Bush NSA spies on Americans

If the NSA was monitoring specific individuals phones without a warrant, and the President was Bill Clinton, he'd be impeached by next week.


Whoa.. what happened? I thought you were a conservative nut-rider.

PS. Are you enjoying the snow and ice on the roads today?
 
Something disturbing to comtemplate since the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA) seemed to already allow wiretaps on suspected terrorists. What (or who else) is Bush secretly monitoring that he couldn't count on FISA to authorize?

Quakers, among others.
 
Whoa.. what happened? I thought you were a conservative nut-rider.

I have been quite steadfast and consistent on here and elsewhere in my opposition to the Patriot Act ever since it was enacted. It is not an unusual position for a Conservative.

PS. Are you enjoying the snow and ice on the roads today?

I might not be able to go to work tomorrow because of it, so no, I am not enjoying it.
 
It is a good sign. One of the more alarming trends over the last few years has been for the news media to abandon their crucial role as government watchdogs.

Evidence? No offense, but when Clinton was elected the wingnuts claimed the media was to blame. When Bush was elected wingnuts like you claimed the same. Same story, different wingnut.
 
Quakers, among others.
That's terrifying. If the Quakers joined forces with the librarians, just think what havoc they could wreak.

There's something about Trappist monks that makes me think they may be in on the plot too. I hope someone's been eavesdropping on them, that would be funny for so many reasons.
 
Another side point--is it just me, or has the news media suddenly woken up? I never would have expected the major news sources to present such an item, under a democratic OR republican president--such nuances as citizens' privacy seems in the past to be barely worth a footnote. I always thought they would much rather present news about whatever trumped-up controversy is distracting from the real issues.

A simpler explanation is that this enormously important discovery (not) was published on the same news day as the Iraqi elections, which turned out to be succesful, just as Bush hoped and exactly the opposite as most of the newpapers and journalists in the USA had hoped. So the New York Times & co. needed something--anything--else as its headline, lest they be percieved as giving comfort to the real enemy, which is, of course, not the "insurgents" in Iraq, but G. W. Bush and other evil neo-cons.

If this non-story (surprise surprise: the most secret spying agency in the USA sometimes does thing that are legally dubious in its spying work) makes Bush look bad, so much the better. But if it was a slower news day, the NYT and Washington Post would rather have had as a headline "Teen Wins Essay-Writing Competition in Local School" than say something good about the Iraqi elections.
 
Evidence? No offense, but when Clinton was elected the wingnuts claimed the media was to blame. When Bush was elected wingnuts like you claimed the same. Same story, different wingnut.

I have observed that on some topics the media tend to give a free pass to whomever is in power. This was already going on during Clinton's time and probably before.
 
Another side point--is it just me, or has the news media suddenly woken up? I never would have expected the major news sources to present such an item, under a democratic OR republican president--such nuances as citizens' privacy seems in the past to be barely worth a footnote. I always thought they would much rather present news about whatever trumped-up controversy is distracting from the real issues.

A simpler explanation is that this enormously important discovery (not) was published on the same news day as the Iraqi elections, which turned out to be succesful, just as Bush hoped and exactly the opposite as most of the newpapers and journalists in the USA had hoped. So the New York Times & co. needed something--anything--else as its headline, lest they be percieved as giving comfort to the real enemy, which is, of course, not the "insurgents" in Iraq, but G. W. Bush and other evil neo-cons.

If this non-story (surprise surprise: the most secret spying agency in the USA sometimes does thing that are legally dubious in its spying work) makes Bush look bad, so much the better. But if it was a slower news day, the NYT and Washington Post would rather have had as a headline "Teen Wins Essay-Writing Competition in Local School" than say something good about the Iraqi elections.
Yes, the simpler explanation that the liberal media is so anti-Bush they're against democracy in Iraq. Yep, that's the ticket. Would it be any less valid for me to argue that you're so anti-liberal that you're against democracy in America?
 
Would it be any less valid for me to argue that you're so anti-liberal that you're against democracy in America?
Go for it. America is a republic, not a democracy, even though SCOTUS & the congress have done their best over the last 50 years or so to make it one.
 
Yes, the simpler explanation that the liberal media is so anti-Bush they're against democracy in Iraq.

Why, yes, actually.
 
That's terrifying. If the Quakers joined forces with the librarians, just think what havoc they could wreak.

There's something about Trappist monks that makes me think they may be in on the plot too. I hope someone's been eavesdropping on them, that would be funny for so many reasons.

This whole thing is wrong on so many levels.

For instance, does our government really have such vast resources that they can spare time and expense to listen in on Quakers? I seriously doubt it, but it can give that impression and feed the "men in black" conspiracy theories out there. The reality is that the government probably doesn't have the resources to spare and are wasting valuable time cracking the oatmeal forumula rather than looking out for, oh, I don't know, terrorists, maybe.
 
Yes, the simpler explanation that the liberal media is so anti-Bush they're against democracy in Iraq. Yep, that's the ticket. Would it be any less valid for me to argue that you're so anti-liberal that you're against democracy in America?

Well it does make one wonder why the NYT sat on this story for a year only to drop it like a bomb on a busy news day which should have belonged solely to the historic Iraqi elections.

Also one must wonder why the liberal media cries so loudly about the outting of the identity of Ms. Plame when they are willing to publicize this NSA story which is in fact a far more important secret to national security than Valerie's CIA employment.

It makes you wonder who's side the MSM is really on.

-z
 
Well it does make one wonder why the NYT sat on this story for a year only to drop it like a bomb on a busy news day which should have belonged solely to the historic Iraqi elections.

Yeah, especially since we were having our own elections a year ago.
 
Random beat me to the punch about FISA.

Assuming that the surveillance happened as claimed (I haven't been able to follow it closely), then it is illegal and a Very Bad Thing.

If Bush kept key personnel in the Senate/House informed, this does not mitigate the level of Badness which characterizes this Very Bad Thing; it merely increases the circle of the guilty.

If it is proven beyond a doubt today that the Terribly Liberally Biased Media withheld publication of this story so as to publish it on a date best suited for diverting attentiong from the Very Good Thing That Is The Iraqi Elections, it is irrelevant.

Yell at the media all you like for being biased and partisan, but do it separately from your condemnation of the Very Bad Thing.
 
Random beat me to the punch about FISA.

Assuming that the surveillance happened as claimed (I haven't been able to follow it closely), then it is illegal and a Very Bad Thing.

If Bush kept key personnel in the Senate/House informed, this does not mitigate the level of Badness which characterizes this Very Bad Thing; it merely increases the circle of the guilty.

If it is proven beyond a doubt today that the Terribly Liberally Biased Media withheld publication of this story so as to publish it on a date best suited for diverting attentiong from the Very Good Thing That Is The Iraqi Elections, it is irrelevant.

Yell at the media all you like for being biased and partisan, but do it separately from your condemnation of the Very Bad Thing.


The Very Bad Thing may well have been a Very Legal Thing....which means that it may not have been Very Bad and only rises to the level of "Thing". Seems to me that the Very Historic Voting in Iraq easily should trump an ambiguous noun which has been kept in cold storage for a year.

After all; wasn't the outting of Plame a "Very Bad Thing" when we could pin it on the Bush White House? But then faded into the background as soon as Bob Woodward let out that he had known about it even before Scooter Libby supposedly blabbed. It sounds like Val's "license to kill" was a very poorly kept secret indeed.

-z
 
After all; wasn't the outting of Plame a "Very Bad Thing" when we could pin it on the Bush White House? But then faded into the background as soon as Bob Woodward let out that he had known about it even before Scooter Libby supposedly blabbed. It sounds like Val's "license to kill" was a very poorly kept secret indeed.

Who did Woodward learn about Plame from? That question remains unanswered, correct?

Lurker
 
Rikzilla,

If it was a Legal Thing after all, then okay, I'll agree it was only a Thing. That's why I opened with the statement I did.

The little I have seen, however, does not indicate that it will turn out to be Legal.

And the business about one Thing "trumping" another Thing is, I think, specious.

There can be multiple Good Things and Bad Things to be discussed. There can even be multiple discussions on whether One Thing In Particular is Good Or Bad.

If the NYT posted this story (whether the Thing is Good, Bad or Only) at the time they did with the motive of "trumping" Iraq, then they should be taken to task (I don't know in what manner, though).

But you can take them to task for that and still ask for accountability regarding the surveillance.

And you can do both of the above while still crowing about the elections. (And I am).
 
The Very Bad Thing may well have been a Very Legal Thing....which means that it may not have been Very Bad and only rises to the level of "Thing".

Somehow, even if spying on Quakers was done legally, I just don't see how a Very Legal Thing still makes a Very Bad Thing just a Thing.

For example, I am opposed to abortion. You can see how a Very Legal Abortion is still a Very Bad Thing in my mind. In fact, government approval just makes the situation all the more Bad.

So it is with spying on Americans simply because they oppose the war. As much as I hate Marxist Blame-America-First losers with seven pounds of brain damage and a megaphone, there is no excuse for the government to spy on them. Or Quakers. WTF does this have to do with preventing terrorist attacks? It's the very abuse of power which made me opposed to the Patriot Act from the get-go.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom