Because I was talking about preferring someone because of their positive attributes - their get up and go - rather than their racial origin.
OK, so like the Nazis racial views? They were very clear that their focus was the characteristics of different groups. That's not being racist?
I'd be equally critical of an immigrant who couldn't be bothered to get up off their ass, and equally supportive of a Brit who was willing to do so
Which racial groups would you apply that to? Bangladeshis perhaps? They seem to be one of the poorest performing immigrant groups in the UK. Would you agree that Bangladeshis are no good? If you dislike another brown immigrant group, by all means name them. Somalis perhaps?
The US had very high levels of immigration during its "isolationist" phase so I'm not clear what point you're making. The isolationism was about an unwillingness to get involved in global politics, not shutting its doors to immigrants.
You said isolationism led to stagnation. You mean something quite specific. Britain was a city of the world in Elizabethan times, and certainly not stagnating... but I don't think anything like the current 15% of the population was foreign born. It didn't seem to be stagnant. Why do you think importing 100,000 unskilled immigrants who mostly form insular communities and don't integrate is necessary to avoid stagnation? Is there something anti-stagnation about the street after street in Birmingham populated by Pakistani families that I'm not seeing? What level of immigration is actually needed to avoid cultural stagnation?
Yes, it was. I grew up in a monochromatic community in the North East of England.
Why is the melanin level of the community important? Do all these old white communities look the same to you?
Now that same town has a number of immigrants from all over and those from the Subcontinent in particular have been very active in the community - especially in providing support and food for those who have suffered as a result of Covid.
And there is something unique about people from the subcontinent that means they are uniquely able to do this and without them everybody would have just sat there and starved?
Yes your great grandfather did what he did, and a proportion stayed at home and did nothing. It's the same now as it ever was.
It isn't the same now. Now we import people to fulfil that role and racist immigrants look down on the native population.
I guess it comes down to a fundamental difference in our outlook. You see any change as diluting your culture because it's a taint from an inferior culture.
No. It isn't a question of being inferior. It is a question of being different and unique. You are the one who has been making claims of racial superiority about how the natives lack "get up and go" and so the immigrants are better.
I see change as enriching our culture and hopefully it cuts both ways.
No. This is simply not how it works. For a nation to function there has to be some common culture, some common sense of purpose, some shared participation in a national identity. Without that you have no uniting idea of "the good" and ultimately one group has to force it's world view on the other. Look at the glorious diversity that the Protestants added to Northern Ireland. If you view diversity in terms of whether there are interesting restaurant choices, then sure... it's great. Diversity has led to ethnic and cultural strife all over the world for thousands of years. It tends to work much better in nice areas where everybody is a citizen of the world. That is not most areas or most people though.
How can it be replacement unless you're keeping score of how many people there are of each colour.
You see 50 of "us" and 50 of "them" replacing "us"
I see 100 of "us".
Lovely for you. Now if we all sing John Lennon's Imagine while telling the native population they lack "get up and go" we will have world peace.
This is such a progressive solution. "OK, people see this particular bad effect in society... let's change the category system to make it invisible... problem solved."