Bush NSA spies on Americans

To some degree it apears the leak was timed to maximize sales possibilities for one of their hack's books soon to be released.

Also, at one time, courts realized that freedom of press, civil rights, blah blah should not become a suicide pact.


The Plame crapola has and had no bearing on the real world except the real world of politicians not in power striving to get some power.

Ed only knows what intelligence assets we've lost by discussing current NSA operations.


Please Ed, let the first suitcase nuke on US soil be close to a large group of the blithering idiots who see no danger except that posed by Bush etal.
I'm not getting into this again with you. You've made it explicitly clear in another thread that you believe the President should have no restraints whatsoever in pursuit of national security (and, as far as I can tell, even if he uses this power for personal or political gain instead of national security--though you haven't said that). This is not a disagreement you and I can resolve by arguing. Especially since you see no middle ground between absolute impunity and suicide pact.
 
Last edited:
That's terrifying. If the Quakers joined forces with the librarians, just think what havoc they could wreak.

There's something about Trappist monks that makes me think they may be in on the plot too. I hope someone's been eavesdropping on them, that would be funny for so many reasons.

This sounds like a game of Illuminati...

Hmm...wait a minute...
 
You've made it explicitly clear in another thread that you believe the President should have no restraints whatsoever in pursuit of national security (and, as far as I can tell, even if he uses this power for personal or political gain instead of national security--though you haven't said that).
Evidence? I don't recall stating anything that could reasonably be construed as that position. If I did, I was certainly in error.
 
Evidence? I don't recall stating anything that could reasonably be construed as that position. If I did, I was certainly in error.

Then why don't you elaborate more fully on your position instead of praying for a neuclear attack on journalists?
 
To some degree it apears the leak was timed to maximize sales possibilities for one of their hack's books soon to be released.

Also, at one time, courts realized that freedom of press, civil rights, blah blah should not become a suicide pact.


The Plame crapola has and had no bearing on the real world except the real world of politicians not in power striving to get some power.

Ed only knows what intelligence assets we've lost by discussing current NSA operations.
Well, it may be that the conservative New York Times (yes I think they are conservative, so sue me) found themselves in a position where they could not keep the story hushed up anymore. It would look kinda silly if a book with this major scandal in it was published and it turned out the NYT had the story for over a year and did nothing about it.

I’m not sure exactly what kind of damage this revelation would do, it’s not like we have been discussing specific names of people who have been spied on or anything. I don’t think that it was a secret that the government was engaged in wiretapping operations, that’s just common sense. The problem was how the Bush administration went about it.

They had the ability to secretly get the warrants that they needed, and decided not to. Why wouldn’t they at least try to get the warrants? There are very few possible answers to that question, and none of them are very good.
 
Thanks Rik! Some questions that are actually worth answering, instead of cheap-shot generalizations about the liberal media.

You're welcome Gnome! :) According to you those questions are worth answering,...before you show that they're NOT worth answering! Here again we travel to the bizarro world of "fake but true"...and "voted for it before voting against it".

The liberal media and liberals in general get what they deserve. When the target has cheapened itself through blatant bias and lies one can hardly blame the "shot" for being cheap itself.
To begin: If the release of the story was timed simply to bash President Bush during a day that would otherwise have been good news for him, why wouldn't NYT have released it before the US election, instead?
I don't know. Why don't you pose your question to the editor of the NYT. It is obvious that the release was timed since the story was held. The timing was entirely up to the NYT editor...perhaps it was aimed at the PA debate instead?
Such a motive doesn't fit the facts. But, there was a more significant reason to print when they did, that happened to coincide with the Iraqi elections--there was an important vote going on regarding the Patriot Act. In fact, I daresay printing the article changed the outcome. That's not an unprincipled attack--that's a relevant disclosure on the eve of an important vote. It's their JOB.

Bullsh!t. The JOB of the press is to report the news; not make the news. By pushing this story to influence the vote on the PA the NYT editor is attempting to influence law. It's not their JOB...it's chutzpah, hubris, meddling.
Regarding the conflict between objecting to leaks regarding Plame, and lauding a leak regarding NSA behavior... that one's pretty simple. Violating secrecy for purposes of a political retaliation is reprehensible.
Okay I'll bite. You're right...but since Bob Woodward had this info before Libby "leaked" it...then Libby (and Rove) are not the leakers. There goes your political retaliation scenario. No wonder the limo-libs are busy shooting Woodward the evil-eye. Luckily Bob had too much integrity to sit silently by. Good for him!
Violating secrecy for purposes of blowing the whistle on a possibly unconstitutional invasion of privacy is why the free press exists. It's about as different a situation as you can get. I actually have a hard time figuring out why you see them as the same.

Possibly...and yet Bush has seen no problem with signing many exec orders that are part of the record. At the very most you have a POTUS who was given bad legal advice...at the least you have nothing at all because it's likely legal all around. We're at war. It's post 9/11...the President must use all powers at his disposal to protect the nation. The editor of the NYT's wishes notwithstanding...after all who is he to attempt to use his unelected position to influence the PA debate in the US Senate and cloak his meddling under the lofty title of: "The Free Press"??

-z
 
I thought I read, when this story first broke, that the Times was going to publish the story a year ago, but agreed not to when asked by the White House on the grounds of national security? I can't find that line again in any of the news stories...did I imagine it? Or was it a mistake that they corrected almost as soon as they posted the story?

I have to say, the Times agreeing to sit on such a story seems rather incredible. If true, then how can they be indignant now, since they were involved in the coverup for a full year?
 
Well, it may be that the conservative New York Times (yes I think they are conservative, so sue me)
Er, your crummy opinion is your business. Thanks for sharing, though.

They had the ability to secretly get the warrants that they needed, and decided not to. Why wouldn’t they at least try to get the warrants? There are very few possible answers to that question, and none of them are very good.
As the Pres attempted to explain to the Bush-haters posing as a press corps (not to mention posing as rational posters here), a time-is-of-the-essence problem was perceived, and dealt with, in the cases in question. When time permits warrants were and are requested.


Disc said:
Then why don't you elaborate more fully on your position instead of praying for a neuclear attack on journalists?
Elaborate on a position I don't hold? Not today, thanks. And did I request nukes be directed at "journalists"? I think not.
 
Bullsh!t. The JOB of the press is to report the news; not make the news. By pushing this story to influence the vote on the PA the NYT editor is attempting to influence law. It's not their JOB...it's chutzpah, hubris, meddling.

Actually, it is the press's job to serve as a government watchdog. That's why we have a First Amendment.

As Supreme Court Justice Potter Stewart explained in a 1974 speech, the "primary purpose" of the First Amendment was "to create a fourth institution outside the government as an additional check on the three official branches" (the executive branch, the legislature and the judiciary).

And, oh, look, that comes from a Government website!

http://usinfo.state.gov/journals/itdhr/0297/ijde/goodale.htm
 
There are certain nations which have peculiar reasons for cherishing the liberty of the press, independently of the general motives that I have just pointed out. For in certain countries which profess to be free, every individual agent of the government may violate the laws with impunity, since the constitution does not give to those who are injured a right of complaint before the courts of justice. In this case the liberty of the press is not merely one of the guarantees, but it is the only guarantee of their liberty and security that the citizens possess.

My pal Al. Democracy. In. America.
 
As the Pres attempted to explain to the Bush-haters posing as a press corps (not to mention posing as rational posters here), a time-is-of-the-essence problem was perceived, and dealt with, in the cases in question. When time permits warrants were and are requested.
The law allows for requesting a warrant retroactively up to 72 hours after the tap has begun. It takes a lot less time to request the warrant, as the court that approves such warrants is designed to issue them quickly.
 
I agree that some people apparently interpret The Law to say such; I admit I don't know what the true interpretation is.

I suspect SCOTUS will eventually let us all know.
 
The law allows for requesting a warrant retroactively up to 72 hours after the tap has begun. It takes a lot less time to request the warrant, as the court that approves such warrants is designed to issue them quickly.

Here's what I wonder about a retroactive warrant. Is the information that is gained from a wiretap used as evidence to support the warrant?

In other words, let's say the cops search your house without a warrant and they find a pound of cocaine. Then they go to the judge and ask for a retroactive warrant. And the judge wants to know why he should grant it. "Well, we found a pound a cocaine."

You see what I mean? That's plainly an unlawful search and seizure.
 
The Times article did not make a clear case that the program was illegal.

Thank you for the permission to feel relieved at not being dumped into the East River. Are you pleased that Mr. Faris was discovered before he was able to find a way to accomplish his mission?

If you want to take seriously a "threat" of a man cutting 15" thick suspension cables, with blow torches, that’s up to you.
 
Elaborate on a position I don't hold? Not today, thanks. And did I request nukes be directed at "journalists"? I think not.

You sir, are a liar.

Please Ed, let the first suitcase nuke on US soil be close to a large group of the blithering idiots who see no danger except that posed by Bush etal.

go look at your post, see it in context.
 
Last edited:
Here's what I wonder about a retroactive warrant. Is the information that is gained from a wiretap used as evidence to support the warrant?

In other words, let's say the cops search your house without a warrant and they find a pound of cocaine. Then they go to the judge and ask for a retroactive warrant. And the judge wants to know why he should grant it. "Well, we found a pound a cocaine."

You see what I mean? That's plainly an unlawful search and seizure.

I agree. They should justify the reason for the search with evidence they had BEFORE the search.
 
The other point is, that if Bush broke a law then we cannot punish them in the courts, any evidence this gives us would not be allowed to be entered in to evidence.

Which is why Mr. Faris has a closed hearing, and the results of the hearing were also sealed. We don't even know if he had a lawyer.

Like half the people held in Cuba, these people will end up being released at some stage in the future. Released with a grudge, is this the security you people crave?
 
Evidence? I don't recall stating anything that could reasonably be construed as that position. If I did, I was certainly in error.

It was an exchange on another message board (my error for mistaking the forum):

http://www.skepticalcommunity.com/phpbb2/viewtopic.php?t=6656

This exchange:

Gnome:

Well, claiming "no recollection" of whether one ordered illegal funding for a terrorist group based on illegally selling weapons to a terrorist state, isn't quite the same as "no recollection" of whether he'd had membership in a group.

Hammegk:

Now there is a question for Roberts: What should POTUS (and his administration) do when faced with actual geopolitical reality but hindered by bad, verging on insane, "law"?

Gnome:

Um... I don't know. I guess you think he should violate his oath of office and authority under the Constitution, and then plead ignorance and let an underling take the rap.

Hammegk:

Erm, yes. The old Better Red than Dead position. Screw the Pres's responsibility for national defense. Got it!

Gnome:

Make the president an unaccountable dictator in handling national defense. Got it.

Hammegk:

You do understand that in our hair-trigger world that is the fact? Nah, probably not.

Ring a bell? If this is not an endorsement of the president being unaccountable on matters of national security, I apologize for the misunderstanding. Perhaps you could explain what you meant instead.

Or, if you simply wish to back off of this position and argue something different, I'm listening.
 
The other point is, that if Bush broke a law then we cannot punish them in the courts, any evidence this gives us would not be allowed to be entered in to evidence.

Which is why Mr. Faris has a closed hearing, and the results of the hearing were also sealed. We don't even know if he had a lawyer.

Like half the people held in Cuba, these people will end up being released at some stage in the future. Released with a grudge, is this the security you people crave?

You are making an assumption.

It could be a closed hearing because it would reveal surveillance methods that are still being used. We wouldn't want to tip Al Queda off which communication methods of theirs we have cracked and are monitoring.
 
You sir, are a liar.
And you are a dunce with comprehension problems.

go look at your post, see it in context.
I don't see "nuke a journalist" anywhere in it, context or not.



gnome said:
Ring a bell? If this is not an endorsement of the president being unaccountable on matters of national security, I apologize for the misunderstanding. Perhaps you could explain what you meant instead.
Hmm. Next you'll accuse me, here, of being the hammegk who posts there ... (no comment).

And that exchange with my final comment "You do understand that in our hair-trigger world that is the fact? Nah, probably not." is much broader in scope than this current tempest-in-a-peapot and covers POTUS responsibility that has been de-facto since the beginning of the Cold War.

Nor does it cover personal/political wrongdoing by POTUS.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom