Can/should European nations maintain their white majorities?

FACT: Israel, Russia and other nations have a identity card which lists their nationality along with citizenship.

Again, why is it ok for Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, China, to have strong immigration laws that seek to preserve their ethnic super-majority, but its not ok for Euro nations to do it? Seems hypocritical.
Has anyone said its ok for Asian countries?

If Ireland takes in 10 million immigrants from Nigeria, India, Taiwan and Indonesia, are they still Irish?
Given that there are only about 6 million Irish, no but then there is a universe between not allowing any immigration and more than doubling your population with immigrants.

If the Irish let in 10 million Irish Americans would they still be Irish, I'd say no.

We should keep to our enlightened and liberal politics and values. Ethnicity is trivial.
This is key in my opinion.

These are key questions. I'm an Irish citizen but I was born outside the country with a goodly proportion of foreign blood and have spent very little of my life there. I'd be interested to know which, if any, of my current rights should be removed from me.

The subject also cropped up in the recent presidential elections here in France where Le Pen proposed defining different classes of French citizens. As dual-nationals my children and I would have been considered less French than our pure-bred neighbours* when applying for jobs, for example. Rampant discrimination is everywhere in France already, of course, but it was surprising to hear it being discussed in those terms.


* Of course we're all hybrids.
I'm also an Irish Citizen, My Grandparents immigrated over 100 years ago, my dad grew up there but as only been back twice in his adulthood, he's over 80. Its pretty silly that I and my children are citizens. I've spent about 2 weeks in Ireland. My wife is a Latvian citizen due to similar circumstances.

What constitutes an Irish person? If an Irish person marries a non-Irish person and they have kids, are the kids only half-Irish? What rights would they have under this ethnocratic state? Would their own children get decreased or increased rights depending on whether the half-Irish offspring reproduce with Irish, half-Irish, or non-Irish people? What are the rules for defining Irishnicity? Show your work: this is a proposed legal framework so you have to be able to define it so it fits every situation.
According to the Irish, the kids are 100% Irish, the grand kids would be 100% Irish so long as they do the paperwork and 100% not Irish if they don't. I have done the work but won't show it on account of too much personal info.
 
Last edited:
Simple question: do European states have the right to maintain their ethnic and/or white majorities?


They have the natural and moral right to not only maintain their white majority, but also their ethnic majority. I believe it is the right of ALL non-colonial nations to do so, especially nation-states.


What say you?

Why and what purpose does it serve?
It's all cultural.
Personally, I'd like a planet with no boarders, and people can go live wherever the hell they want but, there are a few details to work out first.
 
FACT: Israel, Russia and other nations have a identity card which lists their nationality along with citizenship.

Again, why is it ok for Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, China, to have strong immigration laws that seek to preserve their ethnic super-majority, but its not ok for Euro nations to do it? Seems hypocritical.

Who has told you both claims you make?

Also why is this in a politics section?
 
Simple question: do European states have the right to maintain their ethnic and/or white majorities?

I say they do. Ireland is the land of the Irish people. Germany is the land of the German people. Russia the land of the Russians.

They have the natural and moral right to not only maintain their white majority, but also their ethnic majority. I believe it is the right of ALL non-colonial nations to do so, especially nation-states.

South Korea, China, Taiwan, Japan, have all instituted immigration policies that for one thing, work to maintain their ethnic super-majority. There is only one Japan after all, and it has the right to exist.

I believe that Euro nations have the right enforce strict, tight immigration laws that work to maintain their ethnic majorities. Do they have the right to remove non-citizen immigrants who are not white? I say its a little rude, but acceptable. Removing citizens that are not white? Only with some decent compensation, I'd say.

What say you?

Question: Is a black person, born and raised in Ireland, not Irish? If yes, why? If not, why not?
 
Again, why is it ok for Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, China, to have strong immigration laws that seek to preserve their ethnic super-majority, but its not ok for Euro nations to do it? Seems hypocritical.

To echo ahhell's question, who says that's OK?

I have lived in both South Korea and China. The levels of nationalism there are very high, and it doesn't just border on racism, it all too often is racism. The attitude towards foreigners, in terms of their depictions on TV and also how they are treated in the street, and the assumptions of racial superiority in both these countries are quite shocking to see.
This is not a situation I welcome, and I am wondering how much first-hand, or even second-hand experience you have of these attitudes, that has led you to believe they are desirable?
 
Question: Is a black person, born and raised in Ireland, not Irish? If yes, why? If not, why not?

Phil Lynott was Irish, despite being black and not being born in Ireland.

"Is there anybody here with any Irish in them? Is there any of the girls who'd like a little more Irish in them?"
 
Simple question: do European states have the right to maintain their ethnic and/or white majorities?

I say they do. Ireland is the land of the Irish people. Germany is the land of the German people. Russia the land of the Russians.

They have the natural and moral right to not only maintain their white majority, but also their ethnic majority. I believe it is the right of ALL non-colonial nations to do so, especially nation-states.
...

I'm not sure how it's relevant, but most European countries were colonial nations.
 
To echo ahhell's question, who says that's OK?

I have lived in both South Korea and China. The levels of nationalism there are very high, and it doesn't just border on racism, it all too often is racism. The attitude towards foreigners, in terms of their depictions on TV and also how they are treated in the street, and the assumptions of racial superiority in both these countries are quite shocking to see.
This is not a situation I welcome, and I am wondering how much first-hand, or even second-hand experience you have of these attitudes, that has led you to believe they are desirable?
For cultures to survive, there has to be strong ingroup preference holding it together. Without that, all nations will slowly become the same. Difference can only survive if it is resistant to mixing. The type of diversity that is typically advocated is like trying to make the colour palette more diverse by taking all of the tubes paint and mixing them together into some kind of uniform intermediate hue.
 
How can they maintain such white status when so few are white but rather swarthy like the germans?

"Which leads me to add one Remark: That the Number of purely white People in the World is proportionably very small. All Africa is black or tawny. Asia chiefly tawny. America (exclusive of the new Comers) wholly so. And in Europe, the Spaniards, Italians, French, Russians and Swedes, are generally of what we call a swarthy Complexion; as are the Germans also, the Saxons only excepted, who with the English, make the principal Body of White People on the Face of the Earth. I could wish their Numbers were increased. " Ben Franklin

https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2008/02/swarthy-germans/48324/
 
We should keep to our enlightened and liberal politics and values. Ethnicity is trivial.

Sounds good, but the question then is whether those migrating from countries without enlightened and liberal policies will be able to adapt to those policies.
 
As a compromise, I'm willing to accept Whites with one or even two drops of non-Arian blood.
I'm openminded that way.
 
"You can come in our country but first you have to take this Buzzfeed quiz about which Hogwarts House you'd be sorted into. We're only allowing Gryffindor and Hufflepuff in right now."
 
For cultures to survive, there has to be strong ingroup preference holding it together. Without that, all nations will slowly become the same. Difference can only survive if it is resistant to mixing. The type of diversity that is typically advocated is like trying to make the colour palette more diverse by taking all of the tubes paint and mixing them together into some kind of uniform intermediate hue.

Right wing version of the monster under the bed.
 
They have the natural and moral right to not only maintain their white majority, but also their ethnic majority. I believe it is the right of ALL non-colonial nations to do so, especially nation-states.

Why? What is the value in that?
 
FACT: Israel, Russia and other nations have a identity card which lists their nationality along with citizenship.

These are not two countries I would pick as models for a free, prosperous society. Israel is an apartheid state and Russia is waging a war of aggression against a neighbor.
 
They should maintain their educated, liberal democratic majorities. Skin color is entirely irrelevant.
How do they "maintain their educated, liberal democratic majorities"? Also, presumably these asian countries that are being described here as terribly racist do not have a liberal majority. Also, this sounds like a culturally nonspecific nowhere people way of looking at things. There is more to a culture than being liberal.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom