Can/should European nations maintain their white majorities?

Racist in this context just means thinking that government should prioritise the interests and culture of its citizens rather than the global population. You are racist because you don't think John Lennon's Imagine is going to work out.

Which citizens?
 
As far as immigrants from "**** hole" countries, do you think most citizens really want that? Do you think that they also want immigrants from cultures with values in opposition to the prevailing ones? Do they really want more poor, sickly, or uneducated immigrants?

No, we don't. I hope the governments of countries that are not America remember that after America has turned into Gilead. We do not want thousands of violent, obese, uneducated racists fleeing your **** hole country and arriving on our shores, thank you very much.
Oh, is it not so nice when someone describes your own country in those terms?
Negatively stereotyping entire countries or ethnicities is the definition of racism.

Do you think that a society of educated people truly wakes up in the morning and says, "We should infuse our society/culture with a large number of poor/uneducated/primitive people from third-world countries"? Do you think they should?

Is that how you think immigration works? You really don't have any idea what you're talking about, do you?
FYI.

Oh, and 'primitive'? Really? Again, this is an epithet that could just as easily be applied to large sections of American society, if one were as racist as your posts are.
 
Last edited:
Is that how you think immigration works? You really don't have any idea what you're talking about, do you?

When I compare the "get up and go" of immigrants who have come half way around the world to try and improve their lives despite all the challenges they face to the multi-generational unemployed in the Welsh valleys* who turn down work in Cardiff because the 20 minute train journey is too far - I know who I'd like to see contributing to the economy.

Then again, I am biased. My father was an immigrant (though in his later years he'd go on Telegraph fuelled rants about immigrants flooding into rural County Durham), I married an immigrant and I suppose as "and Englishman in Newport" I'm an immigrant too. :o

* - a lazy stereotype but they do exist and Mrs Don comes into contact with them regularly as part of her charity work supporting families who need help with children under 5.
 
I don't see where my statement/observation is racist, at all. I am not saying that vetting people solely based on race is ideal, just that it is within a country's rights to do so. As far as immigrants from "**** hole" countries, do you think most citizens really want that? Do you think that they also want immigrants from cultures with values in opposition to the prevailing ones? Do they really want more poor, sickly, or uneducated immigrants?

Do you think that a society of educated people truly wakes up in the morning and says, "We should infuse our society/culture with a large number of poor/uneducated/primitive people from third-world countries"? Do you think they should?

Countries do not have rights because they are not persons. Your posts are quickly devolving into "Donald Trump" quality.
 
No, we don't. I hope the governments of countries that are not America remember that after America has turned into Gilead. We do not want thousands of violent, obese, uneducated racists fleeing your **** hole country and arriving on our shores, thank you very much.
Oh, is it not so nice when someone describes your own country in those terms?
Negatively stereotyping entire countries or ethnicities is the definition of racism.

...

Oh, and 'primitive'? Really? Again, this is an epithet that could just as easily be applied to large sections of American society, if one were as racist as your posts are.


If a country decides it doesn't want Americans, that would be within their rights to decide, imo. It doesn't offend me at all. Maybe Gambia will bar Americans from their country, as we are not up to their cultural and educational standards? So be it.
 
Last edited:
When I compare the "get up and go" of immigrants who have come half way around the world to try and improve their lives despite all the challenges they face to the multi-generational unemployed in the Welsh valleys* who turn down work in Cardiff because the 20 minute train journey is too far - I know who I'd like to see contributing to the economy.
That sounds kind of racist. I've been told that people are fungible. Is that only not true when we are saying non-whites are better? Seriously though, if there is something about our society that is failing to produce productive people, maybe that is something we need to fix rather than just importing labour? Plenty of civilizations have collapsed by losing their vitality and trying to import new blood.

Immigration allows government to avoid dealing with this fundamental issue. It's like if a parents child was failing at school and so they adopt a couple of hard working indian orphans to keep the family average grade up. Problem solved.
 
If a country decides it doesn't want Americans, that would be within their rights to decide, imo. It doesn't offend me at all. Maybe Gambia will bar Americans from their country, as we are not up to their cultural and educational standards? So be it.
Supposedly this is the model that Putin and Xi Jinping are successfully selling. Profitable business relationships, but not seeking to destroy the local culture by turning it liberal. Whether one trusts them long term is a question, but one can see why it would be more attractive in large parts of the world.
 
That sounds kind of racist. I've been told that people are fungible. Is that only not true when we are saying non-whites are better? Seriously though, if there is something about our society that is failing to produce productive people, maybe that is something we need to fix rather than just importing labour? Plenty of civilizations have collapsed by losing their vitality and trying to import new blood.

Why do you assume that immigrants will be non-white - sounds kind of racist to me :confused:

Experience from the past seems to indicate that societies which are isolationist, tend to atrophy and that the introduction of new ideas and people from outside that society seems important for the maintenance of a vital society.

Immigration allows government to avoid dealing with this fundamental issue. It's like if a parents child was failing at school and so they adopt a couple of hard working indian orphans to keep the family average grade up. Problem solved.

Immigration helps with a number of things. It's not just a matter of providing a workforce (though that has been important for places like the UK with low birth rates), it's about enriching the society in so many other ways.

I was watching the BBC Masterchef series and it reminded me how much modern British food owes to different groups of immigrants. The finalists were two people of British/Subcontinental background and third person from Thailand.

The same is true if you look at modern British music, art, literature, science and so on.
 
Why do you assume that immigrants will be non-white - sounds kind of racist to me :confused:
The thread topic. But the point stands. Why is it OK to talk about how great and superior immigrants are, but racist to prefer the native population?

Experience from the past seems to indicate that societies which are isolationist, tend to atrophy and that the introduction of new ideas and people from outside that society seems important for the maintenance of a vital society.
Isolationism causing atrophy and mass importing foreign labour are two very extreme ends of a scale. Presumably you don't mean to say that the isolationism of the US in the early 20th century caused atrophy? Nobody is proposing locking the West away like some medieval oriental kingdom. We aren't talking about importing poets and philosophers and scientists. We are talking about importing huge numbers of unskilled/low skilled workers.

I'm struggling to think of a positive historical example of a country failing to produce enough internal vigour, importing it, and it turning out well for the original population. Rome is the obvious example, but there are others.

Immigration helps with a number of things. It's not just a matter of providing a workforce (though that has been important for places like the UK with low birth rates), it's about enriching the society in so many other ways.
Contact between cultures is enriching. The Lake District was a unique area. Was it crying out for Pakistani immigrants to improve it? I fail to see how that is enriching. Certainly when cultures touch interesting things can happen. One new arrival brings many new ideas. Two is still brings things but less so than the first. Is the second hundred thousand Pakistanis who arrive in Birmingham really adding something unique and enriching that the first hundred thousand didn't bring?

Also, given how enriching it is, it seems unfortunate that that isn't in a way that restores the natural vigour of the culture. All these decades and you say that still lack "get up and go". My great grandfather supposedly did the classic thing of walking weekly between Manchester and Sheffield for work. It's not that long ago that we had that.

I was watching the BBC Masterchef series and it reminded me how much modern British food owes to different groups of immigrants. The finalists were two people of British/Subcontinental background and third person from Thailand.
Is it necessary to import a million people from country X in order to be able to cook their food? This is the globalised, commercialisation of culture. It's culture as the trinkets being offered to the Native Americans. Sure, your culture is dying, but isn't this Thai food great compensation for it? Irish culture will survive because there are O'Neil's pubs all over the world.

The same is true if you look at modern British music, art, literature, science and so on.
Meanwhile, underneath it the existing culture is dying. You said it yourself when you mentioned a lack of "get up and go". If the solution to that is to bring in new people with the required "get up and go", then you are talking about the great "myth" of replacement which I am told is racist and not happening.
 
Last edited:
The thread topic. But the point stands. Why is it OK to talk about how great and superior immigrants are, but racist to prefer the native population?


Isolationism causing atrophy and mass importing foreign labour are two very extreme ends of a scale. Presumably you don't mean to say that the isolationism of the US in the early 20th century caused atrophy? Nobody is proposing locking the West away like some medieval oriental kingdom. We aren't talking about importing poets and philosophers and scientists. We are talking about importing huge numbers of unskilled/low skilled workers.

I'm struggling to think of a positive historical example of a country failing to produce enough internal vigour, importing it, and it turning out well for the original population. Rome is the obvious example, but there are others.


Contact between cultures is enriching. The Lake District was a unique area. Was it crying out for Pakistani immigrants to improve it? I fail to see how that is enriching. Certainly when cultures touch interesting things can happen. One new arrival brings many new ideas. Two is still brings things but less so than the first. Is the second hundred thousand Pakistanis who arrive in Birmingham really adding something unique and enriching that the first hundred thousand didn't bring?

Also, given how enriching it is, it seems unfortunate that that isn't in a way that restores the natural vigour of the culture. All these decades and you say that still lack "get up and go". My great grandfather supposedly did the classic thing of walking weekly between Manchester and Sheffield for work. It's not that long ago that we had that.


Is it necessary to import a million people from country X in order to be able to cook their food? This is the globalised, commercialisation of culture. It's culture as the trinkets being offered to the Native Americans. Sure, your culture is dying, but isn't this Thai food great compensation for it? Irish culture will survive because there are O'Neil's pubs all over the world.


Meanwhile, underneath it the existing culture is dying. You said it yourself when you mentioned a lack of "get up and go". If the solution to that is to bring in new people with the required "get up and go", then you are talking about the great "myth" of replacement which I am told is racist and not happening.

You still need to show how "culture is dying" and why.
 
The thread topic. But the point stands. Why is it OK to talk about how great and superior immigrants are, but racist to prefer the native population?

...snip...

Because different things are usually considered to be different. In this instance talking about immigrants isn't talking about race, talking about a "native" population is.
 
Simple question: do European states have the right to maintain their ethnic and/or white majorities?

I say they do. Ireland is the land of the Irish people. Germany is the land of the German people. Russia the land of the Russians.

They have the natural and moral right to not only maintain their white majority, but also their ethnic majority. I believe it is the right of ALL non-colonial nations to do so, especially nation-states.

...snip...

You would presumably hold that countries like France, the UK should stop immigration from Spanish folk?
 
The thread topic. But the point stands. Why is it OK to talk about how great and superior immigrants are, but racist to prefer the native population?

Because I was talking about preferring someone because of their positive attributes - their get up and go - rather than their racial origin.

I'd be equally critical of an immigrant who couldn't be bothered to get up off their ass, and equally supportive of a Brit who was willing to do so


Isolationism causing atrophy and mass importing foreign labour are two very extreme ends of a scale. Presumably you don't mean to say that the isolationism of the US in the early 20th century caused atrophy? Nobody is proposing locking the West away like some medieval oriental kingdom. We aren't talking about importing poets and philosophers and scientists. We are talking about importing huge numbers of unskilled/low skilled workers.

I'm struggling to think of a positive historical example of a country failing to produce enough internal vigour, importing it, and it turning out well for the original population. Rome is the obvious example, but there are others.

The US had very high levels of immigration during its "isolationist" phase so I'm not clear what point you're making. The isolationism was about an unwillingness to get involved in global politics, not shutting its doors to immigrants. :confused:


Contact between cultures is enriching. The Lake District was a unique area. Was it crying out for Pakistani immigrants to improve it? I fail to see how that is enriching. Certainly when cultures touch interesting things can happen. One new arrival brings many new ideas. Two is still brings things but less so than the first. Is the second hundred thousand Pakistanis who arrive in Birmingham really adding something unique and enriching that the first hundred thousand didn't bring?

Also, given how enriching it is, it seems unfortunate that that isn't in a way that restores the natural vigour of the culture. All these decades and you say that still lack "get up and go". My great grandfather supposedly did the classic thing of walking weekly between Manchester and Sheffield for work. It's not that long ago that we had that.

Yes, it was. I grew up in a monochromatic community in the North East of England. Now that same town has a number of immigrants from all over and those from the Subcontinent in particular have been very active in the community - especially in providing support and food for those who have suffered as a result of Covid.

Yes your great grandfather did what he did, and a proportion stayed at home and did nothing. It's the same now as it ever was.


Is it necessary to import a million people from country X in order to be able to cook their food? This is the globalised, commercialisation of culture. It's culture as the trinkets being offered to the Native Americans. Sure, your culture is dying, but isn't this Thai food great compensation for it? Irish culture will survive because there are O'Neil's pubs all over the world.

I guess it comes down to a fundamental difference in our outlook. You see any change as diluting your culture because it's a taint from an inferior culture.

I see change as enriching our culture and hopefully it cuts both ways.

Meanwhile, underneath it the existing culture is dying. You said it yourself when you mentioned a lack of "get up and go". If the solution to that is to bring in new people with the required "get up and go", then you are talking about the great "myth" of replacement which I am told is racist and not happening.

How can it be replacement unless you're keeping score of how many people there are of each colour.

You see 50 of "us" and 50 of "them" replacing "us"

I see 100 of "us".
 
When I compare the "get up and go" of immigrants who have come half way around the world to try and improve their lives despite all the challenges they face to the multi-generational unemployed in the Welsh valleys* who turn down work in Cardiff because the 20 minute train journey is too far - I know who I'd like to see contributing to the economy.

Then again, I am biased. My father was an immigrant (though in his later years he'd go on Telegraph fuelled rants about immigrants flooding into rural County Durham), I married an immigrant and I suppose as "and Englishman in Newport" I'm an immigrant too. :o

* - a lazy stereotype but they do exist and Mrs Don comes into contact with them regularly as part of her charity work supporting families who need help with children under 5.

Good points, but not what I was aiming at, as I thought my link would show.
My point is that most countries in general, and America in particular, do not allow unchecked legal immigration from hordes of unskilled workers.
In order to get a green card, for example, you must either be sponsored by an American citizen, or have an offer of employment.
The claim that governments of any country have simply thrown open their borders to anyone who wants to come in is just not true. Applicants are assessed on their skills and qualifications, their grasp of the local language, their financial status, any criminal record they have, among other criteria, before being accepted.
 
I'm struggling to think of a positive historical example of a country failing to produce enough internal vigour, importing it, and it turning out well for the original population. Rome is the obvious example, but there are others.

The Gulf states.
In Kuwait, for example, there are around 1.5 million Kuwaitis and about 3.5 million immigrant workers. The immigrants do all the actual work, whilst the Kuwaitis have a fine time of it. The same is true of the other Gulf states- Saudi Arabia, Qatar and the UAE.
The local (Arab Muslim) culture is not affected one whit by all this.

Regarding your purported search for historical precedents for this, perhaps if you were aware that mass migration is a relatively recent phenomenon, it would have saved you some time. However, I'm guessing you come from America, a country cheerfully acknowledged by Warp12 to be a **** hole country, largely populated by primitive, violent and uneducated people. I guess I can make allowances out of pity, then.
 
Because I was talking about preferring someone because of their positive attributes - their get up and go - rather than their racial origin.
OK, so like the Nazis racial views? They were very clear that their focus was the characteristics of different groups. That's not being racist?

I'd be equally critical of an immigrant who couldn't be bothered to get up off their ass, and equally supportive of a Brit who was willing to do so
Which racial groups would you apply that to? Bangladeshis perhaps? They seem to be one of the poorest performing immigrant groups in the UK. Would you agree that Bangladeshis are no good? If you dislike another brown immigrant group, by all means name them. Somalis perhaps?

The US had very high levels of immigration during its "isolationist" phase so I'm not clear what point you're making. The isolationism was about an unwillingness to get involved in global politics, not shutting its doors to immigrants. :confused:
You said isolationism led to stagnation. You mean something quite specific. Britain was a city of the world in Elizabethan times, and certainly not stagnating... but I don't think anything like the current 15% of the population was foreign born. It didn't seem to be stagnant. Why do you think importing 100,000 unskilled immigrants who mostly form insular communities and don't integrate is necessary to avoid stagnation? Is there something anti-stagnation about the street after street in Birmingham populated by Pakistani families that I'm not seeing? What level of immigration is actually needed to avoid cultural stagnation?

Yes, it was. I grew up in a monochromatic community in the North East of England.
Why is the melanin level of the community important? Do all these old white communities look the same to you?

Now that same town has a number of immigrants from all over and those from the Subcontinent in particular have been very active in the community - especially in providing support and food for those who have suffered as a result of Covid.
And there is something unique about people from the subcontinent that means they are uniquely able to do this and without them everybody would have just sat there and starved?

Yes your great grandfather did what he did, and a proportion stayed at home and did nothing. It's the same now as it ever was.
It isn't the same now. Now we import people to fulfil that role and racist immigrants look down on the native population.

I guess it comes down to a fundamental difference in our outlook. You see any change as diluting your culture because it's a taint from an inferior culture.
No. It isn't a question of being inferior. It is a question of being different and unique. You are the one who has been making claims of racial superiority about how the natives lack "get up and go" and so the immigrants are better.

I see change as enriching our culture and hopefully it cuts both ways.
No. This is simply not how it works. For a nation to function there has to be some common culture, some common sense of purpose, some shared participation in a national identity. Without that you have no uniting idea of "the good" and ultimately one group has to force it's world view on the other. Look at the glorious diversity that the Protestants added to Northern Ireland. If you view diversity in terms of whether there are interesting restaurant choices, then sure... it's great. Diversity has led to ethnic and cultural strife all over the world for thousands of years. It tends to work much better in nice areas where everybody is a citizen of the world. That is not most areas or most people though.

How can it be replacement unless you're keeping score of how many people there are of each colour.

You see 50 of "us" and 50 of "them" replacing "us"

I see 100 of "us".
Lovely for you. Now if we all sing John Lennon's Imagine while telling the native population they lack "get up and go" we will have world peace.

This is such a progressive solution. "OK, people see this particular bad effect in society... let's change the category system to make it invisible... problem solved."
 
Last edited:
The Gulf states.
In Kuwait, for example, there are around 1.5 million Kuwaitis and about 3.5 million immigrant workers. The immigrants do all the actual work, whilst the Kuwaitis have a fine time of it. The same is true of the other Gulf states- Saudi Arabia, Qatar and the UAE.
The local (Arab Muslim) culture is not affected one whit by all this.
How long has that been true for? You can hollow out your country so long as the money keeps coming in. Rome imported barbarians for quite a while and got them to fight its wars before things really fell apart. What would happen to Kuwait if the oil stopped flowing, the US military stopped backing them and the culture actually had to function and be productive?

Regarding your purported search for historical precedents for this, perhaps if you were aware that mass migration is a relatively recent phenomenon, it would have saved you some time. However, I'm guessing you come from America, a country cheerfully acknowledged by Warp12 to be a **** hole country, largely populated by primitive, violent and uneducated people. I guess I can make allowances out of pity, then.
Importing foreign vitality is not a new thing. The Romans did it with the Germanic barbarian tribes. After the Romans left, the Britons did it with the Angles, Saxons and Jutes. There were significant migrations of people throughout European history. There are also many examples of civilizations losing their vitality.
 
How long has that been true for? You can hollow out your country so long as the money keeps coming in. Rome imported barbarians for quite a while and got them to fight its wars before things really fell apart. What would happen to Kuwait if the oil stopped flowing, the US military stopped backing them and the culture actually had to function and be productive?


Importing foreign vitality is not a new thing. The Romans did it with the Germanic barbarian tribes. After the Romans left, the Britons did it with the Angles, Saxons and Jutes. There were significant migrations of people throughout European history. There are also many examples of civilizations losing their vitality.

Please name a few.
 
OK, so like the Nazis racial views? They were very clear that their focus was the characteristics of different groups. That's not being racist?

...snip...

It couldn't be further from Nazis views on racial matters. He has talked about individuals - you are again conflating different things.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom