Chavez taking necessary steps to ensure equality and liberty

I didn't bring up the Venezuelan economy. Matteo was making an argument that essentially sounded like "Even if Chavez is curbing freedoms, it's okay, because Chavez is delivering on his promise to help the Venezuelan poor."

Wrong.
My main point is that Chavez seems to have been elected by the Venezuelan population with free elections and has showed no intention ( so far? ) to take away them.
That was my main point

Notwithstanding that the argument would be fallacious even if factually accurate, I was pointing out that it was not in fact factually accurate. I am not criticizing Chavez for failing to help the poor as much as his neighbors appear to be helping the poor. I am merely rebutting one of Matteo's factual assumptions.

I have made no assumptions, I have post a link to a serious site ( Wikipedia )、which shows that the economy of Venezuela, maybe, is not doing so bad..
 
[/B]It truly brings a tear to the eye and a lump to the throat.

Maybe not, but does make you think why so many people out there are sympathetic with this arrogant, " would-be-dictator-according-to-many "

I know, I know, I keep telling you that John Stewart is a dirty propagandist and Bush sycophant.

I thought you were ironic.
Hey, that` s the video you posted..
 
Maybe not, but does make you think why so many people out there are sympathetic with this arrogant, " would-be-dictator-according-to-many "
Knowing the history of the UN I would be very, very surprised at any other outcome.

I thought you were ironic.
Hey, that` s the video you posted.
Stewart has high JREF street cred as being both fair and honest and very hard on Bush. I like Stewart but I find this to be a delicious and interesting juxtaposition especially since I've had debates that John is not always objective.

So thanks.
 
Knowing the history of the UN I would be very, very surprised at any other outcome.

Why?
The UN too, like Oliver, is critic of Bush, no-matter-what?

Stewart has high JREF street cred as being both fair and honest and very hard on Bush. I like Stewart but I find this to be a delicious and interesting juxtaposition especially since I've had debates that John is not always objective.

So thanks.

Still, this Stewart did not say the whole thing on Chavez.
He did not say that his speech received one minute or so of applauses ( and I doubt that Bush` s speech received ten seconds of applauses ), for example.
Maybe, I do not understand your point
 
Just making my point, about what poor people around the world may be scared about.
Which was a non sequitur to what you quoted from me. I just want to make sure I understand. You quoted me talkign about American wasn't bothered by Chavez and you responded to that quote with a discussion of what the non-American world might fear. A total non sequitur.

So, we agree that Chavez has ( almost ) all the rights to stay where he is.
I also agree the sky is blue. So what? I never denied it!

Then, you can criticize him, for being an " demagogue "
Do you know what a "demagogue" even is? You seem to think it means someone who isn't elected. Demagogue is not a synonym for dictator. They aren't even related words, Matteo.

Yes, we can criticize each other.
Then stop saying Americans should clean up their own backyard before criticizing others.

I have criticized you for criticizing Venezuela in an improper way, that is different.
And your criticism betrays a fundamental lack of reading comprehension.

It was you who said that Chavez was an " demagogue".
SO what? Nothing you have posted contradicts that assessment of him.

The website stated that, from 2003 to 2005:
- the GDP has grown from 35 to 45 trillion VEB;
- GDP pro-capita from 1400 to 1800 thousand VEB
- inflation down from 30 to less than 20%;
- unemployment down from 16 to 12%
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hugo_Chávez#Economic_policy
Other than a dip in unemployment, none of those figures tell us squat about the living standards of the poor. An improved economy is not helpful to the poor if the revenues of that economy are shipped overseas, as Chavez is doing.

And the UN's assessment is in fact that the lives of the poor are falling behind the rest of Latin America's poor.

I notice from the graphs that the year 2003 was a particularly bad year, so, maybe, it was easy to recover from that year.
In fact, 2003 was a bad year for the Venezuelan economy. However, that still has little to do with the data about the living standards of Venezuelan's poor.

My main point is that Chavez seems to have been elected by the Venezuelan population with free elections and has showed no intention ( so far? ) to take away them.
If that were true, you never would have responded to anything I wrote, sin ce I never said anything about that.

Of course, it isn't true. You have said much more.

In post 36, you mentioned nary a word about Democratic elections, but instead tried to make the case that Venezuela's economy was helping the poor. You did it in response to my statement that Chavez was not helping the poor, compared to other nations in the region. And you still refuse to examine the data I cited from the United Nations showing that Venezuela's poor are lagging behind the rest of Latin America during Chavez' administration.

I have made no assumptions, I have post a link to a serious site ( Wikipedia )、which shows that the economy of Venezuela, maybe, is not doing so bad..
But it doesn't show the plight of Venexzuela's poor are improving commensurate with the booming state of the economy. And, in fact, according to the UN, they aren't. Chavez is taking the oil revenues and plowing them into his foreign policy endeavors. He is not helping the poor.
 
Which was a non sequitur to what you quoted from me. I just want to make sure I understand. You quoted me talkign about American wasn't bothered by Chavez and you responded to that quote with a discussion of what the non-American world might fear. A total non sequitur.

Call it as you like.
So what?

I also agree the sky is blue. So what? I never denied it!

Just keep it well in clear, in your mind.

Do you know what a "demagogue" even is? You seem to think it means someone who isn't elected. Demagogue is not a synonym for dictator. They aren't even related words, Matteo.

Did I say " demagogue " and " dictator " were related words?

Then stop saying Americans should clean up their own backyard before criticizing others.

Just keep in mind, that Bush has done ( very ) bad things that Chavez has never done.
Like invading other nations.
Like having nukes deployed in military basis all over the world.
Keep in mind this, before posting, and everything will be fine.

And your criticism betrays a fundamental lack of reading comprehension.

And your posts denote a fundamental arrogance.

SO what? Nothing you have posted contradicts that assessment of him.

In the same terms, we can also call Bush as a demagogue, other than a liar, and probably much more..
Clean-your-own-back-yard-first..

Other than a dip in unemployment, none of those figures tell us squat about the living standards of the poor.

A dip in unemployment, my dear guy, means a lot for the poors..

An improved economy is not helpful to the poor if the revenues of that economy are shipped overseas, as Chavez is doing.

As Chavez is claiming he is not doing.
Chavez is saying he is statalizing the oil industry for the exact goal not to let revenues from oil go abroad.
And that makes sense, even if, of course, you can not agree with him..
I can too, but we are not Venezuelan, and, as long as Venezuelans are happy with him..

And the UN's assessment is in fact that the lives of the poor are falling behind the rest of Latin America's poor.

Not according to the link I have posted
Not according to the GRP pro capita figure I have posted.
Not according to the dip in unemployment I have posted.
Disclaimer
I am not defending Chavez economic policy..

In fact, 2003 was a bad year for the Venezuelan economy. However, that still has little to do with the data about the living standards of Venezuelan's poor.

GDP pro capita and unemployment data have a lot to do with the living standards of the poors

If that were true, you never would have responded to anything I wrote, sin ce I never said anything about that.

I just want to be sure we both agree that Chavez has the rights to stay where he is.

Of course, it isn't true. You have said much more.

In post 36, you mentioned nary a word about Democratic elections, but instead tried to make the case that Venezuela's economy was helping the poor. You did it in response to my statement that Chavez was not helping the poor, compared to other nations in the region. And you still refuse to examine the data I cited from the United Nations showing that Venezuela's poor are lagging behind the rest of Latin America during Chavez' administration.

And you are refusing to consider the data I have posted, which show that two important indicators ( GDP pro capita and unemployment ratio ) have gone better, from 2003 and 2005

But it doesn't show the plight of Venexzuela's poor are improving commensurate with the booming state of the economy. And, in fact, according to the UN, they aren't. Chavez is taking the oil revenues and plowing them into his foreign policy endeavors. He is not helping the poor.

Let them decide if they are helped by the current policy or not.
The indicators I have posted suggest that they are.
They ( the poors ) seem also to be quite happy with Chavez` s policy, at least, according to the results of the last elections.
Now, who are you to say that " he is not helping the poor "?
 
No, there is a history that many nations and their UN representatives have been anti-American no matter what.

I am having a hard time understanding why many nations should be anti-American, no matter what. Please, explain..

Perhaps Stewart is a comedian and perhaps his show is fake news. Perhaps he was trying to do satire and not jounalism?

I do not get all this thing about John Stewart, but, to reply to his question, it seems that a lot of important people are taking U Chavez seriously..
 
I am having a hard time understanding why many nations should be anti-American, no matter what. Please, explain.
I will tell you that the answer ISN'T simple. I will also tell you that it bothers me that so many people today look at recent events and make knee jerk assumptions about America and why America is viewed however they think the world views us.

No nation has always enjoyed favorability by all other nations. No, not even Switzerland.
  • Interdependent global relations are complex.
  • Things are not always as they appear. Be careful about the conclusions you draw from such incidents. That's not conducive to critical thinking. Are you guilty of confirmation bias? Does this event confirm what you think about America? Should it?
I do not get all this thing about John Stewart, but, to reply to his question, it seems that a lot of important people are taking U Chavez seriously.
  • If you hang around long enough you will find that most people who don't like George Bush LOVE John Stewart.
  • John Stewart is a comedian.
  • John Stewart is not a journalist.
  • Satire isn't about being precise.
  • Things are NOT always as the appear.
I don't know what else to tell you. It seems that there is more than enough information there for you to understand my position. I'm sorry. I've got nothing else.
 
I do not get all this thing about John Stewart, but, to reply to his question, it seems that a lot of important people are taking U Chavez seriously..


Understand this. Chavez makes news. Newsmakers get discussed. Nobody makes a big deal out of the latest goings on in Canada because Canadians are boring.

Nobody wants to invade and take out Chavez. We talk about him because he is a news maker.
 
Understand this. Chavez makes news. Newsmakers get discussed. Nobody makes a big deal out of the latest goings on in Canada because Canadians are boring.

Nobody wants to invade and take out Chavez. We talk about him because he is a news maker.

Read this and take your own conclusions ( already posted in another thread ):

PRINCETON, NJ -- Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez's fiery remarks about George W. Bush and the United States on Sept. 20 at the United Nation's 61st General Assembly led news shows around the globe, generated heavy blog traffic, and triggered strong reactions from both Bush supporters and foes alike, including former President Bill Clinton and House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi, the latter going as far as to call Chavez a "thug."

What is the public opinion context in which Chavez made these statements -- both in his home country of Venezuela and in other Latin American countries? Recent Gallup World Poll surveys in 18 countries in Latin America asked residents to rate the leadership of both Venezuela and the United States. The resulting responses provide valuable insights into the regional environment in which the controversial Venezuelan president is operating.

The majority of the surveys were conducted in May 2006, with the exception of Venezuela, Brazil, and Mexico, which were polled in December 2005. The results suggest that Latin Americans are not necessarily aligned in their support of Venezuela's leadership nor do they share a common perspective on U.S. leadership.

http://www.gallupworldpoll.com/content/?ci=24814
 

Attachments

  • poll venezuela us.gif
    poll venezuela us.gif
    22.3 KB · Views: 1
Call it as you like.
So what?
The point is that quoting someone and then responding in a non sequitur is a very confusing means of communication. If your intent is for people to understand what you write, stop being confusing. The fact that it took us ten posts to establish that what you write has no relation to what you quote is rather astounding

Just keep it well in clear, in your mind.
Why?

Did I say " demagogue " and " dictator " were related words?
Yes. In post 139 you wrote: "Then, you can criticize him, for being an 'demagogue', among other things, even if he never said he wants to take away free elections"

This sentence makes no sense unless you believe that the definition of demagogue includes someone who wants to take away free elections. So, yes, Matteo, you did equate demagogue with dictator. And you are wrong to do so.

Just keep in mind, that Bush has done ( very ) bad things
Why should I keep that in mind in a thread about Chavez?

Are you saying that we cannot criticize a politician if there is anybody else in the world who has done arguably worse things?

And your posts denote a fundamental arrogance.
I'd rather be arrogant than wrong.

In the same terms, we can also call Bush as a demagogue, other than a liar, and probably much more..
So what?

Clean-your-own-back-yard-first..
What does this mean, Matteo?

A dip in unemployment, my dear guy, means a lot for the poors.
Not enough, however, according to the UN. That dip in unemployment is peanuts compared to what Venezeula's neighbors are acheiving. It does not rebut my statement that Chavez is not delivering on his promises to help the poor. Compared to Venezuela's neighbors, the poor are of Venezuela are suffering.

As Chavez is claiming he is not doing.
When did Chavez claim he is not sending money overseas?!

Chavez is saying he is statalizing the oil industry for the exact goal not to let revenues from oil go abroad.
No, he says he doesn't want it to go to foreign capitalists. but he's more than happy to send it to Colombian socialist guerillas, or to use it in PR stunts in America.

I can too, but we are not Venezuelan, and, as long as Venezuelans are happy with him.
Well, then why criticize Bush, which you just did? Bush is also elected.

Not according to the link I have posted
Not according to the GRP pro capita figure I have posted.
Not according to the dip in unemployment I have posted.
GDP does not measure improvement in lives of the poor.
The unemployment figures represent a tiny dip in unemployment and in fact do not compare favorably with his neighbors' economic figures.
I am not defending Chavez economic policy..
Good, because you clearly don't understand economics.

GDP pro capita and unemployment data have a lot to do with the living standards of the poors
No, they can have an impact on the poor, depending on other factors. But the UN figures, which actually measure the poor's standar do fliving, show that other factors are in fact overwhelming the cherry-picked data you've been citing.

I'm showing you data on the actual standard of living and you are trying to rebut it with an incomplete assessment of secondary factors.

I just want to be sure we both agree that Chavez has the rights to stay where he is.
Why is it so important for you to keep reiterating a point I never disputed and in fact agreed upon from the very beginning?

And you are refusing to consider the data I have posted, which show that two important indicators ( GDP pro capita and unemployment ratio ) have gone better, from 2003 and 2005
I did consider it and I explained why your data doesn't rebut my point. You don't seem to even comprehend the UN data I showed you.

Now, who are you to say that " he is not helping the poor "?
Someone who is literate and able to read economic data.
 
The point is that quoting someone and then responding in a non sequitur is a very confusing means of communication. If your intent is for people to understand what you write, stop being confusing. The fact that it took us ten posts to establish that what you write has no relation to what you quote is rather astounding

Agreed.
If I generated confusion, I beg for pardon.

Yes. In post 139 you wrote: "Then, you can criticize him, for being an 'demagogue', among other things, even if he never said he wants to take away free elections"

I may have linked two points ( demagogue and free elections ), not directly related.
I acknowledge that.

This sentence makes no sense unless you believe that the definition of demagogue includes someone who wants to take away free elections. So, yes, Matteo, you did equate demagogue with dictator. And you are wrong to do so.

I did not equate demagogue with dictator.
I just linked the two concepts.
I do agree that that sentence was not my best one in terms of logic terms.

Why should I keep that in mind in a thread about Chavez?

Are you saying that we cannot criticize a politician if there is anybody else in the world who has done arguably worse things?

Not if the politician who has done " arguably worse things " is the president of your country.
First, you have to look at the guy you have elected and then, look at what Chavez has done.
I do not like Chavez at all, and maybe he is a demagogue, but I do not speak loud against him as you do, since he has held free elections, so far, and has never attacked, not even plan to attack, any other country.
Especially, you should not speak loud against him, after what Bush has done so far.

I'd rather be arrogant than wrong.

Did I posted any wrong or false information in this post?
I do not think so.
I just wrote, in the same sentence about being a demagogue and taking away free elections, two points not necessarily linked.
I was hardly worng.

So what?


What does this mean, Matteo?

" Clean-your-own-back-yard-first " means, look to what you are doing, and speak against other nations when you are behaving right.
If you have just attacked another nation ( Iraq ), outside the UN legality, basing the invasion on false information ( a polite way to say " lies " ), and this caused tens or hundreds of thousands of deaths, including civilians and your own soldiers, how can you keep criticizing a guy who, well, is not the most polite guy in the world, but, so far, has always respected free elections and never attacked any other country?
Is it so difficult to get?

Disclaimer
I do not like Chavez at all
I do not think that he can be pardoned for shutting down media and newspapers
I do not think that Iraq and Saddam were the " good guys ".
I think that Saddam was a criminal and he deserved to be removed ( to say the least )
I do not think the Americans can be fully blamed for the deaths in Iraq, as it is not them ( mostly ) who kill, but terrorists/fundamentalists..
I agree it is difficult to work within the international community to isolate one nation
I agree that there was a big shock in the US after 911, and that this could have helped making wrong decisions

Not enough, however, according to the UN. That dip in unemployment is peanuts compared to what Venezeula's neighbors are acheiving. It does not rebut my statement that Chavez is not delivering on his promises to help the poor. Compared to Venezuela's neighbors, the poor are of Venezuela are suffering.

I wrote:
" A dip in unemployment, my dear guy, means a lot for the poors. "
You wrote:
" Not enough, however, according to the UN ".

Where does the UN state that a dip in unemployement does not mean a lot for the poors?

When did Chavez claim he is not sending money overseas?!

You are quoting only a part of my reply, in order to deal only with that..
I wrote also:
" Chavez is saying he is statalizing the oil industry for the exact goal not to let revenues from oil go abroad "
That was the meaning of my thought, and you did not quote this..
BTW, the same things are doing Morales, and, maybe soon, Correa

No, he says he doesn't want it to go to foreign capitalists. but he's more than happy to send it to Colombian socialist guerillas, or to use it in PR stunts in America.

Venezuela now is making billions of dollars out of oil.
Does he use billions of dollars for the PR stunts?
Can you provide evidence?
BTW..
Is not America the second exporters of guns and tanks all over the world?
http://www.nationmaster.com/graph/mil_con_arm_exp-military-conventional-arms-exports
Now, if America is exporting more than 5 billions of conventional arms all over the world ( speaking only about ceonventional arms ), how can you even start talking about Chavez exporting money abroad?
This is what I call the " clean-your-own-back-yard-first "

Well, then why criticize Bush, which you just did? Bush is also elected.

I criticize Bush for his foreign policy, not for internal American affair.
And I always keep in mind that Berlusconi was with Bush.
You always forget about who is Bush, when you speak about Chavez..

GDP does not measure improvement in lives of the poor.
The unemployment figures represent a tiny dip in unemployment and in fact do not compare favorably with his neighbors' economic figures.

The figure I posted show quite a remarkable dip in unemployment from 16% to 12%, in the period I was talking about.
Also, unemployment in 2005 was at the lowest levels from 1999, when Chavez took office
Disclaimer
I do not think that Chavez` s policy could be successful in the long run.

Good, because you clearly don't understand economics.

Good, you clearly do not understand economics and international politics

No, they can have an impact on the poor, depending on other factors. But the UN figures, which actually measure the poor's standar do fliving, show that other factors are in fact overwhelming the cherry-picked data you've been citing.

This is a blatant lie.
I did not cherry picked any data, as I pointed the link to the main page of Wikipedia, and quoted all the data there were in that page.
And, when I talked about particular time-frames, I esplicitly wrote that I was not talking about a dip in general of unemployment, but a dip from 2003 to 2005 ( I even aknowledgede that 2003 was a particular bad year )

I'm showing you data on the actual standard of living and you are trying to rebut it with an incomplete assessment of secondary factors.

I would not consider the unemployment ratio as a " secondary factor " in the economy of a nation, and on the quality of life of the poors.
[irony]
But, since you know about economics and I do not, maybe you are right
[/irony]

Why is it so important for you to keep reiterating a point I never disputed and in fact agreed upon from the very beginning?

Just to be sure that we agree on this.

I did consider it and I explained why your data doesn't rebut my point. You don't seem to even comprehend the UN data I showed you.

Someone who is literate and able to read economic data.

Yawn..

Disclaimer
I am not claiming that Chavez` s policy is right or wrong, I just say that people of Venezuela should decide about Venezuela.
And a person who lives in a nation where president is Bush, should be careful about calling a foreign leader a demagogue, when he may have a demagogue as his president
 
If I generated confusion, I beg for pardon.
No problem. I'm just glad we cleared that up. I thought I was going mad!

Not if the politician who has done " arguably worse things " is the president of your country.
First, you have to look at the guy you have elected and then, look at what Chavez has done.
Why? I voted against Bush and contribute to the folks who seek to replace him. All of the elected representatives in my district are outspoken critics of Bush. Short of armed resistance (which I don't support) there's nothing more that I can do to oust Bush.

So because the majority of my country chose a President that I didn't vote for you think I'm not allowed to criticize Chavez? Matteo, that makes no sense.

I do not like Chavez at all, and maybe he is a demagogue, but I do not speak loud against him as you do, since he has held free elections, so far, and has never attacked, not even plan to attack, any other country.
I don't set standards so low that foreign leaders are immune from criticism just because they don't invade other countries and were elected.

I note that in a recent newsletter on the JREF, James Randi criticizes South African President Thabo Mbeki for embracing woo theories on AIDS. Mbeki was elected and has never caused South Africa to invade another. Was Randi (an American) wrong for criticizing Mbeki?

Is Randi now barred from exposing woo in foreign governments until Bush leaves office?

Especially, you should not speak loud against him, after what Bush has done so far.
Why must my ability to offer criticism on any topic be diminished because of a President I did not support?!

I just wrote, in the same sentence about being a demagogue and taking away free elections, two points not necessarily linked.
But you did so to criticize me for calling him a demagogue. Do you have a substantive criticism of that assessment. What if the criticism came from a Canadian rather than an American? Would it be okay?

" Clean-your-own-back-yard-first " means, look to what you are doing
You have no idea what I am doing.

Is it so difficult to get?
Yes, Matteo. Your argument that my President disallows me from offering criticism of any other elected leader is irrational. I don't understand this argument at all.

I do not think that he can be pardoned for shutting down media and newspapers
Well can I criticize him for that? Or do I have to wait for Bush to leave office?

I do not think that Iraq and Saddam were the " good guys ".
Matteo, I really don't understand why you insist on throwing all these no sequiturs into our conversation.
" A dip in unemployment, my dear guy, means a lot for the poors. "
You wrote:
" Not enough, however, according to the UN ".

Where does the UN state that a dip in unemployement does not mean a lot for the poors?
In the link I provide when they show that notwithstanding any dip in unemployment, the lives of the Venezuelan poor are lagging behind their neighbors.

I wrote also:
" Chavez is saying he is statalizing the oil industry for the exact goal not to let revenues from oil go abroad "
I did quote that!

Venezuela now is making billions of dollars out of oil.
Does he use billions of dollars for the PR stunts?
Can you provide evidence?
I did.

Is not America the second exporters of guns and tanks all over the world?
Do you have any substantive response other than the tu quoque fallacy.

Matteo, not every American is a supporter of George Bush. I don't attribute to you every stupid thing Romano Prodi might say.

I criticize Bush for his foreign policy, not for internal American affair.
Why should I be held to your arbitrary standards of criticism?

You always forget about who is Bush, when you speak about Chavez.
Why should I remember him? He's not relevant to this conversation. Do you forget about Prodi when you speak about Chavez?!

The figure I posted show quite a remarkable dip in unemployment from 16% to 12%, in the period I was talking about.
And the figures I showed were standard of living from 1995 to 2005, showing Venezuela lagging behnd.

DO you not understand that you are tyring to use unemployment to infer information about standard of living and I am giving you direct measurements of standards of living? Your indirect measurements are less persuasive that the UN's direct measurements.
Why are you being condescending? I have never condescended to you.

I just say that people of Venezuela should decide about Venezuela.
Yes, but that's not all you say. And you say it in places where it is a total non sequitur.

I'm not saying Chavez should be forcibly removed. I'm saying Chavez is a demagogue whose domestic policies are worthy of reproach and who is not well serving his constituents.
 
I would have no problem admitting that whatsoever, except for the fact that might be considered a criticism of Berlusconi and under Matteo Martini's Rules of ConductTM, I might not be allowed to offer any criticism of foreign leaders until January 2009. ;)
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom