Bush NSA spies on Americans

eta: directed at last post previous page ... damned page break anyhow.

Wow. Are you smoking something or do you inject it?
 
Random said:
If the president tells you, “I’m doing something illegal, but if you tell anybody you will be tried for treason” what sort of responsibilities do you hold?

Reporting it.
 
If FISA is so unworkable, why didn't it get reformed? After all, so much attention and time and energy was spent overhauling things after 9/11. If the administration had a problem with FISA, why didn't they try to reform it, instead of bypassing it and breaking the law?

From what I read the President does have power to do such things in the name of national security, and I don't see lists of those spied upon showing that they were mostly Americans either.

It also seems that our system of checks and balances is working as we speak.

What's the problem?
 
Secondly, there are such things as roving wiretaps. Now, by the way, any time you hear the United States government talking about wiretap, it requires -- a wiretap requires a court order. Nothing has changed, by the way. When we're talking about chasing down terrorists, we're talking about getting a court order before we do so. It's important for our fellow citizens to understand, when you think Patriot Act, constitutional guarantees are in place when it comes to doing what is necessary to protect our homeland, because we value the Constitution.

http://www.whitehouse.gov/news/releases/2004/04/20040420-2.html
 
From what I read the President does have power to do such things in the name of national security, and I don't see lists of those spied upon showing that they were mostly Americans either.

It also seems that our system of checks and balances is working as we speak.

What's the problem?
The president does have the power to do things like what he is saying, but there are legal requirements, procedures, and safeguards in place in order to make these actions legal. Bush didn’t try to comply with any of them, he just decided to create his own pseudo-legal procedure out of whole cloth, and he doesn’t have the authority to do that.
 
The president does have the power to do things like what he is saying, but there are legal requirements, procedures, and safeguards in place in order to make these actions legal. Bush didn’t try to comply with any of them, he just decided to create his own pseudo-legal procedure out of whole cloth, and he doesn’t have the authority to do that.

And if someone has absolute, 100% faith in their leader they won't have a problem with that. For those of us who do not have such blind trust/faith, it is a rather large problem.
 
I think Bush's behavior is grounds for impeachment.

That may be, but I doubt it will ever happen.

Interesting stuff is coming out. Apparently, a lot of this began with Reagan, and continued on until today. I'm still chasing it down, but it seems that Clinton pulled something similar, and when called on it, his staff said that it was well within the President's powers to do this. This would undercut any attempt at impeachment if it's so. Precedent has been set.
 
That may be, but I doubt it will ever happen.

Interesting stuff is coming out. Apparently, a lot of this began with Reagan, and continued on until today. I'm still chasing it down, but it seems that Clinton pulled something similar, and when called on it, his staff said that it was well within the President's powers to do this. This would undercut any attempt at impeachment if it's so. Precedent has been set.
Citations, please.
 
Cater and Clinton both granted their attorney generals the authority to do warrantles wiretaps, provided they obeyed the requirements of the Foreign Intelligence Surveillence Act. The law allows for warrantless wiretaps with some limitation. Bush went outside the bounds of the law it looks like, that is the problem.

This will probably do nothing to change the right-wing talking point however.
 
It's a reasonable question, but not hard to imagine situations where you don't have time. An obvious one would be an internationally intercepted call to the US or a call from the US to an international location (not sure if that means they should stop listening without a warrant), but then the conversation is heard to involve calling someone else in the US to pass an urgent message and so on.

.

My understanding is that they can listen and then they have 72 hours to get the warrent. Seems they didn't bother.
 
Hadn't you heard? Bush's whims ARE the Law. No wonder he's such a fan of its rule.
If we are going to abandon our constitutional democracy and adopt a totalitarian dictatorship, could we at the very least select a dictator who is, oh I don’t know, smart?
 
With 5 more Rep senate seats providing a lock (assuming the House stays R) it'll be fun to see how many Dem incumbents of the 33 up for grabs in 2006 will be willing to go to the mat on this issue.

"Terrorist supporter" will look good in the campaign adds. Have they truly floated so far from reality with the Hate Bush (non)agenda? :)
 
With 5 more Rep senate seats providing a lock (assuming the House stays R) it'll be fun to see how many Dem incumbents of the 33 up for grabs in 2006 will be willing to go to the mat on this issue.

"Terrorist supporter" will look good in the campaign adds. Have they truly floated so far from reality with the Hate Bush (non)agenda? :)
I for one can’t wait to see how the Republican party reacts when President Hillary Clinton starts using these newfangled powers after Bush goes back to Crawford. :D
 
I for one can’t wait to see how the Republican party reacts when President Hillary Clinton starts using these newfangled powers after Bush goes back to Crawford. :D

I can already tell you: they will act like they never supported the powers in the first place. Apologists will demand that we show exactly where and when they did support them...and if we don't have a link to an exact, word for word quote, they will deny it ever happened.

Don't think so? I remind everyone that conservatives all over are now making the claim---with straight faces---that Bush never linked Iraq and 9/11.

Oh...and they will spend millions and millions of tax payer dollars to find dirt on her and won't find a thing.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom