Chavez taking necessary steps to ensure equality and liberty

If my memory serves, many people have done the former; some people have done the latter.

As far as I am concerned, you can post as you like on the topics you like, and have your credibility determined by those posts, as opposed to the country you live in.

So feel free.

I will not call " morons " people who have voted for George W.
I do not see the point insulting them.
I think it is better to understand people, rather than insulting them.
Just my personal opinion, then..
 
Oh, slightly OT digression. People from country (or state, or city, or something else) X elected Mr. Moron for president (or governor, or mayor, or something else). It doesn't mean these people are idiots. Maybe they voted on Mr. Moron just because he was the "less worse" option!

I doubt Al Gore could be called a " more worse " option.
Just my personal opinion
Digression, " less worse " is a grammar mistake.

Or because they were fooled by a marketing campaign...

Then they are morons..
Is that what you mean?

Or because it seemed a good idea by that time...

Not an excuse..
 
Well, maybe.

But if it weights like a duck, looks like a duck, tastes like a duck and quacks like a duck, how should I call it?

Is there an euphenism for demagogue? Populist, maybe?

Again, this can follow a Godwinian path pretty quickly...

So, let` s call George W. a criminal, and people who voted for him, accomplices in a crime..
Do you think this will help understand the present situation better or do any good?
 
I will not call " morons " people who have voted for George W.
I do not see the point insulting them.
I think it is better to understand people, rather than insulting them.
Just my personal opinion, then..

But you didn't ask which was "better."

You asked what should be "allowed."


What you feel is the "better" course has absolutely *no* connection to what you asked.
 
I doubt Al Gore could be called a " more worse " option.
Just my personal opinion
That's an important point, in case you have not noticed. Personal opinion. By the way, isn't this thread about Chavez?

Maybe people from Venezuela considered he was the "less worse" option. Or the lesser of two evils, if you preffer. Still, this can not change my personal opinion about him. Only his acts can change it. So far, they have confirmed.

Digression, " less worse " is a grammar mistake.
An intentional one, but since I make several mistakes... See some lines below for a confession of another one...

Then they are morons..
Is that what you mean?
Can it be inferred somehow from the text below?
Correa Neto said:
Or because they were fooled by a marketing campaign...
Only morons are fooled by marketing and propaganda campaings?
Only morons are victims of false advertising?

Feel free to call me a moron because I voted for Lula and his PT for many years, refusing to see the many signs that something was not right. Feel free to call me naïve for beliving they had a better political and economic proposal and would not make alliances with some politicians of dubious (dubious?) reputation.

Not an excuse..
Matteo, I wrote
Correa Neto said:
Or because it seemed a good idea by that time...
Take the example of my mistake (mea culpa, mea culpa, mea maxima culpa) by voting on Lula and his PT. It seemed a good idea at those times. Am I presenting an excuse? No. I am presenting a reason. I am not taking the burden of the error out of my shoulders.

I presented you reasons (propaganda, erroneous evaluation, delusion) for making mistakes while voting. There are many others. Note that I avoided speaking about ideology. Nothing of what I wrote has as an immediate and unique translation as "Voted for X? You are a moron." Neither it excuses anyone of the burden of a bad decision.

So, let` s call George W. a criminal, and people who voted for him, accomplices in a crime..
Do you think this will help understand the present situation better or do any good?
ARGH!
First of all, this thread is not about this individual... This put, sorry again, but the reasoning is a strawman.

Can you please explain me how saying a given politician is, say, a corrupt equals saying all his voters are corrupt?

What would you call this hypothetical politician if you considered the evidences you have so far indicate he is indeed corrupt? Would you use a politically correct euphenism?

Footnote:
Feel free to complain this thread is not about hypothetical politicians!
 
But you didn't ask which was "better."

You asked what should be "allowed."


What you feel is the "better" course has absolutely *no* connection to what you asked.

Playing with words, again..
If you ( we ) think that Chavez is a demagogoue, do we also think that Bush is a moron?
That is the question..
What about the people who voted for him ( Bush )?
 
That's an important point, in case you have not noticed. Personal opinion.

And mine was a personal opinion that Al Gore could hardly be seen as the " worse evil "

By the way, isn't this thread about Chavez?

Are we allowed to talk only about Chavez, in this thread?

Maybe people from Venezuela considered he was the "less worse" option. Or the lesser of two evils, if you preffer. Still, this can not change my personal opinion about him. Only his acts can change it. So far, they have confirmed.

In representative democracy you have to make a choice among a handful of candidates..
I do not know of any democracy, where people can choose between 1000 candidates for their president/Prime Minister, only democracies where you can choose between two, three, five..

An intentional one, but since I make several mistakes... See some lines below for a confession of another one...

OK.
Maybe the expression " lesser evil " is better

Can it be inferred somehow from the text below?

If you are claiming that voters have been fooled by a marketing campaign, that is very close to call them idiots ( IMHO )

Only morons are fooled by marketing and propaganda campaings?
Only morons are victims of false advertising?

We are not talking about a car, here.
We re talking about a president who has been elected twice, and, last time, he got the majority of the votes after 4 years of running office.
If you claim you have been deceived by a president, after four years that he has done his job publicly, but, when it is the time to vote him again, you do vote again for him, yes you can be called a " moron " ( at least, for voting for him again )
BTW, I do not claim that Americans were deceived by any marketing or political campaign..

Feel free to call me a moron because I voted for Lula and his PT for many years, refusing to see the many signs that something was not right. Feel free to call me naïve for beliving they had a better political and economic proposal and would not make alliances with some politicians of dubious (dubious?) reputation.

If, when there are the next elections, you still vote for Lula, sorry Correa for that, yes, you would become a moron, yes.
BTW.
I do not think, for the little I know, that Lula was so bad.

Matteo, I wrote

Take the example of my mistake (mea culpa, mea culpa, mea maxima culpa) by voting on Lula and his PT. It seemed a good idea at those times. Am I presenting an excuse? No. I am presenting a reason. I am not taking the burden of the error out of my shoulders.

I presented you reasons (propaganda, erroneous evaluation, delusion) for making mistakes while voting. There are many others. Note that I avoided speaking about ideology. Nothing of what I wrote has as an immediate and unique translation as "Voted for X? You are a moron." Neither it excuses anyone of the burden of a bad decision.

See above..

ARGH!
First of all, this thread is not about this individual... This put, sorry again, but the reasoning is a strawman.

Can you please explain me how saying a given politician is, say, a corrupt equals saying all his voters are corrupt?

No, I am not even saying that the politician is corrupt, or that Bush is a moron.
I am not saying anything.
But, if you are saying that Bush is a moron, that, in some way, implies that voters who have voted for him twice, can be called morons as well, do not you think?

What would you call this hypothetical politician if you considered the evidences you have so far indicate he is indeed corrupt? Would you use a politically correct euphenism?

Footnote:
Feel free to complain this thread is not about hypothetical politicians!

First af all, we are not speaking about corruption here.
We were talking about Chavez, who ahs been called a " demagogue " and an " aspiring dictator " in this thread ( even if he has never ruled out fre elections, so far ).
So, my question is, why should people here insult this guy, who has been elected in fair and free elections?
 
Last edited:
Playing with words, again..
If you ( we ) think that Chavez is a demagogoue, do we also think that Bush is a moron?
That is the question..
What about the people who voted for him ( Bush )?


This is completely out of left field.

This is where the communication is breaking down, apparently, because what you are writing has no real connection to my post being quoted by you.

This is *not* playing with words. If you cannot see a distinction, then that may explain why pretty much everyone in this thread seems to be having trouble following your points:

Again: You didn't ask which was "better." You asked what should be "allowed."

There is a huge difference in having an opinion regarding what is a "better" or "good" course of action, and taking the huge step of saying that something isn't "allowed."

You seem to take the position that Americans, for example, should not be "allowed" (your word) to give opinions on various topics.

When called on that, you fall back on giving an opinion regarding what is "better." This is a completely different issue.

I disagree with neo-Nazi's and the KKK, for example. I think they are beyond wrong -- they cross the line into what might be referred to in shorthand as "evil." However -- and this is the bit to pay attention to -- I would never advocate that they not be "allowed" to say their opinions.

As soon as you set yourself (or anyone) as an ultimate arbiter of truth -- the one that decides what people should be "allowed" to say -- you've done a horrible disservice to the truth itself, even if you are actually, objectively right. Say people are wrong. Say you disagree. Say that they are morons, if you like.

But don't start preaching about what type of opinions are going to be "allowed."
 
This is completely out of left field.

This is where the communication is breaking down, apparently, because what you are writing has no real connection to my post being quoted by you.

This is *not* playing with words. If you cannot see a distinction, then that may explain why pretty much everyone in this thread seems to be having trouble following your points:

Again: You didn't ask which was "better." You asked what should be "allowed."

There is a huge difference in having an opinion regarding what is a "better" or "good" course of action, and taking the huge step of saying that something isn't "allowed."

You seem to take the position that Americans, for example, should not be "allowed" (your word) to give opinions on various topics.

When called on that, you fall back on giving an opinion regarding what is "better." This is a completely different issue.

I disagree with neo-Nazi's and the KKK, for example. I think they are beyond wrong -- they cross the line into what might be referred to in shorthand as "evil." However -- and this is the bit to pay attention to -- I would never advocate that they not be "allowed" to say their opinions.

As soon as you set yourself (or anyone) as an ultimate arbiter of truth -- the one that decides what people should be "allowed" to say -- you've done a horrible disservice to the truth itself, even if you are actually, objectively right. Say people are wrong. Say you disagree. Say that they are morons, if you like.

But don't start preaching about what type of opinions are going to be "allowed."

What a tirade just for two words!!
Of course, I am not saying that anyone should not be allowed to speak about Chavez.
I find it is obvious, there are rules in this forum ( and I am not the one who makes them ), therefore, everybody is legally allowed to say anything they want, according to those rules.
When I say that people who live in the US should not speak to Chavez as a " demagogue " or as an " aspiring dictator ", it does not mean, that they are legally or by any reason limited in their freedom to speak, I just point out that, before speaking, their should think about the situation in their own country ( called the " clean-your-back-yard-first " thing ).
I think this is pretty clear reading my posts.
I can not see why you want to make a case out of this, except for the reason of making me lose time.
 
As soon as you set yourself (or anyone) as an ultimate arbiter of truth -- the one that decides what people should be "allowed" to say -- you've done a horrible disservice to the truth itself, even if you are actually, objectively right. Say people are wrong. Say you disagree. Say that they are morons, if you like.

Yawn..
 
And mine was a personal opinion that Al Gore could hardly be seen as the " worse evil "
OK, but please note some people would disagree. And they have several reasons for this other than being morons. Some of them are morons, but some of the people who voted for Gore are also morons... I fail to see where saying "Mr. X is a moron (or a demagogue, or an aspiring dictator, or a criminal, or corrupt)" equals to saying "everyone who voted for X is a moron (or a demagogue, or an aspiring dictator, or a criminal, or corrupt)".

Are we allowed to talk only about Chavez, in this thread?
As far as I know, no, since I am talking also about other real and immaginary politicians, but it seems to me (and I may be wrong) that you are trying to find a way to bring Bush to the spotlight. And he would not be, in my personal opinion, the best option for a comparison with Chavez.

In representative democracy you have to make a choice among a handful of candidates..
I do not know of any democracy, where people can choose between 1000 candidates for their president/Prime Minister, only democracies where you can choose between two, three, five..
So what Matteo?
Do you think its so improbable that among say, five candidates, to find not a single good candidate? I don't. More than once I´ve seen such situation, where I had to choose the "lesser evil". If in five you may not find an adequate option, in just two...

OK.
Maybe the expression " lesser evil " is better
OK, see above. But I still find funnier the complete wreck that "less worse" is.

If you are claiming that voters have been fooled by a marketing campaign, that is very close to call them idiots ( IMHO )
...snip...
I disagree.
Regardless if you like it or not, nowadays, politicians, religions, ideologies and cars are marketed...

Note that there are many possible reasons for a vote. From the moronic "I vote him because he's from my religion" to the "lesser evil", passing, among many, "because I agree with his positions regarding economy and politics".

I do not think, for the little I know, that Lula was so bad.
Given his background, given all he preached before being elected, he was quite a disappointment for me and many other people. Same rotten politicians from before nowadays are orbiting him.

Uh Oh, plane taking off now. Will continue this later
 
OK
You can express your disagreement with the other country position, but that does not mean you should call their leader as " demagogue ", right?
Why not? What's wrong with using the word demagogue to encapsulate my criticism of Chavez's administration to this point.
There are other ( politer ) ways to express disagreement, right?
Since when is it impolite to use the word "demagogue"?

A demagogue is merely "a person, esp. an orator or political leader, who gains power and popularity by arousing the emotions, passions, and prejudices of the people."

As far as describing Chavez' modus operandi, I think it an apt description and I have no idea why you think it impolite to describe Chavez in that way.

Do you understand what "demagogue" means, Matteo? The was you write about the word, it appears you don't actually understand it and think it is some sort of insult on the man's character, rather than a description of his political theater.

"By the way, since we are allowed here to criticize ( and insult ) other freely elected leaders, am I allowed to call Bush a " moron "?"
Of course you are allowed to do that. And your statement would be even more apt if you go on to explain why Bush is a moron (i.e., "a person who is notably stupid or lacking in good judgment").
 
Why not? What's wrong with using the word demagogue to encapsulate my criticism of Chavez's administration to this point.

Since when is it impolite to use the word "demagogue"?

A demagogue is merely "a person, esp. an orator or political leader, who gains power and popularity by arousing the emotions, passions, and prejudices of the people."

Gaining power arousing prejudices..
Not the best quality for a politician..

As far as describing Chavez' modus operandi, I think it an apt description and I have no idea why you think it impolite to describe Chavez in that way.

Do you understand what "demagogue" means, Matteo? The was you write about the word, it appears you don't actually understand it and think it is some sort of insult on the man's character, rather than a description of his political theater.

The word " demagogue " comes from old Greek, which is a language I studied.
Did you?

Of course you are allowed to do that. And your statement would be even more apt if you go on to explain why Bush is a moron (i.e., "a person who is notably stupid or lacking in good judgment").

Because he ( unlike Chavez ) started an unneccessary war, based on faulty intelligence, which led to some tens of thousands of civilian deaths
So, since you called Chavez as " demagogue ", can you also call Bush, with even more reason, at least as a moron?
What about the people who voted ( twice!! ) for him?
Can we ( you included ) call them as morons as well?
If you insult ( yes, " demagogue " is an insult ) Chavez, why not insulting Bush ( and the people who voted for him ) as well, since he has done bad things Chavez has never done?
Why only calling Chavez as a " demagogue " and not Bush as a " moron "?
Is that only because Bush is your President while Chavez is not?
Not fair..
Not fair..
 
Last edited:
OK, but please note some people would disagree. And they have several reasons for this other than being morons. Some of them are morons, but some of the people who voted for Gore are also morons... I fail to see where saying "Mr. X is a moron (or a demagogue, or an aspiring dictator, or a criminal, or corrupt)" equals to saying "everyone who voted for X is a moron (or a demagogue, or an aspiring dictator, or a criminal, or corrupt)".

No way.
If you vote for a President twice, after he has already shown for four years what he is doing and who he is, and you claim that that president is a moron, then, you should also call the people who vote for him as morons.
Disclaimer
I have not called Bush as " moron ", not I have called Chavez as a " demagogue " or as " aspiring dictator ".
Just wanted to know why it is OK to call Chavez as demagogue and not Bush ( and the people who voted for him ) as " moron "

As far as I know, no, since I am talking also about other real and immaginary politicians, but it seems to me (and I may be wrong) that you are trying to find a way to bring Bush to the spotlight. And he would not be, in my personal opinion, the best option for a comparison with Chavez.

It seems to me, that people here are very quick in throwing names against other countries people and presidents, but, not as quick to ackonwledge their own mistakes, and the disasters they have done

So what Matteo?
Do you think its so improbable that among say, five candidates, to find not a single good candidate? I don't. More than once I´ve seen such situation, where I had to choose the "lesser evil". If in five you may not find an adequate option, in just two...

Again, I do not think that Al Gore and John Kerry were so bad people, that the voters had to resort to vote Bush, even if they did not want him, just because it was so bad to vote for Al Gore and John Kerry

OK, see above. But I still find funnier the complete wreck that "less worse" is.

OK

I disagree.
Regardless if you like it or not, nowadays, politicians, religions, ideologies and cars are marketed...

OK

Note that there are many possible reasons for a vote. From the moronic "I vote him because he's from my religion" to the "lesser evil", passing, among many, "because I agree with his positions regarding economy and politics".

Wait a second.
If you voted for him, because you consider his ( right ) economic positions more important than, say, his ( wrong ) positions on a war that has killed tens of thousands of people, well, some people may call you a " moron " for that too..
Anyway, you take responsability of your vote.
Too easy, to say, I voted for him ( twice ), but I have no ( few ) responsabilities of what he has done

Given his background, given all he preached before being elected, he was quite a disappointment for me and many other people. Same rotten politicians from before nowadays are orbiting him.

The Brazilian economy is growing fast..

Uh Oh, plane taking off now. Will continue this later

Have a nice fly..
 
Gaining power arousing prejudices..
Not the best quality for a politician..
No, it's not. But that shoult not prevent me from calling a demagogue a demagogue.

The word " demagogue " comes from old Greek, which is a language I studied. Did you?
As a matter of fact, yes. And Latin, Spanish and a smattering of Hebrew.

But as I was writing in English and not in Ancient Greek, I clearly was using the English definition of the word.

Because he ( unlike Chavez ) started an unneccessary war, based on faulty intelligence, which led to some tens of thousands of civilian deaths
So, since you called Chavez as " demagogue ", can you also call Bush, with even more reason, at least as a moron?
Yes, Bush is a moron.

Did you conveniently forget that I already told you I'm not a fan of Bush, did not vote for him and oppose him in every peaceful way I can?

Bush is a moron. He is a demagogue. He is a bad President. But this thread is about Chavez, despite all your attempts to make it about Bush.

What about the people who voted ( twice!! ) for him?
I don't judge people merely on the basis of their Presidential votes.

If you insult ( yes, " demagogue " is an insult ) Chavez, why not insulting Bush ( and the people who voted for him ) as well, since he has done bad things Chavez has never done?
I will call Bush a moron, as you just insinuated you would. Will you now agree Chavez is a demagogue?
Is that only because Bush is your President while Chavez is not?
Matteo, if you can't even remember what I wrote in post 169, not so long ago, what are to we conclude about your ability to reason?
 
As a matter of fact, yes. And Latin, Spanish and a smattering of Hebrew.

But as I was writing in English and not in Ancient Greek, I clearly was using the English definition of the word.

Which comes from Greek.
Ok, we both know the use of the word " demagogue "

Yes, Bush is a moron.

Did you conveniently forget that I already told you I'm not a fan of Bush, did not vote for him and oppose him in every peaceful way I can?

Bush is a moron. He is a demagogue. He is a bad President. But this thread is about Chavez, despite all your attempts to make it about Bush.

No, no, I am not trying to make this post about Bush, and I am impressed that you did call Bush a " moron " and a " demagogue ", something I have never dared to do.
Now, to bring the argument a little bit further, do not you think that American people should share the guilt for a bad decision?

I don't judge people merely on the basis of their Presidential votes.

Not merely on the basis on their presidential vote.
But, how would you call a person who voted ( twice ) for a president who you called as " moron " and as " demagogue "?
How would you call this person?
Deluded?

I will call Bush a moron, as you just insinuated you would. Will you now agree Chavez is a demagogue?

Err,.. well.. I am not used to call other people names, but, well, since you have been so frank with Bush, well, yes, we can say that Chavez is a demagogue..
 
Which comes from Greek.
Ok, we both know the use of the word " demagogue "
Actually, we've established that I know the definition of the word demagogue (in English). You certainly haven't established that you do.

No, no, I am not trying to make this post about Bush, and I am impressed that you did call Bush a " moron " and a " demagogue ", something I have never dared to do.
Why not? Maybe this is lost in translation, but when someone claims they "have never dared to do" something, it indicates they are fearful of doing such a thing. Do you mean to write that you are afraid of calling Bush a moron?

Now, to bring the argument a little bit further, do not you think that American people should share the guilt for a bad decision?
I don't believe in collective guilt. I don't blame Venezuelans for electing Chavez. I blame Chavez for his own policies. I don't blame Americans for Bush's errors. I don't blame Russians for Putin's errors. I don't blame Italians for Prodi's errors. And now, I will not continue to derail this thread further. Unless your comments are about Chavez, I will be ignoring them in this thread.

Not merely on the basis on their presidential vote.
Well, then your admonition to "clean my own backyard" doesn't apply to me, does it?

yes, we can say that Chavez is a demagogue..
See, that wasn't so difficult, was it?
 
No way.
If you vote for a President twice, after he has already shown for four years what he is doing and who he is, and you claim that that president is a moron, then, you should also call the people who vote for him as morons.
Forget about Bush/Gore for a momment. Think in broader terms. Do you really think its always such a black-and-white situation? It's always good guy x bad guy?

Let me present an example. I said Lula was a disappointment for me. Would I vote for him again? It depends, Matteo... Before his re-election, there was a chance that the other candidate would be a politician who has the nasty tendency of mixing religion with politics and is involved with several issues related to corruption and has poor administrative skills, among other things.

Lesser evil (or "less worse") voting policy, Matteo... Dumping my vote on the garbage bin would be a moronic act. In this case, I think the right way, the only way, would be to do what we called back in the millitary dictatorship times the "usefull vote". Lula would have my vote, again.

Disclaimer
I have not called Bush as " moron ", not I have called Chavez as a " demagogue " or as " aspiring dictator ".
Just wanted to know why it is OK to call Chavez as demagogue and not Bush ( and the people who voted for him ) as " moron "
When I say Chavez is a demagogue, I can back my opinion. For example, he threatened to expropriate supermarkets that were not selling goods (meat, milk, eggs, etc.) at the price that was set by his government (http://oglobo.globo.com/economia/mat/2007/02/15/294585756.asp). Two prime examples of demagogy and flawed policy, in my opinion. Weights like a duck, quacks like a duck, looks like a duck, tates like a duck...

So, if you can back the "Bush is a moron" statement, you are free to call him a moron.

Now, going further and making such a sweeping statement as "all Bush voters are morons" or "all Chavez voters are dummies" is just plain wrong, for the reasons I exposed before.

It seems to me, that people here are very quick in throwing names against other countries people and presidents, but, not as quick to ackonwledge their own mistakes, and the disasters they have done
Sweeping generalization, Matteo. I take full responsability for what now I consider as a bad decision.

Again, I do not think that Al Gore and John Kerry were so bad people, that the voters had to resort to vote Bush, even if they did not want him, just because it was so bad to vote for Al Gore and John Kerry
Your opinion, Matteo. You may be wrong. You can't really say all these people thought "it was bad" voting Gore or Kerry or that Bush voters are morons. Try wearing their shoes, try thinking like some of them at the elections. I will not deny that there are morons (on both sides).

FYI, I do not agree with Bush in many ways. But I don't support making sweeping generalizations about the people who voted for him (or Gore, or Kerry, or Chavez, or Lula), even if I disagree with them.

Wait a second.
If you voted for him, because you consider his ( right ) economic positions more important than, say, his ( wrong ) positions on a war that has killed tens of thousands of people, well, some people may call you a " moron " for that too..
Maybe. But this does not mean they are right and I am a moron. It may have been my mis-evaluation, it may have been because I was really scared by "the terrorist threat to the free world", it may have been because I felt despite his errors in Iraq he's got better chances to deal with it than the other guy...

Anyway, you take responsability of your vote.
Too easy, to say, I voted for him ( twice ), but I have no ( few ) responsabilities of what he has done
Wait wait wait...
Who's saying "we are not responsible"?
Me?

I'm just saying that making a sweeping generalization such as "they are all morons" is not right.

The Brazilian economy is growing fast..
Not as fast as it could, not as fast as it should.
And its not growing because Lula. Its growing because some private companies are growing, mostly fueled by external markets demand. Its their work, not this government's work.
We have serious transportation and power generation/transmittion problems that threaten this growth. And Lula, so far, has done very little to solve the problems besides talking, talking and talking a bit more.

Have a nice fly..
Thanks. It was pretty routine...
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom