usually performed on young girls to preteen age, without anesthesia, and involves removing the clitoris and the labia major, then sewing it shut. (Leaving a small hole for urination and mensturation) Women who undergo this RARELY experience pleasure from sex.


That is only one form of FGM:

http://www.unfpa.org/gender/faq_fgc.htm#4
 
I am not a huge advocate of circumcision, HOWEVER, comparing it to female genital mutiliation is ridiculous, and shows how ignorant people are about the practice of FGM. It is usually performed on young girls to preteen age, without anesthesia, and involves removing the clitoris and the labia major, then sewing it shut. (Leaving a small hole for urination and mensturation) Women who undergo this RARELY experience pleasure from sex. I have never met a circumcised man (or had sex with one) who did not experience pleasure from sex.
If you want to debate whether or not circumcision should be performed, fine. But don't get ridiculous about it.

As I said above in degree it is different however it is still genital mutilation for no rational reason. Part of the reason I believe it is still carried out is because the mutilation part of it is hidden behind a socially acceptable word - circumcision.

If parents were asked "Do you want us to assault your baby and mutilate his genitals?" I am sure many who would answer yes to "Do you want you baby circumcised?" would answer no.
 
Thanks for the link Geni - it shows how right Orwell was...

".... Recently, some organizations have opted to use the more neutral term ‘Female Genital Cutting’. This stems from the fact that communities that practice FGC often find the use of the term ‘mutilation’ demeaning since it seems to indicate malice on the part of parents or circumcisers. The use of judgmental terminology bears the risk of creating a backlash, thus possibly causing an alienation of communities that practice FGC or even causing an actual increase in the number of girls being subjected to FGC. In this respect it should be noted that the Special Rapporteur on Traditional Practices (ECOSOC, Commission on Human Rights) recently called for tact and patience regarding FGC eradication activities and warned against the dangers of demonizing cultures under cover of condemning practices harmful to women and girls (E/CN.4/Sub.2/1999/14)."

Yep let’s rename it to something that doesn't offend! That's rubbish and is trying to use words to hide the real meaning - it is mutilation (whether practiced on men or women).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom