Can/should European nations maintain their white majorities?

Depends on how you mean it. A white guy from France is definitely not "my people" to a greater degree than a black guy down the street.
That's up to you. Maybe it depends a bit on the white French guy and the black guy down your street? There are certainly black guys who are very much my people and others that aren't.

The way you phrased it looked like an attempt to whitewash racism. I'm sure that wasn't intentional. Would you like to rephrase?
From my point of view, there is a continual attempt to rephrame cultural issues as being some kind of one drop neo-eugenics project.
 
This is just so ridiculous. How do you explain various kinds of nationalisms and countries waging war against each other if you try to argue that they are all basically the same?

Look at the Russian invasion of Ukraine. How does this happen on your dim witted race=culture hypothesis?
Why does that have to be explained in terms of race? What about it do you think is this slam dunk against what I've said?
 
Well, I think it is fine if a country decides it doesn't want lots of immigration from "**** hole" countries.

Does anyone really want that? I mean, it isn't their fault if most of these people are black and brown, right? In fact, I'd say any country has a right to limit immigration for any reason it chooses, racial or otherwise.

If someone doesn't like it, oh well. If it is your country and you want to change it, and can do so, go for it. But I bet most people wouldn't lift a finger. Many really don't want these people, but it is unpopular to admit it (in some places).

Wow! May I salute your courage in being an open and unabashed racist then. Many people like Tucker Carlson etc…. hide it under weasel words. But you just go right out and say you don’t want “these people”.

Jesus! How many naked racists do we have on this forum now?
 
Race is a proxy for culture. The overwhelming reason race is important is because it carries a lot of cultural information. This is simply a fact.

Race by the most coherent standard isn't a great way to critically understand culture, unless we just want to be lazy. There are thousands of different cultures within and between races. You seem to always push versions of the "stereotypes are based on truth" line but again these are based heavily on hasty generalization and more importantly people tend to assume that certain behavioral traits are just inherent to a particular appearance, which is harmful and untrue.

One problem I have with race realism, cultural realism, any of the realisms is the nagging conclusion that we just accept it and don't use our big brains to attempt overcome the problems associated with these differences.
 
Membership drive for Stormfront?
There certainly are ideas in the world that are objectionable. The left has worn out it's tone policing card though. It is a dangerous game to play to try and control real things that people see in the world by accusing anybody who notices them of being a racist or a nazi. You kind of undermine those words. The left managed to get it to a point quite a few years ago where people have to ask what you mean when you say those words, because they get applied to such mundane things and are scattered about with such careless abandon.
 
Your idea that race is a proxy for culture. Clearly the Russians and the Ukrainians don’t think so.
Don't they? The war seems to be following the lines of the country that separate the majority Russian speaking part from the majority Ukrainian speaking part. The Ukrainian speaking part seemed to be keen on aligning with the West, where as the Russian speaking part wanted to align with the East. Culture and race are hopelessly intermixed. There certainly was some very ethnicity oriented thinking in the Ukrainian nationalist movement before WW2, but even then you can't untangle it from culture and history.
 
There certainly are ideas in the world that are objectionable. The left has worn out it's tone policing card though. It is a dangerous game to play to try and control real things that people see in the world by accusing anybody who notices them of being a racist or a nazi. You kind of undermine those words. The left managed to get it to a point quite a few years ago where people have to ask what you mean when you say those words, because they get applied to such mundane things and are scattered about with such careless abandon.

Are you not a member already? You have the fundamentals down. You should be as proud of your xenophobia and racism as your white skin. Don’t be scared of what the lefties think.
 
Last edited:
Don't think Russia/Ukraine is a great example.

They're practically the same people sharing the the same culture until fairly recently and the same phenotypes.
 
Last edited:
There certainly are ideas in the world that are objectionable. The left has worn out it's tone policing card though. It is a dangerous game to play to try and control real things that people see in the world by accusing anybody who notices them of being a racist or a nazi. You kind of undermine those words. The left managed to get it to a point quite a few years ago where people have to ask what you mean when you say those words, because they get applied to such mundane things and are scattered about with such careless abandon.

You do know the Right does exactly the same?
I have had it with blind ideologies, period; left or right. You might argue one is more dangerous then the other, but both often indulge in a "if reality clashes with my ideology, reality must be disposed of" mentality.
 
Don't think Russia/Ukraine is a great example.

They're practically the same people sharing the the same culture until fairly recently and the same phenotypes.

I think that is a ridiculously simplistic idea that Ukrainians and Russians have the same culture as if culture is such an easily reducible idea. Ukraine itself and Russia itself contains various cultural influences linguistically, religiously and historically.

The racists like to claim that there is some kind of one to one correlation between “race” and culture. Here you are agreeing with them.
 
Race by the most coherent standard isn't a great way to critically understand culture, unless we just want to be lazy. There are thousands of different cultures within and between races.
There is no list of races. Ukrainians and Russians are both Slavs. You can track that back to individual tribal groups 1000 years ago. It's a mixture of culture, place and people.

You seem to always push versions of the "stereotypes are based on truth" line but again these are based heavily on hasty generalization and more importantly people tend to assume that certain behavioral traits are just inherent to a particular appearance, which is harmful and untrue.
I'm not sure it's particularly important where the traits come from. That seems like mostly an unanswerable question.

One problem I have with race realism, cultural realism, any of the realisms is the nagging conclusion that we just accept it and don't use our big brains to attempt overcome the problems associated with these differences.
Alternatively, by being utopian and idealistic we can get ourselves into all sorts of trouble. Just because you want to be idealistic and resist realism, doesn't mean the rest of the world is going to play ball. That really is a mindset people only have when they feel extremely secure and safe.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom