Bush NSA spies on Americans

If the NYT posted this story (whether the Thing is Good, Bad or Only) at the time they did with the motive of "trumping" Iraq, then they should be taken to task (I don't know in what manner, though).

What if the NYT knew about this spying prior to the 2004 U.S. presidential elections? If they were really out to undermine Bush, wouldn't they have accomplished more damage by releasing the information at that time?
 
Somehow, even if spying on Quakers was done legally, I just don't see how a Very Legal Thing still makes a Very Bad Thing just a Thing.

Well, it transforms a Very Bad Illegal Thing into just a Very Bad Thing.

Unless Rik's contention is that it's only "Very Bad" if it's illegal. In which case I'd guffaw loudly.
 
Who did Woodward learn about Plame from? That question remains unanswered, correct?

Lurker

Yes, but he has admitted that his knowledge of Plame predates the "outting" by Scooter Libby....therefore Libby is not the leaker. He has however screwed himself up legally in other ways...dumb. Dumb but not unusual. There was apparently nothing substantive to the Whitewater allegations; but during the investigation Clinton perjured himself on an unrelated issue. Dumb.

Personally I think all these politically motivated investigations should cease. It's counterproductive. No matter who is in the WhiteHouse the one sure thing is that he or she will be investigated. :rolleyes:
-z
 
Evidence? No offense, but when Clinton was elected the wingnuts claimed the media was to blame. When Bush was elected wingnuts like you claimed the same. Same story, different wingnut.

Was there a point here? I never made that claim. And name calling is just childish. Not that I expect anything else from you.

I am sorry a free press offends you...perhaps you should move to China?
 
Well, it transforms a Very Bad Illegal Thing into just a Very Bad Thing.

Unless Rik's contention is that it's only "Very Bad" if it's illegal. In which case I'd guffaw loudly.


It is certainly only bad for Bush if it is deemed "illegal". That's what I meant. If it's legal then who care whether you or I dislike the thing and call it bad? But if it is illegal then bad it is for the person(s) who violate it.

-z
 
The Very Bad Thing may well have been a Very Legal Thing....which means that it may not have been Very Bad and only rises to the level of "Thing". Seems to me that the Very Historic Voting in Iraq easily should trump an ambiguous noun which has been kept in cold storage for a year.
What historic Iraqi elections? We seem to have elections in Iraq every few months. Granted, lots of stuff is happening politically over there (what with all the voting between anti-American secular Sunnis, anti-American religious Shiites, anti-American secular Shiites, the continually f’d over Kurds, and Iranians who really shouldn’t be voting but are so thrilled about democracy they can’t help themselves), but I’m not sure way this Iraqi election would be so “historic” compared to the other two we’ve had so far.
After all; wasn't the outting of Plame a "Very Bad Thing" when we could pin it on the Bush White House? But then faded into the background as soon as Bob Woodward let out that he had known about it even before Scooter Libby supposedly blabbed. It sounds like Val's "license to kill" was a very poorly kept secret indeed.
Um, that’s still being investigated actually. Fitz basically come out and said that so many people had lied to him that he was having a hard time figuring out who was telling the truth, but he was able to determine that Libby’s story was a lie, so he indicted him for lying. The media hasn’t been reporting so much on this story lately because they really don’t have anything to report on other than blanket republican denials. This is because unlike Ken “Ok media, here’s what I want you to say tomorrow” Starr, Fitz has kept a tight lid on what is going on in his investigation.
 
It is certainly only bad for Bush if it is deemed "illegal". That's what I meant. If it's legal then who care whether you or I dislike the thing and call it bad? But if it is illegal then bad it is for the person(s) who violate it.

Well, see Rik, the thing about people in power is, if they do something that's Bad--whether it's legal or not--it's going to affect the rest of us. I don't care about whether Bush is affected by his actions; in reality, the rest of us ARE. Who cares? I do, and frankly, so should you.

When Dear Leader is using federal resources to spy on the freaking QUAKERS, it's a Bad Thing--legal or not.
 
If it's legal then who care whether you or I dislike the thing and call it bad?

I care because it means we need to repeal, or challenge in court, a law that allows the President or anyone else to spy on people just because they don't like them.
 
Yes, but he has admitted that his knowledge of Plame predates the "outting" by Scooter Libby....therefore Libby is not the leaker.

What if someone leaked it to Woodward, and Woodward kept quiet about it. Then Libby leaked to Novak and Novak wrote his column?

As you can see, Libby can still be a leaker. But it increasingly looks like we will never know how it all went down. Those responsible are keeping quiet.

Lurker
 
It is certainly only bad for Bush if it is deemed "illegal". That's what I meant. If it's legal then who care whether you or I dislike the thing and call it bad? But if it is illegal then bad it is for the person(s) who violate it.

-z

Jim Crow laws were legal. Were they bad?
 
Was there a point here? I never made that claim. And name calling is just childish. Not that I expect anything else from you.

I am sorry a free press offends you...perhaps you should move to China?

Mark, I respect the wry, sarcasm, wit, humor, barbs, and jabs of some great minds with whom I disagree with on this board.

Unfortunately, you are not one of those great minds and your posts will be unread as I am adding you to my ignore list. Best of luck trolling other people into responding to you. Cheers.
 
Mark, I respect the wry, sarcasm, wit, humor, barbs, and jabs of some great minds with whom I disagree with on this board.

Unfortunately, you are not one of those great minds and your posts will be unread as I am adding you to my ignore list. Best of luck trolling other people into responding to you. Cheers.

You're funny...you call me names, completely unprovoked, and then I am the troll. I like you; you say funny things.
 
What historic Iraqi elections?

Ahhhh the stuff of legendary sig quotes! ;)

I won't though...out of context quotes are not my style...but it's still funny that you'd actually post this ludicrous sentence!

Besides, boring old elections that happen regularly are one of the things we've been fighting to create over there. Elections; like good investments; should be boring.

-z
 
Ahhhh the stuff of legendary sig quotes! ;)

I won't though...out of context quotes are not my style...but it's still funny that you'd actually post this ludicrous sentence!

Besides, boring old elections that happen regularly are one of the things we've been fighting to create over there. Elections; like good investments; should be boring.
Well, I just get fed up with the way some people treat these artificial political benchmarks. Every time something constitution-ish gets signed, or a bunch of people trundle off to vote, some people act as if this is some great thing that will change everything in that poor benighted region of the globe. And the body count keeps creeping up. Nation building doesn’t work that way.

The big issues that make that place so messed up (the lack of a Kurdistan, religious feuds, easy to obtain oil, the interests of neighboring countries, etc.) really are not being addressed by any of this purple finger waving as far as I can tell.

And now, back to the thread topic...
 
Yes, the simpler explanation that the liberal media is so anti-Bush they're against democracy in Iraq.

Why, yes, actually.

Way to ignore the question in the other part of my post. So easy to make cheap shots without having to defend them.
 
Well it does make one wonder why the NYT sat on this story for a year only to drop it like a bomb on a busy news day which should have belonged solely to the historic Iraqi elections.

Also one must wonder why the liberal media cries so loudly about the outting of the identity of Ms. Plame when they are willing to publicize this NSA story which is in fact a far more important secret to national security than Valerie's CIA employment.

It makes you wonder who's side the MSM is really on.

-z
Thanks Rik! Some questions that are actually worth answering, instead of cheap-shot generalizations about the liberal media.

To begin: If the release of the story was timed simply to bash President Bush during a day that would otherwise have been good news for him, why wouldn't NYT have released it before the US election, instead? Such a motive doesn't fit the facts. But, there was a more significant reason to print when they did, that happened to coincide with the Iraqi elections--there was an important vote going on regarding the Patriot Act. In fact, I daresay printing the article changed the outcome. That's not an unprincipled attack--that's a relevant disclosure on the eve of an important vote. It's their JOB.

Regarding the conflict between objecting to leaks regarding Plame, and lauding a leak regarding NSA behavior... that one's pretty simple. Violating secrecy for purposes of a political retaliation is reprehensible. Violating secrecy for purposes of blowing the whistle on a possibly unconstitutional invasion of privacy is why the free press exists. It's about as different a situation as you can get. I actually have a hard time figuring out why you see them as the same.
 
Last edited:
Go for it. America is a republic, not a democracy, even though SCOTUS & the congress have done their best over the last 50 years or so to make it one.

Changing the subject with a word game. Substitute "civil rights" for "democracy" if it makes you understand the question better.
 
Regarding the conflict between objecting to leaks regarding Plame, and lauding a leak regarding NSA behavior... that one's pretty simple. Violating secrecy for purposes of a political retaliation is reprehensible. Violating secrecy for purposes of blowing the whistle on a possibly unconstitutional invasion of privacy is why the free press exists. It's about as different a situation as you can get. I actually have a hard time figuring out why you see them as the same.

See, I was thinking along these lines but had trouble articulating it this well.

Lurker
 
To begin: If the release of the story was timed simply to bash President Bush during a day that would otherwise have been good news for him, why wouldn't NYT have released it before the election, instead? Such a motive doesn't fit the facts. But, there was a more significant reason to print when they did, that happened to coincide with the Iraqi elections--there was an important vote going on regarding the Patriot Act. In fact, I daresay printing the article changed the outcome. That's not an unprincipled attack--that's a relevant disclosure on the eve of an important vote. It's their JOB.
To some degree it apears the leak was timed to maximize sales possibilities for one of their hack's books soon to be released.

Also, at one time, courts realized that freedom of press, civil rights, blah blah should not become a suicide pact.

Regarding the conflict between objecting to leaks regarding Plame, and lauding a leak regarding NSA behavior... that one's pretty simple. Violating secrecy for purposes of a political retaliation is reprehensible. Violating secrecy for purposes of blowing the whistle on a possibly unconstitutional invasion of privacy is why the free press exists. It's about as different a situation as you can get. I actually have a hard time figuring out why you see them as the same.
The Plame crapola has and had no bearing on the real world except the real world of politicians not in power striving to get some power.

Ed only knows what intelligence assets we've lost by discussing current NSA operations.


Please Ed, let the first suitcase nuke on US soil be close to a large group of the blithering idiots who see no danger except that posed by Bush etal.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom