Strawman. That was never in dispute. Just like it was never in dispute that Chavez was elected. Just like it was never in dispute that we both dislike the Iraq war. And yet you still feel the need to derail the thread by discussing things that aren't in dispute.
No.
The point of discussion were the
elections
My post:
Why should not Velezuelans take the blame if Chavez does mistakes/crimes, if they have elected him?
Your reply ( 205 ):
Because too many factors go into a single vote. Who were the other options? Were the voters deceived by the candidate? [..]
My reply ( 209 ):
Generally speaking, and considering Chavez` s case, if voters are deceived by a leader, that means, that, at least, the voters have been naive. [..]
Your reply ( 221 ):
Or they aren't privy to the same information because, for example, the leader has been actively silencing dissent.
Now, we are speaking about elections in Venezuela, and if the Veneuzuelans should, or should not take the blame for their vote for Chavez, in case Chavez does bad things to Venezuela.
You said that Venezuelans may have been " privy to the same information ", I say that Chavez` s opponent, Rosales, had the possibility of speak his opinion on the media, before the elections.
That how democracy works.
Two candidates speak, the people choose, and take responsibility of the choice.
Please, stick to the point of your post 205, that is, the elections.
If you think people can't tell what a transparent ploy this is, you are seriously mistaken.
"You have not clear the concept"
This is what you keep writing and I have no idea what you are trying to convey with these words. It's not proper English. Maybe it means something when translated into Italian, but it's nonsensical in English.
I have given you other 5 or 6 different sentences with the same meaning.
Choose the one that looks more clear to you.
I'm trying not to, but your writing is so vague and contradictory that it is not easy. I am trying to figure out why criticizing a country's AIDS policy is fair game, but criticizing a country's attempts to silence the media is not.
There is a
huge difference.
Please, think about it.
But neither of them are as bad as genocide, which is what you had previously said is your standard. That fuzzy red line of yours seems to be an entirely subjective means of you to try to quelch debate.
If the AIDS policy of one nation actively leads to thousands of avoidable deaths, that is pretty close in the region of mass killing, do not you think so?
Again, if you do not see the difference of
not giving help to an ill person and letting him die when he can be saved and shutting down a TV station, there is little I can do..
Bully for you. However, a conversation goes both ways and you don't get to unilkaterally dictate the means by which we discuss things.
You wrote ( post n. 205 ):
" Chavez makes it a crime to use a picture of the late Luciano Pavorotti as your avatar in any website that can be viewed from Venezuela. [..] "
I beg your pardon, but, this is a stupid example.
You did write in post 156: "Especially, you [marksman] should not speak loud against him, after what Bush has done so far."
" Talk " not.equal.to " speaking loud against "
You also wrote (post 156): "how can you keep criticizing a guy who, well, is not the most polite guy in the world, but, so far, has always respected free elections and never attacked any other country?"
" Talk " not.equal.to " criticize "
You also wrote in post 162: "I think you should criticize ... a foreign leader in cases of genocides, mass murders, failing to tackle AIDS, and some other important points.
Nothing that Chavez has done."
" Talk " not.equal.to " criticize "
You also wrote in post 162: "I do not think any person shouls blame a foreign leader so lightly, like you did"
" Talk " not.equal.to " blame "
And in post 248: "you should not criticize a foreign leader for his domestic policy ( unless he commits serious crimes like genodice, mass killings, etc. ), especially, when you have a president that has started a war which led to tens or hundreds of thousands of civilian deaths."
" Talk " not.equal.to " criticize "
And yes, this means that in this thread you have repeatedly told me that I especially should not criticize Chavez because I am an American. And that we should not criticize Chavez at all because he hasn't done anything as bad as genocide, mass murder or failing to tackle AIDS.
" Talk " not.equal.to " criticize "
As, we found out, that I
never told people it is inappropriate to
talk about Chavez in a thread about Chavez ".
Yours was a lie, err., a mistake..
So apologize for telling me not to criticize Chavez because of my President or defend it. But don't deny it.
No, I am not apoligizing.
I do think that you should not
criticize Chavez`
internal policy bacause of what your President has done in Iraq.
No you didn't. You ignored the hypothetical with tu quoques.
Your hypotheticals were quite stupid, sorry, if I use a strong word..
How can you define this
hypothetical?
Your post n. 205:
" Chavez makes it illegal to worship in the Hindu faith. "
Do you really expect me to comment on this?
So, go ahead.
I will keep reminding that you have a president who does worse.
We will both be happy.
I'll count that as yet another word whose meaning you don't know.
Count that as you wish
Once again, you being tired is your proiblem, not ours.
Ours means all the other readers of the forum?
Just guessing..
But neither America nor Venezuela nor Iraq are your houses. Your house is Italy (or possibly Japan). So why should you care if America invades Iraq's house?
If you see a thief entering another person` s house or killing another person, would you at least call the police?
Even if the other person, is not a relative or friend of yours?
You have a weird sense of justice..