Can/should European nations maintain their white majorities?

Hercules56

Banned
Joined
Aug 4, 2013
Messages
17,176
Simple question: do European states have the right to maintain their ethnic and/or white majorities?

I say they do. Ireland is the land of the Irish people. Germany is the land of the German people. Russia the land of the Russians.

They have the natural and moral right to not only maintain their white majority, but also their ethnic majority. I believe it is the right of ALL non-colonial nations to do so, especially nation-states.

South Korea, China, Taiwan, Japan, have all instituted immigration policies that for one thing, work to maintain their ethnic super-majority. There is only one Japan after all, and it has the right to exist.

I believe that Euro nations have the right enforce strict, tight immigration laws that work to maintain their ethnic majorities. Do they have the right to remove non-citizen immigrants who are not white? I say its a little rude, but acceptable. Removing citizens that are not white? Only with some decent compensation, I'd say.

What say you?
 
Japan sells more adult diapers than baby diapers.

The right to be racist aside, this is a recipe for disaster. Wealthy nations with low birth rates are dooming themselves to demographic collapse if they seal up the borders, unless of course the fascists advocating for these policies also follow on with a forced birth program (which would not be unusual).
 
Japan sells more adult diapers than baby diapers.

The right to be racist aside, this is a recipe for disaster. Wealthy nations with low birth rates are dooming themselves to demographic collapse if they seal up the borders, unless of course the fascists advocating for these policies also follow on with a forced birth program (which would not be unusual).

I dont think Japan is "fascist" for wanting a very limited immigration policy.

They want Japan to exist in 200 years, and its their right.


Israel is also not an immigration country, nobody calls them "fascist" for this.
 
I say mixing religions and 'races' creates progress and increases genetic diversity.
Whereas isolation and a longing for 'purity' creates stagnation and inbreeding.

Besides, large portions of our populations will probably have to migrate away in 100 years (or less) as all low lying land floods and fertile land dries up, so better be welcoming now so our children can be welcomed somewhere else.
 
Hopefully the last pure Japanese citizen turns out the lights before they die of old age.



Press X to doubt

I dont think Japan is "fascist" for wanting a very limited immigration policy.

They want Japan to exist in 200 years, and its their right.


Israel is also not an immigration country, nobody calls them "fascist" for this.
Seriously, there won't be a Japan 200 years from now if they leave it up to the Japanese.

To answer the op, they can but they shouldn't.
 
That's up to every Euro nation.

Personally, I say anyone with mostly western Eurasian ancestry.

:)

I hesitate to mention it, but it's hard to avoid, given the subject matter.

I had the opportunity to study some original Ariernachweise when I was in Germany, and I can't tell the difference between what you are proposing and what they were used for.
 
This is some deep, deep "I'm not racist, I'm just saying the world works better if people keep to 'their own kind.'" nonsense.
 
I hesitate to mention it, but it's hard to avoid, given the subject matter.

I had the opportunity to study some original Ariernachweise when I was in Germany, and I can't tell the difference between what you are proposing and what they were used for.

FACT: Israel, Russia and other nations have a identity card which lists their nationality along with citizenship.

Again, why is it ok for Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, China, to have strong immigration laws that seek to preserve their ethnic super-majority, but its not ok for Euro nations to do it? Seems hypocritical.
 
Nations are not ethnocracies.

A nation is a people with common bonds and a shared identity.

Some people may want to limit focus down to ethnicity, but a national identity need not necessarily be defined so. For pragmatic reasons, a shared language is often a requisite, however.

But to base it on some phenotypic characteristics like melanin production or ethnographic ancestry? That was tried in some late colonial settings and in almost every case ended up becoming intertwined in their various independence movements.

It tends to produce an insular, myopic cultural stagnation for the dominant ideology and really nobody "wins."
 
Nations are not ethnocracies.

A nation is a people with common bonds and a shared identity.

Some people may want to limit focus down to ethnicity, but a national identity need not necessarily be defined so. For pragmatic reasons, a shared language is often a requisite, however.

But to base it on some phenotypic characteristics like melanin production or ethnographic ancestry? That was tried in some late colonial settings and in almost every case ended up becoming intertwined in their various independence movements.

It tends to produce an insular, myopic cultural stagnation for the dominant ideology and really nobody "wins."

If Ireland takes in 10 million immigrants from Nigeria, India, Taiwan and Indonesia, are they still Irish?
 
FACT: Israel, Russia and other nations have a identity card which lists their nationality along with citizenship.

Again, why is it ok for Japan, South Korea, Taiwan, China, to have strong immigration laws that seek to preserve their ethnic super-majority, but its not ok for Euro nations to do it? Seems hypocritical.

For that to be hypocritical, you would have to catch me first endorsing their immigration policy - which I don't.
Japan, Korea and China are fundamentally racists cultures, each literally based on the idea that only they are "true" humans, and all the others some kind of demon or undead.
 
The basic flaw is the assumption that Human Heritage is Genetic, when it is clearly Cultural.

You won't find a more True Texan than a local with a strong Mexican heritage a few generations back.
 
Simple question: do European states have the right to maintain their ethnic and/or white majorities?

I say they do. Ireland is the land of the Irish people. Germany is the land of the German people. Russia the land of the Russians.

What constitutes an Irish person? If an Irish person marries a non-Irish person and they have kids, are the kids only half-Irish? What rights would they have under this ethnocratic state? Would their own children get decreased or increased rights depending on whether the half-Irish offspring reproduce with Irish, half-Irish, or non-Irish people? What are the rules for defining Irishnicity? Show your work: this is a proposed legal framework so you have to be able to define it so it fits every situation.
 
We should keep to our enlightened and liberal politics and values. Ethnicity is trivial.
 
What constitutes an Irish person? If an Irish person marries a non-Irish person and they have kids, are the kids only half-Irish? What rights would they have under this ethnocratic state? Would their own children get decreased or increased rights depending on whether the half-Irish offspring reproduce with Irish, half-Irish, or non-Irish people? What are the rules for defining Irishnicity? Show your work: this is a proposed legal framework so you have to be able to define it so it fits every situation.

These are key questions. I'm an Irish citizen but I was born outside the country with a goodly proportion of foreign blood and have spent very little of my life there. I'd be interested to know which, if any, of my current rights should be removed from me.

The subject also cropped up in the recent presidential elections here in France where Le Pen proposed defining different classes of French citizens. As dual-nationals my children and I would have been considered less French than our pure-bred neighbours* when applying for jobs, for example. Rampant discrimination is everywhere in France already, of course, but it was surprising to hear it being discussed in those terms.


* Of course we're all hybrids.
 
What constitutes an Irish person? If an Irish person marries a non-Irish person and they have kids, are the kids only half-Irish? What rights would they have under this ethnocratic state? Would their own children get decreased or increased rights depending on whether the half-Irish offspring reproduce with Irish, half-Irish, or non-Irish people? What are the rules for defining Irishnicity? Show your work: this is a proposed legal framework so you have to be able to define it so it fits every situation.

Oh easy. Just watch "Conspiracy" and replace "German" with "Irish"
 
If Ireland takes in 10 million immigrants from Nigeria, India, Taiwan and Indonesia, are they still Irish?

Would it make a difference if it was 10 million from Sweden, Norway, Finland, and Austria? and why?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom