Chavez taking necessary steps to ensure equality and liberty

You and Chavez seem to have much more in common than 98% of the genetic code.
I would hope that any two human beings have more in common with one another than they do with chimps! As I said, the commonalities aren't as important as the differences.

Generally speaking, and considering Chavez` s case, if voters are deceived by a leader, that means, that, at least, the voters have been naive.
Or they aren't privy to the same information because, for example, the leader has been actively silencing dissent.

Just remembering you that there are a lot of people who have voted for a person who you called as " moron " and " demagogue " near you.
I don't know why you feel the need to "remind" me of stuff I never disputed. Why not try to stick to the topic at hand instead of wasting bandwidth?

And for the record, I don't have the overly simplistic view of voting as you did. I've had to choose in elections between voting for someone I thought was a moron and voting for someone who I thought was corrupt. I'm sure you've faced similar Hobson's Choices. I don't judg people base don their voting record. You, apparently do, but there's no need to hold me to your ridiculous standards of behavior.

Can not see why we can not make comparisons between Chavez and Bush, and Putin, in this thread..
I don't mind the comparisons if they are analogous. That isn't what you've been doing, though.

In my opinion, in cases of genocide, killings of many people, etc.
Define "etc." First you use the qualifier "something like that" and then you use the qualifier "etc." At what point do you decide one cannot criticize an elected official for an internal policy? Obviously, the extreme case of genocide falls on the far side of the meter. My hypotheticals were an attempt to get you to clarify your position, which simply seems like an arbitrary standard you use to try to prevent discussion fo topic you're not comfortable addressing.

Again.
You see how biased you are?
Why do you have the " In God we trust " over the dollar?
Why are you leaving out, let` s say, Buddhists?
If it makes you happy, let's include Buddhists. Will you answer the hypothetical or not?

Taken from the State of Texas Constitution... See how much biased you are?
No, I don't/ I'm not from Texas, so I don't know how the Texas COnstitution evidences my bias.

Let` s talk about the farm subsides
No. Answer my question first. Stop trying to avoid the question by bringing up collateral subjects.

We are flying high on hypotheticals, here..
Yes. That's why I told you I was offering a few hypotheticals.

Wait a second.
I was responding to Zensmack89, Matteo, not you. Please try to read more carefully so you don't make inaccurate accusations in the future. Thanks.
 
Or they aren't privy to the same information because, for example, the leader has been actively silencing dissent.

Rosales was silenced?
See, how biased you are?

I don't know why you feel the need to "remind" me of stuff I never disputed. Why not try to stick to the topic at hand instead of wasting bandwidth?

So, you should be actively criticizing them before you criticize Chavez
See, how biased you are?

And for the record, I don't have the overly simplistic view of voting as you did. I've had to choose in elections between voting for someone I thought was a moron and voting for someone who I thought was corrupt. I'm sure you've faced similar Hobson's Choices. I don't judg people base don their voting record. You, apparently do, but there's no need to hold me to your ridiculous standards of behavior.

You have not clear the concept that the act of voting demands responsibility

I don't mind the comparisons if they are analogous. That isn't what you've been doing, though.

Just your opinion
I find comparisons legitimate

Define "etc." First you use the qualifier "something like that" and then you use the qualifier "etc." At what point do you decide one cannot criticize an elected official for an internal policy? Obviously, the extreme case of genocide falls on the far side of the meter. My hypotheticals were an attempt to get you to clarify your position, which simply seems like an arbitrary standard you use to try to prevent discussion fo topic you're not comfortable addressing.

You are really a polemic, uh?
I said that external intervention should be OK in case of genocide, killings of many people, etc.
like in the case of Rwanda, where the US ( and all the other countries ) did not intervene..
Not in the case of statalization of economy or shutting down a TV station..
See, how biased you are?

If it makes you happy, let's include Buddhists. Will you answer the hypothetical or not?

Reply to my point:
Why do you have the " In God we trust " over the dollar?
Why are you leaving out, let` s say, Buddhists?
See, how biased you are?

No, I don't/ I'm not from Texas, so I don't know how the Texas COnstitution evidences my bias.

Never said you were.
Texas is part of the US, is not it?
Your country ( the US ), has a state ( Texas ) with that constitution..
So, criticize Texans, which are closer to you, before criticize Chavez
See, how biased you are?

No. Answer my question first. Stop trying to avoid the question by bringing up collateral subjects.

You wrote:
" Chavez taxes tomatoes, doubling their price. Can Italian tomato exporters complain? Can they even call him a name, like "protectionist"? "
I replied:
" Let` s talk about the farm subsides which Europe and the US have put in place, which have been criticized as they seem to be used to prevent third world economies from making business with them?
This is not an hypotetical, it is a fact. "
See, how biased you are?

Yes. That's why I told you I was offering a few hypotheticals.

Since you have run out of arguments..

I was responding to Zensmack89, Matteo, not you. Please try to read more carefully so you don't make inaccurate accusations in the future. Thanks.

So, I can not quote you, if you are replying to another poster?
 
Still amazes me to see so many tu quoque arguments on a skeptics board. But I guess we're all easily amazed by *something*.
 
Still amazes me to see how biased can people be..

http://www.ekklesia.co.uk/node/5700

Are you saying that what you are linking is the same as the change announced by Chavez? It sure doesn't look the same to me.

In the UK, the article talks about regulating an obligatory number of students from families outside the faith.

The article about Chavez's changes say they are rewriting the textbooks and if they don't aggree the schools will be taken over by the government.

Not even close to the same situation.
 
Are you saying that what you are linking is the same as the change announced by Chavez? It sure doesn't look the same to me.

In the UK, the article talks about regulating an obligatory number of students from families outside the faith.

The article about Chavez's changes say they are rewriting the textbooks and if they don't aggree the schools will be taken over by the government.

Not even close to the same situation.

Protests from secular and teaching groups have met the announcement by the British government that a large number of faith-based schools are to be brought into the state-funded sector with a pledge to remove "unnecessary barriers" to religious groups

In the UK, the state sponsors faith-based schools..
 
You know, I am reminded of the way in the 1930's certain people defending Joe Stalin as being a champion of democracy right down to the bitter end.
Matteo,why are you defending Chavez so strongly?
If the schools in question in Venezuela do not receive state funding,and are paid for privately,then for CHavez to take them over is indeed the act of a dictator.
 
Rosales was silenced?
See, how biased you are?
Did I say Rosales? No, I mentioned "actively silencing dissent". The OP references the link about Venezuela's attempts. The only bias I have is for rational debate. You should endeavor for such bias yourself.

So, you should be actively criticizing them before you criticize Chavez
See, how biased you are?
In a thread about Bush I criticize Bush. In a thread about Chavez I criticize Chavez. See the title of the thread, Matteo? It's about Chavez. Your attempts to discuss anybody except Chavez in this thread is really quite odd.

You have not clear the concept that the act of voting demands responsibility
I think your translator service is malfunctioning. This sentence doesn't make any sense.

I said that external intervention should be OK in case of genocide, killings of many people, etc.
And I said define "etc."

You had earlier said it was okay for James Randi to criticize the President of South Africa for defending his health minister for expressing superstition as a way to combat AIDS. South Africa is not committing genocide. It is not killing millions of people. It is making an unfortunate decision that will indirectly result in the death of many people. Yet, when I ask you for the standard of behavior, you only mention the worst. The worst is easy to define. It's the line I want you to describe. You do so only with the most vague words you can imagine.

like in the case of Rwanda
But what about South Africa, Matteo? Is it okay to criticize South Africa for their internal policies?

Why do you have the " In God we trust " over the dollar?
Why should I answer the question when you won't?

Why are you leaving out, let` s say, Buddhists?
Do you even understand the hypothetical, Matteo? Why didn't you criticize me for leaving out Shinto? Why only Buddhists? Doesn't that make you as biased as you think I am? Doesn't that also make you a hypocrite?

So, criticize Texans, which are closer to you, before criticize Chavez
See, how biased you are?
No, Matteo. Ulike you, I actually read the title of this thread to understand the topic before I posted in it. I, for example understand this thread is not about Texas. You however, do not understand this. You also appear to think non sequiturs and tu quouque arguments and random accusations of bias are persuasive.

You wrote:
" Chavez taxes tomatoes, doubling their price. Can Italian tomato exporters complain? Can they even call him a name, like "protectionist"? "
I replied:
" Let` s talk about the farm subsides which Europe and the US have put in place, which have been criticized as they seem to be used to prevent third world economies from making business with them?
This is not an hypotetical, it is a fact. "
See, how biased you are?
All I see from this exchange is that you don't understand what a hypothetical is and you didn't answer my question.

Since you have run out of arguments..
Well, it is difficult to have a discussion with someone who won't respond to questions with anything but ad hominems, tu quoques and non sequiturs.

So, I can not quote you, if you are replying to another poster?
Of course you can, Matteo. But your response was written as if my reply was directed at you, not another poster. And so I correctly calle dyou on it. And, as usual, you responded in such a way to make it absolutely clear that you have absolutely no idea what this thread is about.
 
Protests from secular and teaching groups have met the announcement by the British government that a large number of faith-based schools are to be brought into the state-funded sector with a pledge to remove "unnecessary barriers" to religious groups

In the UK, the state sponsors faith-based schools..

Did you bother to read what that means? It means people who do not belong to the faith of the school will no longer be barred from attending. This has nothing to do with changing or mandating curriculum.
 
Matteo,why are you defending Chavez so strongly?
Oddly, Matteo isn't defending Chavez. When pushed against the wall, Matteo will grudgingly agree that Chavez is a demagogue and that he doesn't necessarily agree with Chavez' economic or social policies. Matteo seems to be taking the position that (1) Chavez hasn't done anything so horrible as to be worthy of notice by other nations, and (2) anything Chavez has done is analogous to stuff going on in the UK and US, even though the severity of the action may differ.

I have no idea why Matteo thinks these arguments are valid counterpoints to criticism of Chavez. I have no idea why Matteo thinks it "impolite" to criticize the domestic policies of the leaders of other nations that don't rise to the level of genocide.
 
Did I say Rosales? No, I mentioned "actively silencing dissent". The OP references the link about Venezuela's attempts. The only bias I have is for rational debate. You should endeavor for such bias yourself.

Read your and my old posts
We were talking about the fairness of the Venezuelan election
The opponent was Rosales
Please, bring me evidence that Rosales was silenced.

In a thread about Bush I criticize Bush. In a thread about Chavez I criticize Chavez. See the title of the thread, Matteo? It's about Chavez. Your attempts to discuss anybody except Chavez in this thread is really quite odd.

??
I do discuss about Chavez in this thread.
I was and I am making relevant and meaninful comparisons with Bush, Lula, .. in order to make my point
Is there anything wrong?

I think your translator service is malfunctioning. This sentence doesn't make any sense.

My sentence is:
" You have not clear the concept that the act of voting demands responsibility "

And I said define "etc."

You can ot define
You had earlier said it was okay for James Randi to criticize the President of South Africa for defending his health minister for expressing superstition as a way to combat AIDS. South Africa is not committing genocide. It is not killing millions of people. It is making an unfortunate decision that will indirectly result in the death of many people. Yet, when I ask you for the standard of behavior, you only mention the worst. The worst is easy to define. It's the line I want you to describe. You do so only with the most vague words you can imagine.

You can not always draw a red perfect line in politics.
I have no evidence that Chavez " expressing superstition " and being responsible for not giving medical assistance to AIDS patients.
I have no evidence that in Venezuela there is apartheid
Please, bring me evidence of this..
But what about South Africa, Matteo? Is it okay to criticize South Africa for their internal policies?

Why should I answer the question when you won't?

I am answering all your questions..

Do you even understand the hypothetical, Matteo? Why didn't you criticize me for leaving out Shinto? Why only Buddhists? Doesn't that make you as biased as you think I am? Doesn't that also make you a hypocrite?

You wrote:
Here's some hypotheticals.
[Chavez makes it illegal to worship in the Hindu faith. Can non-Venezuelan Hindus complain? Can they even call him a name like "anti-Hindu bigot"?

My reply:
Again.
You see how biased you are?
Why do you have the " In God we trust " over the dollar?
Why are you leaving out, let` s say, Buddhists?
[..]
See how much biased you are?
The examples above are not hypotheticals

That is, I made an example to counter your hypothetical, and mine, is even true..

No, Matteo. Ulike you, I actually read the title of this thread to understand the topic before I posted in it. I, for example understand this thread is not about Texas. You however, do not understand this. You also appear to think non sequiturs and tu quouque arguments and random accusations of bias are persuasive.

I am making comparisons, between Chavez and Bush, between Venezuela and America.
This, in order to show that the position of some people ( you included ) about Chavez may be biased.
Again, this is my opinion, but I think I am entitled and allowed to talk about other leaders in a thread about Chavez

All I see from this exchange is that you don't understand what a hypothetical is and you didn't answer my question.

You wrote:
Chavez makes it a crime to use a picture of the late Luciano Pavorotti as your avatar in any website that can be viewed from Venezuela. Can you complain? Could you even call him a name, like "uncultured cretin"?

I replied:
We are flying high on hypotheticals, here..

Instead of making day-dream hypotheticals with no connections with reality, why not speak about the real world, which is already complicated enough?

Well, it is difficult to have a discussion with someone who won't respond to questions with anything but ad hominems, tu quoques and non sequiturs.

So much latin, here..
:)

Of course you can, Matteo. But your response was written as if my reply was directed at you, not another poster. And so I correctly calle dyou on it. And, as usual, you responded in such a way to make it absolutely clear that you have absolutely no idea what this thread is about.

OK, OK..
Next time, I will add:
" * this is a reply to a post which was not a reply to a post written by me "..
or, something like this..
 
Last edited:
You know, I am reminded of the way in the 1930's certain people defending Joe Stalin as being a champion of democracy right down to the bitter end.

Biased, biased people, in this forum..
Comparing Chavez with Stalin..

Matteo,why are you defending Chavez so strongly?

If you read this thread, just few posts of mine, you would realize that I am not defending Chavez.

If the schools in question in Venezuela do not receive state funding,and are paid for privately,then for CHavez to take them over is indeed the act of a dictator.

Wow, you use the word " dictator " quite freely here.
Why Chavez should be a dictator?
BTW, can I ask you..
Do you live in the US?
Just to see if I am biased too..
 
Did you bother to read what that means? It means people who do not belong to the faith of the school will no longer be barred from attending. This has nothing to do with changing or mandating curriculum.

No.
My point is that religious schools will be funded with public money.

Protests from secular and teaching groups have met the announcement by the British government that a large number of faith-based schools are to be brought into the state-funded sector with a pledge to remove "unnecessary barriers" to religious groups

In Britain, religious schools have been state funded for some time. The U.K. will open its first Hindu primary school in 2008, the latest edition of the Economist reports. A Sept. 13 article reports the state came late to schools there, with most early schools operated by the Church of England or Catholic church
http://lfpress.ca/newsstand/News/Local/2007/09/18/4504948-sun.html

Govt paves way for expansion of faith schools
The government yesterday set out plans to back faith-based education, in exchange for faith schools promising to foster tolerance and understanding of other religions
http://www.politics.co.uk/news/opinion-former-index/children-and-family/govt-paves-way-expansion-faith-schools-$478202.htm
 
I have no idea why Matteo thinks these arguments are valid counterpoints to criticism of Chavez. I have no idea why Matteo thinks it "impolite" to criticize the domestic policies of the leaders of other nations that don't rise to the level of genocide.

As I am tired to hear Americans criticize Chavez, Morales, Castro, Putin, Ahmadinejad ( that is one case which I agree.. ), Jintao, .. for not being democratic/capitalists/free press oriented/fair when they have George II ( TM ) as president..
 
Read your and my old posts
We were talking about the fairness of the Venezuelan election
The opponent was Rosales
Please, bring me evidence that Rosales was silenced.
Please read this carefully: I never said Rosales was silenced. Never. Please stop misrepresenting what I wrote because when you insist on misrepresenting me in such an obvious fashion, it only reflects poorly on you.

Here's the exchange again:
209 (you): Generally speaking, and considering Chavez` s case, if voters are deceived by a leader, that means, that, at least, the voters have been naive.
221 (me): Or they aren't privy to the same information because, for example, the leader has been actively silencing dissent.
I was not referring to Rosales, but to the media. You assumed I was referencing Rosales and when I told you I was not, you ignored me because you find it easier to fight a straw man than respond to what I wrote.

My sentence is:
" You have not clear the concept that the act of voting demands responsibility "
For the second time, this sentence makes no sense in English.

You can not always draw a red perfect line in politics.
Then stop trying to tell Americans what they can and cannot criticize about foreign leaders' domestic policies. Really, this isn't complicated.

I have no evidence that Chavez " expressing superstition " and being responsible for not giving medical assistance to AIDS patients.
Once again, you do not understand the analogy. i never said Chavez expressed superstition. You said that Americans should only criticize domestic policies of other nations when they are tantamount to genocide. I pointed out that you have no problem with James Randi, an American criticizing South Africa's domestic policy about AIDS prevention, which is not anything close to genocide. That makes you a rank hypocrite.

The truth appears to be that you don't want to listen to Americans unless they are flagellating themselves over their President.

I am answering all your questions..
Matteo, you don't even understand the question, much less answer them.

You wrote:
Here's some hypotheticals.
[Chavez makes it illegal to worship in the Hindu faith. Can non-Venezuelan Hindus complain? Can they even call him a name like "anti-Hindu bigot"?

My reply:
Again.
You see how biased you are?
Why do you have the " In God we trust " over the dollar?
Why are you leaving out, let` s say, Buddhists?
[..]
See how much biased you are?
The examples above are not hypotheticals
What I wrote is a hypothetical. Do you even know what a hypothetical is?

That is, I made an example to counter your hypothetical, and mine, is even true..
If it's true, it's not a hypothetical! It's an example. Really Matteo, I know the word hypothetical in Italian is almost identical to its English counterpart. You really can't pretend to be ignorant of the meaning of this word.

Again, this is my opinion, but I think I am entitled and allowed to talk about other leaders in a thread about Chavez
I'm not telling you that you can't. You're the one telling people it is inappropriate to talk about Chavez in a thread about Chavez. Please stop doing that.

Instead of making day-dream hypotheticals with no connections with reality, why not speak about the real world, which is already complicated enough?
Because I am trying to figure out what your position is and hypotheticals are a good rhetorical tool for that. That you refuse to address the hypotheticals evidences a desire on your part to confront your own hypocrisy.

So much latin, here.
Well, you're having so much difficulty with English, I figured an Italian should at least be able to handle a little Latin.

Next time, I will add:
" * this is a reply to a post which was not a reply to a post written by me "..
or, something like this..
Even better, you should respond to it as if it were written to a third person and not you.

As I am tired to hear Americans criticize Chavez, Morales, Castro, Putin, Ahmadinejad ( that is one case which I agree.. ), Jintao, .. for not being democratic/capitalists/free press oriented/fair when they have George II ( TM ) as president..
We're not responsible for you being tired. If it pains you so to hear Americans discuss anybody but President Bush, you really shouldn't read threads in a forum frequented by so many Americans that pertain to people who are not Bush. It is wholly inappropriate for you to come onto a thread about Chavez and tell people they should only discuss Bush, as you just did above.
 
As I am tired to hear Americans criticize Chavez, Morales, Castro, Putin, Ahmadinejad ( that is one case which I agree.. ), Jintao, .. for not being democratic/capitalists/free press oriented/fair when they have George II ( TM ) as president..


Then we should all be tired to hear an Italian criticize GWB given the mess Italian internal politics have been in for ages ... :rolleyes:
 
Then we should all be tired to hear an Italian criticize GWB given the mess Italian internal politics have been in for ages ... :rolleyes:


I though Matteo said that criticising the head of states of other nations was impolite......a double standard,perhaps?
I am not fan of GWB by any means,but a lot of his critics lose their credibility when they defend heads of state whose record is a lot worse then GWB's.
 
I am not fan of GWB by any means,but a lot of his critics lose their credibility when they defend heads of state whose record is a lot worse then GWB's.

It could even be credibly argued that Chavez is not yet worse than GWB. But so what, I ask Matteo. Just because there are worse people out there doesn't mean the less bad ones don't deserve our criticism.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom