Can/should European nations maintain their white majorities?

Well, I think it is fine if a country decides it doesn't want lots of immigration from "**** hole" countries.

Does anyone really want that? I mean, it isn't their fault if most of these people are black and brown, right? In fact, I'd say any country has a right to limit immigration for any reason it chooses, racial or otherwise.

If someone doesn't like it, oh well. If it is your country and you want to change it, and can do so, go for it. But I bet most people wouldn't lift a finger. Many really don't want these people, but it is unpopular to admit it (in some places).
 
Last edited:
Simple question: do European states have the right to maintain their ethnic and/or white majorities?

I say they do. Ireland is the land of the Irish people. Germany is the land of the German people. Russia the land of the Russians.

They have the natural and moral right to not only maintain their white majority, but also their ethnic majority. I believe it is the right of ALL non-colonial nations to do so, especially nation-states.

South Korea, China, Taiwan, Japan, have all instituted immigration policies that for one thing, work to maintain their ethnic super-majority. There is only one Japan after all, and it has the right to exist.

I believe that Euro nations have the right enforce strict, tight immigration laws that work to maintain their ethnic majorities. Do they have the right to remove non-citizen immigrants who are not white? I say its a little rude, but acceptable. Removing citizens that are not white? Only with some decent compensation, I'd say.

What say you?

Nobody has a right to segregate people based on color religion or ethnicity.
That is not the same as having to welcome any and all with open arms. There are limits to who and how many any nation can absorb at a given time, but you cannot exclude people for not being "white".

Hans
 
Nobody has a right to segregate people based on color religion or ethnicity.
That is not the same as having to welcome any and all with open arms. There are limits to who and how many any nation can absorb at a given time, but you cannot exclude people for not being "white".

Hans
Why does a bunch of 18th century white guys conception of "rights" get to tell the rest of the world how to live? Claiming their view of rights as "universal" seems kind of colonial. Like most colonial projects, it really only works at the point of overwhelming military or economic power.
 
Last edited:
Why does a bunch of 18th century white guys conception of "rights" get to tell the rest of the world how to live?

"I get to be racist because 'don't be racist' is an 18th Century White Guy conception" is one of those "There's no way in the MA to respond to you" things.
 
"I get to be racist because 'don't be racist' is an 18th Century White Guy conception" is one of those "There's no way in the MA to respond to you" things.
Of course it is. You think there is some universal truth that preferring you own people to others is bad? When was this truth brought down from the mountain? These are western values that countries that do not come from our cultural tradition pay lip service to because we are powerful. So far it has been imposed on the old English speaking parts of the British Empire, and with varying success in the areas of the world occupied by the US in WW2. There is nothing universal about it. Even then, how's it going getting Japan to not be racist?

Thinking that you have found the one universal morality is like thinking your religious sect is the only true religion. There is no rational basis for thinking this and every reason in the world to doubt it.
 
Last edited:
In the US census, white covers all of the "original peoples of Europe, North Africa, and the Middle East" which roughly corresponds to the old "Caucasoid" (West Eurasian) category.

I propose European countries should open their borders to all West Eurasian people, like the Afghans. Their slightly lighter skinned brethren failed to liberate them. It's only fair.
 
Simple question: do European states have the right to maintain their ethnic and/or white majorities?

I say they do. Ireland is the land of the Irish people. Germany is the land of the German people. Russia the land of the Russians.

They have the natural and moral right to not only maintain their white majority, but also their ethnic majority. I believe it is the right of ALL non-colonial nations to do so, especially nation-states.

South Korea, China, Taiwan, Japan, have all instituted immigration policies that for one thing, work to maintain their ethnic super-majority. There is only one Japan after all, and it has the right to exist.

I believe that Euro nations have the right enforce strict, tight immigration laws that work to maintain their ethnic majorities. Do they have the right to remove non-citizen immigrants who are not white? I say its a little rude, but acceptable. Removing citizens that are not white? Only with some decent compensation, I'd say.

What say you?

What you have written literally reads exactly like a certain manifesto I glanced through a few hours ago.

Why do people become obsessed with the idea of the purity of their races? It is clearly pseudoscientific fascism.
 
What you have written literally reads exactly like a certain manifesto I glanced through a few hours ago.

Why do people become obsessed with the idea of the purity of their races? It is clearly pseudoscientific fascism.
Normally when we encounter these things it is because race remains a good proxy for culture.
 
For cultures to survive, there has to be strong ingroup preference holding it together. Without that, all nations will slowly become the same. Difference can only survive if it is resistant to mixing. The type of diversity that is typically advocated is like trying to make the colour palette more diverse by taking all of the tubes paint and mixing them together into some kind of uniform intermediate hue.

The 1930’s called. They want their racist theories back.
 
Normally when we encounter these things it is because race remains a good proxy for culture.

And in this case "White" is a proxy for European Culture and all it entails. The culture is what draws the migrants from far and wide to the US/Canada, Europe itself and Australia/NewZealand, not the colour of the European skin. Whether the culture can withstand the influx of migrants from other cultures is whole separate question.
 
Of course it is. You think there is some universal truth that preferring you own people to others is bad?

Depends on how you mean it. A white guy from France is definitely not "my people" to a greater degree than a black guy down the street.

The way you phrased it looked like an attempt to whitewash racism. I'm sure that wasn't intentional. Would you like to rephrase?
 
Normally when we encounter these things it is because race remains a good proxy for culture.

“Race” huh? You mean like how you want to avoid the Jewish race from contaminating Aryan race through blood mixing which no doubt degrades the virility of the nation and its culture and tarnishes the soil of your forebears? Something like that?
 
You keep saying that as if you aren't doing it intentionally.
Race is a proxy for culture. The overwhelming reason race is important is because it carries a lot of cultural information. This is simply a fact.
 
And in this case "White" is a proxy for European Culture and all it entails. The culture is what draws the migrants from far and wide to the US/Canada, Europe itself and Australia/NewZealand, not the colour of the European skin. Whether the culture can withstand the influx of migrants from other cultures is whole separate question.
Yes. This is very obviously true.
 
Race is a proxy for culture. The overwhelming reason race is important is because it carries a lot of cultural information. This is simply a fact.

This is just so ridiculous. How do you explain various kinds of nationalisms and countries waging war against each other if you try to argue that they are all basically the same?

Look at the Russian invasion of Ukraine. How does this happen on your dim witted race=culture hypothesis?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom