Can/should European nations maintain their white majorities?

As always the people who are openly on the side of evil are trying to demand nothing but a mush mouthed discussion of vague truisms about broad "rights."

Their evil happens in the real world but for all their talk about "cancel culture" and "echo chambers" they can only discuss a detached, "civil debate" version of it.

Because their actual opinions are awful. And they know it.
 
As some may know, Australia has gone from the nasty “White Australia Policy” to a multicultural society since WW2, with roughly 50% of the population having at least one parent born overseas. We are a far better country as a result. Failure to grow through immigration would have left us well behind by any metric.

Immigrants were from Europe during my childhood, but since adopting a non-discriminatory immigration policy (during the 60s or 70s by memory) we have had large numbers from Asia, Africa and the Middle East. The place hasn’t fallen apart.
 
Last edited:
Maybe so, but making racial and cultural challenges non-discussible and refusing to see the tensions that are caused by putting culturally different groups in close proximity doesn't fix anything. There was a Trevor Phillips documentary a few years ago where he more or less said he'd realised that this approach had made the situation worse.

Who is stopping you discussing and just asking questions?
 
I wish at the very least people attracted to the closed borders crap could articulate the point as well as you have here, but for the most part I don't see this, and they go full blown xenophobia without a rational basis to change their mind.

There are melting pot countries that have largely overlooked racial differences and variety. So it's not unheard of.
Which ones are you thinking of?

Incidentally, I appreciate your openness and engagement. The thing is I'm not particularly good at articulating this, or particularly knowledgeable. So the question to my mind is, where are the people arguing the case like this in whatever media you are consuming? Such people certainly exist.
 
Only fairly recently did people observe some political difference between the two that resulted in war. But Ukrainians and Russians are like sister nations, people have family on both sides of the border, and they share a common origin.
Yeah, the Franks were a Germanic tribe once upon a time.

There's a lot of history you casually brushed aside.
 
As sme may know, Australia has gone from the nasty “White Australia Policy” to a multicultural society since WW2, with roughly 50% of the population having at least one parent born overseas. We are a far better country as a result. Failure to grow through immigration would have left us well behind by any metric.

Immigrants were from Europe during my childhood, but since adopting a non-discriminatory immigration policy (during the 60s or 70s by memory) we have had large numbers from Asia, Africa and the Middle East. The place hasn’t fallen apart.

Living in Melbourne and Darwin we kind of have a bit of experience with diversity.
 
Which ones are you thinking of?

Incidentally, I appreciate your openness and engagement. The thing is I'm not particularly good at articulating this, or particularly knowledgeable. So the question to my mind is, where are the people arguing the case like this in whatever media you are consuming? Such people certainly exist.

India, Brazil, much of Latin America, parts of North Africa, Indonesia, to name the big ones.

What I find objectionable about the people who usually articulate it as you have done is they share many of the same spaces as the open racists and political extremists.

Yeah, the Franks were a Germanic tribe once upon a time.

There's a lot of history you casually brushed aside.

Sure but that wasn't the topic.
 
Again, in the Trevor Phillips documentary, he talks about working with the Blair government to make these things non-discussable.

I think it is this:
https://youtu.be/Tb2iFikOwYU

A big part of the problem is that racism and xenophobia have become a bit unfashionable these days. For now just keep it respectable and whine about persecution. This stuff can come back in vogue.

If the video has anything relevant for the thread how about you give it voice here.
 
A big part of the problem is that racism and xenophobia have become a bit unfashionable these days. For now just keep it respectable and whine about persecution. This stuff can come back in vogue.
Well, indeed because the basic problems that caused the racism haven't been dealt with.

If the video has anything relevant for the thread how about you give it voice here.
It's a good video, Trevor Phillips was the head of the Commission for Racial Equality in the UK. You mentioned Stephen Lawrence, Trevor Phillips was involved in lots of what came out of that.
 
Well, indeed because the basic problems that caused the racism haven't been dealt with.

A basic problem is wealth opportunity for immigrants and leaving youth to languish in hopeless poverty. The acceptance and community change comes with wealth and rising out of poverty. This is evident in the history of many migrant populations.


It's a good video, Trevor Phillips was the head of the Commission for Racial Equality in the UK. You mentioned Stephen Lawrence, Trevor Phillips was involved in lots of what came out of that.

So what does this authority have to say?
 
Only fairly recently did people observe some political difference between the two that resulted in war. But Ukrainians and Russians are like sister nations, people have family on both sides of the border, and they share a common origin.

Oh yeah, like that friendly famine that the Soviet Union imposed on Ukraine in the 1930s, and of course the invasion of Ukraine by the Soviet Union that ended its independence following World War One.

And the fact that much of Ukraine was actually Poland until WW2. Poland that was invaded by the Soviet Union of course and had its intelligentsia and officers murdered.
 
If "preventing cultural change" were the priority, then people from Alabama would not be permitted to travel to New York. Of course, this idea is unappealing to racists, because fascism must curtail the rights of the undesirables, while maintaining the status quo for the "pure" race.
 
If "preventing cultural change" were the priority, then people from Alabama would not be permitted to travel to New York. Of course, this idea is unappealing to racists, because fascism must curtail the rights of the undesirables, while maintaining the status quo for the "pure" race.

This is what baffles me the most, people have been travelling the globe since before the bible was invented but I can't really point my finger at those "cultures" that have been destroyed.

Spain was occupied by "evil brown people" who believed in a other god, only uneducated idiots would claim that Spain's culture has been wiped out or even significantly changed because of the occupation...but oh well, it's freaking migration we should be afraid of :confused::confused:
 
Well, I think it is fine if a country decides it doesn't want lots of immigration from "**** hole" countries.

Does anyone really want that? I mean, it isn't their fault if most of these people are black and brown, right? In fact, I'd say any country has a right to limit immigration for any reason it chooses, racial or otherwise.

If someone doesn't like it, oh well. If it is your country and you want to change it, and can do so, go for it. But I bet most people wouldn't lift a finger. Many really don't want these people, but it is unpopular to admit it (in some places).

Wow! May I salute your courage in being an open and unabashed racist then. Many people like Tucker Carlson etc…. hide it under weasel words. But you just go right out and say you don’t want “these people”.

Jesus! How many naked racists do we have on this forum now?


I don't see where my statement/observation is racist, at all. I am not saying that vetting people solely based on race is ideal, just that it is within a country's rights to do so.

As far as immigrants from "**** hole" countries, do you think most citizens really want that? Do you think that they also want immigrants from cultures with values in opposition to the prevailing ones? Do they really want more poor, sickly, or uneducated immigrants?

Do you think that a society of educated people truly wakes up in the morning and says, "We should infuse our society/culture with a large number of poor/uneducated/primitive people from third-world countries"? Do you think they should?
 
Last edited:
I don't see where my statement/observation is racist, at all. I am not saying that vetting people solely based on race is ideal, just that it is within a country's rights to do so.

As far as immigrants from "**** hole" countries, do you think most citizens really want that? Do you think that they also want immigrants from cultures with values in opposition to the prevailing ones? Do they really want more poor, sickly, or uneducated immigrants?

Do you think that a society of educated people truly wakes up in the morning and says, "We should infuse our society/culture with a large number of poor/uneducated/primitive people from third-world countries"? Do you think they should?

I think this is the stuff you don't say loud.
 
This is what baffles me the most, people have been travelling the globe since before the bible was invented but I can't really point my finger at those "cultures" that have been destroyed.

Spain was occupied by "evil brown people" who believed in a other god, only uneducated idiots would claim that Spain's culture has been wiped out or even significantly changed because of the occupation...but oh well, it's freaking migration we should be afraid of :confused::confused:

From the little-Englander with the view that "***** begin at Calais", Spain continues to be occupied by "evil brown people". ;)

That said, IMO the Muslim occupation of the Iberian Peninsula has left an indelible mark on Spanish (and Catalan) culture. Spanish culture wasn't wiped out, but it was changed significantly. IMO looking at places like Malaga and Toledo, and considering Spanish food, music and art, those changes were definitely enhancements but likely have left Spanish culture unrecognisable from what went before.

The same is also true IMO for all countries that haven't had extended periods of isolationism, each wave of new arrivals results in changes to that country's culture, food, mores and every aspect of society. IMO in the same way that mutts and moggies are more resilient than pedigree dogs and cats, new "blood" from all over the world enhances a society.

Anyone who thinks that Ian Wright isn't proudly English because he's black needs to take a long hard look at themselves.
 
I don't see where my statement/observation is racist, at all. I am not saying that vetting people solely based on race is ideal, just that it is within a country's rights to do so.
Racist in this context just means thinking that government should prioritise the interests and culture of its citizens rather than the global population. You are racist because you don't think John Lennon's Imagine is going to work out.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom