Chavez taking necessary steps to ensure equality and liberty

Come on, admit Prodi is lightyears better than Berlusconi.

Maybe

Prodi at least has apparently no connections with mafia, he does not have many trials for corrpution as Berlusconi, does not own television or companies ( so, no conflict of interests ), he does not ctiticize the judicial system when has problems, and he is not an arrogant pompous a******* like Silvio.

But so far has solved little of the country problems, and his approval polls are from 35% to 40%.
 
No problem. I'm just glad we cleared that up. I thought I was going mad!


Why? I voted against Bush and contribute to the folks who seek to replace him. All of the elected representatives in my district are outspoken critics of Bush. Short of armed resistance (which I don't support) there's nothing more that I can do to oust Bush.

So because the majority of my country chose a President that I didn't vote for you think I'm not allowed to criticize Chavez? Matteo, that makes no sense.

Depends on the criticism.
If you said, something like:
" I do think Chavez should be bringing down free medias as he is doing

I don't set standards so low that foreign leaders are immune from criticism just because they don't invade other countries and were elected.

But, the fact they do not invade other countries, is a strong point in their favour

I note that in a recent newsletter on the JREF, James Randi criticizes South African President Thabo Mbeki for embracing woo theories on AIDS. Mbeki was elected and has never caused South Africa to invade another. Was Randi (an American) wrong for criticizing Mbeki?

Is Randi now barred from exposing woo in foreign governments until Bush leaves office?

That is quite a different thing, would you agree?
I think you should criticize ( and do more than that!! also killing him, in streme cases could be OK ) a foreign leader in cases of genocides, mass murders, failing to tackle AIDS, and some other important points.
Nothing that Chavez has done.

Why must my ability to offer criticism on any topic be diminished because of a President I did not support?!

But you did so to criticize me for calling him a demagogue. Do you have a substantive criticism of that assessment. What if the criticism came from a Canadian rather than an American? Would it be okay?

I just have the opinion that you do not assess Chavez position fairly.
I do not think any person shouls blame a foreign leader so lightly, like you did, when he has been elected with free elections and has little or no harm to foreign nations.

You have no idea what I am doing.

But I know what your country is

Yes, Matteo. Your argument that my President disallows me from offering criticism of any other elected leader is irrational. I don't understand this argument at all.

I am having an hard time criticizing a leader of a foreign country for his domestic policy, when he was elected by the majority of the people of that country.
After all, is it my or your business at all?

Well can I criticize him for that? Or do I have to wait for Bush to leave office?

Just keep in mind what Bush has done, before criticizing Chavez.
That is all I ask..

Matteo, I really don't understand why you insist on throwing all these no sequiturs into our conversation.

It was just part of the disclaimer, intended to clarify my position on America foreign policy
I wrote it as a spearate " disclaimer " part

In the link I provide when they show that notwithstanding any dip in unemployment, the lives of the Venezuelan poor are lagging behind their neighbors.

It is difficult to assess if the lives of the Venezuelan poors are doing well or not.
I just say that there is no clear evidence in one way or the other.
I do not claim anything.
I just say that, as long as the people of Venezuela are fine, I am fine too

I did quote that!

Yes, you did, but, not in the first paragraph.
Again, I wrote:
" As Chavez is claiming he is not doing.
Chavez is saying he is statalizing the oil industry for the exact goal not to let revenues from oil go abroad.
And that makes sense, even if, of course, you can not agree with him..
I can too, but we are not Venezuelan, and, as long as Venezuelans are happy with him.. "
And, I was meaning that the your reply should have address all my paragraph, not just the first, as I later explained better the meaning of the first part and, if you quoted only the first part, the meaning of the first part alone, could have been mis-leading.
But, OK, if you agree, let` s drop this point.


I do not see where Chavez has spent billions in PR stunts..

Do you have any substantive response other than the tu quoque fallacy.

Matteo, not every American is a supporter of George Bush. I don't attribute to you every stupid thing Romano Prodi might say.

Yes, not every American is a supporter of George W., and his policy, but, that does not mean you are allowed to overlook what the government of your own country is doing before criticizing other countries.
By the way, I am not sure Prodi` s comment was that stupid..

Why should I be held to your arbitrary standards of criticism?

I am just expressing my opinions here.
You can bash Chavez as long as you want, as this is a free forum.
I just do not find this 100% fair.

Why should I remember him? He's not relevant to this conversation. Do you forget about Prodi when you speak about Chavez?!

No, and I do not forget about Berlusconi too.
This is why I try not to bash Chavez for internal matters, and also, not to bash Bush for internal matters too

And the figures I showed were standard of living from 1995 to 2005, showing Venezuela lagging behnd.

DO you not understand that you are tyring to use unemployment to infer information about standard of living and I am giving you direct measurements of standards of living? Your indirect measurements are less persuasive that the UN's direct measurements.

I am not giving an finlal assesment about the state of the economy of Venezuela.
Just saying that there seems to be no final evidence that the economy of Venezuela is doing that bad..

Why are you being condescending? I have never condescended to you.

I ask sorry.
This thread is become very long.
And I am get tired, we are discussing about your comment if Chavez is should be called a demagogue or not
Maybe, too much time spent in just a comment ( my fault )

Yes, but that's not all you say. And you say it in places where it is a total non sequitur.

I'm not saying Chavez should be forcibly removed. I'm saying Chavez is a demagogue whose domestic policies are worthy of reproach and who is not well serving his constituents.

And, I replied we should not care that much, as long as the people of Venezuela are happy with him..
 
Last edited:
I would have no problem admitting that whatsoever, except for the fact that might be considered a criticism of Berlusconi and under Matteo Martini's Rules of ConductTM, I might not be allowed to offer any criticism of foreign leaders until January 2009. ;)

OK, OK, I over reacted.
BTW, I am spending time to defend Chavez, when I do not like the guy at all..
 
:)

Thats a very good thing.

Where would I derail, in my posts, without having RandFan keeping me straight all the time?

:)

BTW, RandFan, I wrote that I do not like Chavez and I do not support him at least 10 times or so, in this thread.

Please, let` s not fall again in the " you criticize the black, so you love the white " error

Second, please, remember that when I criticize Bush, I do it for his foreign policy, you will not find me calling Bush a " demagogue " for, for example, his politics on gun control, social security and so on..

As long you guys elected him, fine for me, fine for everyone..
 
BTW, RandFan, I wrote that I do not like Chavez and I do not support him at least 10 times or so, in this thread.

Please, let` s not fall again in the " you criticize the black, so you love the white " error
I'm not sure I ever made that error but I will heed the caution.

It's a good thing because that is the essence of critical thinking. It's easy to defend those you like and criticize those that you don't.

I would like to see a lot more of this. The problem is that there are so few critical thinkers... especially when it comes to politics.

Second, please, remember that when I criticize Bush, I do it for his foreign policy, you will not find me calling Bush a " demagogue " for, for example, his politics on gun control, social security and so on..
I think you are doing fine, if it is ok for me to say so? ;)
 
OK, OK, I over reacted.
BTW, I am spending time to defend Chavez, when I do not like the guy at all..
No problem. It's easy to get yourself into a rut you didn't intend. It takes a lot of maturity to see you're in the rut and pull yourself out, as you just did with much grace.

By the way, I would have no problem if you were to criticize Bush as a demagogue or for his domestic policies. You might find I would agree with you.
 
No problem. It's easy to get yourself into a rut you didn't intend. It takes a lot of maturity to see you're in the rut and pull yourself out, as you just did with much grace.

By the way, I would have no problem if you were to criticize Bush as a demagogue or for his domestic policies. You might find I would agree with you.

I will not call Bush a " demagogue ", for his internal policies, as I keep in mind it was elected by the American people in fair and regular ( almost? ) elections.

P.S.
The fact that I wrote that I " over reacted " does not mean in any way that I agree to the fact that you should call other leaders in such a way so lightly.
I think it was unneccessary to go in such a tirade just foir a word you said.
And I do think that you should clean your back yard first
Just to clarify
 
I will not call Bush a " demagogue ", for his internal policies, as I keep in mind it was elected by the American people in fair and regular ( almost? ) elections.
So what? by definition, demagogues are elected in fair elections (which are often also regular). Demogoguery has nothing to do with election fairness and I still don't know why you think that to be the be-all-end-all of criticism of foreign diplomats.

The fact that I wrote that I " over reacted " does not mean in any way that I agree to the fact that you should call other leaders in such a way so lightly.
Why do you think I call leaders like Chavez and Bush demagogues lightly? Because I used the word at all?

And I do think that you should clean your back yard first
What do you propose I do about Bush, Matteo Martini? All of my elected representatives -- from both my state Senators down to my local town mayor -- are outspoken critics of Bush. I don't vote for Bush supporters, I contribute money to their opponents.

What more am I supposed to do before you will consent to me criticizing Hugo Chavez when I think he acts inappropriately as a head of State?

I really don't understand the basis for the code of conduct to which you are trying to get me to adhere.
 
So what? by definition, demagogues are elected in fair elections (which are often also regular). Demogoguery has nothing to do with election fairness and I still don't know why you think that to be the be-all-end-all of criticism of foreign diplomats.

[..]

Sorry, but I will not reply on this.
I think I have already made my point quite effectively, and I would like not to repeat my self over and over on the same questions.
I have no intention to push the argument further to prove that I am right ( provided that I am ).
This is a free forum, please, say what you feel appropriate to say.
 
...snip...
As long you guys elected him, fine for me, fine for everyone..
Ah, if it were so simple, so easy...

Be it in Venezuela, be it in USA, Italy, Brazil, Syria, Iraq, France, Argentina, Bolivia, wherever. If the guy elected by "them" makes moves thay may create problems for "us", then its not really fine. Nowadays, in this globalized world, a bad move of CorreaNetoland's government can affect MatteoMartinica's people.

Note that this line of reasoning can lead to a Godwinian response pretty quickly. Perhaps it would be better to rethink it.
 
Ah, if it were so simple, so easy...

Be it in Venezuela, be it in USA, Italy, Brazil, Syria, Iraq, France, Argentina, Bolivia, wherever. If the guy elected by "them" makes moves thay may create problems for "us", then its not really fine. Nowadays, in this globalized world, a bad move of CorreaNetoland's government can affect MatteoMartinica's people.

Maybe you are referring to PetroBras, having investments in Venezuela.

Speaking generally, how would you put the boundary for governemnt` s actions between legitimate actions within their nations, and illegitimate?

Who should decide Venezuela` s economic policy?

Chavez, Lula、Bush??
 
Who should decide Venezuela` s economic policy?

Chavez, Lula、Bush??

No one here is "deciding" Venezuela's economic policy.

People here are -- as allowed in free countries -- offering opinions and criticisms of those policies.



Who should decide who gets to comment about such policies?
It appears -- and maybe you don't mean it this way, but it sure appears -- that you've elected yourself as the arbiter of who may talk about what regarding other countries.

Given that, do you have a list of topics that Americans and Canadians, for example, are allowed to talk about with regards to other countries?
 
Who should decide who gets to comment about such policies?
It appears -- and maybe you don't mean it this way, but it sure appears -- that you've elected yourself as the arbiter of who may talk about what regarding other countries.

Given that, do you have a list of topics that Americans and Canadians, for example, are allowed to talk about with regards to other countries?

OK, OK..

Maybe, I went a little bit too far..
 
Maybe you are referring to PetroBras, having investments in Venezuela.

Speaking generally, how would you put the boundary for governemnt` s actions between legitimate actions within their nations, and illegitimate?

Who should decide Venezuela` s economic policy?

Chavez, Lula、Bush??
Perhaps you are talking about Petrobras in Bolivia.

But I still think you are oversimplifying.

Its not just a matter of a measure being legitimate or not. A government can make perfectly legitimate actions that may, at least potentially, harm other countries.

Suppose our two countries, CorreaNetoland and MatteoMartinica are located in a continent named Latinium.

CorreaNetoland's government decides that a major, private, indigenous company (in full economic/administrative health) now should belong to the sate. This can have a negative impact in MatteoMartinica's economy, for (foreign and national) investors may have reasons to suspect similar moves may be on its way there. So, citizens from MatteoMartinica do have the right to disagree with CorreaNetoland's government on an internal issue. The people and the government of this fictional state has the right (in some cases the obligation) to manifest their opinion.

Now, back to the real world, Chavez's internal policies, even if legitimate, do have a potentially bad impact in Latin America. Similar policies have already been used at other countries with sometimes disastrous results. Its my right to manifest my opinion. I think my government should draw a clear line showing "this is our policy, that's theirs, we're in the same continent but we are not them" (unfortunately Lula's government is not acting it the way I think it should).

I think I should have the right -if not the obligation- to tell you its not a good idea to point a loaded and unlocked pistol to your head while having a finger at the trigger...
 
Perhaps you are talking about Petrobras in Bolivia.

But I still think you are oversimplifying.

Its not just a matter of a measure being legitimate or not. A government can make perfectly legitimate actions that may, at least potentially, harm other countries.

Suppose our two countries, CorreaNetoland and MatteoMartinica are located in a continent named Latinium.

CorreaNetoland's government decides that a major, private, indigenous company (in full economic/administrative health) now should belong to the sate. This can have a negative impact in MatteoMartinica's economy, for (foreign and national) investors may have reasons to suspect similar moves may be on its way there. So, citizens from MatteoMartinica do have the right to disagree with CorreaNetoland's government on an internal issue. The people and the government of this fictional state has the right (in some cases the obligation) to manifest their opinion.

Now, back to the real world, Chavez's internal policies, even if legitimate, do have a potentially bad impact in Latin America. Similar policies have already been used at other countries with sometimes disastrous results. Its my right to manifest my opinion. I think my government should draw a clear line showing "this is our policy, that's theirs, we're in the same continent but we are not them" (unfortunately Lula's government is not acting it the way I think it should).

I think I should have the right -if not the obligation- to tell you its not a good idea to point a loaded and unlocked pistol to your head while having a finger at the trigger...

OK
You can express your disagreement with the other country position, but that does not mean you should call their leader as " demagogue ", right?
There are other ( politer ) ways to express disagreement, right?
 
Who should decide who gets to comment about such policies?
It appears -- and maybe you don't mean it this way, but it sure appears -- that you've elected yourself as the arbiter of who may talk about what regarding other countries.

Given that, do you have a list of topics that Americans and Canadians, for example, are allowed to talk about with regards to other countries?

By the way, since we are allowed here to criticize ( and insult ) other freely elected leaders, am I allowed to call Bush a " moron "?
And, since George W. has been elected ( twice! ) by a large chunk of American people ( including some people on this forum ), can I call them " morons " as well?
 
By the way, since we are allowed here to criticize ( and insult ) other freely elected leaders, am I allowed to call Bush a " moron "?
And, since George W. has been elected ( twice! ) by a large chunk of American people ( including some people on this forum ), can I call them " morons " as well?

If my memory serves, many people have done the former; some people have done the latter.

As far as I am concerned, you can post as you like on the topics you like, and have your credibility determined by those posts, as opposed to the country you live in.

So feel free.
 
OK
You can express your disagreement with the other country position, but that does not mean you should call their leader as " demagogue ", right?
There are other ( politer ) ways to express disagreement, right?
Well, maybe.

But if it weights like a duck, looks like a duck, tastes like a duck and quacks like a duck, how should I call it?

Is there an euphenism for demagogue? Populist, maybe?

Again, this can follow a Godwinian path pretty quickly...
 
Oh, slightly OT digression. People from country (or state, or city, or something else) X elected Mr. Moron for president (or governor, or mayor, or something else). It doesn't mean these people are idiots. Maybe they voted on Mr. Moron just because he was the "less worse" option!
Or because they were fooled by a marketing campaign...
Or because it seemed a good idea by that time...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom