Bush NSA spies on Americans

Is it OK to at least be pleased that Mr. Faris was discovered before he found a way to take down the Brooklyn Bridge, or that the fertilizer truck-bomb plot in England was thwarted?
Feel any way you like about it. Is it OK for the president to break the law?
 
Feel any way you like about it. Is it OK for the president to break the law?
No, but at least some US citizens prefer to maximize the chance that while in the US we will be alive to discuss it, rather than being a cloud of expanding particles in a fission bomb explosion, or dead from some man-made bioweapon.
 
Last edited:
The Times article did not make a clear case that the program was illegal.

Thank you for the permission to feel relieved at not being dumped into the East River. Are you pleased that Mr. Faris was discovered before he was able to find a way to accomplish his mission?
 
Thank you for the permission to feel relieved at not being dumped into the East River. Are you pleased that Mr. Faris was discovered before he was able to find a way to accomplish his mission?
I can't speak for others, but for me, it depends on how the intended attempt was learned about. If we uncovered it because of illegal methods, or unethical methods that have been made legal, then I disapprove.
 
The sad thing is that Bush’s orders were was completely unnecessary. The Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act covers everything that Bush could have wanted. It allows for starting a wiretap without a warrant if there is no time to get one, you just have to apply for the warrant retroactively within 72 hours. It’s not like the FICA court has a higher standard for issuing warrants. In the past 25 years they have approved about eighteen thousand requests, and have rejected four (that’s it, just four). The whole mechanism for getting questionable but legal wiretaps is already in place.

All the Bushies had to do was walk down a hall and have a sleepy FISA judge sign a piece of paper that he might not even read and they could have had their intel legally (at least technically). Instead, they cook up some phony-baloney extra-judicial process whose sole purpose seems to be to violate the constitution. Now we have a president who is engaged in what can only be considered an unconstitutional enterprise, a bunch of republicans who want to find the person who leaked this information to the press, and yet another news story for the so-called “liberal” media to screw up.

Bush- The morals of Nixon, the brains of Quayle...
 
I think it'll be hilarious when the next Democrat to get elected starts using all these new and exciting presidential powers. Naturally the Republicans will not protest at all, of course, because such powers are necessary to the security of the nation.
 
Is it OK to at least be pleased that Mr. Faris was discovered before he found a way to take down the Brooklyn Bridge, or that the fertilizer truck-bomb plot in England was thwarted?

Is it okay if Mr. Faris is released because the evidence against him was obtained illegally?
 
I seem to recall the NSA was doing this anyway through ECHELON.

ECHELON monitors all traffic for key words. It does not target specific individuals.

If the NSA was monitoring specific individuals phones without a warrant, and the President was Bill Clinton, he'd be impeached by next week.
 
C'mon, people. Dictators don't live under the same rules as the people he dictates. What's the problem here?
 
quote:
Senate refuses to extend Patriot Act amid eavesdropping row
Suzanne Goldenberg in Washington
Saturday December 17, 2005
The Guardian

The White House yesterday suffered a new assault on its conduct of the war on terror when the Senate refused to renew provisions of the Patriot Act.
The rebuff, which leaves the anti-terror law in limbo before crucial portions expire on December 31, was delivered amid growing outrage at reports that President George Bush secretly authorised eavesdropping on Americans inside the US without court oversight.

It was the second setback for the White House in two days after Mr Bush yielded to Congress and agreed to ban cruel and inhumane treatment of detainees...
http://www.guardian.co.uk/usa/story/0,12271,1669540,00.html



In a sane world this would be regarded as an outrageous sentence:

"It was the second setback for the White House in two days after Mr Bush yielded to Congress and agreed to ban cruel and inhumane treatment of detainees."
 
All the Bushies had to do was walk down a hall and have a sleepy FISA judge sign a piece of paper that he might not even read and they could have had their intel legally (at least technically). Instead, they cook up some phony-baloney extra-judicial process whose sole purpose seems to be to violate the constitution. Now we have a president who is engaged in what can only be considered an unconstitutional enterprise, a bunch of republicans who want to find the person who leaked this information to the press, and yet another news story for the so-called “liberal” media to screw up.
Getting a FISA warrant wouldn't have achieved the real goal: getting Americans to accept anything as long as it's covered by the mantle of "protecting American lives from terror".
 
Megalomaniacs tend to think that they can and should use any means to get their ends met.
 
I agree. The degree of percieved threat should inform such decisions.

"perceived threat" is so fluid these days. This administration has proven excellent at getting the population to perceive serious threats--which is not to say they're not real. However, here we show a direct connection between the amount of fear generated and the amount of power the executive branch can claim. This isn't very reassuring.

True. In past times of war civil liberties have been widely rolled back without much dissent from the American people. Propaganda, disinformation, censorship, and even the overtly racist internment of a target ethnic group has been tolerated. All in the name of national security during wartime.

Don't forget, this power has been abused in the past for political means other than national security as well...

We at least have a good record of repealing such curtailment of liberties once the threat has passed.

As another poster mentioned--this threat can be presented indefinitely.
 
Another side point--is it just me, or has the news media suddenly woken up? I never would have expected the major news sources to present such an item, under a democratic OR republican president--such nuances as citizens' privacy seems in the past to be barely worth a footnote. I always thought they would much rather present news about whatever trumped-up controversy is distracting from the real issues.

Instead we see the president on TV forced to explain and justify a rather serious point of national policy. Whether he is right or wrong, it can only be healthy that he must do so.
 
Another side point--is it just me, or has the news media suddenly woken up? I never would have expected the major news sources to present such an item, under a democratic OR republican president--such nuances as citizens' privacy seems in the past to be barely worth a footnote. I always thought they would much rather present news about whatever trumped-up controversy is distracting from the real issues.

Instead we see the president on TV forced to explain and justify a rather serious point of national policy. Whether he is right or wrong, it can only be healthy that he must do so.

It is a good sign. One of the more alarming trends over the last few years has been for the news media to abandon their crucial role as government watchdogs.
 
Details on the fisa:
http://www.fas.org/irp/agency/doj/fisa/

The act is published on the Cornell Law site, linked early on.

A cursory reading certainly seems to cover what a President might want to do and the procedures to follow in order to be within the law.

It might have been more difficult to get approval for things like spying on peace protesters or tens of thousands of Americans though.
 
. . . It might have been more difficult to get approval for things like spying on peace protesters . . .

Something disturbing to comtemplate since the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) seemed to already allow wiretaps on suspected terrorists. What (or who else) is Bush secretly monitoring that he couldn't count on FISA to authorize? Or is it time for me to take off my tin foil hat?

http://people.csail.mit.edu/rahimi/helmet/
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom