Chavez taking necessary steps to ensure equality and liberty

OK, but Chavez said its imposed by American imperialism. Check the second link. OK, its in Portuguese, but I guess Italian is close enough to it so you can understand most of it. OK, I may be biased since I studied a bit of Italian.

How whould you call such declaration?

I do not call it at all.
It is Chavez` s opinion.
As long as Chavez does not makes anything bad to other nations, he should be entitled of his opinions.
Now, how would you call George H. W.` declaration that Chavez is an " ass "?
Is he a demagogue, too?

OK, they should handle it, but...

Its my opinion that I -as well as anybody else, with or without clean backyards- can call a guy a demagogue if his actions point towards this directions.

Then we disagree.
I do not think that ( especially, but not only ) Americans should criticize Venezuela` s domestic policy after all their president has done in Iraq.
Of course, I would not prohibit ( even if I were the only moderator of the forum ) anyone to criticize any other leader, I just find it hypocrital.
Of course, this is just my private opinion.

Are the voters of Venezuela responsible for such nonsensical measures? Should they be blamed for these things? Are Chavez voters demagogues? Including those who do not support him? Or those who only partially support(ed) him?

I do not think you can all a voter as demagogue.
It looks like contradiction in terms..

The board of a company should handle the consequences of their decisions. But its shareholers are not the only ones who can -and in some cases should- criticize them. So we, bystanders of foreign politicians making their silly and/or dangerous moves are entitled to do the same.

Please, tell me which " dangerous " moves has Chavez done, so far?
Has he started any war, recently?
 
I guess you don't want to stop the discussion. I stand corrected once again.
No.
The point of discussion were the elections
The point of this whole thread has been the shutting down of a tv station, since the first post. You tried to change the topic and I'm not playing that game, Matteo.

That how democracy works.
Democracy requires a free media, Matteo. For you to change th egolaposts shows an astounding lack of understanding.

I have given you other 5 or 6 different sentences with the same meaning.
None of them make any sense, Matteo. The phrase you began with is nonsensical. It sounds like you put an Italian phrase through a computer translator and it came out as gibberish.

There is a huge difference.
Please, think about it.
There are lots of differences betwee AIDS policies and

If the AIDS policy of one nation actively leads to thousands of avoidable deaths
But it doesn't. Randi's criticism was of a public statement. Notwithstanding that statement, South Africa still imports AIDS medications. You seem to fundamentally ignorant about what James Randi (the "JR" in "JREF") is criticizing. (More specifically, you seem to be making up facts to justify your nonsensical position.

You wrote ( post n. 205 ):
" Chavez makes it a crime to use a picture of the late Luciano Pavorotti as your avatar in any website that can be viewed from Venezuela. [..] "

I beg your pardon, but, this is a stupid example.
It's a hypothetical, not an example and you didn't answer the question.

" Talk " not.equal.to " speaking loud against "
As, we found out, that I never told people it is inappropriate to talk about Chavez in a thread about Chavez ".
So we're only aloud to agree with Chavez? Since I desire to criticize him, then yes, you did tell me not to talk about Chavez because the talking I wish to do is critical talking. For you to try to parse words like this is silly.

I do think that you should not criticize Chavez` internal policy bacause of what your President has done in Iraq.
So in your opinion I can only speak in glowing terms about Chavez?! Really. That's the position that you want to stake out on a skeptics' forum?

Your hypotheticals were quite stupid, sorry, if I use a strong word.
So you admit you didn't respond to them?
How can you define this hypothetical?
Your post n. 205:
" Chavez makes it illegal to worship in the Hindu faith. "
Do you really expect me to comment on this?
Yes, I do, Matteo. Your answer would have been illustrative. Clearly, you're not interested in discussing viws. You're only interested in getting people not to criticize Chavez.

Ours means all the other readers of the forum?[/uote]
No, the Americans you are tired of listening to.

Just guessing..
Are you even aware that this is a forum for skeptics?

If you see a thief entering another person` s house or killing another person, would you at least call the police?
Even if the other person, is not a relative or friend of yours?
You have a weird sense of justice..
I will answer you stupid hypotheticals when you answer mine and not before.
 
I guess you don't want to stop the discussion. I stand corrected once again.

I am not very interested, to talk with a stubborn guy, which is not willing to engage in a fair discussion

The point of this whole thread has been the shutting down of a tv station, since the first post. You tried to change the topic and I'm not playing that game, Matteo.

The point of our discussion, started from your post n. 205

Your reply ( 205 ):
Because too many factors go into a single vote. Who were the other options? Were the voters deceived by the candidate? [..]

Democracy requires a free media, Matteo. For you to change th egolaposts shows an astounding lack of understanding.

The concept of " free media " as necessary for democracy is debatable.
In Italy, during Berlusconi, we had Berlusconi choosing the board of the three public nationals televisions, and Berlusconi directly owning the three private public televisions.
Does that mean that the media were free, in your opinion?
Does that mean Italy was not a democracy, under Berlusconi?

None of them make any sense, Matteo. The phrase you began with is nonsensical. It sounds like you put an Italian phrase through a computer translator and it came out as gibberish.

OK
You are not willing to debate on this.
Let` s stop.

There are lots of differences betwee AIDS policies and

And?

But it doesn't. Randi's criticism was of a public statement. Notwithstanding that statement, South Africa still imports AIDS medications. You seem to fundamentally ignorant about what James Randi (the "JR" in "JREF") is criticizing. (More specifically, you seem to be making up facts to justify your nonsensical position.

I can not read everything Randi writes.
I think that criticizing South Africa` s current stance on fight on AIDS is correct, for the reasons I have stated.

It's a hypothetical, not an example and you didn't answer the question.

Your hypothetical:
" Chavez makes it a crime to use a picture of the late Luciano Pavorotti as your avatar in any website that can be viewed from Venezuela. [..] "
is stupid, sorry..

So we're only aloud to agree with Chavez?

Never said that you have to agree with Chavez

Since I desire to criticize him, then yes, you did tell me not to talk about Chavez because the talking I wish to do is critical talking. For you to try to parse words like this is silly.

Yawn..

So in your opinion I can only speak in glowing terms about Chavez?! Really. That's the position that you want to stake out on a skeptics' forum?

Never said that you have to " speak in glowing terms " about Chavez
You are mis-representing my position ( a gentle term, for not calling you a liar )

So you admit you didn't respond to them?

I did respond to them, even if they were stupid hypotheticals.

Yes, I do, Matteo. Your answer would have been illustrative. Clearly, you're not interested in discussing viws. You're only interested in getting people not to criticize Chavez.

I am not very much interested in answering to your hypothetical:
" Chavez makes it illegal to worship in the Hindu faith ".

No, the Americans you are tired of listening to.

Some ( few ) Americans..

Are you even aware that this is a forum for skeptics?

Re-yawn..

I will answer you stupid hypotheticals when you answer mine and not before.

My hypothetical:

" If you see a thief entering another person` s house or killing another person, would you at least call the police?
Even if the other person, is not a relative or friend of yours? "

is not stupid

Your hypothetical:

" Chavez makes it illegal to worship in the Hindu faith "

is stupid.

I feel sad that you can not appreciate the difference.
But, if you do not get it, it is your problem.
BTW
Can I ask you how old are you?
I am 35
 
Last edited:
I do not call it at all.
It is Chavez` s opinion.
Opinion?
The guys said timezones are imposed by American imperialism!
Just an opinion?
Plain and simple demagogic ********, quite possibly coupled with ignorance or an attempt to explore ignorance.
And this comes from a guy who wants to reform education...
What's next?
Abolish the metric system in favor of a "Bolivarian" system?
Timecube guy for minister of education?
OK, that was a slippery slope argument, my bad...

As long as Chavez does not makes anything bad to other nations, he should be entitled of his opinions.
Matteo, as I told you before, Chavez's speeches and actions can potentially (potentially?) harm other Latin American nations.

Not to mention that if he is entitled to have his opinions, and express them, so am I as well as anyone else!

Now, how would you call George H. W.` declaration that Chavez is an " ass "?
"Ass" was IMHO a bit heavy-handed, since dimplomacy usually requires a polite packing to the message.
Aniway, If he can back his point, he is entitled to do so- just as I am, just like everyone else should be. See above!

Is he a demagogue, too?
Bush?
Ah, yes, I would say yes, since the "god tod me to do" line is cheap demagogy.

Then we disagree.
I do not think that ( especially, but not only ) Americans should criticize Venezuela` s domestic policy after all their president has done in Iraq.
Of course, I would not prohibit ( even if I were the only moderator of the forum ) anyone to criticize any other leader, I just find it hypocrital.
Of course, this is just my private opinion.
I can't help but disagree.
You are again making a sweeping generalization.
Politicians take decisions following their own minds. The consequences of their decisions weight upon their shoulders.
Besides this, not all Americans voted for Bush and not all Bush voters comletely agree with his external and internal policies.

Suppose a CEO says and/or makes something that may or will have a negative impact on his company. You have no shares of that company. His actions, however, may have a negative impact on a company whose shares you own. Want a reali-life example? Google for Briex and gold.
Its internal business, but its your right to say what you think this guy really is.
Even if its impossible for you to be affected somehow by his actions, its your right to express your opinions.

I do not think you can all a voter as demagogue.
It looks like contradiction in terms..
But you want voters to be fully responsible for the actions of their elected candidates... Your reasoning implies the voters are in full agreement with their candidates...
You are contradicting yourself!

Please, tell me which " dangerous " moves has Chavez done, so far?
For some reason you are failing to comprehend what I wrote, Matteo, maybe because English is not our first language...
Here's what I wrote (check the bold):
Correa Neto said:
So we, bystanders of foreign politicians making their silly and/or dangerous moves are entitled to do the same.

Chavez makes silly things?
I think so. I exposed some of them.
Chavez makes things that are potentially (potentially?) dangerous to his country and Latin America as a whole?
Yes, and I shown some of them.
My personal opinion is that calling him a demagogue might even be a bit on the "light side"...

Has he started any war, recently?
No.
But some months ago, when our president visited Venezuela in the heat of the ethanol discussions (Brazil and Venezuela have different perspectives), Chavez was eager to show his new toys- Sukhoi fighters- as soon as Lula set his feet at the airfield.
Coincidence?
Bad diplomacy?
"Mine is bigger than yours?"

And you know, there are persistent rumors about Chavez and guerrillas at other countries...
 
Last edited:
Opinion?
The guys said timezones are imposed by American imperialism!
Just an opinion?
Plain and simple demagogic ********, quite possibly coupled with ignorance or an attempt to explore ignorance.
And this comes from a guy who wants to reform education...
What's next?
Abolish the metric system in favor of a "Bolivarian" system?
Timecube guy for minister of education?
OK, that was a slippery slope argument, my bad...

Now, did the decision of changing time zones harm or killed anyone?
Chavez wanted to change the time zone of the country he is President.
So what?
Is that a problem for you and me?
About what he said, many leaders say stupid things, look at what Putin recently said:

Putin praises sexual prowess of Israeli president
http://www.guardian.co.uk/russia/article/0,,1927726,00.html

Shall we call Putin too, as a demagogue?

What about our own Berlusconi?

"The role of kapo would be perfect for you", Berlusconi
http://globalfire.tv/nj/03en/politics/kaposchulz.htm

Shall we call Berlusconi too, as a demagogue?

See, how biased you are?

Matteo, as I told you before, Chavez's speeches and actions can potentially (potentially?) harm other Latin American nations.

Presidents of any nations make decisions that harm other nations all the time.
Chavez is no exception.
Lula is no excpetion.
Morales is no exception.
Not to speak about Bush, Prodi, Sarkozy, Merkel, ..

Not to mention that if he is entitled to have his opinions, and express them, so am I as well as anyone else!

If you say that he is entitled to have opinions, you can not call him a " demagogue ", when he expresses his opinions, just because you do not like them..

"Ass" was IMHO a bit heavy-handed, since dimplomacy usually requires a polite packing to the message.
Aniway, If he can back his point, he is entitled to do so- just as I am, just like everyone else should be. See above!

If you say that he is entitled to have opinions, you can not call him a " demagogue ", when he expresses his opinions, just because you do not like them..

Bush?
Ah, yes, I would say yes, since the "god tod me to do" line is cheap demagogy.

I see..
So, Bush is a demagogue too..
What about Berlusconi?
What about Putin?

I can't help but disagree.
You are again making a sweeping generalization.
Politicians take decisions following their own minds. The consequences of their decisions weight upon their shoulders.
Besides this, not all Americans voted for Bush and not all Bush voters comletely agree with his external and internal policies.

Suppose a CEO says and/or makes something that may or will have a negative impact on his company. You have no shares of that company. His actions, however, may have a negative impact on a company whose shares you own. Want a reali-life example? Google for Briex and gold.
Its internal business, but its your right to say what you think this guy really is.
Even if its impossible for you to be affected somehow by his actions, its your right to express your opinions.

So, Chavez is entitled to express his own opinions ( without being called as a " demagogue " ).

But you want voters to be fully responsible for the actions of their elected candidates... Your reasoning implies the voters are in full agreement with their candidates...
You are contradicting yourself!

No, as I did not call the leader ( Chavez ) as a demagogue, in first place.

For some reason you are failing to comprehend what I wrote, Matteo, maybe because English is not our first language...
Here's what I wrote (check the bold):


Chavez makes silly things?
I think so. I exposed some of them.
Chavez makes things that are potentially (potentially?) dangerous to his country and Latin America as a whole?
Yes, and I shown some of them.
My personal opinion is that calling him a demagogue might even be a bit on the "light side"...

OK.
If you want, I can give you a list of silly things that Bush, Berlusconi, Prodi, Shinzo Abe, .. have done so far.
And, I only speak about those countries as they are the only ones I know, but I bet the same could be said for many many other nations.
About " dangerous moves ", what about Russia:

Russia cuts Ukraine gas supplies
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/europe/4572712.stm

What about Japan?

Abe refrains from stating position on Yasukuni visit
http://findarticles.com/p/articles/mi_m0WDQ/is_2006_June_5/ai_n16442309

Are Shinzo Abe, Vladimir Putin all demagogues?

See that you are biased?

No.
But some months ago, when our president visited Venezuela in the heat of the ethanol discussions (Brazil and Venezuela have different perspectives), Chavez was eager to show his new toys- Sukhoi fighters- as soon as Lula set his feet at the airfield.
Coincidence?
Bad diplomacy?
"Mine is bigger than yours?"

And you know, there are persistent rumors about Chavez and guerrillas at other countries...

What about the nuclear arsenals of Russia, US, UK, France, Israel, Pakistan, India?
Are Putin, Bush, Brown, Sarkozy, Olmert, .. all " demagogues "?
 
Presidents of any nations make decisions that harm other nations all the time.
Chavez is no exception.
Lula is no excpetion.
Morales is no exception.
Not to speak about Bush, Prodi, Sarkozy, Merkel, ..
And whenever they take these decisions, its everyone's right to discuss them and to labell the decision makers according to their acts, regardless of who they are and where they are from.
If Chavez and Lula use demagogy, so they are demagogues.
Same is valid for anyone else.

If you say that he is entitled to have opinions, you can not call him a " demagogue ", when he expresses his opinions, just because you do not like them.. ...snip...
Matteo, the answer to all the other "see how biased you are?" follows:
All it takes for me to call someone a demagogue are demagogic acts from the part of this individual. This is independent of my agreement (or lack of agreement) with the said person(s).

It sems you don't have a clue on which of the cited politicians I agree or not, but this is irrelevant. But the following is relevant: If they make demagogic acts, then they are demagogues, regardless of their positions. If they like to play their wardrums, then they are beligerant. Took part on corruption schemes? Then they are corrupt. Somehow tried to supress democracy? Then they are anti-democratic. Using you own line, "see how biased you are?"

No, as I did not call the leader ( Chavez ) as a demagogue, in first place.
But I did. And I stand by this declaration, since it was based on his own acts.
Again, if it quacks like a duck, acts like a duck, weights like a duck, looks a like a duck and tastes like a duck and has a duck's DNA, why not calling it a duck?

"Because this duck is the leader of a nation" is not a valid reason. Its just politically correct crap IMHO. And unfair crap also, since it gives them a status they do not deserve.

And the Briex guys, Matteo? What are we allowed to call them?
And Moralez?
And Pinochet?
And Salazar?
And Franco?
And Peron?
And Fidel?
And the Pope?
And Jerry Falwell?
And Uri Geller?
And me?
And you?

What about the nuclear arsenals of Russia, US, UK, France, Israel, Pakistan, India?
Matteo, this obfuscation attempt will not make the fact that Chavez attenpts to interfer in other countries' internal politics...

Are Putin, Bush, Brown, Sarkozy, Olmert, .. all " demagogues "?
Read above.
 
Last edited:
And whenever they take these decisions, its everyone's right to discuss them and to labell the decision makers according to their acts, regardless of who they are and where they are from.
If Chavez and Lula use demagogy, so they are demagogues.
Same is valid for anyone else.

So, what about " Bush, Prodi, Sarkozy, Merkel, .. "??
Are they, sometimes, harming other nations?
Are they also demagogues?
Can I ask you, which world leader can not be called as a demagogue?

Matteo, the answer to all the other "see how biased you are?" follows:
All it takes for me to call someone a demagogue are demagogic acts from the part of this individual. This is independent of my agreement (or lack of agreement) with the said person(s).

The word " demagogic acts " are not univoque.
Are based on subjective judgment.
Is Putin a demagogue?
If not, why not?
What about the French foreign minister, who spoke about war with Iran?

It sems you don't have a clue on which of the cited politicians I agree or not, but this is irrelevant. But the following is relevant: If they make demagogic acts, then they are demagogues, regardless of their positions. If they like to play their wardrums, then they are beligerant. Took part on corruption schemes? Then they are corrupt. Somehow tried to supress democracy? Then they are anti-democratic. Using you own line, "see how biased you are?"

I can not avoid to think that politics are not mathematics.
Definitions as " demagogue " are based on internal judgment.
How many Americans think Bush is not a demagogue?
Are they all wrong/stupid/ignorant/biased??
I do not think so..

But I did. And I stand by this declaration, since it was based on his own acts.
Again, if it quacks like a duck, acts like a duck, weights like a duck, looks a like a duck and tastes like a duck and has a duck's DNA, why not calling it a duck?

You wrote:
" But you want voters to be fully responsible for the actions of their elected candidates... Your reasoning implies the voters are in full agreement with their candidates...
You are contradicting yourself! "

I am not contradicting my self as I did not call the leader ( Chavez ) as a demagogue, in first place.

"Because this duck is the leader of a nation" is not a valid reason. Its just politically correct crap IMHO. And unfair crap also, since it gives them a status they do not deserve.

Because the duck has been freely elected.

And the Briex guys, Matteo? What are we allowed to call them?
And Moralez?
And Pinochet?
And Salazar?
And Franco?
And Peron?
And Fidel?
And the Pope?
And Jerry Falwell?
And Uri Geller?
And me?
And you?

And Merkel?
Putin?
Prodi?
Sarkozy?
Abe?
All demagogues?

Matteo, this obfuscation attempt will not make the fact that Chavez attenpts to interfer in other countries' internal politics...

Not 1/100 of what Americans do, and you know it..
 
The point of our discussion, started from your post n. 205

Your reply ( 205 ):
Because too many factors go into a single vote. Who were the other options? Were the voters deceived by the candidate? [..]
No, Matteo. Our discussion is a subset of the topic, which is the attempt to silence media dissent. Clearly you didn't understand what I wrote. I think we've now cleared it up.

The concept of " free media " as necessary for democracy is debatable.
Holy crap. You really believe that one can have a democracy without having a free media?!

In Italy, during Berlusconi, we had Berlusconi choosing the board of the three public nationals televisions, and Berlusconi directly owning the three private public televisions.
Does that mean that the media were free, in your opinion?
Does that mean Italy was not a democracy, under Berlusconi?
Are Italians illiterates unable to read newspapers?

At any rate, I do think that Berlusconi's control over Italian media was troubling, to say the least. Don't you?

You are not willing to debate on this.
I'm willing to debate it, if you would write it in intelligible English.

I can not read everything Randi writes.
Are you kidding me? This is a skeptic's forum. He only puts out a brief newsletter once a week, and you can't even be bothered to read it?

Never said that you have to agree with Chavez
You said I should not "criticize" Chaven but that I can "talk" about him. If the only "talk" I can no is not "criticizing" than I can only be agreeing with him.

So, yes, you did say that I have to agree with him, if I am to talk about him at all.
I did respond to them, even if they were stupid hypotheticals.
Calling them stupid is not a response.
Can I ask you how old are you?
I am 35
I'm older than you, though I fail to see why that's of any importance.
 
So, what about " Bush, Prodi, Sarkozy, Merkel, .. "??
Are they, sometimes, harming other nations?
Are they also demagogues?
If they make frequent demagogic appeals, speeches, etc., then they are.
Chavez will continue being what he is regardless of other people's behavior, as far as I'm concerned...

Can I ask you, which world leader can not be called as a demagogue?
Yes, you can ask.
But since I don't have informations about all of them, my answer is that I just don't know. Not to mention that I try to avoid sweeping generalizations as much as I can.
But suppose the answer is "yes, all of them are demagogues". Would this somehow excuse Chavez's demagogy and authoritarian tendencies?

The word " demagogic acts" are not univoque.
Are based on subjective judgment.
Is Putin a demagogue?
If not, why not?
The propper place for such discussion would be a thread about Putin...
And if the answer is "yes"...
So what?
Chavez becomes a lesser demagogue?
He is excused?

What about the French foreign minister, who spoke about war with Iran?
Belligerant?
Aggressive?
Hey, demagogue is not the only labell...

I can not avoid to think that politics are not mathematics.
Definitions as " demagogue " are based on internal judgment.
It may be subjective, but there is no need for relativism here.
Too much demagogy = the guy is a demagogue
Too much war drum beating = the guy is aggressive

Taking in to account Chavez's actions, I say he is a demagogue. If you do not agree, please expose evidence against my opinion, since I have already exposed my case.

No, saying "But Bush..." will not be of any help. Its just like a kid, after breaking a window saying another kid broke another window...

How many Americans think Bush is not a demagogue?
Are they all wrong/stupid/ignorant/biased??
I do not think so..
So what?
I fail to see any link.
Bush's actions as far as I know, are not a motivation, a reason for Chavez's own decisions.

You wrote:
" But you want voters to be fully responsible for the actions of their elected candidates... Your reasoning implies the voters are in full agreement with their candidates...
You are contradicting yourself! "

I am not contradicting my self as I did not call the leader ( Chavez ) as a demagogue, in first place.
Then, if you do not agree with my opinion, and if you want to discuss it, you have to expose your evidences and arguments backing the position that he is not a demagogue, since I already exposed my case. And again, "but Putin made..." is not a valid argument.

Because the duck has been freely elected.
So what?
I can no longer say a duck is a duck because the duck was freely elected?
What a weak argument, Matteo!

Politicians should be judged by the same criteria that standard, run-of-the-mill citizens are. The labells that are applied to Politicians should the same that are applied to standard, run-of-the-mill citizens. They are no better than us.

The very facts that we ellect them, we empower them, and that they are supposed to represent us and our will, is perhaps enough to justify being even more rigorous when examining their actions.

And Merkel?
Putin?
Prodi?
Sarkozy?
Abe?
All demagogues?
Suppose I consider them as being so (or bellicose, arrogant, etc.). Would this make Chavez a better or worse politician?

Not 1/100 of what Americans do, and you know it..
So what?
We are discussing Chavez's authoritarian and demagogic acts. They will still be authoritarian and demagogic acts regardless of what USA, Brazil, Italy, Japan, Russia, Canada, China, [add country name here] do!

Not to mention that I think its unfair to blame the population of a country for the acts of its rulers...

You are placing yourself in to a corner, Matteo...
 
If they make frequent demagogic appeals, speeches, etc., then they are.
Chavez will continue being what he is regardless of other people's behavior, as far as I'm concerned...

My point was that 90% ( 100%? ) of the politicians I know make demagogic appeals, speeches, etc.
So, ( almost ) all the politicians should be called as " demagogues ".
Anyway, I have a proposal.
I am pretty tired of this thread, what about stopping here?
No blame on you, no blame on me..
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom