Can/should European nations maintain their white majorities?

You do know the Right does exactly the same?
I have had it with blind ideologies, period; left or right. You might argue one is more dangerous then the other, but both often indulge in a "if reality clashes with my ideology, reality must be disposed of" mentality.
Maybe they do. What aspect of the Right are you talking about? I'm not an avatar for anybody's opinions but my own.
 
3 pages in, no evidence whatsoever for "The white majority in country X is in danger".

Just a rather dull "Well, country X has a very liberal immigration ruling, clearly this must mean the white majority and their culture is in danger of not being the majority anymore and now imagine how that would look, Ireland full of black people, everyone is banging on drums, no one is doing the Riverdance anymore!!"
 
3 pages in, no evidence whatsoever for "The white majority in country X is in danger".

Just a rather dull "Well, country X has a very liberal immigration ruling, clearly this must mean the white majority and their culture is in danger of not being the majority anymore and now imagine how that would look, Ireland full of black people, everyone is banging on drums, no one is doing the Riverdance anymore!!"
I don't think adding more ethnic divisions to Ireland is such a good idea. They can get really uptight.
 
"A natural and moral right" to stay white?

To hell with that namby weak-eyed bleat! I'm the whitest guy here, and I have an unnatural and immoral right to shove your wimpy "culture" all the way up never mind where.

Me and Mr. Armalite got all the white entitlement we need. 200 rounds of it.

And Herc56 has our back. Hooah.
 
3 pages in, no evidence whatsoever for "The white majority in country X is in danger".

Just a rather dull "Well, country X has a very liberal immigration ruling, clearly this must mean the white majority and their culture is in danger of not being the majority anymore and now imagine how that would look, Ireland full of black people, everyone is banging on drums, no one is doing the Riverdance anymore!!"

Well here's some evdence: this black guy, migrating to Ireland from a foreign land, and then playing godless foreign music that over-excites the native young folks!!!11!



Will nobody think of the children? (No, Father Kelly, lower your hand. You don't want to be shuffled off to yet another parish, do you?).
 
Last edited:
I'm not sure it's particularly important where the traits come from. That seems like mostly an unanswerable question.

Well the important thing is they aren't immutable, particularly when it comes to behavior.

Alternatively, by being utopian and idealistic we can get ourselves into all sorts of trouble. Just because you want to be idealistic and resist realism, doesn't mean the rest of the world is going to play ball. That really is a mindset people only have when they feel extremely secure and safe.

I don't resist realism in principle. I like to follow the evidence where it leads. But most self-professed realists tend to have a callous, almost fatalistic attitude to applying their views in my experience.
 
Well here's some evdence: this black guy, migrating to Ireland from a foreign land, and then playing godless foreign music that over-excites the native young folks!!!11!



Will nobody think of the children? (No, Father Kelly, lower your hand. You don't want to be shuffled off to yet another parish, do you?).

I hear Father Ted is a racist now.
 
Then stop with the “they do have the same culture and phenotypes” crap.

Only fairly recently did people observe some political difference between the two that resulted in war. But Ukrainians and Russians are like sister nations, people have family on both sides of the border, and they share a common origin.
 
Well the important thing is they aren't immutable, particularly when it comes to behavior.
The question really isn't whether notionally they are mutable or not. If we are talking about immigration, the question is whether, when you have mass immigration such that people can live in communities that conform to their previous culture, they in fact do keep their old behaviour or conform to the wider society.

I don't resist realism in principle. I like to follow the evidence where it leads. But most self-professed realists tend to have a callous, almost fatalistic attitude to applying their views in my experience.
Well, yes. Many aspects of the human condition haven't changed in all of recorded history. That does tend to make one a bit pessimistic that this time it's going to be different.
 
Only fairly recently did people observe some political difference between the two that resulted in war. But Ukrainians and Russians are like sister nations, people have family on both sides of the border, and they share a common origin.
There was an anti-Rus ethnonationalist movement in Ukraine before WW2. Kiev spent the better part of a thousand years being pulled between the Moskovites, the Poles, the Lithuanians, the Swedes, the Ottomans, the Golden Horde, the Cossacks and many others. There is a historic connection with the Rus, but that was a long time ago.
 
As casual and genteel you like to frame racial discrimination the consequences are evil.

Give it the bigun 'round town
Have a drink and puff your chest out
Not a racist, you're just proud
Why should you be left out?
The fairies get a march
And the nig-nogs get a month
We've got the right to vote
I mean, what more could we want?
Free to go where I like
If I look like I belong
If not, **** off
Go on boy, move along
Remember Stephen Lawrence
He too was free to roam
Eighteen years old at the bus stop
Murdered on his way home

We didn't appear out of thin air
We live here
We didn't appear out of thin air
We live here

​

 
The question really isn't whether notionally they are mutable or not. If we are talking about immigration, the question is whether, when you have mass immigration such that people can live in communities that conform to their previous culture, they in fact do keep their old behaviour or conform to the wider society.

Well, yes. Many aspects of the human condition haven't changed in all of recorded history. That does tend to make one a bit pessimistic that this time it's going to be different.

I wish at the very least people attracted to the closed borders crap could articulate the point as well as you have here, but for the most part I don't see this, and they go full blown xenophobia without a rational basis to change their mind.

There are melting pot countries that have largely overlooked racial differences and variety. So it's not unheard of.
 
As casual and genteel you like to frame racial discrimination the consequences are evil.
Maybe so, but making racial and cultural challenges non-discussible and refusing to see the tensions that are caused by putting culturally different groups in close proximity doesn't fix anything. There was a Trevor Phillips documentary a few years ago where he more or less said he'd realised that this approach had made the situation worse.
 
I believe that any sovereign state should be able to set whatever policies they choose. The rest of the world has a right to react however they choose to those policies.

Plenty of nations have racist, oppressive policies and the rest of the world does nothing about it. We might whine about it, but nothing is actually done. The economic benefits we get from those countries -oil, cheap manufacturing, etc- take precedence over whatever moral issues we might have with such policies.

There are exceptions of course: NK has some pretty rough sanctions against them and now Russia does too. But at the end of the day, every nation does what they want. So to answer the OP, on a practical level, that’s what’s happening. On a moral level? Ha! As if we really care about the morality of things happening far away from us.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom