Chavez taking necessary steps to ensure equality and liberty

Actually, we've established that I know the definition of the word demagogue (in English). You certainly haven't established that you do.

Yawn..

Why not? Maybe this is lost in translation, but when someone claims they "have never dared to do" something, it indicates they are fearful of doing such a thing. Do you mean to write that you are afraid of calling Bush a moron?

I try to respect other countries` head of state ( Bush and Chavez included ) when they have been free and fairly elected and they do not do anything wrong with other countries; the latter applies to Chavez, but not to Bush, unfortunately, but I try to avoid calling Bush with names as well.
By the way, since you did you call Bush as a " demagogue " and a " moron ", i beg to notice, that you and Chavez have something in common
:)

I don't believe in collective guilt. I don't blame Venezuelans for electing Chavez. I blame Chavez for his own policies. I don't blame Americans for Bush's errors. I don't blame Russians for Putin's errors. I don't blame Italians for Prodi's errors. And now, I will not continue to derail this thread further. Unless your comments are about Chavez, I will be ignoring them in this thread.

No, no..
Please, do not go away.
This is the main point of discussion.
Why should not Americans take the blame if Bush does mistakes/crimes, if they have elected him twice?
Why should not Velezuelans take the blame if Chavez does mistakes/crimes, if they have elected him?
Power of voting gives you freedom to choose your candidate, but, also the responsibility of that choice, uh?

Well, then your admonition to "clean my own backyard" doesn't apply to me, does it?

No, but it applies to many many people who live close to you..

See, that wasn't so difficult, was it?

:)
 
I don't believe in collective guilt. I don't blame Venezuelans for electing Chavez. I blame Chavez for his own policies. I don't blame Americans for Bush's errors. I don't blame Russians for Putin's errors. I don't blame Italians for Prodi's errors. And now, I will not continue to derail this thread further. Unless your comments are about Chavez, I will be ignoring them in this thread.

BTW, if talking about real leaders ( Bush, Chavez, Putin ) is unconfortable for you, we can talk about a leader X of country Y, if this is more OK with you..
 
Forget about Bush/Gore for a momment. Think in broader terms. Do you really think its always such a black-and-white situation? It's always good guy x bad guy?

Let me present an example. I said Lula was a disappointment for me. Would I vote for him again? It depends, Matteo... Before his re-election, there was a chance that the other candidate would be a politician who has the nasty tendency of mixing religion with politics and is involved with several issues related to corruption and has poor administrative skills, among other things.

Lesser evil (or "less worse") voting policy, Matteo... Dumping my vote on the garbage bin would be a moronic act. In this case, I think the right way, the only way, would be to do what we called back in the millitary dictatorship times the "usefull vote". Lula would have my vote, again.

Lesser evil, " lesser worse "or not, you should take responsibility of your vote.
If the two ( 3 or 5 ) cadidates are all unacceptable, you can always cast a blank or invalid vote, in sign of protest.
Nobody forces you to vote a candidate you do not want.
If you vote for someone, you are supporting him, and you should take responsibility for this.
You can be wrong the first time, as you do not know the guy very well, but, if you vote for him again, after x years of presidency, and he keeps making mistakes/crimes, you can not claim, at the end, that you were just " wrong ".
You have to admit you were a moron.

When I say Chavez is a demagogue, I can back my opinion. For example, he threatened to expropriate supermarkets that were not selling goods (meat, milk, eggs, etc.) at the price that was set by his government (http://oglobo.globo.com/economia/mat/2007/02/15/294585756.asp). Two prime examples of demagogy and flawed policy, in my opinion. Weights like a duck, quacks like a duck, looks like a duck, tates like a duck...

Setting prices for goods, is not being a demagogue, is an economic strategy, not demagogy.
You can agree with it or not ( I do not want to debate this ), but it is a legitimate economic strategy

So, if you can back the "Bush is a moron" statement, you are free to call him a moron.

The comment " Bush is a moron " can be backed quite easily, but I will not say that Bush is a moron

Now, going further and making such a sweeping statement as "all Bush voters are morons" or "all Chavez voters are dummies" is just plain wrong, for the reasons I exposed before.

Which I reject.
Too easy to vote for someone ( twice ), and then do not take responsibility of your vote.

Your opinion, Matteo. You may be wrong. You can't really say all these people thought "it was bad" voting Gore or Kerry or that Bush voters are morons. Try wearing their shoes, try thinking like some of them at the elections. I will not deny that there are morons (on both sides).

FYI, I do not agree with Bush in many ways. But I don't support making sweeping generalizations about the people who voted for him (or Gore, or Kerry, or Chavez, or Lula), even if I disagree with them.

So, if some American thought that voting for Kerry and Gore could have been so so bad, but they still did not want to vote for Bush, they could have cast a void or invalid ballot, or do not go to vote.
I use only the American example, but, you can talk about Brazil, if you like

Maybe. But this does not mean they are right and I am a moron. It may have been my mis-evaluation, it may have been because I was really scared by "the terrorist threat to the free world", it may have been because I felt despite his errors in Iraq he's got better chances to deal with it than the other guy...

If you mis-evaluation the the performance of a president, four years after he is doing his job, that makes you at least " quite moronic ", at least in the act of choosing presidents..
BTW, the vote of the 2004, was held in November 2004, quite some time after Iraq was invaded, and quite after the results of the Iraq invasion were seen..

Wait wait wait...
Who's saying "we are not responsible"?
Me?

I'm just saying that making a sweeping generalization such as "they are all morons" is not right.

Then, if you have mistaken in choosing a president ( twice ), call yourself as you should.

Not as fast as it could, not as fast as it should.
And its not growing because Lula. Its growing because some private companies are growing, mostly fueled by external markets demand. Its their work, not this government's work.
We have serious transportation and power generation/transmittion problems that threaten this growth. And Lula, so far, has done very little to solve the problems besides talking, talking and talking a bit more.

At least, Lula is not stopping other nations to do business in Brazil, right.
That is already something ( if you look at Morales, Chavez and Castro, for example )
 
Disclaimer
I do not think that Bush, Putin or Chavez or Lula, should be called names, for what they do inside their own countries, if they have been voted with free and fair elections, unless they do genocides, mass killings, or something like that..
 
since you did you call Bush as a " demagogue " and a " moron ", i beg to notice, that you and Chavez have something in common :)
We have many things in common. You and I have many things in common. You and Bush have many things in common. Bush and I have many things in common.

Heck, you and I share 98% of our genetic code with chimps. Having commonality is pretty common.

It's the differences that make life interesting.

Why should not Velezuelans take the blame if Chavez does mistakes/crimes, if they have elected him?
Because too many factors go into a single vote. Who were the other options? Were the voters deceived by the candidate? Were the issues on which Chavez is being criticized even known to the voters at the time? Has the candidate changed position since the last vote? These are only examples. It is wrong to attribute to an electorate all the wrongs of their elected officials. Voting is a single act based on innumerable factors.

Power of voting gives you freedom to choose your candidate, but, also the responsibility of that choice, uh?
Being blamed for the failures of the representatives is not a parcel of that responsibility, however. Living with those failures is.

No, but it applies to many many people who live close to you.
So what? You're not having a discussion with those people, but with me.

BTW, if talking about real leaders ( Bush, Chavez, Putin ) is unconfortable for you, we can talk about a leader X of country Y, if this is more OK with you..
It's not uncomfortable. It's off-topic.

I do not think that Bush, Putin or Chavez or Lula, should be called names, for what they do inside their own countries, if they have been voted with free and fair elections, unless they do genocides, mass killings, or something like that..
Define "something like that". At what point are internal policies of elected officials deserving of criticism?

Here's some hypotheticals.
  • Chavez makes it illegal to worship in the Hindu faith. Can non-Venezuelan Hindus complain? Can they even call him a name like "anti-Hindu bigot"?
  • Chavez taxes tomatoes, doubling their price. Can Italian tomato exporters complain? Can they even call him a name, like "protectionist"?
  • Chavez makes it a crime to use a picture of the late Luciano Pavorotti as your avatar in any website that can be viewed from Venezuela. Can you complain? Could you even call him a name, like "uncultured cretin"?
 
Lesser evil, " lesser worse "or not, you should take responsibility of your vote.
If the two ( 3 or 5 ) cadidates are all unacceptable, you can always cast a blank or invalid vote, in sign of protest.
Nobody forces you to vote a candidate you do not want.
If you vote for someone, you are supporting him, and you should take responsibility for this.
That's an issue that has been debated countless times here in Brazil, back in the millitary dictatorship days (and before). We used invalid votes a number of times as a sign of protest against the government(s). An old rhino and a chimp got a lot of votes...

For a while, I considered null and invalid votes as a good protest strategy. Nowadays, I think its not, since the number of null and invalid votes will most likely never be high enough to render the election itself invalid. And elected candidates never cared about having less votes than the null+invalid votes, as far as I know. So, personally, I stick with the "less worse" usefull vote option.

Note that we had elections back in the millitary rule. However, the candidates were pre-chosen among those less likely to pose any significant challenge to the government and were not even close to the left. In other words, the government controlled the elections.

In other words, being legally elected may not necessarily mean the true will of the people...

You can be wrong the first time, as you do not know the guy very well, but, if you vote for him again, after x years of presidency, and he keeps making mistakes/crimes, you can not claim, at the end, that you were just " wrong ".
You have to admit you were a moron.
Only if there were other (and better) options. You are building a false dichotomy, Matteo.

Setting prices for goods, is not being a demagogue, is an economic strategy, not demagogy.
You can agree with it or not ( I do not want to debate this ), but it is a legitimate economic strategy
Legial, it may be, but its also demagogic, innefective and has negative side-effects. Just like threats expropriating supermarkets and turning them in to state-owned companies...
Been, there, seen that, done that... OK, not at Venezuela, but right here in Brazil. The cause? Cheap demagogic discourse and actions. The result? A failure. I have no reasons to believe the same will not happen elsewhere.

The comment " Bush is a moron " can be backed quite easily, but I will not say that Bush is a moron
So say it. I say Chavez is a demagogue and his polictical actions indicate a totalitarian tendency.
Regarding Bush, I would not use moron. I would use (when it comes to external policy) arrogant, stubborn, prone to miscalculations, etc.

Which I reject.
Too easy to vote for someone ( twice ), and then do not take responsibility of your vote.
And I reject easy sweeping generalizations and collective guit.

So, if some American thought that voting for Kerry and Gore could have been so so bad, but they still did not want to vote for Bush, they could have cast a void or invalid ballot, or do not go to vote.
I use only the American example, but, you can talk about Brazil, if you like
Its not "so so bad" its just "worse", I mean "more worse", in their opinion, to keep the linguistic wreck.

And I have already used examples from Brazil where I considered a null or invalid vote option as not appliable. Between Lula and the guy who mixes religion with politics, I would vote Lula, the "lesser worse".

If you mis-evaluation the the performance of a president, four years after he is doing his job, that makes you at least " quite moronic ", at least in the act of choosing presidents..
BTW, the vote of the 2004, was held in November 2004, quite some time after Iraq was invaded, and quite after the results of the Iraq invasion were seen..
You are making a false dicothomy. As I wrote before, there are more than just two options, such as
because I was really scared by "the terrorist threat to the free world", it may have been because I felt despite his error in Iraq he's got better chances to deal with it than the other guy
among others.

Then, if you have mistaken in choosing a president ( twice ), call yourself as you should.
False dicothomy, again.

At least, Lula is not stopping other nations to do business in Brazil, right.
That is already something ( if you look at Morales, Chavez and Castro, for example )
Directly not. But he is not contributing as he should for the advance of the economy by improving transport, power generation/distribution, new taxes legislation, education, health and security. Where would you invest your money? A country with good transport and power generation/distribution infrastructre or one with poor infrastructure? He also sometimes makes some demagogic speeches that may harm our frail economy.
 
Yes it's too bad they don't have complete freedom of the press like we have in the good ole USA. Freedom to print as much news as you can buy.

http://usinfo.state.gov/media/misinformation.html
Identifying Misinformation

http://www.netscape.com/viewstory/2...le/2006/02/13/AR2006021301897.html&frame=true

UPDATE: PREPACKAGED NEWS
2006 The Washington Post
Tuesday, February 14, 2006; Page A13
How much is good press worth? To the Bush administration, about $1.6 billion.
That's how much seven federal departments spent from 2003 through the second quarter of 2005 on 343 contracts with public relations firms, advertising agencies, media organizations and individuals, according to a new Government Accountability Office report.

http://www.counterpunch.org/cnnpsyops.html

CNN AND PSYOPS
By Alexander Cockburn
March 26, 2000
“The facts are", De Vries told me, " that the US Army, US Special Operations Command and CNN personnel confirmed to me that military personnel have been involved in news production at CNN's newsdesks.

http://www.buzzflash.com/analysis/03/04/18_clear.html

One Thing is Crystal Clear: Clear Channel is a Subsidiary of Bush, Inc

The Texas-based Clear Channel Worldwide, Inc., a media giant with a nationwide network of 1,240 radio stations –- and a clear line to Bush.
It's no coincidence that Clear Channel executives Tom Hicks and L. Lowry Mays have contributed tens of thousands of dollars to Bush's gubernatorial and presidential campaign coffers. Or that Clear Channel gave $119,370 in "soft money" to Republicans in 2001-2002, this on top of the $82,850 it gave in 2000. (Democrats, meanwhile, got $25,000 in soft money in that same three-year period.) Or that Clear Channel stations have been known to pull radio ads criticizing Republicans.

http://mediamatters.org/items/200412010002

FOXNews.com, Chicago Sun-Times deleted connection between Ohio official, Bush campaign from AP story
In a November 30 article titled "Nearly a Month Later, Ohio Fight Goes On," detailing the controversy in Ohio over the results of the November 2 election, the Associated Press correctly identified J. Kenneth Blackwell -- who, as Ohio's secretary of state, oversees the election process -- as "a co-chairman of Bush's re-election campaign in Ohio." But two large news organizations, FOXNews.com and the Chicago Sun-Times, omitted that reference from their versions of the story.

http://archives.cnn.com/2000/ALLPOLITICS/stories/12/12/tv.foxexecutive.ap/
Fox executive spoke five times with cousin Bush on Election Night
December 12, 2000
Web posted at: 9:24 AM EST (1424 GMT)
NEW YORK (AP) -- The head of Fox's projection team said he spoke five times with his cousin, George W. Bush, on election night but insists he did not give out confidential exit poll information. Bush got that information elsewhere, he said.
 
Ah, the tu quoque fallacy. Is there any thread that cannot be turned into a cause to bash America?
 
We have many things in common. You and I have many things in common. You and Bush have many things in common. Bush and I have many things in common.

Heck, you and I share 98% of our genetic code with chimps. Having commonality is pretty common.

It's the differences that make life interesting.

You and Chavez seem to have much more in common than 98% of the genetic code.

Because too many factors go into a single vote. Who were the other options? Were the voters deceived by the candidate? Were the issues on which Chavez is being criticized even known to the voters at the time? Has the candidate changed position since the last vote? These are only examples. It is wrong to attribute to an electorate all the wrongs of their elected officials. Voting is a single act based on innumerable factors.

Generally speaking, and considering Chavez` s case, if voters are deceived by a leader, that means, that, at least, the voters have been naive.
If also, like in the case of Bush, the voters vote for him twice, that means an even strong connection ( and co-responsibility ) between the leader` s actions and the voters` intentions.
BTW, in the case of Bush and ( for what I know ) Chavez, the two did not change so much their positions, from the positions which they held when they have been elected.

Being blamed for the failures of the representatives is not a parcel of that responsibility, however. Living with those failures is.

Again, I do think that voters should take responsibility of the people who vote, and have ( indirect ) responsibility of his actions.
This is even more true, if the leader has been voted twice.

So what? You're not having a discussion with those people, but with me.

OK with that.
Just remembering you that there are a lot of people who have voted for a person who you called as " moron " and " demagogue " near you.
Not so far away.
Just remembering you..

It's not uncomfortable. It's off-topic.

Can not see why we can not make comparisons between Chavez and Bush, and Putin, in this thread..
Is it forbidden?

Define "something like that". At what point are internal policies of elected officials deserving of criticism?

In my opinion, in cases of genocide, killings of many people, etc.
The cases of Darfur, just to give you an example.
Or, in case of sending to death a large number of people
Not because a foregin leader shuts a news paper or has commuinists views on the economy.

Here's some hypotheticals.
[Chavez makes it illegal to worship in the Hindu faith. Can non-Venezuelan Hindus complain? Can they even call him a name like "anti-Hindu bigot"?

Again.
You see how biased you are?
Why do you have the " In God we trust " over the dollar?
Why are you leaving out, let` s say, Buddhists?

Taken from the State of Texas Constitution, Article 1 — BILL OF RIGHTS, Section 4 — RELIGIOUS TESTS:

No religious test shall ever be required as a qualification to any office, or public trust, in this State; nor shall any one be excluded from holding office on account of his religious sentiments, provided he acknowledge the existence of a Supreme Being.

See how much biased you are?
The examples above are not hypotheticals

Chavez taxes tomatoes, doubling their price. Can Italian tomato exporters complain? Can they even call him a name, like "protectionist"?

Let` s talk about the farm subsides which Europe and the US have put in place, which have been criticized as they seem to be used to prevent third world economies from making business with them?
This is not an hypotetical, it is a fact.
See, how biased you are?

[*]Chavez makes it a crime to use a picture of the late Luciano Pavorotti as your avatar in any website that can be viewed from Venezuela. Can you complain? Could you even call him a name, like "uncultured cretin"?[/list]

We are flying high on hypotheticals, here..
 
Last edited:
Ah, the tu quoque fallacy. Is there any thread that cannot be turned into a cause to bash America?

Wait a second..
I am not bashing anyone.
I like America ( well, not the current administration` s foreign policy)、but I think a lot ( and, when I say a lot, I mean a lot ) of things in America should be learned by the rest of the world as:
- freedom of expression
- the scientific and academic American world
- start-ups and the entrepreneurial system;
- freedom of press;
- Microsoft, AMD, Google, Intel, Genentech, Nanosolar, and a whole lot of other companies;
- Ray Kurzweil;
- IBM and what they are doing with nanotech;
- ..
I could continue for hours

I am just concerned with the fact that many Americans ( you included ) are too biased in making statements about foreign countries.
 
That's an issue that has been debated countless times here in Brazil, back in the millitary dictatorship days (and before). We used invalid votes a number of times as a sign of protest against the government(s). An old rhino and a chimp got a lot of votes...

Then, if they got a lot of votes, a lot of people have voted for them
If the elections were free

For a while, I considered null and invalid votes as a good protest strategy. Nowadays, I think its not, since the number of null and invalid votes will most likely never be high enough to render the election itself invalid. And elected candidates never cared about having less votes than the null+invalid votes, as far as I know. So, personally, I stick with the "less worse" usefull vote option.

If we are speaking about Chavez, I beg you to remember that the population, according to independent polls, seems to back him ( until recent times, at least )
If you are speaking aboutb Bush, I beg you to remember that, in the 2000 elections, there were, only in the primaries, some ten candidates or so, and Bush has been chosen among them.
In the 2004, you could choose between Bush and Kerry, and I have watched that elections quite closely, and I can not imagine how a person can say that Kerry is such a bad evil..
That is, they voted for Bush because they liked him, not because they had to

Note that we had elections back in the millitary rule. However, the candidates were pre-chosen among those less likely to pose any significant challenge to the government and were not even close to the left. In other words, the government controlled the elections.
In other words, being legally elected may not necessarily mean the true will of the people...

This is why I was speaking about free elections, not about legal elections

Only if there were other (and better) options. You are building a false dichotomy, Matteo.

Legial, it may be, but its also demagogic, innefective and has negative side-effects. Just like threats expropriating supermarkets and turning them in to state-owned companies...
Been, there, seen that, done that... OK, not at Venezuela, but right here in Brazil. The cause? Cheap demagogic discourse and actions. The result? A failure. I have no reasons to believe the same will not happen elsewhere.

Very well.
Venezuelans will pay for having chosen the wrong leader

So say it. I say Chavez is a demagogue and his polictical actions indicate a totalitarian tendency.
Regarding Bush, I would not use moron. I would use (when it comes to external policy) arrogant, stubborn, prone to miscalculations, etc.

I would not also say that Bush is a " moron ".
But, he was wrong to invade Iraq

And I reject easy sweeping generalizations and collective guit.

Too easy to vote for a candidate ( once or even twice ) and then claim " I did not know "..

Its not "so so bad" its just "worse", I mean "more worse", in their opinion, to keep the linguistic wreck.

And I have already used examples from Brazil where I considered a null or invalid vote option as not appliable. Between Lula and the guy who mixes religion with politics, I would vote Lula, the "lesser worse".

Then, if Lula does something really bad, you also should take the responsibility of having put in power that man ( Lula )

You are making a false dicothomy. As I wrote before, there are more than just two options, such as among others.


False dicothomy, again.

Uh?
I am not used to such difficult words " dichotomy " :)

Directly not. But he is not contributing as he should for the advance of the economy by improving transport, power generation/distribution, new taxes legislation, education, health and security. Where would you invest your money? A country with good transport and power generation/distribution infrastructre or one with poor infrastructure? He also sometimes makes some demagogic speeches that may harm our frail economy.

OK
I do not want to speak so much about a leader of a country I do not know so so well.
But, Lula has been voted twice, won well, and there were many other candidates, uh?
Many Brazilians seem to like him..
 
I am not used to such difficult words " dichotomy " :)
Dichotomy: Binary. Bifurcate. Yes/no. On/Of. 0/1.

False dichotomy: falsified dilemma, fallacy of the excluded middle, black and white thinking, false correlative, either/or fallacy.
 
Then, if they got a lot of votes, a lot of people have voted for them
If the elections were free
They were not. The candidates were pre-chosen by the millitary.
However, since the voters had to write the names of the candidates in the ballots, Cacareco the rhino and Tião the chimp could receive votes...

Writing sentences with the f-word was also quite common.

If we are speaking about Chavez, I beg you to remember that the population, according to independent polls, seems to back him ( until recent times, at least )
Polls -as well as how their results are presented- can be deceiving.
And how exactly would this backing be? They back him because they truly belive an support his polices? Or because they see no other option?

If you are speaking aboutb Bush, I beg you to remember that, in the 2000 elections, there were, only in the primaries, some ten candidates or so, and Bush has been chosen among them.
In the 2004, you could choose between Bush and Kerry, and I have watched that elections quite closely, and I can not imagine how a person can say that Kerry is such a bad evil..
That is, they voted for Bush because they liked him, not because they had to
You are being too black-and-white, again.
Maybe these people voted Bush just because they considered him a better option. It may have nothing to do with "liking Bush" or considering Kerry "such a bad evil"...

This is why I was speaking about free elections, not about legal elections
Chavez's election: free and legal or just legal?
Check these legal elections:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/2331951.stm
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/6700021.stm
Were they free? What about the guys who won them? What would be the results of polls regarding the support they receive from the population?

Very well.
Venezuelans will pay for having chosen the wrong leader
"Pay for their choice"...
Black-and-white reasoning again, Matteo!
What options they had instead of Chavez?

Following this line of reasoning, these people are also paying for their choice...
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/2331951.stm

Wouldn't it be more precise to say people pay for the choices their leaders make? Leaders that quite often are not the ones people would really like or deserve to have?

I would not also say that Bush is a " moron ".
But, he was wrong to invade Iraq
I agree he was wrong.
But by no means I think its correct to blame all Americans -not even all of those who voted in Bush- for the war and its consequences.

Too easy to vote for a candidate ( once or even twice ) and then claim " I did not know "..
As easy as it is to make sweeping generalizations...
As easy as it is to evaluate possibilities with hindsight bias...

Then, if Lula does something really bad, you also should take the responsibility of having put in power that man ( Lula )
So, if he dissolves the congress and labells himself Lula I, emperor of the Kingdom of Brazil, its my fault?
People pay for the choices their leaders make, but people are not necessarily responsible by their leader's mistakes...

Uh?
I am not used to such difficult words " dichotomy " :)
Check RandFan's Huntster moment:p
Sorry, RandFan, I'm really sorry. I just could not resist... My bad... Mea culpa, mea culpa, mea maxima culpa. Matteo, people can call me a moron for making bad jokes, but not for voting Lula.

OK
I do not want to speak so much about a leader of a country I do not know so so well.
But, Lula has been voted twice, won well, and there were many other candidates, uh?
Many Brazilians seem to like him..
So what?
Does it makes him a good politician?
Does it forces me to agree with his actions?
Many Brazilians do like him. But what are the other options?
And even if I liked him, do I have to fully agree and support him?
Other folks were elected at other countries twice (or more) and running against other candidates...
The people of these countries, all of them agree with and like the winner?
What were the backgounds, the contexts of the elections?
Do we, as foreign people, have to agree with and like the winners?
 
They were not. The candidates were pre-chosen by the millitary.
However, since the voters had to write the names of the candidates in the ballots, Cacareco the rhino and Tião the chimp could receive votes...

Writing sentences with the f-word was also quite common.


Polls -as well as how their results are presented- can be deceiving.
And how exactly would this backing be? They back him because they truly belive an support his polices? Or because they see no other option?

Elections in Brazil under the military were not " free ".
Elections in Venezuela were free with other potential good electable candidates running.
Quite a difference

You are being too black-and-white, again.
Maybe these people voted Bush just because they considered him a better option. It may have nothing to do with "liking Bush" or considering Kerry "such a bad evil"...


Chavez's election: free and legal or just legal?
Check these legal elections:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/2331951.stm
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/6700021.stm
Were they free? What about the guys who won them? What would be the results of polls regarding the support they receive from the population?

You are making a sound mistake!!
Do not compare elections in Iraq under Saddam, with elections in Venezuela

President Hugo Chavez of Venezuela has won a third term in office, securing a clear lead over rival Manuel Rosales.

Read this carefully:
Sunday's election saw a high turnout and the poll was monitored by hundreds of international observers.

From the BBC:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/6205128.stm

"Pay for their choice"...
Black-and-white reasoning again, Matteo!
What options they had instead of Chavez?

This guy:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manuel_Rosales

Not an idiot, nor a criminal, it seems..

Following this line of reasoning, these people are also paying for their choice...
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/middle_east/2331951.stm

Yawn..

Wouldn't it be more precise to say people pay for the choices their leaders make? Leaders that quite often are not the ones people would really like or deserve to have?

Too easy..
Too easy..

I agree he was wrong.
But by no means I think its correct to blame all Americans -not even all of those who voted in Bush- for the war and its consequences.

Disagreeing with you.

So, if he dissolves the congress and labells himself Lula I, emperor of the Kingdom of Brazil, its my fault?
People pay for the choices their leaders make, but people are not necessarily responsible by their leader's mistakes...

" not necesarily " OK
But, they are quite often responsibile.
BTW, in the case of George W, he was re-elected after he invaded Iraq

So what?
Does it makes him a good politician?

If the majority of people like him, he is a good politician, quite by definition

Does it forces me to agree with his actions?

No

Many Brazilians do like him. But what are the other options?

There were quite many options, during the elections
And, you know it.

And even if I liked him, do I have to fully agree and support him?

Not fully agree, but you take responsibility of your vote

Other folks were elected at other countries twice (or more) and running against other candidates...
The people of these countries, all of them agree with and like the winner?
What were the backgounds, the contexts of the elections?
Do we, as foreign people, have to agree with and like the winners?

No time to reply to this.
It is quite long..
 
No time to reply to this.
It is quite long..
Well Matteo, this whole discussion boils down to these questions.
The "everyone who voted for X is a moron" line is directly related to the questions below.

The people of these countries, all of them agree with and like the winner?
What were the backgounds, the contexts of the elections?
Do we, as foreign people, have to agree with and like the winners?

The rest of your post, well, its a bit late here and tonight I'm quite tired... Please forgive me if I comment it a bit later.
 
Well Matteo, this whole discussion boils down to these questions.
The "everyone who voted for X is a moron" line is directly related to the questions below.

I think that if a person voted for a almost-universally-recognized-as-moron PM or president once or, even more, twice, he has to acknowledge that he/she too, is quite moronic, at least, when it comes to vote.

The rest of your post, well, its a bit late here and tonight I'm quite tired... Please forgive me if I comment it a bit later.

Good night!!
 
Last edited:
Still tired and sleepy, but here it goes...
Elections in Brazil under the military were not " free ".
Elections in Venezuela were free with other potential good electable candidates running.
Quite a difference
"Potentially good" does not mean the other candidate was considered as better than Chavez...

You are making a sound mistake!!
Do not compare elections in Iraq under Saddam, with elections in Venezuela

President Hugo Chavez of Venezuela has won a third term in office, securing a clear lead over rival Manuel Rosales.

Read this carefully:
Sunday's election saw a high turnout and the poll was monitored by hundreds of international observers.

From the BBC:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/americas/6205128.stm
Of course I was, and on purpose!
See? Sweeping generalizations and dichotomies are quite often flawed.

This guy:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Manuel_Rosales

Not an idiot, nor a criminal, it seems..
Maybe so, maybe no. Who knows (specially if you evaluate it all within the context)?
At this very Wikilinkie, one can read that he participated at a coup attemp in a "moment of confusion"...

Wait, so did the "democratic" Chavez!

So, putting things in context, can someone really say there were any "good" options?

Or they just choosed the "less worse"?

Yes, that's the reaction sweeping generalizations cause...

Disagreeing with you.
OK, its your right.

" not necesarily " OK
But, they are quite often responsibile.
BTW, in the case of George W, he was re-elected after he invaded Iraq
Quite often is not the same thing as always.
And again, you should view things under the propper context.
DISCLAIMER:
I do not support Bush's external policies. I am not defending him. I am only saying that voters usually can not take full responsability for the actions of the politicians they elected.

If the majority of people like him, he is a good politician, quite by definition
Depends on your defiition of good politician. If by "good politician" you mean a politician that manages to re-elect himself for president, then he is.
But wait, then Bush is also a good politician!

Then we must mean something else by "good politician", don't we?

There were quite many options, during the elections
And, you know it.
I know that there were other options. However, it doesn't mean I considered any of them as "good".

Not fully agree, but you take responsibility of your vote
For my vote? Yes.
For all the (good or bad) actions of the person I voted in? No.

I think that if a person voted for a almost-universally-recognized-as-moron PM or president once or, even more, twice, he has to acknowledge that he/she too, is quite moronic, at least, when it comes to vote.
I disgree with you, for the reasons I exposed before.
Context, Matteo, context. And shades of grey instead of black-and-white...
 
Still tired and sleepy, but here it goes...

"Potentially good" does not mean the other candidate was considered as better than Chavez...

Mr. Rosales looked quite as a good candidate..

Of course I was, and on purpose!
See? Sweeping generalizations and dichotomies are quite often flawed.

Iraq is not comparable with Venezuela

Maybe so, maybe no. Who knows (specially if you evaluate it all within the context)?
At this very Wikilinkie, one can read that he participated at a coup attemp in a "moment of confusion"...

Wait, so did the "democratic" Chavez!

So, putting things in context, can someone really say there were any "good" options?

Or they just choosed the "less worse"?

Choosing the " less worse " is still a choice which demands responsibility

Quite often is not the same thing as always.
And again, you should view things under the propper context.
DISCLAIMER:
I do not support Bush's external policies. I am not defending him. I am only saying that voters usually can not take full responsability for the actions of the politicians they elected.

But they should take partial responsibility..


Depends on your defiition of good politician. If by "good politician" you mean a politician that manages to re-elect himself for president, then he is.
But wait, then Bush is also a good politician!

Then we must mean something else by "good politician", don't we?

I am not sure.
The opinion of the majority is what counts, in this world..
Anyway..
Not the main point..

I know that there were other options. However, it doesn't mean I considered any of them as "good".

But they were there.
And you voted for Lula. Take responsiblity for that.

For my vote? Yes.
For all the (good or bad) actions of the person I voted in? No.

The two things are inter-related
 
Mr. Rosales looked quite as a good candidate..
The small detail of his participation in the coup attempt was included in your evaluation?

Truth is Chavez and Rosales were involved in coup attempts. This, IMHO indicates that both are individuals with non-democratic tendencies. One for the "right" and one from the "left", but both with evidences of anti-democratic tendencies.

My reading of the situation it that people from Venuzela considered the guy with the nationalist and leftist discourse was the "less worse" option.

Iraq is not comparable with Venezuela
And Chavez is comparable to Bush? And Venezuela is comparable to USA?

A sweeping generalization such as "All Bush voters are morons" contais similar errors and mistakes.
Every time someone sees the world in black and white similar mistakes and errors are made.

Choosing the " less worse " is still a choice which demands responsibility
For the vote? Yes.
For all the actions of the elected candidate? No.

But they should take partial responsibility..
See above.

I am not sure.
The opinion of the majority is what counts, in this world..
Anyway..
Not the main point..
You are sure of that?
I am not, on the contrary, I think quite often what actually counts is the opinion of decision makers...
I agree that this is not the main point, but there is a connection.

But they were there.
And you voted for Lula. Take responsiblity for that.
Do I need to dig a link to the post where I do take responsability for my vote?
However, I will not take responsability for his inaction when it comes to investments in infrastructure and cheap demagogic policies such as distributing food, for example. Neither for his other blunders or by some eventual success.

The two things are inter-related
Again,
Electors take responsability for their votes. However, electors are not responsible by all the actions of the persons they elected. A politician (as well as any elected person such as school director or a company's CEO may be) make his/hers own decisions following his/hers own minds. Individual choices whose burden lies upon their shoulders.

We elect people for what we expect the to do, for what we want them to do and for what we think they can do. However, as soon as they are in power, quite often what they do has little if anything to do with what we expected them to do.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom