Bush NSA spies on Americans

Republicans seem to be willing to risk our constitutional rights to protect our lives from terrorists, yet Democrats seem to be willing to risk our lives to protect us from Republicans.

Because, as we all know, the only way to fight terrorism is to let the Government Do whatever it darn well pleases, civil liberties be damned, they're for wussies anyway.

(One good Strawman deserves another)
 
No, not really. The Democrats have always pushed for similar powers. One of the worst escalations of the War on Drugs, and concurrent violations of civil rights (such as expanded wire-tap powers) was during Clinton's presidency, and many bad laws were signed by him. The original Communications Decency Act, which would have greatly restricted speech on the Internet and many other places, was a creation of the Democrats (sen. Exon, to be precise). LBJ was responsible for just as much nastiness as Nixon when it came to chipping away at Constitutional protections.

Regardless of the various issues and principles that they pay lip service to; the primary goal of both parties is simply to increase their own power as much as possible.
A good reason to make sure the Supreme Court is balanced, especially when one party controls the other two branches of government. Why, oh why, Sandra, did you have to retire NOW?

Just to make the point, I have been an opponent of the excesses of the War on Drugs and the CDA... I am happy to speak against abuses of power even when a Democrat is in charge. Perhaps it is just the partisan in me that sees the current style of republicans in charge as excessively power-hungry... everyone can make up their own mind about that I suppose.
 
A good reason to make sure the Supreme Court is balanced, especially when one party controls the other two branches of government. Why, oh why, Sandra, did you have to retire NOW?

Just to make the point, I have been an opponent of the excesses of the War on Drugs and the CDA... I am happy to speak against abuses of power even when a Democrat is in charge. Perhaps it is just the partisan in me that sees the current style of republicans in charge as excessively power-hungry... everyone can make up their own mind about that I suppose.

Just a little bump here.


When you speak of abuses of power, are you specifically referring to spying on fanatical terrorists, or just those they may be ordering pizza from?

Since spying is by definition something you don't let the other guy know you are doing, shouldn't we just ban all spying since it might inadvertently involve the pizza guy?

Clearly the whole point is secrecy and we know very well that nobody can keep secrets (except about captured UFOs and certain key assasinations), and since it seems obvious now that even the NSA can't keep secrets, so why don't we just abolish this whole farce of intelligence operations and hope the bad guys just screw up from time to time, so we can let the pizza guy have his privacy??????:boxedin:
 
Just a little bump here.


When you speak of abuses of power, are you specifically referring to spying on fanatical terrorists, or just those they may be ordering pizza from?

Since spying is by definition something you don't let the other guy know you are doing, shouldn't we just ban all spying since it might inadvertently involve the pizza guy?

Clearly the whole point is secrecy and we know very well that nobody can keep secrets (except about captured UFOs and certain key assasinations), and since it seems obvious now that even the NSA can't keep secrets, so why don't we just abolish this whole farce of intelligence operations and hope the bad guys just screw up from time to time, so we can let the pizza guy have his privacy??????:boxedin:

Or, we can just allow domestic spying, except they have to follow the rules that exist about it, how about that?
 
Or, we can just allow domestic spying, except they have to follow the rules that exist about it, how about that?

I'm just saying that the rules that exist (including the right to exceptions to them, as is still being debated) quite clearly would not allow any secrecy. Since even the NSA can't kep a secret, do you think possibly hundreds of judges and their staff could?
 
I'm just saying that the rules that exist (including the right to exceptions to them, as is still being debated) quite clearly would not allow any secrecy. Since even the NSA can't kep a secret, do you think possibly hundreds of judges and their staff could?

FISA called for about 11 judges. Authorization by a single judge is all that is required to obtain a warrent. I don't recall any secrecy problems from the judges under this program. Quite clearly, legal secrecy has been doing just fine thank you.
 
FISA called for about 11 judges. Authorization by a single judge is all that is required to obtain a warrent. I don't recall any secrecy problems from the judges under this program. Quite clearly, legal secrecy has been doing just fine thank you.

You may be right. I'm playing devil's advocate here, but I do know that when secrecy is important the less involved the better, and I also know that normal legal standards of suspicion probably require more than a hint of a connection, which might never be obtained if the hint cannot be investigated.

The truth is that we can live with such standards when it concerns "normal" criminal behaviour. When it concerns war, of any kind, all nations, always, have had to make some concessions to win. I get the impression that many of those so afraid of being wrongly connected to terrorism (or some conspiracy against democracy) don't think there is a war to begin with.
 
You may be right. I'm playing devil's advocate here, but I do know that when secrecy is important the less involved the better, and I also know that normal legal standards of suspicion probably require more than a hint of a connection, which might never be obtained if the hint cannot be investigated.

The truth is that we can live with such standards when it concerns "normal" criminal behaviour. When it concerns war, of any kind, all nations, always, have had to make some concessions to win. I get the impression that many of those so afraid of being wrongly connected to terrorism (or some conspiracy against democracy) don't think there is a war to begin with.
I'm perfectly satisfied to lower the burden of proof when the risk is increased that much. I just want to have a rule about it, and follow it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom